2 Key Valuation Issues I. The Value of Shares for Physician Buy-in and II. Valuing Compensation Relationships in Under Arrangement Models 14 th Annual.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
CONFIDENTIAL Health Care 1 Scott Becker, Partner McGuireWoods LLP Presented to: Webinar September 26 th, 2007 Webinar September 26 th, 2007 Joint Ventures.
Advertisements

FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT I AND II
What Should the Appraiser Ask the Broker or Principal of the Sale When Confirming a Transaction? Presented By Jeff Binder, MAI Senior Living Investment.
Hospital-Physician Integration: What Do We Do Now?
Stock Ownership Less Than 100%
Accessing Resources for Growth from External Sources
Valuing Stocks Chapter 5.
CONCEPTS of VALUE. FACTORS OF VALUE UTILITY –THE ABILITY OF A PRODUCT TO SATISFY HUMAN WANTS. RELATES TO THE DAMAND SIDE OF THE MARKET. SCARCITY –THE.
Pesented by: Brooke A. Liggett, CPA, CVA. “How much is my business worth?”
C A V Employee Stock Ownership Plans Basics of ESOP Stock Valuation 21 st Annual Ohio Employee Ownership Conference Fairlawn, OH April 20, 2007 Richard.
Chapter 13.
© 2014 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part, except for use as permitted in a license.
Informal Risk Capital, Venture Capital, and Going Public
Blocher,Stout,Cokins,Chen, Cost Management 4e ©The McGraw-Hill Companies 2008 Management Compensation, Business Analysis, and Business Valuation Chapter.
“I Will Return!!” (not GEN MacArthur) A Charter Class member returns to speak on PE Valuation Bruce B. Bingham, FASA, FRICS 23 September 2013.
Informal Risk Capital, Venture Capital, and Going Public
E. N. Kemp & Associates, Inc. Aloha. BUSINESS VALUATION 101 Where do I begin to tell the story…...
This week its Accounting Theory
Barbara McAneny MD. 2 3 » Legal entity through which the Affordable Care Act’s Shared Savings Program will be implemented » Comprised of groups of eligible.
Week 10 DIFD 321 Accounting & Finance. WHAT IS MARKETING? The action or business of promoting and selling products or services, including market research.
Physician Preference Items: A New Paradigm By John M. McGuire President & CEO Surgical Implant Services, LLC.
Management Compensation, Business Analysis, and Business Valuation Chapter Twenty McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2013 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
 Business is owned and run by one individual  Nearly 76% of all businesses  Owner receives all of its profits and bear all of its losses.
ENTR 452 Chapter 14: Accessing Resources for Growth
 Business valuation is a logical, defendable process of arriving at the opinion as to the worth of a business given the information available, assumptions.
Hospital/Healthcare Provider Analysis 7/9/15. HCA owns and operates approximately 166 hospitals and approximately 113 freestanding surgery centers in.
Uncovering the Gem: Hidden Elements in ASC Valuation Presented by Lorin E. Patterson, JD, Partner, Reed Smith LLP Todd J. Mello, ASA, AVA, MBA, Principal,
Why Do We Need Accounting? Companies of all sizes need to implement a streamlined accounting system in order to accurately record and report business transactions,
© 2012 VMG Health AARON MURSKI SENIOR MANAGER VMG HEALTH ASC Valuation Update & Current M&A Trends.
Lecture 12 Lease Financing. It has emerged as a supplementary source of financing. Increase in off-balance sheet methods of financing. Increase in scope.
Valuation Program USMSS Richard Flom, CPA/ABV/CFF, CVA.
Cancer Center Business Summit October 2007 Chicago, IL Buying, Selling, Merging and Valuation Presenters: Presenters: Chris E. Rossman, Partner, Foley.
ILLUSTRATION 13-1 PARTNERSHIP CHARACTERISTICS
Value: An Introduction to Alternative Structures and Transactions Involving MHS Presentation to the City Assets & Enterprises Sub- Committee of the Committee.
Presented by: Todd J. Mello, MBA, AVA, Principal How Do the ASC Companies Assess Value? A Presentation by HealthCare Appraisers, Inc. based upon its 4.
FUNDAMENTALS OF CORPORATE FINANCE MGF301 Fall 1998 Vigdis Boasson SUNY at Buffalo
© 2012 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. Principles of Business, 8e C H A P T E R 5 SLIDE Forms of Business Ownership 5 C H A P T E R Economic.
ACCOUNTING FOR HEALTHCARE Pertemuan 8-12 Matakuliah: A1042/Accounting Software Package for Services Tahun: 2010.
CORPORATE FORM OF ORGANIZATION A corporation is a legal entity created by law that is separate and distinct from its owners.
Chapter McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2008 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Cost of Capital 11.
CORPORATIONS: ORGANIZATION AND SHARE CAPITAL TRANSACTIONS CHAPTER 14.
STARK II PHASE II AWPHD BOARD RETREAT AUGUST 12, 2004 By Lori K. Nomura.
Chapter 3 Arbitrage and Financial Decision Making
Business Valuations. Reasons for wanting to know about value:  Market transactions  Scorecards  Estate planning  Family transfers  ESOP  Litigation.
Chapter 8– Bond Valuation and Structure of Interest RatesCopyright 2008 John Wiley & Sons 1 MT480 Unit 4 Chapters 8 and 9.
Conceptual Tools The creation of new and improved financial products through innovative design or repackaging of existing financial instruments. Financial.
Bona Fide Service Fees Context –Impact of arrangements with Distributors/Wholesalers on Government Pricing Calculations Letter to HDMA re fee-for-service.
Analysis of Financial Statements. Learning Objectives  Understand the purpose of financial statement analysis.  Perform a vertical analysis of a company’s.
Analyzing Financial Statements Chapter 13 McGraw-Hill/Irwin © 2009 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
Analyzing Financial Statements
Receivables Management For Management Related Notes and Assignments, Visit
© 2012 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a publicly accessible website, in whole or in part. Company.
Tri-Party Arrangements: Considering All Perspectives Presented by, Max Reiboldt, CPA, President / CEO Coker Group 2015 New York Metro ASC Symposium October.
Chapter 9 The Cost of Capital. Copyright ©2014 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.9-1 Learning Objectives 1.Understand the concepts underlying.
Chapter 11 Cost of Capital Copyright © 2011 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Private Placements and Venture Capital Chapter 28 Tools & Techniques of Investment Planning Copyright 2007, The National Underwriter Company1 What is it?
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright (c) 2002 by the McGraw-Hill Companies Inc Principles of Taxation: Advanced Strategies Chapter 11 Chapter 11 Dispositions of.
Financial Statements, Forecasts, and Planning
Chapter 36 Financing the Business Section 36.1 Preparing Financial Documents Section 36.2 Financial Aspect of a Business Plan Section 36.1 Preparing Financial.
What does finance mean ?  Finance = f (money)  Money = anything that is generally accepted as payment for goods and services and repayment of.
Ratio Analysis…. Types of ratios…  Performance Ratios: Return on capital employed. (Income Statement and Balance Sheet) Gross profit margin (Income Statement)
Best Practices in Navigating Emerging ASC Legal Challenges Carol K. Lucas, Esq
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright (c) 2003 by the McGraw-Hill Companies Inc Principles of Taxation: Advanced Strategies Chapter 11 Dispositions of Equity Interests.
Uncovering the Gem: Hidden Elements in ASC Valuation
Types of Business Structures
Valuation Issues for ASCs
Intercompany Indebtedness
Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP)
What is the business worth?
Presentation transcript:

2 Key Valuation Issues I. The Value of Shares for Physician Buy-in and II. Valuing Compensation Relationships in Under Arrangement Models 14 th Annual Ambulatory Surgery Center Conference October 20, 2007 Presented By: Stephan Peron, VMG Health, LLC Curtis Bernstein, HealthCare Appraisers, Inc.

Definition of FMV In Revenue Ruling 59-60, the Internal Revenue Service defines fair market value as “the amount at which property would change hands between a willing seller and a willing buyer when the former is not under any compulsion to buy and the latter is not under any compulsion to sell and when both have reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts.”

Valuation Guidance from the IRS Revenue Ruling also states that all relevant factors should be considered, including the following:  The nature of the business and history of the enterprise from its inception;  The overall economic outlook, and the condition and outlook of the specific industry in particular;  The book value of the stockholders’ equity and the financial condition of the business;  The earning capacity of the company;  The dividend-paying capacity of the enterprise;  Sales of the stock and the size of the block to be valued; and  The market price of publicly traded stock of corporations in similar industries or lines of business.

Basic Valuation Theory Time Value of Money  If I invest $1,000 today at 10% annually, I will earn $100 next year, $110 in year 2, etc.  The inverse is true – if I expect to earn $100 next year, $110 in year two, etc. from an investment in which I expect to earn 10%, I would be willing to pay $1,000 today for that investment

Conversion to a Multiple The current FMV of a non-controlling interest in an ASC is currently trading between 3.0 and 4.5 times adjusted* EBITDA less debt.  Reconciliation to “Basic Valuation Theory”  An investor would expect a 22% to a 33% return annually on an investment in a non- controlling interest in a particular ASC. *Adjusted based on post DRA revenue

The Value of Shares for Physician Buy-in Considerations Selling Equity to Physicians  Current ownership structure  Percentage equity available for sale  Availability of existing shares for sale  Sale of new shares  Maximum and minimum percentage available per physician  Return on investment (ROI) of equity investment  OIG and IRS regulatory requirements related to valuation  ASC safe harbors of the Anti-Kickback Statutes  Term of existing operating agreement  Management of partnership  Buyout provisions and covenants not to compete  Value of equity at minority and control level

Valuation Issues  Regulatory requirements for valuation (OIG and IRS)  Fair market value opinion vs. pricing analysis  Pricing analysis using limited valuation methods  Fair market value opinion using complete valuation process  Timing and cost considerations  Reasonable consideration of non public minority level equity

Valuation Issues Specific to ASCs  Physician ownership makeup or lack thereof  Physician risk is the most important risk factor in ASC valuation  Case volume, mix, and reimbursement  Change in volume and reimbursement per case  Diversification (e.g., # of surgeons, number & type of specialties, payors)  Nature of payor contracts – “out of network” business  Market reimbursement risk analysis  Ability to generate sustainable cash flow and distributions

 Financial leverage, working capital, and capital expenditures  Quality and age of facility and equipment  Opportunity for expansion (rooms, surgeons)  Competent management  Barriers to entry (e.g., CON)  Terms of operating agreement  Divesture required upon retirement, relocation, and inactivity  Restrictive covenants Valuation Issues Specific to ASCs

Valuation Methodology Decision Tree Depending upon standard of value, apply discounts Compare value to market transactions Adjust for atypical working capital Use asset approach to establish floor of value ASC Attributes

Valuing Minority Interests  Simply states: Interests providing absolute control (i.e., greater than a 50% interest whereby key aspects of control are not diminished by governing documents or otherwise) are worth more than interests which do not have the same control rights  Control granted by the governing documents (examples on next slide)  Concept of “effective” control – physicians control with their feet and their hands  Valuation Guidance: absence of control adjustments in financial projection (preferable approach) or application of minority interest discount (reliance on published studies or other more difficult to quantify and support)

Valuing Minority Interests Matters Subject to Control  Capital calls  Admission of new investors  Borrowings greater than a certain amount  Acquisition of equipment greater than a certain amount  Selling, assigning or otherwise disposing or encumbering assets  Entering into material contracts  Management agreement contracts (assigning/cancelling)  Selling, liquidating, or merging the entity  Changing the core governing documents  Typical ASC ownership agreement are very friendly to the minority shareholder  Note: Physicians display a certain level of control regardless of ownership interest level

II Under Arrangements – Compensation

Stark - Phase III Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (“CMS”) posted the final Stark Phase III on August 27, (Federal Register September 5 th ) With respect to indirect compensation arrangements, CMS explains in the final rule that the relationship between the physician and his or her physician organization is disregarded and the physician “stands in the shoes” of his or her physician organization. CMS states, “many arrangements that may not have met the definition of an ‘indirect compensation arrangement’ under the Phase I and Phase II analysis will constitute direct compensation arrangements that must satisfy the requirements of an exception in order for the physician to make DHS referrals to the entity furnishing DHS.” RESULT: Consult your regulatory attorneys to assist with the legal issues associate with an under arrangement structure

Case Study: “Under Arrangements” Business Model Primary Model, can vary depending upon desired structure and state-specific regulations –Hospital contracts with a separate legal entity formed to provide turnkey surgical management services to Hospital’s outpatient department (i.e., separate legal entity is not an outpatient surgical center, but rather, a management company) –Management company, “NewCo,” can be jointly owned by Hospital and Physicians or 100% physician owned –NewCo would provide facility services to the hospital pursuant to a written agreement –The Hospital would bill for those services under the Hospital’s name and provider number –Hospital directly compensates NewCo for its services in an amount that is reasonable based on the going rate charges in the community to other entities that provide comparable services

Case Study: “Under Arrangements” Business Model - Advantages  Allows hospital to offer seamless outpatient surgical services to patients in collaboration with physicians within the community, enhancing quality of care and patient satisfaction  Increased efficiency & cost controls: MDs generally have a demonstrated ability to offer cost-effective services on an outpatient basis  Creates an alternative mechanism for hospitals and physicians to offer outpatient services to patients beyond the standard free- standing, independent surgery center  Preserves hospital’s ability to leverage upon existing payor contracts  Expansion of current services through access to needed capital: allows hospital to preserve capital for other equally important projects  Creates a mechanism to recruit and retain physicians  Creates an opportunity for physicians to participate with hospital and earn economic returns in exchange for assuming certain business and financial risk

“Under Arrangements” Business Typical Model HOSPITAL OUTPATIENT DEPARTMENT Maintains patient relationship, QA, and Medical Records Holds managed care contracts and performs billing & collection function Contracts with NewCo for the provision of “turnkey” services Pays NewCo a management fee “NEWCO” JOINT VENTURE Purchases equipment and supplies; employs staff Can be jointly owned by hospital and physicians or 100% MD owned Contracts with hospital for the provision of “turnkey” outpatient surgical services Receives management fee from hospital, which is comprised of reimbursement of reasonable and necessary operating costs as well as a market rate of return

Case Study Facts:  Small rural area of about 50,000 population;  One local hospital with outpatient surgical volumes of approximately 4,000 annually;  Estimated income to hospital - $1,00,000 annually;  Physicians threaten to start own ASC;

Case Study Freestanding ASC model  Hospital and physicians joint venture the ASC.  Who determines who gets what percent?  Hospital is required to over build to meet the needs of certain physicians (“politics” says Hospital’s CEO)  New Center is required to get new Medicare number and negotiate new payor contracts  Center and Hospital compete in same market – increased competition leads to ASC getting lower reimbursement than Hospital.  Resulting income = ($350,000) in year one and making a slight profit by year four

Case Study Under Arrangement Model  Hospital owns department;  Hospital and physicians joint venture management company;  Hospital outpatient department already build out – no additional build out capital expenditure necessary;  Hospital contracts in-place – no delay in payments and no renegotiation;  Hospital continues to earn a significant profit, actually exceeding historic profits from its outpatient surgery business by year four;  Under arrangement company only earns a 10% profit but returns to investors equal to 30% annually.  Result: Hospital retains income that can be used to fund non- profitable business such as the ED, Labor & Delivery, etc.  Result: Physicians have their ownership in outpatient surgical business and make profit similar to that made in their own business.

Methodology for Establishing FMV  Clearly define which entity will provide which service  Determine Managers estimated cost of providing the turnkey service; differentiate fixed from variable; perform sensitivity analysis over a relevant range of volume assumptions  Mirror costing assumptions to proposed level of payment (i.e., one weighted average per case fee vs. payment designed around specific procedures)  Research similar arrangements in the marketplace; research market rates of return for comparable operating entities and leasing companies; apply operating margin return to manager’s fully loaded cost per case figure (example on next page)  Examine rates of return for each party to the agreement over a relevant range of volume assumptions; assess for reasonableness and equity

Methodology for Establishing FMV Per Case Fee Calculation (Simplified Example) Assume: fully loaded cost per case (including debt service on equipment) = $1,000 / case Assume: Market research indicates that profit margins reasonably range between 20% and 30% Per Case Fee calculated as (Cost Per Case) / 1 – Operating Margin) Low: $1,000 / ( ) = $1,250 (i.e., $250 represents a 20% operating profit margin on $1,250 in “revenue” to manager) High: $1,000 / (1 – 0.3) = $1,429 (i.e., $429 represents a 30% operating profit margin on $1,429 in “revenue” to manager) Depending upon scope of services provided, look at RBRVS reimbursement as a measure of reasonableness CANNOT BASE “PER CASE” PAYMENT ON HOSPITAL’S REIMBURSEMENT: FMV WOULD DICTATE THAT HOSPITAL PAY A MARKET RATE OF RETURN FOR SERVICES PURCHASED AND NOTHING MORE....

Stephan Peron, AVA VMG Health, LLC Three Galleria Tower Noel Road, Suite 2400 Dallas, Texas (214) Curtis Bernstein, CPA/ABV, CVA, MBA HealthCare Appraisers, Inc. 858 Happy Canyon Road, Suite 240 Castle Rock, CO (303)