1 Gender and Pension Reform— what policies matter and what would we like to know? by Estelle James Presented at World Bank ECA Workshop, January 2008.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Gender Issues in Pension Systems By Estelle James Prepared for Women and Pensions Workshop, Paris, March 2010.
Advertisements

Gender Issues in NDC Plans By Estelle James Prepared for the conference on NDC plans, December 2009.
What Other Countries have Done: Issues for Government and Providers Presented at IIF conference, Dublin, November 2006 By Estelle James.
Disability benefits in an individual account system by Estelle James FIAP conference, 2007.
Issues in survivors’ insurance Estelle James World Bank Pension Mini-Course, 2011.
Comments on “The Effect of Social Security Auxiliary Spouse and Survivor’s Benefits on the Household Retirement Decision” by David Knapp Courtney Coile.
Coverage in the Chilean Pension System Solange Berstein– Chair IOPS Technical Committee Pensions Supervisor, Chile IOPS Regional Workshop Amman, Jordan.
Aging Seminar Series: Income and Wealth of Older Americans Domestic Social Policy Division Congressional Research Service November 19, 2008.
Women, Taxes and Social Security Income Taxes Social Security.
Keeping Seniors Connected to the Labor Market Benefits to working longer Work patterns and trends at older ages Work impediments at older ages.
The Impact of Chile’s Pension System on Work Propensities of Men and Women: Alejandra Cox Edwards and Estelle James, MRRC Workshop
Controversy 9 What Is the Future for Social Security?
Nonfinancial Defined Contribution Schemes in a Changing Pension World Eds.: Robert Holzmann, Edward Palmer & David Robalino Edward Palmer Swedish Social.
Pension Analysis and the PER Richard P. Hinz, Adviser, HDNSP Anita M. Schwarz, Lead Economist, ECSHD April 2007.
Lesson 16 Investing for Retirement. Key Terms  401(k) Plan  Annuity  Defined-Benefit Plan  Defined- Contribution Plan  Employer- Sponsored Retirement.
Impact of the Financial Crisis on Pension Systems in LAC Waldo Tapia Labor Market Unit Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) OECD/IOPS GLOBAL FORUM ON.
Group 6.  Definition: a plan for setting aside money to be spent after retirement. ◦ Individual retirement account (IRA )  contribute a limited yearly.
Chapter 9 – Social Insurance I: Social Security and Unemployment Insurance Public Economics.
1 Design features of an IA System: What Can We Learn from Other Countries? By Estelle James.
1 The Gender Impact of Pension Reform—What Is It and Why? by Estelle James Presented at University of Lund, September 2006.
The United States Social Security System “Nuts and Bolts” October 11, 2006.
© 2008 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. 3/1/2008 LCN Understanding Deferred Annuities.
11/27/2007 Pension Reforms in China and Taiwan Hongxia Jiao Yi-Ying Chen.
The United States Social Security System “Nuts and Bolts” October 2, 2007.
Work Disincentives for Women in Old Age Security Systems (and how to ameliorate them) By Estelle James Prepared for the World Bank, June 2010.
Chile’s 2008 re-reforms: what are they and what are the implications? By Estelle James, Alejandra Cox Edwards & Augusto Iglesias MRRC Research Workshop,
Taxes, Inflation, and Investment Strategy
Minimum Pension Guarantee in Poland Zofia Czepulis-Rutkowska Seminar for social security actuaries and statisticians: actuarial aspects of pension reform.
The fiscal costs of ageing in the euro area: will the young have to pay the bill? Ad van Riet Head of the Fiscal Policies Division European Central Bank.
Payout choices in Chile: what are they are why? (and comparisons with Singapore) by Estelle James,
Pension Systems in Times of Financial Crises: Serbia
1 Pension Challenges and Pension Reforms in OECD Countries Peter Whiteford Social Policy Division OECD
Key Social Security Policy Choices in Thailand by Estelle James.
Criteria for Evaluating Social Security Systems in Thailand By Estelle James.
A presentation for the Women’s Institute for a Secure Retirement February 28, 2008 Barbara D. Bovbjerg Director Education, Workforce, and Income Security.
The Payout Stage in Chile and Singapore--and implications for older women by Estelle James.
Privatizing Social Security Under Balanced-Budget Constraints: A Political-Economy Approach Assaf Razin and Efraim Sadka.
Sarosh Sattar November 28, 2011 Europe and Central Asia Region The World Bank.
Pension Reform: What Can the United States and Australia Learn from Each Other? by Jon Forman Alfred P. Murrah Professor of Law University of Oklahoma.
Lessons from LAC reforms Parallels with Chile’s next generation reforms Carolin A. Crabbe Sr. Financial Specialist, Infrastructure and Financial Markets.
A centrist solution to social security’s problems By Estelle James.
Design features of an IA System: What Can We Learn from Other Countries? By Estelle James.
The Role of Annuities in Public Retirement Systems Jeffrey R. Brown Presentation to World Bank May 3, 2002.
Do Individual Accounts Postpone Retirement? Evidence from Chile Alejandra C. Edwards and Estelle James.
Social Security: Where Are We? Where Are We Going? Melanie Griffin.
Removing the Disincentives in Social Security for Long Careers October 20, 2006 Gopi Shah Goda, Stanford University John Shoven, Ph.D., Stanford University.
1/1 World Economic and Social Survey 2007 Development in an Ageing World Canadian Institute of Actuaries Montreal 15 April 2008 Rob Vos Director Department.
Social Security Spouse and Survivor Benefits for the Modern American Family Melissa M. Favreault and C. Eugene Steuerle The Urban Institute August 10,
Modeling Health Reform in Massachusetts John Holahan June 4, 2008 THE URBAN INSTITUTE.
Chapter 5: Social Security Chapter 5 Social Security Copyright © 2009 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Gender and Labor Market Issues Workshop Capacity Building for Implementation of the GAP in ECA by Sarosh Sattar Senior Economist October 23, 2008.
1 The Gender Impact of Pension Reform—What Is It and Why? By Estelle James.
Chapter 8 Finances and Economics. Table 8.1 Older Population’s Average Annual Income © 2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.
20 CHAPTER Social Security PUBLIC SECTOR ECONOMICS: The Role of Government in the American Economy Randall Holcombe.
Impact of Social Security Reform on Labor Force Participation: Evidence from Chile Alejandra C. Edwards and Estelle James Presented at AEI, November 2009.
Political Economics Riccardo Puglisi Lecture 6 Content: An Overview of the Pension Systems Distinguish Features Economic and Political Explanation A Simple.
Mitchell Wiener 15 December 2011 ILO Expert Meeting Social Security and Social Protection Floor Pension Reform in Indonesia.
The Swedish Public-Private Mix in Pensions Eskil Wadensjö Swedish Institute for Social Research.
Measuring Political Risk of Hungarian Social Security System Is there a really good reform? Juraj Kopecsni.
Chapter 15 Economics of Aging (c) 2005 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Changing employment relations & reforms of social security systems.
A Inter-regional Trade Union Training on Social Security Gender and Social Protection Social Protection Programme ITC- ILO July 2010 Presented by.
TRENDS AND CHALLENGES IN SOCIAL SECURITY: LESSONS FROM LATIN AMERICA Andras Uthoff Independent consultant. Ex Officer in Charge Social Development Division.
Redistributive Impact of Pension Systems Anita M. Schwarz Lead Economist Europe and Central Asia Region World Bank.
Changing world of work & reforms of social security systems
“The Future of Social Security”
Pension Challenges and Pension Reforms in OECD Countries
OECD REPORT PREVENTING AGEING UNEQUALLY
Disability benefits in an individual account system
A Inter-regional Trade Union Training on Social Security
Presentation transcript:

1 Gender and Pension Reform— what policies matter and what would we like to know? by Estelle James Presented at World Bank ECA Workshop, January 2008

2 What is the impact of pension reform on women vs. men? Recent pension reforms in LAC, ECA region and OECD include 2 pillars: –Privately managed individual accounts that link benefits more closely to contributions –Downsized public benefit for risk diversification and safety net –Critics argue that close B-C link hurts women We studied this in Latin America and found positive impact on relative position of women. Similar studies in ECA, Sweden have different results. Why? What design features determine gender impact? Do women behave differently from men in response to new system?

3 Why the gender difference in pensions? (labor market) Low labor force participation rates, more household work –Women work half as much as men, in L.Am. –Often part-time work Low wages (2/3 as much as men) So if benefits depend on contributions and contributions depend on wages and work, women get low benefits Women allowed to retire earlier than men (60/65) -policy exacerbates low work history

4 Why gender differences? (demography) Women live 3-5 years longer than men and are younger than husbands, become widows Household income may fall by 70%, yet expenses only fall by 30-35% (household economies of scale) Husbands often make financial decisions, don’t save and insure enough for wives, so non-pension resources used up Very old widows often pockets of poverty

5 Our methodology New systems don’t have retirees yet and absolute benefits in old systems were unsustainable We constructed synthetic work histories of representative men and women using hh surveys We applied rules of new and old systems to simulate future benefits for young workers average vs. 10 year vs. full career (FC) women workers in 5 different educational groups We compared relative (not absolute) positions of men and women in new and old systems

6 We found: Women’s monthly pension from own account is only 30-50% that of men—very unequal But other transfers double this amount –Public benefit adds disproportionately to low earners (mainly women) –Joint pension raises lifetime income of married women more than public benefit –Both set floor on income of very old women So average married woman gets 70-80% as much as men over her lifetime; full career married women get more than men Must take all parts into account; policies can accentuate or mitigate labor market differences

7 Gender ratios trebles due to public benefit, joint pension, more work

8 Building blocs (1) individual accounts Lower wages, work, retirement age Workers get back their contributions + interest, no redistribution Gender-specific mortality tables used Monthly annuity 30-50% that of men –higher on lifetime basis Would increase by 50% if retirement age equalized (more interest, fewer years)

9 2) Redistributive public benefit In LAC targeted to low earners (women). Raises female/male pension ratio –Minimum pension in Chile--sets floor for contributors –PASIS sets meant-tested floor for non-contributors –Social quota in Mexico—flat payment per day of work –Flat benefit in Argentina for 10 yr contributors Northern Europe— universal flat or min. pension— higher coverage, cost ECA (NDC, BD)-- more work-related, less redistributive to women Key issues: –What mix of poverty avoidance, work incentives, cost? –How to handle non-contributors, informal economy? –Indexation—to prices or wages?

10 (3) Survivors benefit, joint pension Survivors benefits important to women because they live longer, have lower wealth and incomes, if husband dies hh income falls more than costs In LAC, husbands must purchase joint pensions Enforces implicit family contract re hh division of labor after husband’s death (family co-insurance) –Big income to widows, no cost to public treasury –Adds 50-80% to lifetime own-pension –Keep own+joint pension (no work disincentive) –Avoids controversial unisex issue, subsidy to middle class married women Survivors benefit downsized but joint pension not required in ECA, Sweden—looming problem

11 Own annuity public benefit

12 Women’s position improved in new system. Which women? Women gained relative to men, especially: –Low earners due to public benefit –Married women, especially those who work--keep joint annuity + own pension –Full career women (flat age-earnings profiles) Mixed results for: –Women who worked 10 years or less--low own pension, sometimes not eligible for public benefit –Single and divorced women—no joint pension Single men also gained because they don’t have to pay tax to finance widow’s benefit

13 Different impact in transition economies (East & C. Europe) Wage inequality is growing, so accounts unequal Public benefits less targeted toward low earners Survivors’ benefit reduced to save money Policies re joint annuities not yet clear Many single and divorced women Earlier allowable retirement age hurts women more in new systems Therefore new systems appear to increase gender inequality in pensions in transition economies Detailed design features matter a lot

14 How to increase and share growth dividend among women: Equalize retirement ages and get rid of other policies that discourage women’s work –increases GDP, raises women’s pensions –earlier retirement is example of myopia that mandatory system are supposed to counteract Consider more redistributive public benefit –to help women, low earners, informal sector –partial wage indexation once costs are under control Require joint pensions –In Europe survivors’ benefits downsized to save money, but this inevitably hurts older women (poverty is high) –Joint pension protects widows, no cost to public treasury –women keep own + joint pension (no work disincentive) Share assets in case of divorce

15 Research on how pension reform changes behavior of M and W In Chile old and new systems co-exist and retrospective data set built so we study impact of new system on behavior, which affects outcomes: –Does new system postpone pension age for M&W? –Does it postpone withdrawal from labor market because work restrictions removed, exemption from payroll tax? –Which retirees choose annuitization? –Do M and W make different risk-return investments? –How well informed are M and W about new system? We found: Women less likely to annuitize, have smaller LS impact. M and W have very limited information. Can comparable studies be done for ECA?