Transformation: The Rubric Paradigm Gary Brown The Center for Teaching, Learning & Technology.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

What Does the Net Generation Expect From Us? SAC August 8, 2005 SAC August 8, 2005 Copyright © 2005, Joel L. Hartman. This work is the intellectual property.

Advertisements

NLII Focus Session Transformative Inklings and the Mystery of “Faculty Buy-In.” Gary Brown, Director The Center for Teaching, Learning, & Technology Washington.

Creating A More Educated Georgia Plagiarism Detection: Is Technology the Answer? USG Surveys Liz Johnson Project Manager Advanced Learning Technologies.

Ubiquitous Distributed Learning and Global Citizenship Michael Sperling, Associate Provost for Interdisciplinary, Distributed and Global Learning Fairleigh.

Copyright Statement Copyright Crit Stuart, This work is the intellectual property of the author. Permission is granted for this material to be shared.

An Online, Interactive Approach to Copyright and Intellectual Property Law Education EDUCAUSE Midwest, March 2007, Chicago Christine Greenhow, Ed.D. J.D.

Assessing the Effects of Virtual Communities of Practice on Professional Development 2003 AAHE Assessment Conference Darren Cambridge & Vicki Suter EDUCAUSE/NLII/AAHE.

Faculty Workshops Series

The Road to Distance Learning May Be Closer Than You Think….. Copyright Polley Ann McClure This work is the intellectual property of the author.

Assessing for Transformation Gary Brown The Center for Teaching, Learning & Technology.

Carolyn Awalt University of Texas at El Paso Paul Resta

Chatham College Community and Computers Pervasive Computing at a Liberal Arts College Charlotte E. Lott, Ph. D. Lynda Barner West, Ed. D. Copyright Charlotte.

National Research Agenda to Support Transformation National Learning Infrastructure Initiative Focus Session June, 2003 Copyright Jillian Kinzie, 2003.

NLII Mapping the Learning Space New Orleans, LA Colleen Carmean NLII Fellow Information Technology Director, ASU West Editor, MERLOT Faculty Development.

Copyright Copyright Chris Byrd and Jeff Farnham, This work is the intellectual property of the author. Permission is granted for this material to.

Developing Professional Leaders Georgia Institute of Technology Linda A. Cabot, Director, OIT/ITS EDUCAUSE Midwest Regional 2006 Copyright Linda A. Cabot,

“Transformative Assessment Case Study” June 20, 2003 Gloria M. Rogers, Ph.D. Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology Copyright [Gloria M. Rogers, Rose-Hulman.

The Need to Meet Accreditation Standards: A Systems Analysis of Technology Integration in Teacher Education Lincoln University of Missouri Division of.

Developing Online Degree Programs using a Collaborative Approach with Industry Experts as SMEs Copyright: Terry Norris This work is the intellectual.

The Team Approach: A Paradigm Shift for Designing Successful Online Courses NERCOMP 2005 College for Lifelong Learning, Manchester, NH.

A Balanced Scorecard is a Process Not Numbers MID ATLANTIC EDUCAUSE 2005 Saint Michael’s College Bill Anderson – Chief Information Officer Billie Miles.

Best Practices For Using Technology To Deliver Instructional Support Services Dr. Steven G. Sachs Northern Virginia Community College Copyright Steven.

Exploring Faculty Learning Communities: Building Connections Among Teaching, Learning and Technology Nugent, J., Smith, F., & Rhodes, J., Virginia Commonwealth.

The Influence of Intellectual Property Rights Over Distance Education Jonathan Alger University of Michigan April 17, 2002 Copyright Jonathan Alger, 2002.

Sharing Information and Controlling Content: Continuing Challenges for Higher Education Susanna Frederick Fischer Assistant Professor Columbus School of.

Making Big Classes Small: Penn State’s Blended Learning Initiative Renata Engel John T. Harwood January 30, 2006 Copyright Penn State, This work.

NERCOMP 2002, College for Lifelong Learning What Students, Faculty and the College are Learning about Teaching and Learning Online Managing the 24x7 Classroom.

Digital/e-Portfolios & Learning: From Mosaic to Kaleidoscope – Static to Dynamic EDUCAUSE 2005 Linda Ehley Alverno College.

Building the Integrated Learning Center Having the right people at the table Chris Johnson, Senior Consultant for Learning Technologies University of Arizona.

Issues Associated with ePortfolios in Small Colleges EDUCAUSE Mid-Atlantic Regional Conference 2006 Ed Barboni, Senior Advisor, Council of Independent.

Higher Education and the New International Imperative David Ward President American Council on Education Global Challenges and Higher Education Duke University.

The University of Texas at Dallas 1 Palm Pilot 2003 at UT Dallas EDUCAUSE Southwest Regional Conference February 26, 2004 Doug Jackson Daniel Calhoun Copyright.

The Real At Risk E-Content: University Web Resources EDUCAUSE Joanne Kaczmarek University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Taylor Surface OCLC October 12,

Copyright Copyright University of Washington This work is the intellectual property of the author. Permission is granted for this material to be.

Developing Professional Leaders Georgia Institute of Technology Linda A. Cabot, Director, ITS John Mullin, CIO, OIT Copyright Linda A. Cabot, This.

November 7, 2005EDUCAUSE Live1 An Eye to the Future with a Brief Look at the Past Jack McCredie UC Berkeley November 7, 2005 Copyright John W. McCredie.

George Mason University Assessing Technology Support: Using Portfolios to Set Goals and Measure Progress Anne Agee, Star Muir, Walt Sevon Information Technology.

Transformative Assessment: A Progress Report from NLII Vicki Suter, EDUCAUSE Stephen C. Ehrmann, TLT Group Gary Brown, WSU Joan Lippincott, CNI.

NLII05 Annual Meeting Professional Development of Faculty and Instructional Technology Staff through Communities of Practice University of Memphis: Technology.

Copyright [Dr. Michael Hoadley, Chat Chatterji, and John Henderson ] [2004]. This work is the intellectual property of the authors. Permission is granted.

EDUCAUSE 2006 Electronic Portfolios, A Perfect Solution to Assessment in an Online English Composition Course Dr. Mary Jane Clerkin Copyright Dr. Mary.

Integration is Critical for Success Curriculum Course Delivery Ongoing Support Instructor & Learner.

Improving the Social Nature of OnLine Learning Tap into what students are already doing Tap into what students are already doing Educause SWRC07 Copyright.

A Cat-Herding Tale Forging a Single Course Management System for a Decentralized Institution Copyright Abdul Shibli, 2004.This work is the intellectual.

1 Effective Incident Response Presented by Greg Hedrick, Manager of Security Services Copyright Purdue University This work is the intellectual property.

EDUCAUSE 2003 Copyright Toshiyuki Urata 2003 This work is the intellectual property of the author. Permission is granted for this material to be shared.

CATS in the Classroom Spring 2007 Faculty Workshops Series Dr Aziza Ellozy Center for Learning and Teaching Copyright Notice.

Creating an Agile and Responsive IT Organization Presented by Ohio University - Zanesville.

1 Top 10 Challenges of the Academic Technology Community John P. Campbell & Dennis A. Trinkle EDUCAUSE Live! Monday, May 21, :00-2:00 PM Copyright.

Copyright Linda Ehley & Kelly Talley, This work is the intellectual property of the author. Permission is granted for this material to be shared.

Legal Issues in the “E-Learning Business” Jonathan Alger University of Michigan October 29, 2001 Copyright Jonathan Alger This work is the intellectual.

Policies for Success on the New Learning Object Frontier Veronica Diaz, University of Arizona Patricia McGee, The University of Texas at San Antonio Copyright.

Mining User Data: Getting the Most out of your CMS John Fritz, UMBC.

COUNTING NEW FORMS OF SCHOLARSHIP TOWARD TENURE AND PROMOTION Peter Angelos and Linda Deneen University of Minnesota Duluth October 2010 This work is the.

Copyright James Kulich This work is the intellectual property of the author. Permission is granted for this material to be shared for non-commercial,

Chief Information Officer Effectiveness in Higher Education Wayne Brown, Ph.D. Copyright Wayne Brown This work is the intellectual property of the.

Copyright Michael White and Sylvia Maxwell, This work is the intellectual property of the author. Permission is granted for this material to be shared.

© Scottsdale Community College Leveraging the Power of E-Learning Taking your course to a higher level Presented by Sidne Tate Director, Instructional.

Top 10 Challenges of the Academic Technology Community Veronica Diaz, John Campbell, Dennis Trinkle Wednesday, October 24, :50 p.m. - 4:40 p.m.

Systemic Progress in Teaching and Learning Common Elements that Support Campus-Wide Innovation Copyright Andrea Nixon, A. Michael Berman, Christine Haile,

October 2006 Funded by JISC and ESRC to serve the UK academic and research communities. Voyage of the U.K. JISC Federation: Shibbolizing the U.K.'s Research,

Southeast Missouri State University

Malia Crouse Regis University January 22, 2009

Using Camtasia to Create Online Tutorials to Ease the Learning Curve

Ed Barboni, Senior Advisor, Council of Independent Colleges

Blaine A. Brownell, President,

Project for OnLine Instructional Support (POLIS)

myIS.neu.edu – presentation screen shots accompany:

An App A Day Copyright Tina Oestreich and Brian Yuhnke This work is the intellectual property of the author. Permission is granted for this material.

EDUCAUSE Networking 2002 Washington, D.C. April 17, 2002

Presentation transcript:

Transformation: The Rubric Paradigm Gary Brown The Center for Teaching, Learning & Technology

Copyright Statement Copyright Gary Brown, This work is the intellectual property of the author. Permission is granted for this material to be shared for non-commercial, educational purposes, provided that this copyright appears on the reproduced materials and notice is given that the copying is by permission of the author. To disseminate otherwise or to republish requires written permission from the author.

We should not expect the guidance for change of this magnitude—in institutional culture and values—to come from the faculty ranks. After all, faculty are deeply rooted in the traditional values of higher education. Fundamentally, this is a leadership issue. --Carole Barone, Vice President Educause

Student Enrollments in WSU Online Learning Spaces

The Goals, Activities, and Practices Invite faculty to join in the process of formulating the assessment. A series of two short, online surveys designed to provide formative assessment: one instructor survey and one student surveys.

The Assessment Gold Standard Participants Who Used Data to Inform Change

Transformation?

Rubrics—a road map AND a compass Help faculty grade student performance Help students understand expectations Provide measures of growth Help inform policy What is a rubric? The Rubric Paradigm

Critical Thinking and Measures of Growth Scant _____________________________ Substantial Identifies and summarizes the problem/question at issue (and/or the source's position). Does not identify and summarize the problem, is confused or identifies a different and inappropriate problem. Does not identify or is confused by the issue, or represents the issue inaccurately. Identifies the main problem and subsidiary, embedded, or implicit aspects of the problem, and identifies them clearly, addressing their relationships to each other. Identifies not only the basics of the issue, but recognizes nuances of the issue.

7 Dimensions of Critical Thinking 1.Identifies and summarizes the problem/question at issue (and/or the source's position). 2.Identifies and presents the STUDENT’S OWN perspective and position as it is important to the analysis of the issue. 3.Identifies and considers OTHER salient perspectives and positions that are important to the analysis of the issue. 4.Identifies and assesses the key assumptions. 5.Identifies and assesses the quality of supporting data/evidence and provides additional data/evidence related to the issue. 6.Identifies and considers the influence of the context * on the issue. 7.Identifies and assesses conclusions, implications and consequences.

Critical Thinking: one course/two semesters

One Particular Finding The faculty questionnaire revealed a singular focus on grading over fostering critical thinking for broader life-long learning. If we want our constituencies to value what we do, we might consider how to make what we do more valuable….

Dimensions of Transformation 1.Purpose 2.Data 3.Application 4.Dissemination Premise—”High Standards” is not the same as standardization

Criteria for Prioritizing Scoring Form Rater:Project: *Faculty*Designer *Student*Assessment Specialist *Community Colleague*Administrator *Other _________ Rating Assessment Purpose Data & Data Acquisition Application Dissemination Bonus—Faculty Rewarded for Assessment Total Score Comments: The Scoring Form

U#1U#2U#3U#4U#5Dimension Average Purpose Data Application Dissemination University Average Pilot Findings

Reviewers’ Suggestions U#1 Include faculty more in this process; audience is clearly the upper echelon of the institution and future employers.

Reviewers’ Suggestions U#2 Not many rewards for assessment. No feedback to faculty and students.

Reviewers’ Suggestions U#3 Assesses key concern: learning to learn. No plan to apply or fund results of findings. Faculty support neglected.

Reviewers’ Suggestions U#4 Assumes that tech alone causes transformation

Reviewers’ Suggestions U#5 Good start but…