Implantable Cardioverter-Defibrillators in VHA and Healthcare Cost Growth: 2001-2010 Peter W. Groeneveld, M.D., M.S. Philadelphia VAMC University of Pennsylvania.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Diabetes Quality of Care among Nursing Home New Admission Cohort Charlene C. Quinn, RN, PhD Assistant Professor University of Maryland School of Medicine.
Advertisements

Hospital Volume and 30-day Mortality following Hospitalization for Acute Myocardial Infarction and Heart Failure Joseph S. Ross, MD, MHS Mount Sinai School.
IntroductionMethods (continued)Results (continued)Strengths and Limitations Background Pharmacologic treatments are efficacious in reducing post-myocardial.
Implementation of Medicare Part D and Nondrug Medical Spending for Elderly Adults With Limited Prior Drug Coverage Haiden Huskamp PhD, J. Michael McWilliams.
Coding for Medical Necessity
Technology Diffusion, Hospital Variation, and Racial Disparities Among Elderly Medicare Beneficiaries: Peter W. Groeneveld, MD, MS Sara B. Laufer,
Costs of chronic kidney disease USRDS 2008 Annual Data Report.
FATE: Family Assessment of Treatment at End-of-life David J Casarett MD MA CHERP, Philadelphia VAMC Division of Geriatrics University of Pennsylvania.
Use of Primary Care in VA and Medicare among VAMC and CBOC Patients Chuan-Fen Liu, MPH PhD HERC Cyber Seminar September 17, 2008.
MEDICARE: PAST, PRESENT AND F UTURE James G. Anderson, Ph.D. Department of Sociology & Anthropology.
Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillator Rebecca Boduch Biomedical Engineering University of Rhode Island.
INTRODUCTION Polypharmacy and Distinctive Demographics of Congestive Heart Failure Patients Seenu Abraham 1, Peter Vayalil 1, Sagar Patel 1, Tim Quinn.
INTRODUCTION TO ICD-9-CM
Standard 5: Patient Identification and Procedure Matching Nicola Dunbar, Accrediting Agencies Surveyor Workshop, 10 July 2012.
David Card, Carlos Dobkin, Nicole Maestas
Memorial Hermann Healthcare System Clinical Integration & Disease Management Dan Wolterman April 15, 2010.
Clinical Effectiveness of Implantable Cardioverter-Defibrillators Among Medicare Beneficiaries With Heart Failure Adrian F. Hernandez, MD, MHS; Gregg.
Implementing Medicare Hospital Payment Systems
Spatial Econometric Model of Healthcare Spending Garen Evans MISSISSIPPI STATE UNIVERSITY LOCAL!
A Structural Misclassification Model to Estimate the Impact of Non- Clinical Factors on Healthcare Utilization Alejandro Arrieta Department of Economics.
Demonstration of a Process- Outcome Link for Smoking Cessation Melissa M. Farmer, PhD 1,2 Elizabeth M. Yano, PhD 1,2 Brian S. Mittman, PhD 1,2 Scott E.
1 Estimating non-VA Health Care Costs Todd H. Wagner.
What do we know about overall trends in patient safety in the USA? Patrick S. Romano, MD MPH Professor of Medicine and Pediatrics University of California,
Integrating Clinical Data Warehouses: How Can Multi- System Care for Older Veterans Be Measured Consistently? AcademyHealth Annual Research Meeting Tuesday,
What is Clinical Documentation Integrity? A daily scavenger hunt.
Veterans Using and Uninsured Veterans Not Using VA Health Care Karin Nelson, MD, MSHS Gordon A. Starkebaum, MD Gayle E. Reiber, PhD, MPH VA Puget Sound.
Medicare Coordinated Care Demonstration May 13, 2003.
US Department of Veterans Affairs Hip Fractures in VA/Medicare-Eligible Veterans: Mortality and Costs Elizabeth Bass, PhD, 1 Dustin D. French, PhD, 1 Douglas.
Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development Day for Night: Hospital Admissions for Day Surgery Patients in California, 2005 Mary Tran, PhD, MPH.
THE URBAN INSTITUTE Examining Long-Term Care Episodes and Care History for Medicare Beneficiaries: A Longitudinal Analysis of Elderly Individuals with.
Fee Basis & NPPD Data Mark W. Smith, Ph.D. August 3, 2005 Health Economics Teleconference Seminar access code
Demographics and Associated Costs of Dying for Enrolled Veterans Preliminary Findings James Breckenridge, PhD James Hallenbeck, MD Co-Principal Investigators.
THE EFFECT OF A HEART ASSIST DEVICE CLINICAL STUDY ON HOSPITAL REFERRALS AND REVENUES Background From May 1998 to July 2001, chronic end-stage heart failure.
Mark W. Smith July 28, 2010 Fee Basis Data. Overview of Fee Basis Program Pays for care at non-VA facilities when –it is the only source available, or.
Medicaid Per Capita Costs for Persons with Disabilities Five Slide Series, Volume 5 October
Hospital Safety: Do race and ethnicity matter? Ernest Moy, MD, MPH Elizabeth Dayton, MA Roxanne Andrews, PhD The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.
1 Patterns of Quality for Patients with Three Chronic Conditions Stephen M. Davidson, Ph.D. Michael Shwartz, Ph.D. Randall S.Stafford, M.D. Academy of.
Do veterans with spinal cord injury and diabetes have greater risk of macrovascular complications? Ranjana Banerjea, PhD 1, Usha Sambamoorthi, PhD 1,2,3,
© 2011, KAISER PERMANENTE CENTER FOR HEALTH RESEARCH Which Data Source Provides More Complete Information for Assessing Preventive Care Utilization in.
Chuan-Fen Liu, PhD MPH HERC Cyber Seminar January 16,
Primary Care Continuity and Health Care Expenditures in a Depressed Sample of Florida Medicaid Recipients Andrea M. Lee, M.S. Robert G. Frank, Ph.D. Zoe.
Prior studies have demonstrated racial/ethnic differences in access to innovative cardiovascular technologies. Background and Objectives Conclusions Data.
The Quality of Reporting on Race & Ethnicity in Medicare Data: Assessing the Effect of Improved Coding Ernest Moy, Linda G. Greenberg Center for Quality.
Teaching Intensity, Race and Surgical Outcomes Jeffrey H. Silber The University of Pennsylvania The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia.
Does Managed Care Affect Quality? Appropriateness, Referral Patterns and Outcomes of Carotid Endarterectomy Ethan A. Halm, MD, MPH Depts of Medicine and.
Comparing the Effectiveness of Carotid Stent Systems versus Endarterectomy Peter W. Groeneveld, MD, MS Assistant Professor of Medicine Philadelphia Veterans.
“SEVERE MENTAL ILLNESS & CONGESTIVE HEART FAILURE OUTCOMES AMONG VETERANS” by Jim Banta UCLA Committee members: Alexander Young, Gerald Kominksi, William.
A Comparison of Quality of Care in General Hospitals, Specialty Hospitals, and Ambulatory Surgery Centers Cheryl Fahlman, PhD Phil Kletke, PhD Chuck Wentworth,
Cost of Readmission: Can the VHA Experience Inform National Payment Policy.
The Impact of Cost Sharing on Middle-Income Children AcademyHealth Annual Research Meeting June 2008 Amy M Lischko.
Cost Drivers of Cancer Care: Medicare and Commercially Insured Populations Pamela Pelizzari April 1, 2016.
Chapter 2 An Overview of the US Healthcare System Copyright 2015 Health Administration Press1.
Risk Factors for Lower Extremity Ulcer in the Morbidly Obese Diabetics Elly Budiman-Mak MD, MPH, MS. 1,2 Min–Woong Sohn, Ph.D. 1,3 Rodney M. Stuck, DPM.
Foot surveillance was associated with reduced risk of major amputation among patients with diabetes Chin-Lin Tseng, DrPH 1,2 ; Drew Helmer, MD, MS 1,2.
Intersecting roles CMS and FDA – implications for pharmaceutical and device industries Peter B. Bach, MD, MAPP Senior Adviser, Office of the Administrator.
Clinical Terminology and One Touch Coding for EPIC or Other EHR
Transition to Value Based Payment
These slides highlight a presentation at the Late Breaking Trial Session of the American College of Cardiology 52nd Annual Scientific Sessions in Chicago,
Home Health Remote Patient Monitoring For Heart Failure
FY13 Budget and Caseload Update Fiscal Committee October 1, 2012
Use of BCBSRI Primary Care Provider Profile to Improve Performance
White River Junction, Vermont VA Outcomes Group REAP
Chapter 6: Health Expenditures for Persons with CKD
The Latest Trends in Income, Assets, and Personal Health Care Spending Among People on Medicare November 2015.
ICD-10 Updates.
Chapter 7: Healthcare Expenditures for Persons with CKD
VA can improve older enrollees' outcomes by directing private sector care to high performance hospitals William B Weeks, MD, MBA 1-4 Alan N West, PhD.
Heart Failure Currently, an estimated 5.7 million Americans are living with heart failure. An additional 670,000 new cases are diagnosed annually, up.
Registered Nurse’s Use of HIT, 2006: Findings from a National Survey
Presentation transcript:

Implantable Cardioverter-Defibrillators in VHA and Healthcare Cost Growth: Peter W. Groeneveld, M.D., M.S. Philadelphia VAMC University of Pennsylvania

Acknowledgements Diane Richardson, PhD Elina Medvedeva, MS C. Brent Roberts, BS QUERI RRP Award # VA CHF QUERI

Conflicts of Interest No relationships to disclose

Background/1 Implantable cardioverter-defibrillators (ICDs): »Class IA guideline-recommended therapy since 2005 for patients with chronic heart failure (CHF) and reduced left ventricular ejection fraction

Background/2 Chronic heart failure (CHF) is common among veterans over age 65 Large numbers of veterans are likely ICD- eligible Unknown how many VHA-enrolled veterans with CHF have received ICDs during the past decade

Background/3 ICDs are costly to implant (>$30,000 in device cost alone) and to monitor Unclear how ICDs have impacted VA’s health care costs Likewise uncertain how ICDs implanted outside VA among veterans enrolled in VHA ultimately impacted VA’s costs of care

Study Objectives/1 To identify the total number of dual-enrolled (i.e., Medicare and VHA) veterans who received ICDs during To quantify the fraction of veterans with ICDs who received devices at VA (vs. outside) To determine the number of veterans living with an ICD who receive ongoing device care at VA

Study Objectives/2 To determine costs of VA health care attributable to ICD implantation and ongoing device care To measure the rate of VA ICD implantation among historically disadvantaged groups of veterans

Data VA national administrative data from (Medical SAS datasets) VA Fee Basis data VIReC VA-Medicare merged data (inpatient/outpatient facility claims and physician claims)

Identifying implantation and continuity care in VA data Implantation identified by relevant ICD-9 or CPT codes in the VA’s hospitalization, surgery, procedure, or fee-basis administrative datasets ICD continuity care identified by »1 relevant ICD-9 or CPT code on an outpatient administrative record after a confirmed implant, or »2 distinct outpatient entries with relevant codes for patients with no prior documented implant

Identifying implantation and continuity care in Medicare data ICD implantation identified by the relevant ICD-9 or CPT codes in Medicare hospitalization or outpatient facility claims ICD continuity care identified by: »1 relevant ICD-9 or CPT code on an outpatient claim subsequent to a confirmed implantation, or »2 distinct outpatient claim with relevant codes for patients with no prior documented implant

Cost attribution Costs of VA health care were estimated using HERC’s Average Cost Datasets using 1-to-1 matches between Medical SAS and ACD records, added to Fee-Basis paid costs ICD implantation costs included the hospital costs of implant plus any other ICD-related encounters within 30 days of implant ICD continuity costs included all ICD-related costs outside of the implant window

Identifying Race and SES Veterans’ race determined from Medicare enrollment data Veterans’ socioeconomic status (SES) approximated by median income (2000 U.S. Census) from veterans’ residential ZIP code Veterans living in ZIP codes from the lowest 25 th percentile median income (population- weighted) were identified as low-SES

ICD Implants in the VHA,

Total Veterans Receiving ICD-related VA Healthcare,

% of ICD Implants Among Dual- Eligible Veterans Occurring in VA

Origin of Veterans’ ICDs Among veterans receiving regular ICD continuity care in VA from : 26% originally received ICD in VA 34% received ICD outside VA covered by Medicare 40% had no prior ICD implantation record in either VA or Medicare data

Per-patient ICD Implantation Cost (2010 $thousands), $50.5K $64.6K, (P=0.01)

Per-patient ICD Continuity Care Cost (2010 $), P=NS

Total VA Health Expenditures on ICD- Related Care (2010 $millions), $43 million $166 million

ICD Implant Rates in Black Veterans: VA and Medicare % Hosp CHF veterans--black Medicare Implants 10.6% 13.4%, p=0.03

ICD Implant Rates in SES Veterans: VA and Medicare % Hosp CHF Veterans Low-SES Medicare Implants 31% 28%, p=0.02

Conclusions – Volume of Care VA ICD implant rates increased substantially from , but plateaued from at approximately 2,250 implants/year The number of unique veterans with ICDs who receive care in VA annually has increased steadily throughout the last decade; these veterans now number ~30,000 Sizeable numbers of veterans with ICDs had their devices implanted outside VA

Conclusions - Costs Average VA inflation-adjusted cost of ICD implantation increased significantly from $50,500 in 2001 to $64,600 in 2010 Total VA expenditures on ICD care increased markedly, from $43 million to $166 million from At least $14 million in annual VA healthcare costs result from ICD care for veterans who did not receive their devices in VA

Conclusions – defibrillators for minority veterans The % of VA ICD recipients who were black increased significantly from 2001 to 2008 VA implanted ICDs in a higher % of black veterans than in the Medicare program VA’s black ICD-implant % in 2008 approximates the % of VA’s hospitalized CHF patients who are black

Conclusions – Defibrillators for low- SES veterans The % of VA ICD recipients who were from low-SES ZIP codes decreased slightly from 2001 to 2008 VA implanted ICDs in a higher % of low-SES veterans than in the Medicare program Low-SES ICD implant rates in VA were comparable to the % of low-SES veterans hospitalized with CHF

Limitations VA records may not accurately capture all ICD implantations (e.g., contracted care) Cost attribution to ICDs was inexact—these patients often have multiple chronic conditions and thus it is possible costs were measured with error There are no indicators of appropriate use of ICDs in either VA or Medicare data, thus it is uncertain if ICDs were underused or overused

Impact of these findings on VA ICDs were a source of significant cost growth that was unlikely to have been anticipated in 2001 Despite growing volume of ICD care and high costs, there are no widely available sources of VA data about clinical appropriateness/ outcomes of VA’s ICD implants VA often inherits the care (and costs) of implantable technology from other health systems

VA’s Technology Imperative Costly implantable devices are likely to continue to be introduced as routine components of high-quality care VA must balance the need to practice state- of-the-art medicine with the imperative to limit healthcare spending on technology VA must likewise ensure that disadvantaged veterans continue to receive high-technology care equal in quality to other veterans

Summary ICD implantation rates and the # of veterans who receive routine defibrillator care have risen dramatically in VA during past decade VA’s ICD-related healthcare costs have also risen sharply over time VA appears to be delivering equitable high- technology care to disadvantaged populations