L ECTURE 2: W HAT IS P HILOSOPHY ?. T OPIC R ECAP.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Knowledge as JTB Someone S has knowledge of P IFF: 1. S believes P 2. S is justified in believing P 3. P is true.
Advertisements

FATE v. FREE WILL. Fatalism The idea of fatalism coincides with destiny. This means that everything in our lives is predestined by fate. In other words,
Asian Philosophy Lecture 1.
WHAT IS THE NATURE OF SCIENCE?
Value conflicts and assumptions - 1 While an author usually offers explicit reasons why he comes to a certain conclusion, he also makes (implicit) assumptions.
Genesis on a laptop God’s operations from the beginning.
L ECTURE 3: R EASONING AND L OGIC. R ECAP In our previous lecture we: 1.Looked at the origins of philosophy a)Investigated Thales’ metaphysical theory.
Best Practice Precepts [... next] Arguments Arguments Possibility of the Impossible Possibility of the Impossible Belief, Truth, and Reality Belief, Truth,
3. Jan 23. Socrates. Chapter 4 esp p Ignorance and Wisdom Jan 25. Plato. skim Chapter 5. Forms, allegory of cave. Aristotle Jan 27. Logic primer:
Introduction to Philosophy
Some Methods and Interests. Argument Argument is at the heart of philosophy Argument is at the heart of philosophy It is the only method for getting results.
Is there a rational basis for the belief in God..
© 2005 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved. Chapter 1 Explaining Behavior.
First Essay Feedback These Essays were graded liberally as I figured there would be issues.
The Problem of Knowledge. What new information would cause you to be less certain? So when we say “I’m certain that…” what are we saying? 3 things you.
Chapter 1 The Nature of Science
TRUTH AND SPIRITUALITY What do we mean when we say something is true? This has more than one answer Depending on who you ask A scientist will provide.
Knowledge & Faith Dr. Carl J. Wenning Department of Physics Illinois State University.
CHAPTER 3 RESEARCH TRADITIONS.
Section 2: Science as a Process
Looking at the Roots of Philosophy
Questions You may not “double-dip” in regards to the HSP/REC requirement Must specify class when signing up Cozby as an e-book? Different section with.
Chapter 13 Science and Hypothesis.  Modern science has had a profound impact on our lives— mostly for the better.  The laws and principles of science.
HZB301 Philosophy Room 158 Mr. Baker.
BIOLOGY THE SCIENCE OF LIFE AND THE GOD OF LIFE. GOD AND SCIENCE In Biology we see all sorts of amazing things, as well as a lot of disease, death, and.
Why Does Anything at all Exist? Why is there something rather than nothing? Leibniz - the principle of sufficient reason.
WHAT IS THE NATURE OF SCIENCE?. SCIENTIFIC WORLD VIEW 1.The Universe Is Understandable. 2.The Universe Is a Vast Single System In Which the Basic Rules.
The Nature of Scientific Knowledge. Goal of Modern Science… …to understand and explain how the natural world works. Science only gives us descriptions.
L ECTURE 6: D ESCARTES. L ECTURE O UTLINE In today’s lecture we will: 1.Become introduced to Rene Descartes 2.Begin our investigation into Descartes’
The Natural Philosophers
Philosophy 224 What is a Theory of Human Nature?.
L ECTURE 4: P LATO. T ODAY ’ S L ECTURE In today’s lecture we will: 1.Begin our investigation into the question of reality (metaphysics) 2.Briefly consider.
Introduction to Earth Science Section 2 Section 2: Science as a Process Preview Key Ideas Behavior of Natural Systems Scientific Methods Scientific Measurements.
THE PRESOCRATIC SOPHOS Men have talked about the world without paying attention to the world or to their own minds, as if they were asleep or absent-minded.
Why Does Anything at all Exist? Why is there something rather than nothing? Leibniz - the principle of sufficient reason.
Philosophical Aspects of Science Soraj Hongladarom Department of Philosophy Faculty of Arts.
What is Materialism?.
Introduction to Philosophy Lecture 1-a What is philosophy? By David Kelsey.
Someone might wonder…. What am I? What is consciousness? Could I survive my death? Am I a puppet of destiny or do I have my own free will? Does the world.
Research for Nurses: Methods and Interpretation Chapter 1 What is research? What is nursing research? What are the goals of Nursing research?
False Assumptions 2012/03/25/false-assumptions-lesson/
Humanism is a philosophy of life based on concern for humanity in general and for the individual in particular. It is a view of life which combines thinking.
Introduction to Philosophy
Scientific Methods in Earth Science. What You Will Learn  Explain how scientists begin to learn about the natural world.  Explain what scientific methods.
Philosophy An introduction. What is philosophy? Ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle said that philosophy is ‘the science which considers truth’
What Is Science?. 1. Science is limited to studying only the natural world. 2. The natural world are those phenomena that can be investigated, discovered,
Chapter 1 Introduction to Research in Psychology.
Proof of God? Inquiries into the Philosophy of Religion A Concise Introduction Chapter 12 Faith and Reason By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright © 2012 Glenn.
Lecture 5: Plato.
World Philosophy Mr. Zuercher. What is philosophy? ▪ Philosophy is critical and creative thinking about fundamental questions. – What is a person – What.
PHILOSOPHY AS A SECOND ORDER DISCIPLINE
Introductory Class. Course code/course title GST 113 LOGIC, PHILOSOPHY AND HUMAN EXISTENCE.
Introduction to Philosophy Descartes’ First Meditation
WHAT IS THE NATURE OF SCIENCE?
PHILOSOPHY AS A SECOND ORDER DISCIPLINE
Starter: Mix-Pair-Share
What is Philosophy?.
Methods and Interests.
PHILOSOPHY OF HUMAN PERSON
What is Scientific Literacy?
WHAT IS THE NATURE OF SCIENCE?
Theory of Knowledge Review
WHAT IS THE NATURE OF SCIENCE?
Question 1: INSTRUCTIONS Each person will answer the questions. If you get it right, you get the points. If you get it wrong, you get a strike.
The Foundations of Ethics
The Nature of Scientific Knowledge
What is a Theory of Human Nature?
Philosophy of science is as useful to scientists as ornithology is to birds.
Introductory Class.
Somethings are fairly straightfoward
Presentation transcript:

L ECTURE 2: W HAT IS P HILOSOPHY ?

T OPIC R ECAP

What is Philosophy? Philosophy involves the activity of asking questions Philosophy asks questions about itself (Meta-Philosophy) Philosophers seek to build theories and explanations Philosophy is NOT a science Philosophers Primarily deal with Open Concepts Philosophy involves making arguments

T OPIC R ECAP Who Does Philosophy? Not Just academics/students/professors/people wearing togas Anyone that asks a philosophical question We are all capable of being philosophers, it just depends on the questions we ask and how we look at them Why should we do philosophy? Perhaps it is in our nature to ask philosophical questions. Some philosophical questions are important. Some questions are wholly philosophical and there is no other way of looking at them or avoiding them. Philosophy can be a powerful tool and can help us learn valuable skills. Self-Improvement

T OPIC R ECAP How do we do Philosophy? Philosophy involves formulating arguments There are many different means of making philosophical arguments (comic books, letters, paintings, essays, film, literature, music, poetry etc. etc.)... To be continued

W HAT IS P HILOSOPHY ?

T ODAY ’ S L ECTURE In today’s lecture we will: 1.Look at the origins of philosophy 2.Discuss in further detail the differences between science and philosophy 3.Discuss the methodological differences between science and philosophy 4.Conclude by discussing the value of philosophy

T HE O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY The origins of philosophy and science The natural sciences were originally a part of philosophy (Prior to figures such as Galileo and Newton) Before modern science there was little, if any, distinction to be made between the natural sciences, mathematics, astrology, and philosophy. Science and philosophy are distinct spheres of inquiry But their shared origins suggest that there are some crucial similarities between science and philosophy Where did Philosophy come from?

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY Thales of Miletus Lived 580 B.C.E. Regarded as the first philosopher in the Western tradition Thales formulated the first metaphysical theory Believed that everything was composed of water

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY Thales’ Metaphysical Theory Observation (O) The Nile, unlike almost every other known river, dries up in the winter and floods in the summer. Hypothesis (H1): O is caused by the wind.

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY Thales’ Metaphysical TheoryQuestion: What is everything composed of? Hypothesis (H2): Everything is composed of water.

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY An alternative to Thales’ metaphysical theory Observation (O): The Nile, unlike almost every other known river, dries up in the winter and floods in the summer. Hypothesis (H3): O is caused by the will of the Gods.

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY Thales’ Hypothesis in contrast to his Predecessors Hypothesis (H1): The Nile’s flooding and drying up is caused by the wind. Hypothesis (H2): Everything is composed of water. Hypothesis (H3): The Nile’s flooding and drying up is caused by the will of the Gods.

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY Hypothesis (H1): The Nile’s flooding and drying up is caused by the wind. Hypothesis (H2): Everything is composed of water. Hypothesis (H3): The Nile’s flooding and drying up is caused by the will of the Gods. Natural Phenomena Thales’ Hypothesis in contrast to his Predecessors Supernatural Events

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY The significance of Thales’ Question Question: What is everything composed of? Assumptions: 1.Despite the numerous changes we observe, something must remain constant for change to be possible 2.The world is composed of many different things; the concept of difference is logically dependent on the concept of sameness 3.The human mind is capable of knowing and fathoming what the one behind the many is Why is this question significant? Thales was the first to maintain the belief that reality is composed of one thing

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY Discussion: 1. In what way, if any, is Thales’ theory of reality similar to the theories endorsed by modern natural scientists? 2.In what way, if any, is Thales’ theory distinct from his peers and predecessors? 3.How does Thales’ come to his conclusion that everything is composed of water?

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY Mythical Thinking ( Mythos ) Thales’ predecessors used supernatural and mythical explanations to account for natural phenomena Mythical thinking maintains that everything can be traced back to gods and supernatural events Mythical explanations often begin ‘Once long ago...’ Mythical explanations are often unhistorical, unchanging, and are handed down from generation to generation within a culture

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY An example of mythical thinking: Once when ‘Care’ was crossing a river, she saw some clay; she thoughtfully took up a piece and began to shape it. While she was meditating on what she had made, Jupiter came by. ‘Care’ asked him to give it spirit, and this he gladly granted. But when she wanted her name to be bestowed upon it, he forbade this, and demanded that it be given his name instead. While ‘Care’ and Jupiter were disputing, Earth arose and desired that her own name be conferred on the creature, since she had furnished it with part of her body. They asked Saturn to be their arbiter, and he made the following decision, which seemed a just one: ‘Since you, Jupiter, have given its spirit, you shall receive that spirit at its death; and since you, Earth, have given its body, you shall receive its body. But since ‘Care’ first shaped this creature, she shall possess it as long as it lives. And because there is now dispute among you as to its name, let it be called ‘ homo’, for it is made of out humus (earth).’ Martin Heidegger, Being and Time, Trans & Ed. John Macquarrie & Edward Robinson. (New York: Harper & Row, 1962), p. 242

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY Thales’ Thinking Thales employed reasoning and rational thinking ( logos ), as opposed to mythical thinking ( mythos) Rationalism “The view that affirms reason, with its interest in evidence, examination, and evaluation, as authoritative in all matters of belief and conduct” () “The view that affirms reason, with its interest in evidence, examination, and evaluation, as authoritative in all matters of belief and conduct” (Miller, Ed L. Questions that Matter, ) Examples of rational thinking include: SciencePhilosophyMathematics Natural Theology Thales traces natural phenomena back to their ontological roots

O RIGINS OF P HILOSOPHY Two Quick Definitions: Nonrational: A nonrational claim is one that is justified, if at all, through an appeal to something other than or different from reason. Authority, feeling, intuition, religious illumination, mystical experience and the like are all nonrational justifications. Irrational: An irrational claim is contrary to reason. There are two forms of irrational claims. 1.A claim that flies in the face of everything we would expect from history, experience, and nature. 2.A claim that could not conceivably be true: it involves a self-contradiction and is therefore logically impossible. (Miller, Ed L. Questions that Matter, p.13)

S CIENCE AND P HILOSOPHY

Similarities between Science and Philosophy? In what way are science and philosophy similar? Both science and philosophy promote reason and rationalism as authoritative, particularly over mythical modes of thinking Both are seeking knowledge Both are attempting to formulate explanations Both proceed by appealing to evidence, examination and evaluation

S CIENCE AND P HILOSOPHY What is the difference between science and philosophy? What knowledge does science seek? Knowledge of the natural, physical world Science seeks to arrive at closed concepts and theories How does science proceed? Empirical research Depends on quantifiable evidence Formulates and tests theories to explain natural phenomena The scientific method (observation, control and experimentation) Uses scientific tools (test tubes, laboratories, microscopes)

S CIENCE AND P HILOSOPHY What is the difference between science and philosophy? What knowledge does philosophy seek? Knowledge of the world (not just restricted to the natural world) Primarily investigates open concepts Knowledge of the human experience How does philosophy proceed? Discussion Critical thinking Tests the logic and validity of arguments, concepts and theories Conducts rational investigations into objects and concepts that cannot be investigated empirically

S CIENCE AND P HILOSOPHY Closed Concepts: What is a Triangle? A closed shape with three sides and three angles that equal 180 0

Open Concepts What is Time? What is Truth? Time saving truth from falsehood and envy, François Lemoyne, What is Justice? Justice, Luca Giordano, S CIENCE AND P HILOSOPHY

What is a Mammal? A Warm-Blooded Vertebrate MammalsNot Mammals

Everything is Water! Oh No it Isn’t! Nothing Changes but Change Itself! (Heraclitus) Err... If you say so! Not everything can be examined scientifically!

S CIENCE AND P HILOSOPHY What is This? Is it a duck or is it a rabbit?

S CIENCE AND P HILOSOPHY What is This? a)Square suspended in a frame b)Lampshade seen from above c)Lampshade seen from below d)Looking into a tunnel e)Aerial view of a truncated pyramid Some questions do not have any definite answers but are still valid questions!

C ONCLUSION

T OPIC R ECAP What, How, and Why do we do Philosophy? Philosophy involves the activity of Critically and Rationally thinking about the question it asks Philosophy involves formulating arguments Philosophy has a wider investigative and methodological scope than science Examines questions and formulates theories that science is unable to investigate: Is lying wrong? Does god exist? Is the scientific method valid? Philosophy of.. [insert discipline] Philosophy can be useful tool for critically examine the assumptions implicit in other systems of thought Remember: Philosophy like any tool has a limited role and application!

D ISCUSSION

Questions for Discussion: 1.Is the distinction between mythical and rational thinking valid? Or does modern science constitute another form of myth-making? 2.Could science do without philosophy or vice versa? 3.Can philosophy be scientific? 4.Can science be philosophical?