WP3 : Academic freedom and the changing conditions of academic work: legal and conceptual aspects.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Data Protection & Human Rights. Data Protection: a Human Right Part of Right to Personal Privacy Personal Privacy : necessary in a Democratic Society.

Advertisements

Carolyn M. Byerly, Ph.D., professor Department of Journalism and Graduate Program in Mass Comm & Media Studies TENURE: BASIC INFO AND ISSUES.

Concept of Law and Sources of Law

Constitutions, Law and Judiciary

Disability and human rights What are the human rights of people with disabilities?

Political Science Leonardo Morlino Introductory Course – Fall term.

Procedures Tenured v. Non-Tenured Tenured Have a property interest in their continued employment. Property interest is a substantive right and procedural.

Jenn Nichols, AAUP This PowerPoint Presentation was initially designed by long-time AAUP activist Glenn Howze ( ) Faculty Governance: Definitions.

INTRODUCTION INTO PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW OF THE EUROPEAN UNION Marko Jovanovic, LL.M. MASTER IN EUROPEAN INTEGRATION Private International Law in the.

The Supreme Court and Roe vs. Wade. Initiating Questions What is Roe vs. Wade? What is Roe vs. Wade? Why is this case significant? Why is this case significant?

Education Educational Equality, Equity, and Sui Generis Rights in Australian Higher Education Theorising the Tensions and Contradictions.

Copyright © 2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved. Insert: Book Cover (when available)

Legal Foundations of Education Chapter 6 Introduction to the Law Preaching vs. Teaching Letter Pedagogical Objections Ethical Objections Legal Objections.

Mediation as a Source of Law Dale Dewhurst Athabasca University New York – IALMH, 2009.

International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board Accounting Estimates, Including Fair Value Accounting Estimates, and Related Disclosures ISA Implementation.

1 7th Framework Programme Specific Programme “Ideas” European Commission Directorate B November 2005.

Business and Society: Ethics and Stakeholder Management, 5E Carroll & Buchholtz Copyright ©2003 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning. All.

CLN4U Heritage 1 Thoughts Can you think of an act / behaviour that is always wrong? Why is it wrong? Is it wrong in all contexts? Has it always wrong.

Philosophy A philosophy is a system of beliefs about reality.

Lesson 1: What Did the Founders Think about Constitutional Government?

Theoretical Background and Principles of Communication Law

 The 5 th Amendment limits the national government, but the 14 th guarantees that states cannot deprive rights without “Due Process.”  Due process is.

Chapter 1: Understanding Psychology’s History Chapter 1: Understanding Psychology’s History.

DISCIPLINARY PROCEDURES. SOCIAL POLICY Guidance on sports, societies and groups organising social activity Asks that you are respectful of local residents.

Identity A legal perspective FIDIS WP2 workshop 2/3 december 2003

Basic Principles: Ethics and Business

April 11, 2008NAGS Annual Meeting, NYC1 Academic Freedom in the 21 st Century for All Faculty Arthur Hochner Associate Professor, Human Resource Mgt. Fox.

Disciplinary boundaries and heterogeneity of sciences Catherine Laurent ( UWC 5-6 november 2007)

Adapted from a presentation by Mark Lieu Academic Senate for California Community Colleges - Leadership Institute 2006 Academic Senate for California Community.

Public Administration Jay Shaftitz & E. W. Russell

The Philosophy of Science Claude Oscar Monet: London: Houses of Parliament at Sunset, 1903.

Education for Democracy and Human Rights Education: good practices, lessons learned and challenges from ODIHR’s perspective International Seminar on Education.

A Framework for Practical work, Argumentation and Scientific Literacy to plan research Ros Roberts York, June 2011.

Freedom of speech. Freedom of speech is the freedom to speak freely without censorship. The term freedom of expression is sometimes used synonymously,

The Eighth Asian Bioethics Conference Biotechnology, Culture, and Human Values in Asia and Beyond Confidentiality and Genetic data: Ethical and Legal Rights.

Challenges of Sharia in the Modern World - Iranian Experience Iraj Babaei Law & Economic Institute of Erasmus University Rotterdam June 2009.

Second expert group meeting on Draft fiche on delegated act on the European code of conduct on partnership (ECCP) Cohesion Policy

Academic Arguments Using the Discourse of the Academy Copyright 2012 Lisa McNeilley.

INITIAL TEACHER EDUCATION IN PORTUGAL Escola Básica e Secundária Padre Manuel Álvares Madeira Islands, Portugal Liseth Cristina Andrade Ferreira Physics.

Basic concepts in Human Rights

Strengths and weaknesses of the implementation of the Bologna Process: Spain Round Table Bratislava,10-12 October Guillermo Bernabeu, University of Alicante.

1 7th Framework Programme “Ideas” 2   Basic research has an important impact on economic performance   Europe is not making the most of its research.

ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES Lecture 1. 1.adm. law is being taught in many institutions of higher education as well as in numeorus special institutes, 2.for.

History of Law Presentation John Locke Kitti, allison, vincent, alex.

Ethical Awareness Professional Ethics Unit 7. Professional ethics carries additional moral responsibilities. It could mean professional individuals possess.

23rd July Workshop on Revised Syllabus of FOUNDATION COURSE II Module A-Human Rights Mahesh Bhagwat, Mithibai College, Vileparle.

APS Day 15 Enduring Understanding(s) 1. Procedural democracy focuses on how government decisions are made, while substantive democracy focuses on the results.

Public Participation in Legislative Process in Slovakia Public Participation in Legislative Process in Slovakia JUDr. Milan VETRÁK.

HUMAN RIGHTS & POLICE ETHICS IN POLICE TRAINING The 4th INTERPA Conference May 2015 Abudhabi Dr. Mustafa YAYLA Turkish National Police Academy ANKARA.

Doc.JUDr.Soňa Skulová, Ph.D. Principles of Good Governance.

UNITS 4:3-4:4 Patients’ Rights and Legal Directives for Health Care.

Criminal Justice and Criminology Research Methods, Second Edition Kraska / Neuman © 2012 by Pearson Higher Education, Inc Upper Saddle River, New Jersey.

Institutional Aspects of the Parliamentary System Presentation by Douglas Millar, formerly Clerk Assistant and Director General of Chamber and Committee.

Postmethod ELT in the Posmethod Era. Of methods and post-methods According to Douglas Brown (2002, p. 9), “a method is a set of theoretically unified.

Kinds of law and sources of law. What is law? DEFINITION OF LAW The system of rules that a particular country or community recognizes as regulating the.

PHILOSOPHY AS A SECOND ORDER DISCIPLINE

Administrative law is the law that governs and is applied by, the executive branch of the govt. The rapid growth of AD.LAW in the 20 TH century was due.

PHILOSOPHY AS A SECOND ORDER DISCIPLINE

Lesson 18: How Has the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment Changed the Constitution?

ADM 636 Competitive Success/snaptutorial.com

ADM 636 Education for Service-- snaptutorial.com.

ADM 636 Teaching Effectively-- snaptutorial.com

Conflicts of Criminal Jurisdiction: Roadmap to Legislation at EU Level A Model for the Allocation of the Exercise of Jurisdiction in the AFSJ Prof.

INTRODUCTION INTO PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW OF THE EUROPEAN UNION

In a court, should the truth always be found? Yes or No? Justify.

Function of the International Court of Justice (ICJ):

Fundamental rights in the higher education within the EU

Mr. Vasquez AP U.S. Government and Politics

3RD EU-CHINA IP ACADEMIC FORUM

Why Study Public Speaking?

Presentation transcript:

WP3 : Academic freedom and the changing conditions of academic work: legal and conceptual aspects

(1) Main concepts and issues that the texts define or contest Hunt (2010) Definitions academic freedom related to the ”freedom from retaliation for their statements that goes beyond the freedom accorded to other members of society” – ”By tradition and often by legally binding contractual arrangements ” – = Bargain with society Double standard which is used by society Observations Articles (both Hunt and Karran) are not written with the idea of defining the concepts Hunt does not discuss or question the conceptualization/concept of academic freedom but takes it for granted Hunt does not give evidence for some of its claims (versus: to be responsible you have to give evidence)

(1) Main concepts and issues that the texts define or contest Karran (2007) Parameters for measuring academic freedom constitutional protections for freedom of speech, academic freedom, freedom of training and research, institutional autonomy specific national legislation relating to academic freedom, freedom of training and research, institutional autonomy institutional autonomy and internal governance of the university (self- governance) Method of appointment of the university rector Existence of academic tenure  levels of protection: low, medium, high

(1) Main concepts and issues that the texts define or contest Karran (2007) Definitions Autonomy: UNESCO defintion : ”Autonomy is that degree of self- governance necessary for effective decision making by institutions of higher education regarding their academic work, standards, management and related activities... and respect for academic freedom and human rights.” + “institutional form of academic freedom” Procedural + substantive autonomy (Berdahl (1990))

(1) Main concepts and issues that the texts define or contest Karran (2007) Observations The concept of academic freedom is not defined in itself  concepts of autonomy, institutional autonomy, freedom of teaching and research, freedom of speech are all used This is a discussion of the existing legislation (legal perspective), not of the existing practice(s) Analysis is very quickly outdated (rapidly changing legal context)

(2) Theoretical and political position? Why? Hunt (2010)  2 aspects to evaluating a speech: – Worrying about the truth of what is said (scientists) – Worrying about the implications of saying it (other parts) Karran (2007) from the legal perspective Epistemologically: – He is aware of the limitations of his research – Does not make claims on the presence or practices of these laws in everyday life – This research = opening for further studies

(3) in your own research? in your theoretical or empirical work? Not directly, but indirectly