Job Training Programs. What has been tried? How well does it work?

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
B45, Second Half - The Technology of Skill Formation 1 The Economics of the Public Sector – Second Half Topic 9 – Analysis of Human Capital Policies Public.
Advertisements

What randomized trials have taught us about what works and doesn’t work in education Jon Baron Coalition for Evidence-Based Policy December 9, 2003.
Job Search Assistance Strategies Evaluation Presentation for American Public Human Services Association February 25, 2014.
1 Empirical Approaches to Assessing Discrimination.
Estimating net impacts of the European Social Fund in England Paul Ainsworth Department for Work and Pensions July 2011
Stephen A. Wandner Senior Economist U.S. Department of Labor Michael Wiseman Research Professor George Washington University.
Wisconsin Disability Employment Initiative
Expenditure Programs. Table 8.1 shows that welfare spending is a shared expense between the federal and state/local governments. Subsidized medical care.
Jobcentre Plus Get Britain Working Jobcentre Plus support Get Britain Working measures Work experience Sector-based work academies Flexible Support Fund.
PERFORMANCE ACCOUNTABILITY: WIA YOUTH PERFORMANCE MEASURES John J. Heldrich Center for Workforce Development Rutgers, the State University of New Jersey.
Economic Development Work Force Training =. An Example: Travis County Funds long and short term job training out of economic development funds. One long.
1 VITA at Colgate: The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) VITA Presentation Nicole Simpson January 2013.
Eta EMPLOYMENT AND TRAINING ADMINISTRATION UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR ETA FY 2006 Budget Request ETA FY 2006 Budget Request February 7, 2005 Jobs.
Overview of Income Redistribution Programs
U.S. Department of Labor Assistant Secretary William E. Spriggs Office of Policy July 25, NAACP Convention: Labor Workshop Labor Market Outlook.
Poverty Reduction Strategies in the Central Valley Reducing Poverty in Stanislaus County: Subsidized Employment and Beyond February 24,2011.
Chapter 15: Employment Policies. Increasing Demand PolicyExamples, Dates, Targets General Fiscal PoliciesTax Cuts Non-targeted increases in government.
The Intersection of Performance Measurement and Program Evaluation: Searching for the Counterfactual The Intersection of Performance Measurement and Program.
Poverty: Facts, Causes and Consequences Hilary Hoynes University of California, Davis California Symposium on Poverty October 2009.
1 Transitions to Adulthood: Comparing TANF and Foster care Youth Pamela C. Ovwigho, PhD Valerie Head, MPP Catherine E. Born, PhD Paper presented at the.
Welcome to the Division of Training. OUR MISSION IS TO Develop and implement programs that will provide the territory with a viable workforce. Address.
1 Food Stamp Employment and Training Operating a Volunteer Program Spring Training 2011.
Workforce Development Partnerships Zachary Morris Energy & Skilled Trades Business Service Manager.
The U.S. Public Workforce System An Overview. Overview: The Workforce System and its evolution Defining today’s innovation economy WIRED Initiative and.
Exeter Job Corps Academy RI School Counselor Association Annual Spring Conference April 27, 2007.
Revisiting Work Opportunity: From Tax Credits to Subsidized Jobs Big Ideas for Job Creation in a Jobless Recovery June 16, 2011 Elizabeth.
Poverty in America Sociology. U.S. Census Bureau Reports million million million (year before the recession) million.
PAI786: Urban Policy Class 2: Evaluating Social Programs.
REDUCING CHILD CARE ASSISTANCE: THE IMPACT ON WEST VIRGINIA’S LOW- INCOME WORKING FAMILIES Governor’s Child Care Assistance Meeting Friday, November 9,
Workforce Investment Act Board Orientation P.L Updated 2/13/2013.
IMPACTS OF A WORK-BASED POVERTY REDUCTION PROGRAM ON CHILDREN’S ACHIEVEMENT AND SOCIAL BEHAVIOR: THE NEW HOPE PROJECT Aletha C. Huston, Greg J. Duncan,
 The state or condition of having little or no money, goods, or means of support; condition of being poor.  Absolute poverty or destitution refers to.
Early Childhood Education The Research Evidence Deborah Lowe Vandell December 11, 2003.
Overview of SNAP Employment & Training Ed Bolen Senior Policy Analyst Center on Budget and Policy Priorities November 2014.
The Net Impact Initiative Pilot Evaluation Findings Spring 2015 See presenter notes for annotations.
LSE seminar: London in recession The Recession – London’s experience and some policy implications Duncan Melville, Senior Associate 27 May 2009.
1 What Can Be Learned from Implementing the Workforce Investment Act (WIA) Presentation on Structure of WIA Special APPAM Session November 7, 2009 Dianne.
Welfare and Welfare Reform. AFDC (Aid for Families with Dependant Children) Cash Welfare 87% of funds generally went to those who would be poor Targeted.
Welfare and Welfare Reform. AFDC (Aid for Families with Dependant Children) Cash Welfare 87% of funds generally went to those who would be poor Targeted.
Moving to Opportunity in Boston: early results of a randomized mobility experiment Lawrence F. Katz; Jeffrey R. Kling & Jeffrey B. Liebman Presented by.
Integrated Performance Information (IPI) Project Mike Switzer Workforce Florida, Inc. Jay Pfeiffer Florida Department of.
Income Security and Programs Why was the Social Security Act of 1935 so controversial? What are the two cornerstones of social welfare policy in the US?
Providing a Safety Net. The Poverty Problem The wealth has spread unevenly throughout society as the free market has generated wealth. Some people are.
Ohio Commission on Fatherhood Legislative Discussion September 24, 2015.
Poverty Programs. NEW DEAL REFORMS Created during the Depression President Franklin D. Roosevelt.
Providing a Safety Net. Why Households Differ One of the main reasons why household income differs is because the number of household members who work.
1 Implementing WIA Performance Measures for the European Social Fund Cynthia Fagnoni, Managing Director Education, Workforce, and Income Security Issues.
0 Emerging Findings from the Employment Retention and Advancement (ERA) Evaluation Gayle Hamilton, MDRC Workforce Innovations 2005 Conference.
Modeling Health Reform in Massachusetts John Holahan June 4, 2008 THE URBAN INSTITUTE.
Domestic Policy Mr. Stroman AP Government. Social Welfare Domestic policy is often more contentious than economic policy, because it gets to the essence.
11/2015 v3 DRAFT Welcome to Pilot Program (Region Name) Orientation Counties listed here.
1 The Effects of Customer Choice: First Findings from the Individual Training Account (ITA) Experiment Mathematica Policy Research, Inc. Social Policy.
Lessons from the United States: Evaluating Employment Services is Neither Easy Nor Cheap November 7, 2009 Sheena McConnell Peter Schochet Alberto Martini.
Chapter 3.4 Providing a Safety Net Shea Carrington 5 th period.
TEAM: KIRISOR COUNTRY: ROMANIA Learn more than just theory, learn skills!
Chapter 3 Section 2.
President’s FY2017 Budget Request February 12, 2016.
Workforce Development under the Recovery Act Washington Area Women’s Foundation Stimulus Forum Rachel Gragg
[Presentation location] [Presentation date] (Confirm ABT logo) Building Bridges and Bonds (B3): An introduction.
Do Performance Measures Track Longer-Term Program Impacts? A Case Study for Job Corps Peter Z. Schochet, Ph.D. OECD, Paris April 27, 2016.
Chapter 15: Policies for the Working Poor: Training, Worker Subsidies, and the Minimum Wage “ There is nothing training cannot do. Nothing is above its.
Job Corps: Lessons from U.S. Programs for At-Risk, Disadvantaged Youth Peter Z. Schochet, Ph.D. Sciences Po, Paris April 15, 2016.
Overview of Income Redistribution Programs
Chapter 14 Workforce and Career Development History
The Workforce Investment System and Welfare Reform
Wealth and Poverty.
Hi, welcome to this orientation to Transition Services offered through the Division of Rehabilitative Services…or DRS. The purpose of this orientation.
Poverty and the Governments Role
Estimating net impacts of the European Social Fund in England
Burt S. Barnow George Washington University
Presentation transcript:

Job Training Programs

What has been tried? How well does it work?

Job Training Programs Started in the 1960s (war on poverty) with Manpower Training and Development Act (MTDA) Implemented a variety of job training programs including Job Corps Updates include Comprehensive Employment and Training Act (CETA) in 1970s, Job Training Partnership Act (JTPA) in 1980s. Both moved control over programs away from Federal Government toward state governments. In 1998, Workforce Investment Act (WIA) DOL was to provide “one-stop” service These have generally been available to disadvantaged and other workers needing assistance, but all voluntary.

Job Training Programs There were also a variety of training programs aimed at aid recipients that were mandatory. Work Incentive Program (WIN) Required single parent recipients of AFDC who did not have pre- school aged kids to participate (consensus is that program had little effect) Job Opportunities and Basic Skills (JOBS) – 1988 More extensive than WIN, but still quite limited. Welfare-to-work (WtW) Part of welfare reform (AFDC to TANF) State based, with matching funds from Federal govt.

Job Training Programs In addition to those mentioned, there are also numerous smaller state programs and federal pilot programs, or more specialized targeted programs. In 1999, GAO identified 16 government sponsored training programs aimed at the economically disadvantaged, costing $16.2 billion and serving almost 3 million people. Should we expect these programs to have an effect? Largest program (under TANF) served almost 1 million people at a cost of about $1000/person Second largest (Food Stamp Employment and Training Program) served around ¾ million people at cost of $266/person.

Job Training Programs In 1999, US spent an average of $6500/student in school in 1 yr. Typical estimates of return to a year of education are roughly 8% So to get an increase of 10% in each trainee’s earnings capacity, govt would have to spend roughly $8000. Of all programs, only WtW, Job Corp, and a couple of local programs spend anywhere near that much (cover only 200,000 participants) Most training programs focus on resume/application writing, interviewing, job search skills. Not really new “productive” skills, rather skills that help participants distinguish themselves over other low-skilled workers.

Job Training Programs Evaluating job training programs What makes this so hard?

Job Training Programs Schochet, Burghardt, and McConnell. (2009). “Does Job Corps Work? Impact Findings from the National Job Corps Study.” American Economic Review. Job Corps yr old Legal US resident Economically disadvantaged Live in environment characterized by disruptive homelife, high crime neighborhood, limited job opportunities Need additional education, training, and job skills Free of serious behavior problems

Job Training Programs Program focused around residential job training centers. Training available for a variety of trades and academic skills (including GRE) Length of training varied, but on average 8 months. After completion, Job Corps placement services helps with job search. In 1995, services cost about $16,500 per participant.

Job Training Programs Study Interested in the long-term effects of Job Corps on education, earnings, and arrests. How does this study overcome the selection problem? Given the sampling methodology, what question can this study hope to help answer? What questions can it not answer?

Job Training Programs Study can answer: “What is the average effect of being allowed to enroll in Job Corps on outcomes for volunteering eligible individuals above and beyond other available programs?” (Impact per eligible applicant) “What is the average effect of enrolling in Job Corps on outcomes for volunteering eligible individuals above and beyond other available programs?” (IV estimates) (Impact per eligible participant) What is difference?

Job Training Programs What study cannot answer: “What is the average effect of being allowed to enroll or enrolling in Job Corps on outcomes for a randomly chosen individual?” “What is the average effect of being allowed to enroll or enrolling in Job Corps on outcomes for a random eligible individual?” Why not?

Job Training Programs Data Randomization occurred between Nov 1994 and Dec 1995 Follow-up surveys 12, 30, and 48 months after random assignment. Response rates for 48 month follow-up were 81% for treated, 78% for controls (what could be an issue here?) Administrative earnings records Tax records and Unemployment insurance records.

Job Training Programs Were those in “treatment” group treated? 72% enrolled Avg stay 8 months (though with large variation)

Job Training Programs Impacts on Education and Training

Job Training Programs Impacts on Earnings (using survey data)

Job Training Programs Longer-term impacts on Earnings (all data)

Job Training Programs Longer-term impacts by subgroup on earnings and arrests

Job Training Programs In Summary, Job Corps program seemed to have some effect on short-run Participants get more training, earn more, and are arrested less in the 4 yrs after enrollment. However, these effects are relatively small and appear to fade away over time. The most affected group in the long-term is older youth who get involved. Appears to offer a different type of opportunity than otherwise available to turn life around. More generally, most evidence suggests that tackling poverty via job training seems to be hard and expensive (should this really be surprising though?)