Sustainable Investment Initiative Green & Climate Neutral BuildingsReduced Risk & Higher Valued Collateral Green Mortgages Cheaper Cost of Capital / Increased.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Who will invest in Green Real Estate? David Wood, Director Initiative for Responsible Investment Harvard Kennedy School of Government Co-Director, Responsible.
Advertisements

CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE Billions of 2005 Dollars Real Gross Domestic Product Gross Domestic Product (GDP): The total market value of goods and services.
Chapter 1 The Nature of Real Estate and Real Estate Markets Real Estate FIN 331.
Sustainability and the Dynamics of Green Building Nils Kok UC Berkeley Maastricht University John M. Quigley UC Berkeley Piet Eichholtz Maastricht University.
1 MOTIVATIONS AND TRENDS. Slide header copy In This Chapter >Sustainability in commercial property >Quantitative motivators >Qualitative motivators >Client.
Green Building Prepared By: Hui Chin, Wong. Build Green What is Green Building? Why Build Green? Rating Systems for Green Buildings Benefits.
Greg Kats, Capital –E Greening Our Built World Greg Kats, Capital –E, May 2010.
Mark Hopkins United Nations Foundation June 2009.
Creating New Opportunities
TRANSPORTATION DEMAND MANAGEMENT INSTITUTE (TDMI) – GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE ON MOBILITY MANAGEMENT PRESENT AND FUTURE European Conference on Mobility Management.
June 2011, ERES Eindhoven Piet Eichholtz Maastricht University Sustainable Buildings: Performance, Users, Investors.
Sustainable Investment Initiative Green & Climate Neutral BuildingsReduced Risk & Higher Valued Collateral Green Mortgages Cheaper Cost of Capital / Increased.
Sustainable Investment Initiative Green & Climate Neutral BuildingsReduced Risk & Higher Valued Collateral Green Mortgages Cheaper Cost of Capital / Increased.
Cost Benefit Analysis of LEED Green Building Design and Construction Tom Link Youngtao Shi Bill Morrow.
Chapter 20 Ownership Structures for Financing and Holding Real Estate © OnCourse Learning.
RenewAire is On the Move! New 35,000 SF facility.
“Real Estate Principles for the New Economy”: Norman G. Miller and David M. Geltner Chapter 11 Introduction to Investment Concepts.
The Value of Green Buildings New Evidence from the United Kingdom Andrea Chegut Maastricht University Finance Department
“Real Estate Principles for the New Economy”: Norman G. Miller and David M. Geltner Chapter 20 Commercial Real Estate Finance.
Green School Design Gary A. Jerue ED 846 Spring 2010.
The Impact of Energy Performance Certificates on the Rental and Capital Values of Commercial Property Assets: Some Preliminary Evidence from the UK Franz.
MTS: leading environmental groups, governments & companies Using high leverage activities to achieve 90% sustainable products market penetration by 2015:
Do Sydney tenants pay energy efficient office premiums? Jeremy Gabe & Michael RehmJuly 2013.
Green Condo Financing. Our role: Incubating climate solutions Established by City Council in 1991, TAF has provided $20 million in grants to the not-for-profit.
Michael Eckhart Managing Director Global Head of Environmental Finance Corporate & Investment Banking Citigroup Capital Markets, Inc.
Chapter 1 The Nature of Real Estate and Real Estate Markets Copyright © 2010 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
NEW YORK BANKERS ASSOCIATION Pennsylvania Credit Union Association Kevin W. Poirot Vice President May 23, 2008 Building Green: What You Should Know.
Research. Design. Build. Develop. Don Slaght Executive Vice President Workstage, LLC.
Using Life Cycle Resources to Look at a Product’s History from Cradle-to-Cradle Deborah Dunning, President International Design Center for the Environment.
Sustainable Textiles. DMJM Sponsored by: MTS is comprised of leading environmental groups, governments, & companies A nonprofit public charity.
Leveraging an Energy Plan Managing Energy to Reduce Operating Cost and Improve Building Valuation.
ENGAGING PRIVATE SECTOR INVESTMENT AT SCALE FOR CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION IN EMERGING ECONOMIES Insights from a GtripleC Project funded by the ASIAN DEVELOPMENT.
1 Chapter 01 Introduction to Financial Management McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2012 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Green, Energy and Buildings INSERT YOUR LOGO HERE.
Green Mortgage Backed Securities (MBS) MTS is comprised of leading environmental groups, governments & companies. It uses high leverage activities to achieve.
1 Sustainability and real estate investment performance Dr Paul McNamara OBE Head of Research, PRUPIM Co-Chair, UNEP FI Property Working Group SPR RESEARCH.
GREE BUILDING PRESENTED BY: Hector Landaeta Abdullah Namankani Marcos Soto.
*Green City “Briefing” presentation to the City Council Summer 2008 GCGC GCGC * Project Location is confidential.
Sustainability at NMSU A part of the integrated planning process.
© 2012 Cengage Learning. Residential Mortgage Lending: Principles and Practices, 6e Chapter 3 Role of Residential Mortgage Lending in the Economy.
Chapter 7 Commercial bank financial statement Salwa Elshorafa 2009 © 2005 Pearson Education Canada Inc.
McGraw-Hill © 2004 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin 1.0 Introduction to Financial Management Chapter 1.
ERES 2010 Arch. Simone Spreafico Engagement Director, Investment, Engagement Director, Investment, Advisory & Valuation Division Advisory & Valuation Division.
1 “Using Carbon Markets to Encourage the Uptake of Low Carbon Vehicles” Meeting the Low Carbon Challenge The Low Carbon Vehicle Partnership Third Annual.
Corporate Real Estate Investor view: implications of the change in user preferences on investment strategies Nick French Professor in Real Estate & DTZ.
Sustainable Building and Housing
Financial Management and Securities Markets
Electricity Transportation Heating Allocation of 6.2 GtC/yr Electricity: 40% Fuels used directly: 60% 60% of Global Carbon Reduction Needed in 5-10 yrs.
© zerofootprint 2005 © Zerofootprint 2007 Green Real Estate Workshop, Toronto Credit Risk and Capital Management Global Warming Real Estate Building What.
ENERGY STAR Webinar: Energy Efficient Mortgages (EEMs) 101 Brian Ng Lender Partnership Coordinator ENERGY STAR for Homes U.S Environmental Protection Agency.
Energy Efficiency Financing October 15, About Virginia Community Capital  Founded in 2006, then Governor Mark Warner privatized $15M state loan.
What is Sustainable Design? Southern Connecticut State University Residence Hall Designed for LEED Certification The goal of green or sustainable building.
Going Green Is it Worth it? Melbourne Convention and Exhibition Centre AIPC July 2010.
The Investment Function in Banking
Unit I - Personal Finance Building Wealth: Saving & Investing.
Commercial Real Estate and Hotel Industry: What is the Smart Money Saying and Doing? January 26, 2009.
Green Real Estate: An Introduction Source: The Green Revolution by Jerry Yudelson.
GREEN BUILD INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE & EXPO 2010 NOV 17, 2010 RD04: Public Housing Authorities as Sustainable Building Innovators.
SBA 504 Loan Program Long Term Fixed Asset Financing For Small Businesses.
Saving and Investing What’s the big deal?. What is the difference between saving and investing?
Planning for LEED ® © 2010 Project Lead The Way, Inc.Civil Engineering and Architecture Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design LEED ® and its related.
Assessing Geopolitical Economics in Securities A panel on the impact of economic and geopolitical forces.
Energy efficiency As first fuel
Unit 5 and 6 Financial Markets, Consumer/Personal Finance, Economic Indicators and Measurements.
Banking and the Management of Financial Institutions
Economics Unit 3 Investing and Saving
ASSET SECURITIZATION.
SMaRT© Consensus Sustainable Product Standard
Jorn van de Wetering, Franz Fuerst, Peter Wyatt
INTD409 Interior Environmental Technology Fall 2016/17
Presentation transcript:

Sustainable Investment Initiative Green & Climate Neutral BuildingsReduced Risk & Higher Valued Collateral Green Mortgages Cheaper Cost of Capital / Increased Liquidity Green Building SecuritiesGreen Convertible Securities Green Building Underwriting Standards Improves quality of life FSC Certified Wood Stops Illegal Logging & Irreversible Dangerous Climate Change

Capital Markets Partnership (CMP) - Partial List City of San Francisco City of Chicago City of Dallas City of Denver City of Miami City of New York City of Oakland City of San Jose City of Santa Monica City of Seattle

Capital Markets Partnership CMP Officers Green Building Underwriting Standards Committee EMERGENCY Consensus Standards Launched in April 2008 by JPMorgan Chase, Wells Fargo Wachovia. Unanimously Approved Sept. 2, 2008 & Amended Sept. 4, 2009 Market Tested by JPMorgan, Jones Lang LaSalle, CB Richard Ellis, Comerica, Transwestern. Officers Johanna Partin, Director, Climate Change Initiatives, San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom Steve Hoffmann, President, Hoffmann & Associates Rich Pietrafesa, Managing Director, Destiny USA Tomek Rondio, President, Mortgage Green Michael Schneider, Vice President, Marxa Kubo Mario Silvestri, Vice President, Wells Fargo Wachovia Ken Willis, Vice President & Director, Federal Home Loan Bank of Boston Dan Winters, Managing Principal, Evolution Partners

Develop / Finance / Occupy Green Buildings

Sustainable Investment Initiative Capital Markets Briefing Paper: Business Case for Commercializing Sustainable Investment © Summarizes four years of Wall Street due diligence with investors, investment banks & rating agencies concluding that green buildings and SMaRT certified sustainable products are: More profitable Less risky Preferred by investors in Survey initiated with S&P covering over $3.3 trillion in assets National statistically valid data Peer Reviewed Briefing Paper was released for top management at CMP New York Stock Exchange Press Conference, Aug. 18, 2009

Sustainable Investment Initiative Green Building Securities (GBS) are bonds backed by green building mortgages. GBS & Green Value Score are part of Rebuilding America’s call for 50 million green buildings in the next 10 years. There is substantial latent investor demand for GBS. Based on successful precedent, investment banks expect GBS Pilots to start a resecuritization of the building stock providing cheaper cost of capital for green building renovations facilitating: Refinancing addressing commercial real estate crisis Substantial climate pollution reductions Green jobs / economic stimulus Capital markets’ increased liquidity & confidence

Sustainable Investment Initiative Green Building Securities (GBS) LEED Certified Apartments have been identified as GBS candidates with leading financial institutions for pilot single property / asset securities. Moody’s & S&P has been briefed with Leading financial institutions and the method identified for Green Value Score © alignment with Moody’s financial factors for rating GBS Pools and potential higher ratings. Single asset Pilot GBS and pools are under development. Partners include DOE, the States, FHLB, Fed, House Financial Services, investment banks.

Sustainable Investment Initiative Green Value Score © Equity Loan Refinancing Program. Based on a property’s Green Value Score ©, commercial refinancing is available through the a program of CMP, Environmental Bankers Association, and TD Bank. There are about $500B in commercial loans that need refinancing in 2010 with very few options according to EBA and the Congressional Joint Economic Committee. The Program: is available for renovations too commits to have the appraisal fully reflect the added value from the Value Score

Electricity Transportation Heating Allocation of 6.2 GtC/yr Electricity: 40% Fuels used directly: 60% Green Building Securities (GBS) Carbon Reduction in 5-10 yrs Enhances Energy Security & Stops Imminent Irreversible Dangerous Climate Change Fossil fuel use in 2000 (IEA) Allocation of 6.2 GtC/yr. (Princeton) Buildings generate most of world’s climate pollution from electricity and heating. On average, certified green buildings have 40% less conventional energy & climate pollution.

Economic Benefits Projected* 70% US Commercial Green Building Market Penetration * Projected* 70% US Commercial Green Building Market Penetration * Energy Savings & Daylighting: $36 Billion/yr Construction Waste Reduction: $6.7 B/yr Water Pollution Savings from Water Conservation: $20 B/yr Energy Savings from appliances & Lighting: $24 B/yr Added Value from Increased Occupant Productivity Energy Savings & Daylighting: $36 Billion/yr Construction Waste Reduction: $6.7 B/yr Water Pollution Savings from Water Conservation: $20 B/yr Energy Savings from appliances & Lighting: $24 B/yr Added Value from Increased Occupant Productivity (5%), IAQ & Reduced Absenteeism: $632 B/yr Health Care Savings $75 B/yr Emission Reductions’ Market Value: $ 1.1 B/yr Total $795 Billion/yr. value added Emission Reductions’ Market Value: $ 1.1 B/yr Total $795 Billion/yr. value added * 1. Leonardo Academy / MTS Projections 2003, Surgeon General 2006 (certified bdgs). 2. Green retail buildings will also accrue increased retail sales. 2. Green retail buildings will also accrue increased retail sales. 3. Excludes overwhelming benefits from avoided climate damages, & originator profits. 3. Excludes overwhelming benefits from avoided climate damages, & originator profits. 4. Dollar benefits are $200B/yr. for UK, $200B/yr. for rest of Western Europe, $87B/yr. 4. Dollar benefits are $200B/yr. for UK, $200B/yr. for rest of Western Europe, $87B/yr. for Canada & $80B/yr. for Australia. GBS is a $4 trillion market (SEC 2003). for Canada & $80B/yr. for Australia. GBS is a $4 trillion market (SEC 2003).

LEED EB CERTIFIED National Geographic Society Headquarters, Wash., DC The Society added $16M in value from this LEED certification from a higher appraised value, raising tenant rents, lower operating costs, increased credit rating from Moody’s, & lower interest rates on large loans secured to the building. Presentation at 2003 Congressional Green Building Luncheon by Chris Liedel, CFO, National Geographic Society.

US Conference of Mayors Support Resolution June million green and climate neutral buildings & 1.2 million certified sustainable products needed by 2015 to prevent Dangerous Climate Change From going Irreversible

Stops Imminent Irreversible Unmanageable Dangerous Climate Change

Jim Hansen of NASA, the world’s leading climate scientist, speaking of business as usual stated, “[climate change] threatens not only the millions of species on the planet but also the survival of humanity itself--and the timetable is shorter than we thought…. Today’s climate is not terribly far from the runaway situation…. If the world does not make a dramatic shift in….policies over the next few years, we may well pass the point of no return.” (2009) Before It’s Too Late

UK – Stern Review – Nov ‘06 Report analyzes economic global impacts of climate change –“Business as Usual” vs. global innovation and market-based intervention –QUOTE: “Climate change…greatest and widest ranging market failure ever seen…” Relates costs/risks on economic, environmental, and social scales –Floods / Storms –Agriculture Yields –Fresh Water Access –Disease Bush White House 2008 Climate Report Concurs with these Impacts –Mass Human and Species Migration –Species Extinction –Heat Waves / Cooling / Doughts PROJECTED GLOBAL WARMING ECONOMIC IMPACT - Up to 20% of Global GDP

Occupancy Rates Energy Star Buildings vs Market Comparables Occupancy Rates – Office Source: CoStar Analytics

Occupancy Rates – Office Source: CoStar Analytics Down Market – Flight to Quality Energy Star Buildings vs Market Comparables

Rental Rates Energy Star vs. Market Comparables Direct Rental Rates – Office Source: CoStar Analytics Difference = $2.32 Difference = $3.80

Rental Rate Separation Doubled in Two Years From $2.30 to $4.60 Direct Rental Rates – Office Source: CoStar Analytics

LEED Certified Rental Rates vs Peer Group Early Returns on Minimal Data Points Source: CoStar Analytics

Occupancy Rates – Office Source: CoStar Analytics Occupancy Rate Superiority Significant Outperformance in Down Market

Academic Studies – Similar Results over 3,000 green buildings compared to their peers - statistically validated CoStar Building Peering Study (2007) Miller, Spivey, Florance (2008) –EPA Energy Star Partner of the Year –American Real Estate Society Best Paper 2008 CoStar Building Peering Study – Update 1 (2008) Fuerst and McAllister (2008) Eicholtz, Kok & Quigley (2008) CoStar Building Peering Study – Update 2 (2009) Pivo & Fisher (2009) Note: CoStar continues to make its data set available to academic researchers for further analysis

Green Building Underwriting Standard Principles 1.Performance based 1.Easy to analyze / simple to implement 1.Disciplined Tangible financial impacts showing green building attributes increasing cash flow Acknowledgement of intangible value 2.National Consensus Standard unanimously approved 1.Third-party verified & legally binding If you cannot measure, report, and verify…you cannot manage it.

CMP Score Distribution Properties with high CMP scores: Reduced exposure to conventional energy cost volatility Superior location attributes Reduced obsolescence risk Greater leasing prospects upon lease churn Reduced liability exposure to indoor air quality issues

CMP Green Score – Implementation Example 2000 Tower Oaks Blvd – Washington DC Suburban Office Washington DC SuburbsRockville Super Class A Office2008 LEED RatingPlatinum LEED Points48 pts Height9 Stories Gross SF198,000 Floorplate SF 23,000

2000 Tower Oaks – LEED Platinum

Implementation – 2000 Tower Oaks Capital Markets Partnership Green Score Formula Energy Star Score = 87 LEED Platinum Certified Some Proximity to Mass-Transit Energy / Water LEED Credits Various IEQ LEED Credits

Sustainable Manufacturing National Consensus Underwriting Standard CMP Corporate Green Value Score Value measured by increased share value Higher value at Silver, Gold & Platinum Levels Higher value for Green-e Power & Conventional Energy Reductions Higher value for higher reduction of pollutants Higher value for reuse – avoids disposal risks Covers multiple attributes & all products other than planes & vehicles Underwrites Green Convertible Securities (GCS) For manufacturers & retailers. GCS cover debt & equity. Launched at Aug. 19, 2009 MTS New York Stock Exchange Meeting

1511 Wisconsin Avenue NW Washington, DC