Points for discussion Panel Allocation systems and transparency Leiden, January 19 th 2012 Chair: D.C. Dragos, Romania.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Matching the supply of technical assistance with recipient needs and ensuring best practices – a donor's experience Agust Jonsson, consultant

Advertisements

LAPSI 2nd Public Conference New Hungarian Data Protection and Freedom of Information Authority Tamás Kovács HUNAGI.

Role of National Parliaments

Slovenian experience on 98/34 Notification Procedure Conference on the Functioning of the 98/34 Notification Procedure, Brussels, 22 June 2005 mag. Irena.

1 In France, new capacity is developed and allocated via open season procedures The GGPOS establish how an open season should be conducted To compete with.

Commission’s draft staff working document on Art. 22 ERGEG’s view ERGEG’s Gas Focus Group (GFG) XV Madrid Forum, 6/7 November 2008.

HELP Water Law and Policy Dr. Patricia Wouters Director, Water Law and Policy Programme University of Dundee, Scotland Member of HELP Task Force.

1 Priority issues for the French-UK-Irish regulators What is expected from TSOs? 30 May 2006 To increase trade between adjacent markets and therefore have.

GATS & Telecom Transparency. Key Ingredients for Reform }Clearly set out policies in laws, regulations, licenses, contracts }Make all processes open.

Creating a Single Electricity Market Across Borders: Pitfalls, Constraints, and Opportunities Paul K Gorecki Economic & Social Research Institute & Trinity.

International Federation of Accountants International Education Standards for Professional Accountants Mark Allison, Executive Director Institute of Chartered.

European Commission Slot allocation at Community airports Infrastructures and Airports Unit Klaas Pel.

Control procedures in polish public procurement law Public Procurement Office 2007.

PAWEL MAGDZIAREK IRREGULARITIES DETECTED DURING IMPLEMENTATION OF THE REGIONAL OPERATIONAL PROGRAM FOR WIELKOPOLSKA REGION.

Accreditation and Evaluation in Higher Education in Slovakia Pavol Návrat Slovak University of Technology, formerly Vice-Chairman, Accreditation Commission.

André Piérard, ERGEG Project Leader on Complaints Citizens’ Energy Forum, London, September 2009 Draft advice on Customer Complaint Handling, Reporting.

ITS Biennal Conference September 4-7, 2004 Berlin 1 Power and discretion in independent regulation. The Portuguese case. João Confraria School of Economics.

The Italian Institutional Design for Administrative Simplification HIGH LEVEL REGIONAL SEMINAR ON “STRATEGIES, TOOLS AND CAPACITIES FOR ADMINISTRATIVE.

ECO-MANAGEMENT AND AUDIT SCHEME Performance, credibility, transparency Accreditation & Registration Systems in EMAS.

Experience and Lessons of Utilizing National and EU Funds for Innovation in Bulgaria Enhancing Bulgaria’s Competitiveness through Innovation.

Sales Law October 27, 2009 Winn. Sales Law October 27 Reading estimate for Thursday 10/29 – Problems 3-5 to 3-9 Introduction to Standards – What connection.

Codes, Standards & Conformity Assessment GP Russ Chaney CEO, The IAPMO Group

Open Competition Intellectual Property Specialists (AST 3/ AD6) OHIM, Alicante – Spain Open for application: October 31st 2013 Apply before : December.

6. Decreasing Discretionary Power 1. Definition of discretionary power Discretionary power is the power to issue a regulatory measure (of general or particular.

Public Procurement Seminar Wednesday 16 th – 17 th June 2010 Savannah Hotel, Barbados The Certificate of Independent Bid Determination (CIBD) Fair Trading.

ETF Conference, Building & Financing European Transport Infrastructure, Brussels, 23rd Oct Building & Financing European Transport Infrastructures.

Romanian Court of Accounts years of existence.

Evaluations at the EC (the IP context) Kamil Kiljański Geneva, 6 October 2011.

Nanotechnology Standards Panel CONFERENCE ON U.S. LEADERSHIP IN ISO AND IEC ISO BREAKOUT SESSION REPORT Breakout Session Moderator: Mr. David Miller ANSI.

USSOCOM / Industry Collaboration NDIA Debrief 20 August 2015 Strategic Business Solutions.

1 Social Considerations in EC Public Procurement Loredana Puiu Internal Market & Services DG Directorate C: Public Procurement Policy.

Economics: The study of scarce resources

European Commission 1 TSM Regulation: Spectrum Briefing on Telecoms Single Market Package Anthony Whelan Head of Unit – Spectrum Electronic Communications.

THE NEW DIMENSIONS OF THE EUROPEAN PUBLIC PROCUREMENT POLICY Christian SERVENAY DG MARKT/Unit C1.

Third Generation mobile Licensing: the UK approach Jane Humphreys Radiocommunications Agency, UK.

Presentation “Green Investment Schemes – greenhouse gas emissions quotas trading mechanisms in Ukraine according to the Kyoto Protocol to the Convention.

Public procurement audit - the Polish experience Batumi, June 2015 Krzysztof Kwiatkowski President Supreme Audit Office of Poland (NIK) Dr hab. prof. Andrzej.

Eliza Niewiadomska EBRD Legal Transition Programme Kiev, 19 May 2012 Building Confidence in Public Procurement Review Best practice for enforcing public.

Towards improvement: Institution of appeal in public procurement – topical procedural and evidentiary issues Kyiv, April , 2012 Oleksandr Voznyuk.

Legal developments in the Polish Power Sector Arkadiusz Krasnodębski.

Structures and Procedures with Regard to the Code of Conduct for MPs and with Regard to the Integrity of Parliamentary Staff FINAL SUMMARY Zlatko Atanasov.

Public Procurement Uinsinn Finn Galway County Council Roads, Transportation, Marine.

Regulatory Policy The Potential for Common Federal- Provincial-Territorial Policies on Regulation Robert Johnson Presentation for “Rules, Rules, Rules,

Institutional Mechanisms of NGO State Funding Mladen Ivanovic, Association of Municipalities in Croatia Baku, 30 May CASE STUDY: CROATIA.

Cooperation with the Seimas Audit Committee Tomas Mackevičius Deputy Auditor General.

Gas Regional Initiative North West Region - Draft Framework Guidelines Capacity Allocation Mechanisms BNetzA/CRE Pre-Comitology Meeting Bonn – 26 May 2011.

1 This project is supported by the European Union 3 rd MEDREG-IMME Seminar Reform and Opening of Maghreb Electricity Markets September 2013 MRA (Malta)

REPUBLIC OF ALBANIA PUBLIC PROCUREMENT AGENCY Eighth Regional Public Procurement Forum May, 22-25, 2012 Tirana

Comparative Telecommunications Law Spring, 2007 Prof. Karl Manheim 6: Spectrum Management Copyright © 2007.

ROMANIA NATIONAL NATURAL GAS REGULATORY AUTHORITY Public Service Obligations in Romanian Gas Sector Ligia Medrea General Manager – Authorizing, Licensing,

Themes in Social Studies

Potential Solutions Most economics would suggest sealed-bid auction.

Round Table on "The challenges in the design of a merger control regime for young and small competition authorities Sixteenth Session of the Intergovernmental.

EU law and the legislative procedure of European Union

Partnership in Developing OGP in Georgia

Module 8 : Implementing Port Reform

Corruption and Bid-rigging

Corruption and Bid-rigging

The competition enforcement in regulated sectors

Working on Phytosanitary legislation

Ministry of Economic Development and Trade of Ukraine

Performance Standards

Legal Aspects of Finance

Outline Background: development of the Commission’s position

Audit of Contracting Arrangements of Public Services

CRISTINA BREDEN – Director ROMANIAN COURT OF ACCOUNTS

6 th Grade Connecting Themes Enduring Understandings.

12-13 June, Tirana Dr.sc. Helena Popovic

Public Procurement in Macedonia Achievements in 2014

Prof. Dr. Willemien den Ouden

Presentation transcript:

Points for discussion Panel Allocation systems and transparency Leiden, January 19 th 2012 Chair: D.C. Dragos, Romania

ALLOCATION SYSTEMS TYPE OF RIGHTS TO BE ALLOCATED Scarcity vs. Public policy Natural / technicalPublic interest

Procedure Order of application : 1 st came, 1 st served Drawing of lots: similar offers Bid (auction) : highest offer Tender: combination of criteria Gambling: monopolies / restrictions Radio: EU harmonization CO2: trading schemes

What scope for transparency? Institutional arrangements ◦ Governmental bodies vs. professional bodies ◦ Independence? ◦ Freedom of choice regarding public policy  Choice of the allocation system  Design of the allocation system

What scope for transparency? Allocation procedure ◦ Establishing criteria Usage of the scarce right ◦ Limitation of possible applicants: new entrants (competition) vs. past experience

1. Ex ante transparency Drafting the rules – legal certainty Availability of the right Design of the allocation system Publicity

2. Transparency of the procedure Competent body Timeframes – reasonableness Communication with interested parties – publicity Redress procedures ◦ access to documents Legal consequences for lack of transparency

3. Ex post transparency Control mechanisms Transparency of findings Sanctions and their publicity Consequences for infringement of transparency requirements Redress Transparency of requirements for renewal ◦ Conditioned by performance – assessment? ◦ Regardless of performance – new entries, competition?