A Comparative Policy Analysis on Stock Market, Money Supply and Interest Rates in US, China and Australia during 2000 – 2011 DOLY HAN, BRITTANY HARRISON, TENZIN TUSNDU, JENNA BROOKS ECO /30/2013
Introduction Understanding GDP’s relationship to economic variables is crucial to policy makers Important component in ensuring effective macro- economic stability policies Stronger Relationship >>> More Attention when developing policies to grow GDP Comparative Analysis for years between 1. China 2. United States 3. Australia Why these countries??
Variables Selected Real Gross Domestic Product Money Supply -----M2 for US & China -----M3 for Australia Stock Market Total Share Prices for all shares Discount Rate Gathered from FRED website
Regression Analysis Test 1 or -1 = Perfect Correlation ----If correlation is closer to 1 or -1 = Stronger Relation Negatively Correlated >> Variables Have Inverse Effect Ie. If Variable A Increases that causes Variable B to decrease Po sitively Correlated >>> Variables move in the same direction Ie. If Variable A Increases that causes Variable B to Increase
China GDP’s correlation with Money Supply (M2)=.994 ^^^ Very Strong Positive Correlation GDP’s correlation with Share Price=.596 ^^^ Moderate Positive Correlation GDP’s Correlation with Discount Rate=.144 ^^^ Weak Positive Correlation
United States GDP’s correlation with Money Supply (M2)=.898 ^^^ Very Strong Positive Correlation GDP’s correlation with Share Price=.696 ^^^ Strong Positive Correlation GDP’s Correlation with Discount Rate= ^^^ Weak Negative Correlation GDP Money Supply(M2) Share Prices Federal Fund Rate GDP 1 Money Supply (M2) Share Prices Federal Fund Rate
Australia GDP’s correlation with Money Supply (M2)=.970 ^^^ Very Strong Positive Correlation GDP’s correlation with Share Price=.699 ^^^ Strong Positive Correlation GDP’s Correlation with Discount Rate= ^^^ Weak Negative Correlation
Comparative Analysis of Correlations GDP & Money Supply China:.994 Australia:.970 United States:.895 Money Supply is important tool in conducting monetary policy Policies are placed to control money supply to keep GDP growing ie: US open market operations Why is the United States lower?
Comparative Analysis of Correlations GDP & Share Prices China:.596 Australia:.699 United States:.696 All positive & moderately strong GDP & Discount Rate China:.144 Australia: United States: All very weak relationships
Comparative Analysis of Correlations Discount Rate & Money Supply China:.064 >>>> Very Weak Australia: >>>> Weak United States: >>>> Moderately Strong
Conclusions More factors play a role but all things held constant all three countries have similar correlations Evident that some of these macro-economic variables do have strong effects on GDP and play a key role in the stabilization of the economy When growing GDP--- We assume policymakers would focus a great deal on… Stock market ---- Money Supply (Monetary Policy)
Questions??