Ethical issues in human research

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Ethics in Research. Little Albert Little Albert Little Albert 1. Why was this experiment performed? 2. What was the result(s) of the experiment? 3. What.
Advertisements

Social psychology Concerned with how others influence the thoughts, feelings, and behaviors of the individual Social thinking When something unexpected.
RESEARCH ETHICS Research Methods. Research Ethics Marketplace of ideas--no scientific misconduct  Research fraud = falsification of data  Plagiarism.
Definition, pg 225 Introduction to the Practice of Statistics, Sixth Edition © 2009 W.H. Freeman and Company.
Stanley Milgram A lesson in obeying. How far do you think people will go in the name of obedience?
Why Good People Do Bad Things Thesis The capacity for doing bad or even evil things can be explained (in part) by understanding social psychology The.
Social Psychology Social psychology studies the beliefs and behaviors of the individual (the self) within a group (others). Humans are social animals:
Agenda Objective: 1.To understand the ethical obligations of researchers with human subjects. 2.To understand the questionable history of human subjects.
Power of the Situation (cont.)
1 Social Psychology Psychology 40S. 2 Focuses in Social Psychology Social psychology studies how we behave, think and feel in social situations. Social.
Ethical Psychology How to conduct research in an ethical manner.
Social Psychology. How does society affect our thinking and actions?
6.S196 / PPAT: Principles and Practice of Assistive Technology Monday, 17 Sept 2012 Prof. Rob Miller Today: Ethics of Human Subject Research.
Ethics in Psychological Research Mr. Jochem. Reflections on Ethics Before we begin… answer the following question: 1) What is Ethics? What do you know.
____________ 1 ___________________ 2 __________ 3 ____________________________ 4 _______________ 5 students have been given instructions. You MUST follow.
The Milgram Experiment. The Milgram Experiment was a series of social psychology experiments conducted in the early 1960s by Yale University psychologist.
Born March 23, 1933; in New York Professor at Stanford University Majors in anthropology, psychology, & Sociology from Brooklyn College in 1954 He completed.
The Milgram Obedience Experiment The Perils of Obedience "The social psychology of this century reveals a major lesson: often it is not so much the kind.
Human Subjects’ Research. Learning Objectives Discuss key ethical concerns The role of the IRB Principles and origin of Belmont Report Principle of informed.
IRB – Institutional Review Board Purpose  Protect the Right of Human Subjects participating in research  Protect VULNERABLE populations  This includes.
Procedures and Ethics in Research Sociology: Chapter 2, Section 3.
INTRODUCTION TO THE SOCIAL SCIENCES Social Sciences The social sciences describe disciplines that explore human behavior and use the scientific method.
Social Psychology Contents What is Social Psychology? Assumptions Methods of Investigation Core Studies from Social Psychology: Milgram. (1963) and Zimbardo.
“Ordinary People” Doing Evil
Runaway Trolley Listen to the story and answer this question… Would you pull a switch that sends a man to his death to save Five others on a runaway trolley?
Ethics and Social Research
Chapter 14: Psychology in Our Social Lives “We must learn to live together as brothers or perish together as fools.” – Martin Luther King, Jr. ( )
Announcements Lab 5 Due Today Nothing due today! Due Next Lab Lab Assignment 5: CITI training New links on Blackboard site i.e. “class slides” & “lab slides”
Social Psychology & Nazi Germany
THE SCIENTIFIC METHOD IN SOCIOLOGY. Theoretical DEDUCTIVE Empirical INDUCTIVE Theoretical THE BASIC SCIENTIFIC METHOD.
Social Psychology. Social psychology Two major assumptions –Behavior is driven by context –Subjective perceptions guide our behavior.
THE MILGRAM EXPERIMENT
Milgram’s Experiment. The Purpose of the Experiment Prompted by Milgram’s interest in Eichmann and the Nazi’s obedience to Hitler in the Holocaust. This.
PSYCHOLOGICAL RESEARCH METHODS AND STATISTICS. What is research?  Samples- relatively small group out of a whole population under study  Must be representative.
Chapter Three: Ethics in Psychological Research. The Need for Ethical Principles Psychologists must ask and answer questions such as: Are we putting our.
Obedience to Authority “The Final Solution”. The Holocaust “The Nazi extermination of European Jews is the most extreme instance of abhorrent immoral.
By Jane Glanzer. What was it?  The Tuskegee syphilis experiment was an infamous clinical study conducted between 1932 and 1972 in Tuskegee, Alabama by.
A History of Unethical Research. In the USA, before the Pure Food and Drug Act was passed in 1906 there were no regulations on performing research on.
Ethics. Ethics Just because researchers could do a study, doesn’t mean that they should Is the science adding to a body of knowledge? Is the research.
Is public "Health” & “Pride” influence by? Health & Pride Nationalism Public Opinion PropagandaJustice Presentation by Maria C Alvarez May 6 th, 2015.
Announcements Unit 1 exam: -2 nd period: September 30 1 st period: September 29 Quiz NEXT CLASS: -Cognitive approach: strengths and weaknesses -Mann, Vrij,
Conformity and Obedience to Authority. What is Conformity? Quick Write: What do you think of when you hear the word ‘conformity’? Why do people conform?
Welcome to Unit 2 Any Questions So Far?. Getting Ready For Project 1: Unit 3 Read assignment carefully Review Rubric and use as checklist Proof read carefully.
Groups & Obedience The Milgram Experiment
Milgram’s Experiment.
THE TUSKEGEE SYPHILIS STUDY EFFECT ON CURRENT RESEARCH.
Ethics in Research What’s a good researcher to do?
Social Psychology How are our actions, thoughts and feelings influenced by others.
Ethics in Research A class discussion. What is Ethics in Research? and Why is it Important?
Quick Review of Things  GROUP DECISION- MAKING Groupthink Great Person Theory Polarization Social Loafing  INFLUENCING BEHAVIORS Deindividuation Bystander.
Responsible Conduct of Research Dr. Jean Hillstrom Chair, Social Science Department CUNY IRB Vice Chair.
Obedience. Occurs within hierarchy – person above has right to prescribe behaviour – emphasis on power Behaviour adopted is different from authority figure.
Psychology and Ethics September 22 & 23. Bellringer (5-7 sentences in journal) What does the term “ethics” mean to you? What is ethical and what is not?
Obedience to Authority
Unit 1.4 Research Methods Ethics
Stanford Prison Experiment
Unit Topic: Methods of Research in Psychology
Unit Topic: Methods of Research in Psychology
Chapter 3, 4.
Groups & Obedience The Milgram Experiment
Understanding Psychology Unit 1 Chapters 1 & 2.
The BIG Idea EXPERIMENTS
Unit 3 Research Methods Ethics
Obedience to Authority & the Psychology of Evil
Conformity and Obedience to Authority
How to conduct research in an ethical manner
What is Research?.
Social Psychology Overview— UCLA Demonstration, Milgram, & Stanford
The Stanford prison experiment
Presentation transcript:

Ethical issues in human research (Some of the )25 of the Scariest Science Experiments Ever Conducted, http://io9.com/ ,Gawker Media

Stanford Prisoner Experiment Philip Zimbardo's Stanford prisoner experiment took place in the 1970s. The psychiatrist took 24 undergraduates and assigned them roles as either prisoners or guards, in a mock prison on campus. After just a few days, 1/3 of the guards exhibited sadistic tendencies, two prisoners had to be removed early due to emotional trauma, and the whole experiment only lasted six of the planned 14 days. It showed just how easily normal individuals can become abusive, in situations where it is encouraged. http://www.stanford.edu/dept/news/pr/97/970108prisonexp.html

THN1412 Drug Trial In 2007, drug trials started for THN1412, a leukemia treatment. It had been tested previously in animals, and was found completely safe. Generally a drug is deemed safe to test on humans when it is found to be nonfatal to animals. When testing began in human subjects, the humans were given doses 500 times lower than found safe for animals. Nevertheless this drug, safe for animals, caused catastrophic organ failure in test subjects. Here the difference between animals and humans was deadly.

Nazi Experiments The medical atrocities performed by the Nazis are well-documented, and undeniably horrifying, with Josef Mengele's work on twins being especially disturbing. What's also terrifying is how useful this information was to medical science. A large amount of our knowledge about how hypothermia and cold effect humans is based on this data. Many have raised questions about the morality of using data gathered under such horrific circumstances. http://www.romove.cz

Milgram Experiments The infamous "shock" experiments conducted by Stanley Milgram in the 1960s showed just how far people would go, when ordered to hurt somebody else by an authority figure. The well-known psychological study brought in volunteers who thought they were participating in an experiment where they would deliver shocks to another test subject. A doctor requested that they deliver greater and greater shocks, even when the "test subject" started to scream in pain and (in some cases) die. In reality, the experiment was to see how obedient people would be when a doctor told them to do something that was obviously horrific and possibly fatal. Many participants in the experiments were willing to shock the "test subjects" (actors hired by Milgram) until they believed those subjects were injured or dead. Later, many participants claimed they were traumatized for life after discovering that they were capable of such inhumane behavior. http://www.integratedsociopsychology.net/milgram_experiment.html

The Tuskegee Syphilis experiment Between 1932 and 1972, 399 impoverished African-American farmers in Tuskegee, Alabama, with syphilis were recruited into a free program to treat their disease, but were denied effective treatment (penicillin) even after it existed. This was done as an experiment by scientists who wanted to see how the disease would progress if untreated. The leaking of this event lead to major changes in American laws on informed consent in medical experiments. www.washingtonvoz.com/.../20061103/tuskegee.jpg