1. Become familiar with evidence on relationship between democracy and: 1.Economic class balance/ structure. 2.Education. 3.Religion. 4.Political Culture. 5.Facilitating Events. 2. Assess persuasiveness of causal links.
A certain balance of relations among classes is necessary. ◦ Esp. middle class/ bourgeoisie (Aristotle, Moore). Argued middle class “moderate” for various reasons – sheer numbers or position “in middle”. Bourgeoisie crucial due to autonomous income. ◦ Powerful landowning class can hinder.
Education
Economic growth Democracy
Predicted “free” countries (Freedom House measures) by Actually 87 “free” countries by those measures in 2010.
EducationEconomic growth Democracy Directly Indirectly
Religion
1988: 39/46 democratic countries dominant Christian Reasons? ◦ Emphasis on autonomy and dignity of individual? ◦ Separation between church and state?
Pre-1900: ¾ of democratic countries. Catholicism considered hindrance until 3 rd wave.
Pre-1960s: Catholic Church associated with powerful elites in society. ◦ Mid-1960s: Church began to oppose authoritarian regimes (“liberation theology”) ◦ Influence on Brazil, Chile, Philippines, Poland transitions.
Persistent set of undemocratic countries. Possible difficulties reconciling restrictions on participation with democratic principles. Yet 2/3 of Muslims live in democratic regimes. Manji: Problem is with Islamist political ideology. Manji Ibrahim: problem not with Islam but history and rulers on Arab peninsula.
Considered mostly unimportant now.
Civic Culture
“Civic political culture” necessary for stable democracy. Citizens: ◦ Feel competent ◦ Have urge to participate ◦ Are tolerant of diversity ◦ Are positive towards their political institutions Problem: causal direction between democracy and civic culture?
Alexis de Tocqueville: Democracy in America Robert Putnam: Making Democracy Work “civic community” in northern Italy
Civic CultureDemocracy
1. Economic crisis 2. Losing a major military conflict
Performance as source of legitimacy for recent authoritarian regimes. Legitimacy to particular government rather than procedures of regime.
Democratic regimes: legitimacy of regime rules and procedures as well as current government.
Economic Crisis ◦ E.g. oil crises and 1979 Oil-importing countries suffered. Loss of Major Military Conflict ◦ Argentina (Falklands-Malvinas) ◦ Greece (Cyprus) ◦ Portugal (colonial wars) ◦ USSR (Afghanistan)