Diurnal Studies of Methane in the London Region The use of mixing ratio and automated stable isotope measurements from a fixed site to evaluate sources.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
High resolution fossil\industrial CO 2 : Historical Context Kevin Gurney Purdue University Department of Earth and Atmospheric Science Purdue Climate Change.
Advertisements

CO 2 monitoring and modelling across Greater London Lester Kwiatkowski.
Triple Oxygen Isotopes 11/1/10
Activity 2.3 Team CarboEurope-IP Meeting, Posen, Poland, 7-12 Oktober, 2007 Flask network (A 2.3) Multiple species measurement What is expected from A.
The atmosphere is warming. Source: IPCC AR4 Where does the excess heat go?
Measurements of methane emissions, methane oxidation and VSCs at Swedish landfills using FTIR spectroscopy Jerker Samuelsson Bo Galle Chalmers University.
Climate Change Science
Carole Helfter 1, Anja Tremper 2, Giulia Zazzeri 3, Simone Kotthaus 4, Janet Barlow 4, Sue Grimmond 4 and Eiko Nemitz 1. Sources of greenhouse gases and.
Three-State Air Quality Study (3SAQS) Three-State Data Warehouse (3SDW) 2008 CAMx Modeling Model Performance Evaluation Summary University of North Carolina.
Observations show that the increase of carbon dioxide is fully caused by human activities Pieter P. Tans NOAA Earth System Research Laboratory Boulder,
1.The effects of reduced tillage resulted in lower microbial R during the interval between fall plowing and the onset of winter. Carbon gain from the oats.
University of Leicester CityZen Contributions
Picarro Cavity Ring Down Spectrometry (CRDS) for High-Precision Continuous Monitoring of Atmospheric CO 2 and CH 4 Dave Lowry, Rebecca Fisher, Mathias.
Evaluating the Role of the CO 2 Source from CO Oxidation P. Suntharalingam Harvard University TRANSCOM Meeting, Tsukuba June 14-18, 2004 Collaborators.
The Anthropogenic Ocean Carbon Sink Alan Cohn March 29, 2006
S. Maksyutov, P.K. Patra and M. Ishizawa Jena; 13 May 2003 TDI experiment with NIES model and interannually varying NCEP winds.
January 10, 2006 Global and Regional Climate Change: Causes, Consequences, and Vulnerability Climate Science in the Public Interest
CAST: VOC observations from WAS using GC-FID and GC-MS Stephen Andrews, Jimmy Hopkins, Richard Lidster, Shalini Punjabi, Jamie Minaeian, Dene Bowdalo,
OTAG Air Quality Analysis Workgroup Volume I: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Dave Guinnup and Bob Collom, Workgroup co-chair “Telling the ozone story with data”
Atmospheric chemistry Day 5 Ozone and air quality Air quality and climate change.
Characterisation of mixing processes in the lower atmosphere using Rn-222 and climate-sensitive gases P. Schelander, A. Griffiths, A.G. Williams, S. Chambers.
Colorado Front Range Emissions Study Regional study of the impact of oil and gas operations on ambient hydrocarbon levels in the Northern Front Range based.
Mapping Greenhouse Gas Emissions in the Los Angeles Basin by Remote Sensing Using a Fourier Transform Spectrometer on Mt. Wilson Kam Weng (Clare) Wong.
Diurnal cycles of fossil fuel CO 2 : Comparison of model results with observations at Heidelberg and Schauinsland Felix Vogel 1 including work of: I. Levin.
Observational Evidence: Ozone and Particulate Matter EMEP SB, 13 September summary Chapter 2 Kathy Law LATMOS-CNRS,
Did the recession impact recent decreases in observed sulfate concentrations? Shao-Hang Chu, US EPA/OAQPS/AQAD October, 2011.
Observation and Modeling Evidence of Ozone Transport to and from Asia Hajime Akimoto (Oliver Wild and Pakpong Pochanart) Frontier Research Center for Global.
Effects of ploughing on land- atmosphere exchange of greenhouse gases in a managed temperate grassland in central Scotland. C. Helfter 1, J. Drewer 1,
InGOS – an integrating activity preparing for improved Greenhouse Gases monitoring over Europe Ingeborg Levin, Samuel Hammer, Dominik Schmithüsen, Ute.
TOP-DOWN CONSTRAINTS ON REGIONAL CARBON FLUXES USING CO 2 :CO CORRELATIONS FROM AIRCRAFT DATA P. Suntharalingam, D. J. Jacob, Q. Li, P. Palmer, J. A. Logan,
Indianapolis flux (INFLUX) in-situ network: quantification of urban atmospheric boundary layer greenhouse gas dry mole fraction enhancements 18 th WMO/IAEA.
Technical tool to evaluate the effectiveness of control measures I. ALLEGRINI and C. PERRINO Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche ISTITUTO sull’INQUINAMENTO.
CRAZ Ozone Analysis Xin Qiu, Ph.D., ACM, EP May 3 rd, 2011.
Fig.6a,b. Simulation of wind fields and toluene plumes on (a) May 12 and (b) May 13. Red dot is the beach site. Very low level of toluene was observed.
Trace that Nitrate An Overview of “Nitrate Stable Isotopes: Tools for Determining Nitrate Sources Among Different Land Uses in the Mississippi Basin” by.
Field research was conducted at the University of Minnesota Rosemount Research and Outreach Center. The experiment was conducted in a 17 ha agricultural.
Chapter 11 Orbital-Scale Changes in Carbon Dioxide and Methane Reporter : Yu-Ching Chen Date : May 22, 2003 (Thursday)
Diurnal Variations of CO 2 Emissions during CalNex-LA: Magnitude and Sources Sally Newman 1, Xiaomei Xu 2, Sergio Alvarez 3, Bernhard Rappenglueck 3, Christine.
Quantification of anthropogenic emissions from an urban region: First results of time-integrated flask samples from the Indianapolis Flux Project (INFLUX)
Sediment trap data. Constraining the seasonal particle flux in the eastern North Atlantic with Thorium isotopes M. Roy-Barman (1), R. El Hayek (1), I.
Page 1© Crown copyright 2004 The Hadley Centre The forcing of sea ice characteristics by the NAO in HadGEM1 UK Sea Ice Workshop, 9 September 2005 Chris.
August 1999PM Data Analysis Workbook: Characterizing PM23 Spatial Patterns Urban spatial patterns: explore PM concentrations in urban settings. Urban/Rural.
© Crown copyright Met Office Estimating UK and NW European CH 4 emissions using inversion modelling Alistair Manning with thanks to Simon O’Doherty & Dickon.
An attempt to quantify fossil fuel CO 2 over Europe Ute Karstens 1, Ingeborg Levin 2 1 Max-Planck-Institut für Biogeochemie, Jena 2 Institut für Umweltphysik,
INTERCONTINENTAL TRANSPORT OF OZONE AND ITS SEASONAL VARIATIONS IN EUROPE Dick Derwent rdscientific 2 nd ICAP Workshop Chapel Hill, North Carolina October.
Evaluation of CO and SF 6 as quantitative tracers for fossil fuel CO 2 : The Experimentalists’ view Ingeborg Levin 1, Ute Karstens 2, Ulrike Gamnitzer.
OVERVIEW OF ATMOSPHERIC PROCESSES: Daniel J. Jacob Ozone and particulate matter (PM) with a global change perspective.
Evapotranspiration Estimates over Canada based on Observed, GR2 and NARR forcings Korolevich, V., Fernandes, R., Wang, S., Simic, A., Gong, F. Natural.
Figure 1: Global time series plots of CH 4 and δ 13 C of CH 4 from The recent rise in CH 4 is concurrent with a decrease in δ 13 C of CH 4.
Quantifying the decrease in anthropogenic methane emissions in Europe and Siberia using modeling and atmospheric measurements of carbon dioxide and methane.
Regional scale N 2 O fluxes in eastern and central Amazônia: Monica T.S. D’Amelio Luciana Vanni Gatti John B. Miller Pieter Tans.
Emission source sampling and monitoring Topic 6 Ms Sherina Kamal May
The Use of Natural Abundance of 13 CO 2 to Determine Soil Respiration Components in an Agro-Ecosystem a School of Environmental Sciences, University of.
Detection and Quantification of Atmospheric Boundary Layer Greenhouse Gas Dry Mole Fraction Enhancements from Urban Emissions: Results from INFLUX NOAA.
A second, but different NBL case Seasonal Variation Diurnal Variation Continuous Tower-Based Ozone Measurements L.C. Patrick 1, S.J. Oltmans 2, J.C. Williams.
List of the measurements performed at Mace Head:
Top Down Emission Analyses Theme 17 th GEIA Conference Nov. 19, 2015 Alex Guenther Department of Earth System Science University of California, Irvine.
Spatial and temporal dynamics of atmospheric pollutants in London, UK. Carole Helfter, Eiko Nemitz, Chiara Di Marco, Ben Langford, Neil Mullinger, Ute.
Quantification of emissions from methane sources in Indianapolis using an aircraft-based platform Maria Obiminda Cambaliza 1, Paul Shepson 1, Brian Stirm.
August 1999PM Data Analysis Workbook: Characterizing PM23 Spatial Patterns Urban spatial patterns: explore PM concentrations in urban settings. Urban/Rural.
MOCA møte Oslo/Kjeller Stig B. Dalsøren Reproducing methane distribution over the last decades with Oslo CTM3.
Evaluation of pollution levels in urban areas of selected EMEP countries Alexey Gusev, Victor Shatalov Meteorological Synthesizing Centre - East.
Yuqiang Zhang1, Owen R, Cooper2,3, J. Jason West1
Conclusions on methanol controls
Colin Michel1, C. Amelynck3, M. Aubinet1, A. Bachy1, P. Delaplace2, A
Atmospheric CH4 and N2O measurements at Suva, Fiji
Alexey Gusev, Victor Shatalov, Olga Rozovskaya, Nadejda Vulyh
Title Why do we underestimate Elemental Carbon in PM?
Victoria Schoenwald Undergraduate Program
Presentation transcript:

Diurnal Studies of Methane in the London Region The use of mixing ratio and automated stable isotope measurements from a fixed site to evaluate sources Rebecca Fisher, David Lowry, Srimathy Sriskantharajah and Euan G. Nisbet Department of Earth Sciences, Royal Holloway, University of London, Egham, Surrey, TW20 0EX, UK. AGU Fall Meeting, 10 th – 14 th December 2007

Outline CH 4 monitoring in the London region In situ CH 4 stable isotopic analysis using CF-IRMS Diurnal studies of methane  13 C Diurnal and seasonal variations in the methane source mix Implications for emissions inventory verification

Location of the Royal Holloway air monitoring site 30 km WSW of centre of London, in Egham, Surrey Air inlet 15 m above local ground, 45 m above London basin

Methane mixing ratio at Royal Holloway, Egham CH 4 mixing ratio monitored since 1995 Measured at 30-minute intervals using HP 5890 GC-FID, current precision (±3 ppb) Calibrated to the NOAA 04 scale Decline of approximately 9 ppb/year over the last decade Monthly mean CH 4 mixing ratio in Egham

Mace Head Egham Comparison of methane mixing ratio at Egham and Mace Head CH 4 mixing ratio Egham – Mace Head (plotted by K. Masarie, NOAA) Question: Question: Which sources have changed to drive the decrease in methane mixing ratio measured in SE England? Decline in the excess of CH 4 mixing ratio in SE England’s air over Atlantic Mace Head air, on average -5.5 ppb/year. SE England methane emissions flux is growing more slowly than the background and appears to be decreasing in absolute terms. Larger changes occurred in the late 1990s. Since then, UK methane emissions appear to have been nearly static anomaly – heatwave across Europe

London Atmospheric Emissions Inventory 2003 Methane SourceEmission Tonnes/yr Typical δ 13 C (‰) Road transport Gas consumption Industrial (gas) Oil Sewage ± ± 3 (North Sea gas) -37 ± ± 3 TOTAL Emissions data from LAEI, published by the Greater London Authority,  13 C = [(R sample -R ref )/R ref ] x 1000 ‰ where R= 13 C/ 12 C. C reference is V PDB. Norlands Lane landfill site, 4 km from Royal Holloway Another large source not included in the inventory: Landfill site emissions, -53 ± 4‰. Most landfills in the Greater London area are now closed, but many continue to emit methane.

Requires 60 litres of air per analysis. Offline combustion of CH 4 followed by dual inlet mass spectrometry. Each analysis takes 2-3 hours to complete. Data precision is very high, 0.03‰ repeatability. Methane  13 C Monitoring (I) Conventional Offline Extraction / Dual Inlet Method Methane extraction line PRISM MS Technique described in Lowe et al., JGR Atmos, 1991.

Methane  13 C analysis (II) Continuous Flow GC IRMS Continuous flow techniques generally offer: Smaller sample volume Faster analysis time so higher sample throughput Convenience of automation …but usefulness may be limited by the precision obtained. GV Instruments’ Trace Gas connected to IsoPrime Mass Spectrometer in continuous flow set-up. 75 mL of air for atmospheric samples. 16 minute analysis time. Changes made to automate inlet and improve precision (repeatability) to 0.05‰ for CH 4  13 C analysis. See Fisher et al., Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry, 2006.

Automated valve inlet: Up to 3 tanks/sample bags can be connected up and automatically analysed. Or outside air pump connected and outside air analysed every 30 minutes. Developments made to the Trace Gas at Royal Holloway Furnace catalyst: Complete oxidation of CH 4 to CO 2 is a key step. Different catalysts tested. High precision using palladium powder on quartz wool catalyst at 790ºC.

Methane  13 C monitoring – diurnal studies High CH 4 mixing ratio recorded under inversion – typically still, anticyclonic conditions. Methane  13 C measured at intervals throughout the night. Used to calculate the mixed source signature of regional sources. This technique has been used in other urban areas to assess CH 4 sources, e.g. Heidelberg, Germany (Levin et al., 1999). Diurnal studies were carried out at Royal Holloway during events in 1996 – L SS tanks filled to 8 bar, collected at 2 hour intervals, analysed using offline extraction and dual inlet mass spectrometry (Lowry et al., JGR Atmos., 2001). Since 2003 the automated continuous-flow Trace Gas system has been used for diurnal studies.

Hot dry summer of 2003, high temperatures across Europe. Wind direction from East to North- east (London direction). Diurnal study 4 th -5 th August 2003 Keeling plot: Mean overnight source signature: ± 0.7‰, i.e. dominated by biogenic sources.

Diurnal variation in source signature Isotopically enriched methane coincides with morning and evening rush hours and times when domestic boilers would be turned on Diurnal cycle of CH 4 mixing ratio - background (2005)  13 C source signature (2005 diurnals)

Seasonal variation Mean overnight (22:00 – 06:00)  13 C source signature during diurnal studies and mean monthly CH 4 mixing ratio recorded at Royal Holloway in 2005 CH 4 more depleted in 13 C during the summer months - biogenic CH 4 production higher. Enrichment in 13 C during the autumn. Increased fossil fuel emissions.

Comparison between diurnal studies in 1996 and 2005 Considering the London sector (45 to 110º): In 1996: mean CH 4  13 C source signature was ± 0.3‰ (Lowry et al., 2001). In 2005: mean CH 4  13 C source signature was ± 0.7‰. Likely to have been caused by a substantial decrease in emissions from gas leaks in recent years. This supports inventory estimates for London (LAEI) inventory: Tonnes/yr CH 4 from natural gas inventory: Tonnes/yr CH 4 from natural gas.

Emissions inventory verification 2003 LAEI inventory suggests a methane source signature of -35.9‰. From the diurnal studies: 1996 measured value of -48.7‰ indicates source of 77% biogenic (landfill/sewage) and 23% fossil fuel (e.g gas leaks) measured value of -50.1‰ indicates source of 85% biogenic and 15% fossil fuel. If the source signature measured at Egham is typical of the source signature for London, then current inventory estimates are missing 167 kTonnes / year of biogenic source (e.g. landfill at -53‰). This is an overestimation: the Egham site is closer to some biogenic sources (local landfills and ruminants) than is typical of the London area - future diurnal studies in central London are planned to measure the central London methane source signature.

Quantifying regional methane emissions: the radon tracer method 222 Rn, emitted at uniform rate from soils, builds up under inversion layer. Assume radon flux of 60 Bqm -2 h -1 (mean flux for European soils – Eckhardt, 1990). Methane also builds up under the inversion – measure concentrations of 222 Rn and CH 4 → calculate the CH 4 emission rate. Mean emission rate in 2005 calculated using this technique: 1.21 (± 0.69) g(CH 4 ) km -2 s -1, equivalent to 94 ktonnes/yr for London. Higher than London inventory estimate of 34 kT/yr - could account for the missing biogenic source implied in isotope studies. Correlation between CH 4 and 222 Rn, 10 th to 12 th August monthly averages of CH 4 emission rate calculated using the radon tracer method

Conclusions Long-term monitoring of CH 4 mixing ratio and  13 C from a single well- placed site can provide valuable insight into emissions from a region. Results from the Royal Holloway site have highlighted the seasonal and diurnal variability of CH 4 sources in the London region and suggested that biogenic sources such as landfill sites have a larger influence on methane emissions than implied in the London Atmospheric Emissions Inventory. Reduction in methane emissions in the London region over the last decade appears to have been due to decreased emissions from gas leaks or other fossil fuel sources. The instrumentation has the capability of being run continuously to get a half hourly record of methane  13 C. This could be useful at either a moderately polluted site to evaluate regional emissions, or combined with back trajectory analysis at a background site to consider changes in sources over a larger area. Acknowledgements: Meth-MonitEUr