Evidence-Based Guidelines Affecting Policy, Practice and Stakeholders (E-GAPPS) December 10, 2012 New York, NY Joanne Schottinger, MD Assistant Medical.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Making Payment Reforms Work for Patients and Families Lee Partridge Senior Health Policy Advisor National Partnership for Women and Families January 28,
Advertisements

The Advanced Medical Home ACP Attributes of Advanced Medical Home Evidence-based care/clinical decision support Chronic care model approach for all patients.
CANCER SCREENING 2011 DELAWARE CANCER EDUCATION ALLIANCE STEPHEN S. GRUBBS, M.D. HELEN F. GRAHAM CANCER CENTER DELAWARE CANCER CONSORTIUM OCTOBER 5, 2011.
©PPRNet 2014 Designing a PPRNet PCORI Application to Improve Adherence to USPSTF Grade D Recommendations for Cancer Screening.
The Rhode Island Chronic Care Sustainability Initiative: Building a Patient-Centered Medical Home Pilot in Rhode Island.
April 2009 Netta Conyers-Haynes, Principal Consultant, Communications Kaiser Permanente National Guideline Program Implications of IOM SR Standards Wiley.
Department of Vermont Health Access Vermont Blueprint for Health: Using APCD to Evaluate Health Care Reform Pat Jones, MS Blueprint Assistant Director.
Clarity, consent and coverage for research-related injuries 6 th Annual Columbia University IRB Conference Boston, MA Patrick Taylor Children’s Hospital.
HOW STANDING ORDERS HELPED US IMPROVE CANCER SCREENING: REPORT FROM A NEW PPRNet MEMBER JULIO A SAVINON, MD RIO GRANDE MEDICINE INC. HARLINGEN, TX.
Hospital Pharmacy Payam Parchamazad, PharmD Staff Pharmacist
COMING UP ROSES: CULTIVATING A CONTINUUM OF SERVICES FOR PREVENTION, DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT OF FETAL ALCOHOL SPECTRUM DISORDERS IN THE GARDEN STATE Susan.
April 2009 Netta Conyers-Haynes, Principal Consultant, Communications Kaiser Permanente National Guideline Program (NGP): Implications of IOM CPG Standards.
Clarity, consent and coverage for research-related injuries 6 th Annual Columbia University IRB Conference Boston, MA Patrick Taylor Children’s Hospital.
Cancer Program Standards 2012: Ensuring Patient-Centered Care
Consulting Services Our core consulting services focus on government and commercial health programs from both sides: our provider-physicians and health.
Geriatric Health Maintenance: Cancer Screening Linda DeCherrie, MD Geriatric Fellow Mount Sinai Hospital.
BREAST AND CERVICAL CANCER CONTROL PROGRAM Emily Vance Nursing 250.
Component 1: Introduction to Health Care and Public Health in the U.S. 1.5: Unit 5: Financing Health Care (Part 2) 1.5d: Controlling Medical Expenses.
Keith J. Mueller, Ph.D. Director, RUPRI Center for Rural Health Policy Analysis Head, Department of Health Management and Policy College of Public Health.
Proposed Cross-center Project Survey of Federally Qualified Health Centers Vicky Taylor & Vicki Young.
CSI-RI: Community Health Team Planning Workgroup 11/8/13.
A STRATEGIC APPROACH TO THE REALLOCATION OF RESOURCES BASED ON THE SOUNDNESS OF INTERVENTIONS GERTRUDE BOURDON, CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER DANIEL LA ROCHE,
Essential Service # 7:. Why learn about the 10 Essential Services?  Improve quality and performance.  Achieve better outcomes – improved health, less.
Time Tested Guideline Development and Implementation : The Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement (ICSI) Collaborative Process © 2007 Institute for.
Implementation of an evidence-based cancer screening program for an urban disabled population Ryan Goetz BSCh Lewis Cancer & Research Pavilion at St. Joseph’s/
Overview Community Care of North Carolina. Our Vision and Key Principles  Develop a better healthcare system for NC starting with public payers  Strong.
SustiNet Board of Directors Recap of Board Decisions Summary of Survey Reponses on “Additional Questions” December 15, 2010.
1 Evidence and the next stage of health care reform: Why consumer engagement is so important Steven D. Pearson, MD, MSc President, Institute for Clinical.
Kaiser On-the-Job® (KOJ)
1 Addressing Racial & Ethnic Disparities in Health Care AHRQ 2007 Annual Conference September 28, 2007.
The Business Case for Bidirectional Integrated Care: Mental Health and Substance Use Services in Primary Care Settings and Primary Care Services in Specialty.
“Working Together, Reducing Cancer, Saving Lives”
How can healthcare networks develop policy autonomy within an environment shaped by external mandates? Carla L. Cassidy, CRNP, MSN Director, Evidence-Based.
PRESENTATION TO THE GOVERNOR’S COMMISSION The Health Care (R)Evolution: How FLHCC Employer Members Are Improving Value and Quality in Health Care Karen.
Leveraging IT to Transform Health AcademyHealth Delivery System Meeting – Transforming Health and Health Care June 21, 2013 Amy Compton-Phillips, MD Associate.
Health Care Reform and its Impact on Michigan Janet Olszewski, Director Michigan Department of Community Health Senate Health Policy Committee May 5, 2010.
Patient Centered Care on the Internet Anna-Lisa Silvestre Vice President, Online Services Internet Services Group January 2005.
Esther S. Han, MPH Senior Health Care Analyst, Research July 15, 2009 Innovative Practices in Multicultural Health Care: Health Plan Initiatives.
Napa Valley Fall Prevention Coalition StopFalls Napa Valley Coordinated Fall Prevention Outreach and Services.
Ann OBrien RN MSN CPHIMS National Senior Director of Clinical Informatics Kaiser Permanente Robert Wood Johnson Executive Nurse Fellow Data Analytics and.
Implementing the DxCG Likelihood of Hospitalization Model in Kaiser Permanente Leslee J Budge, MBA
Performance Measurement Sets Dolores Yanagihara Program Development Manager IHA.
CMS as a Public Health Agency: Effective Health Care Research Barry M. Straube, M.D. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services January 11, 2006.
The Center for Health Systems Transformation
Climate Change Uncertainties: Opportunities for Business Innovation? The Business Perspective: UPMC Allison Robinson, PhD, MS Director, Environmental Initiatives.
HW215: Models of Health & Wellness Unit 7: Health and Wellness Models Geo-political Influences.
Copyright © 2010 by ICSI 1 #2257 Copyright © 2010 by ICSI Transforming Health Care Through Collaboration Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement (ICSI)
Put Prevention Into Practice. Understand the PPIP Program What is Put Prevention Into Practice (PPIP)? What is Put Prevention Into Practice (PPIP)? Why.
Assessing Quality of Care AHRQ State Healthcare Quality Improvement Workshop January 17, 2008 Rhonda Jaster Prevention Specialist.
Managed Care. In the broadest terms, Kongstvedt (1997) describes managed care as a system of healthcare delivery that tries to manage the cost of healthcare,
VA National Center for Health Promotion and Disease Prevention Using USPSTF Recommendations in VHA Clinical Practice Linda Kinsinger, MD, MPH Chief Consultant.
Joni Reynolds, RN-CNS, MSN Director of Public Health Programs Winnable Battles: Cancer in Colorado.
Introduction to Healthcare and Public Health in the US The Evolution and Reform of Healthcare in the US Lecture b This material (Comp1_Unit9b) was developed.
Systematic Reviews and American College of Physicians Clinical Practice Guidelines Amir Qaseem, MD, PhD, MHA, FACP Director, Clinical Policy American College.
EPSDT and SUD Treatment in California Presentation to CBHDA Governing Board December 9, 2015 Lucy Pagel, Molly Brassil, and Don Kingdon, Harbage Consulting.
Copyright © 2016 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.
GERIATRIC EDUCATION SERIES Presented in partnership by Funded in part by a grant from the EJC Foundation.
Overview of KP Behavioral Health Delivery System Dr. Stuart Buttlaire Regional Director of Inpatient Psychiatry and Continuing Care Regional Chair, Integrated.
Update on Medicaid Integration in SW Washington January 7, 2016 Erin Hafer, MPH Director, New Programs Integration & Network Development.
Institute of Medicine Committee on Standards for Developing Trustworthy Clinical Practice Guidelines Washington, DC January 11, 2010 Marguerite Koster,
Comparative Effectiveness Research (CER) and Patient- Centered Outcomes Research (PCOR) Presentation Developed for the Academy of Managed Care Pharmacy.
Morristown Medical Center ~ Somerset County Department of Health Cancer Coordinator ~ Coalition Members at large Policy and Environmental Change ~Tobacco.
How Do We Individualize Guidelines in an Era of Personalized Medicine? Douglas K. Owens, MD, MS VA Palo Alto Health Care System Stanford University, Stanford.
Kaiser Permanente: A Model of Integration and Market Leader in Quality and Service Differentiation Healthcare Information Technology January 14, 2003 Robert.
Family Voices of CA Health Summit
Cancer Screening Guidelines
Disclosures Successful completion of this continuing education activity includes the following: Signing into the conference and providing your address.
Advancing Choosing Wisely®
Health Services Research Postdoctoral Fellowship
Component 1: Introduction to Health Care and Public Health in the U.S.
Presentation transcript:

Evidence-Based Guidelines Affecting Policy, Practice and Stakeholders (E-GAPPS) December 10, 2012 New York, NY Joanne Schottinger, MD Assistant Medical Director, Quality & Clinical Analysis Kaiser Permanente Southern California Permanente Medical Group How can health care networks develop policy autonomy within an environment shaped by external mandates?

2 Statement of Disclosure  I have no commercial or academic conflicts of interest  Employed by the Southern California Permanente Medical Group (SCPMG), which contracts exclusively with the Kaiser Foundation Health Plan in the U.S.  Affiliations/Positions: Assistant Medical Director for Quality & Clinical Analysis Responsible for Medical Technology Assessment and Clinical Practice Guidelines Programs for KPSC National Kaiser Permanente Clinical Lead for Cancer Care Programs Practicing internist, specializing in oncology

3 About Kaiser Permanente (KP) Description: Largest nonprofit health plan in the U.S. (founded 1945) Prepaid integrated health care delivery system 9 million members (3.5 million in So. California Region) 16,000+ physicians 173,000+ employees 37 hospitals and med centers 600+ medical offices Active National Guideline Program (Care Management Institute) 8 regions serving 9 states and the District of Columbia Kaiser Foundation Hospitals Permanente Medical Group Kaiser Foundation Health Plan ++ Kaiser Permanente

KP Southern California (KPSC) Region  200 medical offices  5,700 physicians  19,500 nurses  60,000 employees   3.5+ million members   140+ languages spoken   8 counties   13 service areas   14 medical centers

5 KP’s National Guideline Program (NGP)  NGP identifies, develops and maintains a core set of 17 evidence-based clinical practice guidelines Preventive care: Immunizations, cancer screening (breast, cervical, colorectal, prostate), screening/counseling for HIV/STIs Chronic conditions: Asthma, ADHD, depression, CVD risk reduction, heart failure, osteoporosis  National Guideline Directors (NGD) Oversee all NGP efforts – at least one representative from each of 8 KP regions Sponsored by KP’s Care Management Institute, funded by regions  Guideline Development Goal is to provide best available, systematically derived clinical guidance to improve care delivery and optimize the health of KP members

6 External Influences on Guideline Development  Regulatory California Department of Managed Health Care  Accreditation National Committee on Quality Assurance (NCQA) The Joint Commission  Government Health care reform (PPACA) Medicare/Medicaid  Legal California State Senate and Assembly Medical lawsuits

Case Example: Accreditation Organizations 7   Issue: NCQA HEDIS performance measures that lag behind or are inconsistent with current evidence Breast Cancer Screening: Mammogram every 2 years for women aged – –Evidence suggests balance of benefit/harms of breast cancer screening uncertain in women (USPSTF) – –Increases unnecessary biopsies, overdiagnosis and anxiety due to false positive tests – –Raises health system costs for potentially unnecessary/harmful procedures   Cervical Cancer Screening: Pap test every 3 years for women aged – –Evidence suggests change in screening interval for women to Pap + HPV testing every 5 years (USPSTF, ACS, ASCCP, ACOG) – –HEDIS measure will not change in 2013, delaying implementation and cost savings for patients and health systems

Case Example: Accreditation Organizations (cont.) 8   KPSC Response: Breast Cancer Screening: Discuss benefits and harms of mammography, offer screening every 2 years Cervical Cancer Screening: Change Pap + HPV screening interval to every 5 years   Implications: Risk/harms of overdiagnosis and unnecessary/ineffective treatments Lowers nationally reported performance rates; organizations appear to be “underperforming” Influences large purchaser and consumer perceptions of health system performance Potential loss of patients and small/large group purchasers Increases cost to patient and health system

Case Example: Legislative & Regulatory Requirements 9   Issue: Medical practice by legislation, later incorporated into state regulatory requirements CA Senate Bill 1538 – Breast Density Legislation: – –Requires “…a health facility at which a mammography examination is performed to include in the summary of the written report that is sent to the patient a prescribed notice on breast density.” CA Senate Bill 946 – Autism Legislation – –Requires behavioral health treatment for patients with autism or pervasive developmental disorder, including applied behavioral analysis (ABA). CA Senate Bill 1 (Section 2248) – Prostate Cancer Screening Legislation – –Requires that physicians conducting prostate examinations must provide information to the patient about the availability of appropriate diagnostic tests, including but not limited to PSA.

Case Example: Legislative/Regulatory (cont.) 10   KPSC Response: Breast Density: – –Conducted repeat evidence search and technology assessment on automated breast ultrasound system (ABUS) – –Required specific language added to letters to patients – –Developed FAQ for primary care and educational materials for women Autism: – –Required creation of developmental specialist teams in each medical center to coordinate evaluation and treatment – –Extensive external contracts initiated to provide services Prostate Cancer Screening: – –Required development of educational materials on benefits/harms of prostate-specific antigen testing and shared decision making – –Emphasized not doing harm with PSA test in patients aged 75+

Case Example: Legislative/Regulatory (cont.) 11   Implications: Large increase in costs to health system, leading to potential increases in health care dues for patients Focuses resources and funding on interventions that may result in no benefit to patient or harm Risk/harms of overdiagnosis and unnecessary/ineffective treatments Limits research for more effective treatments

Conclusion/Comments 12   Guidelines reflect the evidence, but implementation also impacted by external influences   Regulations are a hard stop   NCQA/accreditation has room to finesse – more systematic interventions to achieve high rates where evidence supports doing so