The Need A strength training device that is safe for in-home use requires minimal setup or user training is affordable is portable motivates patient participation Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach
The Scope To design an at-home ankle strengthening device – Flex2Play – that motivates participation by interfacing therapy with a WiiMote which controls online video games Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach
Design Specifications Full range of motion 30° from neutral in DF -50° from neutral in PF Progressive Resistance 35 Nm DF torque 101 Nm PF torque Available in at least 15% increments Affordable – $200 target Portable – 8 ft 3 Virtual Reality Interface 2010 BME401 Group “Wii Controlled Gaming for Therapy” Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach 20° Dorsiflexion 0° Neutral –50° Plantarflexion Plantarflexion τ=F*d*sin(θ) F=101Nm/(0.28m*sin(90)) F=361N Dorsiflexion τ=F*d*sin(θ) F=35Nm/(0.28m*sin(90)) F=125N
Alternatives Mechanism of Resistance SpringsGravitationalMagnetismMotorsElastic Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach
Springs Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach Left: Torsion Middle: Compression Right: Extension
Pulleys Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach Use free weights to provide resistance In plantarflexion, pulley used to alter direction of force
Levers Consist of fulcrum, load, and effort Magnitude of effort based on distance from fulcrum Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach
Magnetism Use permanent magnet, electromagnet, or combination of both Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach
Motors AC Motor Ideal for fixed speed applications DC Brushed Motor DC Brushless Motor Speed controlled by adjusting amount of electrical current Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach Side View Front View
Elastic Bands Elastic bands provide resistive force tan = extra thin yellow = thin red = medium blue = extra heavy black = special heavy silver = super heavy gold = max Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach
Criterion for Pugh Chart Essential Cost, Safety, Strength Range, Range of Motion, Ability to Interface with Wii High Importance Durability, Train Both PF and DF Important Size, Weight, Ease of Setup, Ease of Use Other Strength Resolution, Train with Knee Extended, Train More than One DOF Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach
Pugh Chart Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach
Springs Pugh Results High score Cost ($1-$24) Safety Strength Range Low score Strength Resolution More than One Degree of Freedom Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach
Motor Pugh Results High Score Strength Range Range of Motion Train Both PF and DF Low Score Very Expensive ($122-$966) Safety Durability Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach
Chosen Design: Elastic Bands Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach Left: Iso View Top Right: Top View Bottom Right: Back View
Flex2Play Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach Limitations Does not reach maximum PF force value Variability among patients
Design Schedule Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach
Team Responsibilities Overview ○ Alternatives○ Analysis of Designs ○ Chosen Design ○ Our Approach Liz – Expressive Final Presentation Web Designer Research on Alternative Ideas Kelly – Analytical Preliminary Presentation Weekly Reports Research on Alternative Ideas DesignSafe Meet weekly with mentor Write and revise reports Conduct background research Provide feedback to group Amanda – Driver Progress Presentation Schedule Manager Research on Chosen Design
Works Cited Aisen, ML, et al. "Cerebral Palsy: Clinical Care and Neurological Rehabilitation." Lancet Neurology 10.9 (2011): Boley, B. L. (1997). Overview of Motor Types Tutorial. Retrieved October 23, 2011, from Compression Springs. 23 October Dynetic Systems. (n.d.). Brushless vs Brushed. Retrieved October 23, 2011, from Dynetic Systems: Pinneger, Gavin J and Andrew G. Cresswell. "Residual force enhancement after lengthening is present during submaximal plantar flexion and dorsiflexion actions in humans." Journal of Applied Physiology (2006): Simple Machine Elements. 23 October The Hygenic Corporation. (2006). Resistance Band & Tubing Instruction Manual. Akron, OH, USA. Torsion Springs. 23 October