The Child’s Voice in Private Law Family Proceedings in Scotland Kirsteen Mackay School of Law Funded by the ESRC.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Of.
Advertisements

NIGB NATIONAL INFORMATION GOVERNANCE BOARD FOR HEALTH AND SOCIAL CARE Sams Story Information Sharing module.
Based on novel Tuesdays With Morrie Presented by Ying Xiong.
DAVID ARCHARD PROFESSOR OF PHILOSOPHY What does it mean to have a right of participation?
The Church at your Home From the Unity Perspective His Grace Bishop Paula.
UNTOLD DAMAGE Children’s accounts of living with harmful parental drinking Collaborative research SHAAP/ ChildLine in Scotland to explore what children.
Proactive Interventions: Incorporating a Children’s Rights Approach
Domestic Abuse & Child Contact Part 1: Understanding the issues (Speaker: Nel Whiting, Scottish Women’s Aid)
What your Families, Children & Young People think…
Parents as Partners A GROUPWORK PROGRAMME WITH A COUPLE APPROACH DFE funded.
Violence Against Women and Their Children Professor Marianne Hester.
Megan Mitchell National Children’s Commissioner Friday 7 March 2014 The Right to Participate National Children’s Week Council Meeting facebook.com/MeganM4Kids.
Megan Mitchell National Children’s Commissioner 18 March 2014 Safeguarding the mental health of children and ensuring the opportunity to thrive – themes.
The Brussels II Regulation The jurisdiction of courts.
DOMESTIC ABUSE AND CONTACT CASES BEFORE THE COURTS S11(7A) Children (S) Act 1995.
Seeking God During Grief July 19. Think About It Consider the quote: Which do you think is more important – faith or hope? Why? “Faith is that which lays.
Hearing the child and taking account of his or her best interests: what do lawyers know? Thalia KrugerRome, 24 October 2014
How Teens Reach Out to Adults Sometimes teens are very direct when they want your attention. “I need to talk with you.” “Can you and I go to the park tomorrow?”
Article 12(1) of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child “States Parties shall assure to the child who is capable of forming his or her own views.
NGO's and Participation. International Non-Governmental Organisations with a child focus UNICEF Plan Oxfam Catholic Relief Services CARE International.
The first steps Anna Lóa Ólafsdóttir Career counselor og project manager of The First Steps.
PDMU Team 2010/2011 Daphne Wilson.
Ethics in Self-Help Centers: What Staff and Volunteers Need to Know.
NISHA PRICHARD University of New South Wales Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences School of Social Science w.edu.au 18 th August.
‘We want Scotland to be the best place in the world for children to grow up’ Kay Tisdall, Programme Director of MSc in Childhood Studies,
The Family Support Program Presenter: Laurie D. Miller 2012.
Action for Prisoners’ Families Working together – Maintaining familiy ties. Sam Hart 1.
1. Dwelling continuously upon the negative. Dwelling continuously upon the negative. Effects how one thinks and what one does. Effects how one thinks.
JENNIFER SMESTAD ERIN CROCKETT GIRESSE TCHEGHO Enrique’s Journey.
Module 2 Unit 1 Tales of the unexplained Welcome to the Unit.
Engaging Young People in Creating Safe Environments Matthew Keown, Euan Lindsay and Niall Moore.
Seldom seen and rarely heard: Children’s voices in post-divorce decision-making. Symposium presented by: Lisbeth T PIKE, Paul T MURPHY, & Alan D CAMPBELL.
Standing up for yourself Tariq is walking home from the shops. He sees three boys walking towards him. He knows who they are – two weeks ago they pushed.
The right of children to be heard. International legal framework The UN Convention on the rights of the child states that all children have the right.
Walsall Children & Young People’s Partnership Private Fostering To make growing up in Walsall as good as it can be.
Involving Girls in Advocacy © 2014 Public Health Institute.
From Nairobi to Oslo Young people as keys to sustainable development.
Safety Framework Supervisors as Coaches Department of Children and Families.
Choosing to marry Chapter 8. The ability to give and receive love  The ability to give and receive love is vital  Willing to commit yourself to help.
Project HOPE-VA Youth Summit Older Youth Experiencing Homelessness June 2013 Barbara Duffield, NAEHCY Policy Director 1.
Practice Always Makes Perfect The Company Man Unit Five.
Irregular Immigrants and EU Citizens: A Regularising Relationship? The Case of Ireland Alan Desmond, PhD Candidate, Faculty of Law, University College.
Welcome to the Quarterly FTM Facilitator Advanced Training  Please make sure you have signed in.  In order to receive PE training hours you must be registered.
Sight Words List 1 Mr. Matthews Grade One can.
 2011 National Fatherhood Initiative 1 Responsible Fatherhood: What’s Mom Got To Do With It? ________________________________________________ Improving.
The role of school social workers in preventing child abuse in Fukuoka city ― A case study of in-house school social workers Kenichi Okumura
How To Get Your Kids Back Parents as Case Managers.
ENGAGING WITH FATHERS Tom Carroll and Neil Sutherland.
District 200 High frequency words
Barnardo’s Registered Charity Nos and SC CHILDREN’S CENTRES;WORKING WITH UNDER FIVES AND THEIR FAMILIES AFFECTED BY IMPRISONMENT Owen Gill.
Moral Development By: Margaret Wellman & Brigid McGuire.
Sean O’Sullivan, Head of Health and Social Policy Royal College of Midwives 30 th September 2015.
Convention on the right of the child principals. Principals ? Rights /principals ?
1 Foundation module 2 Child rights-based approaches.
SofS Trainers/Consultants Gathering - Alnmouth 3-5 July 2013.
Summer Of My German Soldier Michele Eick Due: 11/3/11 Period: 8.
S 1 st World Conference of Women’s Shelters August 2008.
"Human Rights and the European Union Regulations on Private International Law : the needs to protect the right of family members " Elisabetta Bergamini.
Lastensuojelun polku Path of child welfare. Societies are different Ways and models of operation are different due to different historical and cultural.
CHILDREN. FAMILY BREAKDOWN CAN HAVE A NEGATIVE IMPACT ON CHILDREN. THEY CAN BE THE INNOCENT VICTIMS CAUGHT UP IN THE ADULTS' EMOTIONAL WHIRLPOOL. THE.
What does it look like and how do we handle it?. Bullying:  "A person is bullied when he or she is exposed, repeatedly and over time, to negative actions.
ACWA Conference 2010 Barnardos Find-a-Family Working Together – Promoting Positive Relationships to Enhance Permanency Lisa Velickovich and Laura Ritchie.
SUBSTANCE USE AND ABUSE By: Emma Widman. Case Study 10 ( Tobacco) My friends have asked me to give them a pack of cigarettes. I don’t know what to say.
Involving children in decision-making has received much attention in New Zealand, and internationally, recently. Care of Children Act 2004 attempts to.
Hague Convention Procedure in Canada Japan’s Ratification of the Hague Convention on Child Abduction and its Implications Yuji Matson, DLA Piper (Canada)
CH 3 Section 2. Introduction (page 70) Children think differently from adults in many ways. Children form their own ideas about how the world works. Describe.
Stages of Attachment Lesson 2.
Challenges Today - the Parliaments and their Responsibilities
The Children Act 1989 Allocates duties to local authorities, courts, parents and other agencies in the United Kingdom to ensure children are Safeguarded.
Presentation transcript:

The Child’s Voice in Private Law Family Proceedings in Scotland Kirsteen Mackay School of Law Funded by the ESRC

United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child – Article 12 “1. States Parties shall assure to the child who is capable of forming his or her own views the right to express those views freely in all matters affecting the child, the views of the child being given due weight in accordance with the age and maturity of the child.” 2. For this purpose, the child shall in particular be provided the opportunity to be heard in any judicial and administrative proceedings affecting the child either directly, or through a representative or an appropriate body [...]”

Emphasis on the Father-Child Relationship “As a natural father of the said children, the pursuer has a positive contribution to make to the said children’s upbringing [...] It is important for the children’s self-esteem and development to know the identity of their natural father [...] the said children will become alienated from the pursuer in the absence of a regular pattern of contact.” (Case 1/95) No similar assertions in respect of contact with a Mother

Views Expressed by Children in the Data Set

Contact Outcomes

Children Not Wanting to See their Mother Children Not Wanting to See their Mother Case 1/75 Jamie: “ I do not want to see her as she hit me for telling the truth to dad.” Age 12. Claire: “ I do not want to see or even to call her mum because of what she did to my brother.” Age 11 Outcome: Residence to Dad. No Contact with Mum

Children Not Wanting to See their Father Case 2/72 Katie and Sophie see the reporter together and state: “they do not want to see their father and say they will run away if they are made to see him.” Aged 8 & 10 years. “There appear to be no child welfare based reasons why contact should not operate [....]I do not feel that either of the girls are sufficiently mature to be able to evaluate their feelings objectively. [....]The girls are obviously fearful of their father, but I do suspect this is a result of the perception of their mother’s reaction rather than a genuine fear of spending time with the pursuer.” Outcome: Contact ordered

Relative Merits: Mother’s Drinking v Father’s Violence Mother’s Drinking v Father’s Violence Case 2/40 Reporter recounts: Hannah: “does not want to stay with her mother as she would not feel comfortable and because they would not be fed but would be sent to the shop to buy [food].” Aged 10 Jason: “..is clear he would like to live with his mum as his dad is always shouting for no reason and because his dad has ‘hit him more in the last 6 months than his mum did in six years.’ Aged 9 Reporter: “In all the circumstances I recommend the children continue to live with [their father] and that the issue of contact is left to the discretion of [their father].”

Boredom and Absent “contact” Parent Case 2/109: Non-Resident Father Louise: “says she does not want to stay over mid-week at all. She said that when they go for contact her dad goes out and it is their grandparents that look after them. She also said that her sister cries at her dads and that she misses her mum and their [baby] brother.” Aged 13. Outcome: All of every 2 nd Weekend Contact. Case 2/156: Non-Resident Mother Cassie says: “.... Is very clear she doesn't not want contact with her mother at this stage because she was put in a room by herself during contact while her mother entertained her boyfriend. She said it was not a ‘quality’ visit but was ‘boring’.” Aged 11 Outcome: NO contact.

Concluding Remarks:  Evidence of a fundamental assumption that a child’s welfare is dependant on ongoing contact with their Father specifically. Children’s views are most likely to be over-ridden when they are negative about seeing their father.  Evidence of a weaker assumption of contact with non-resident Mothers.  Historical power imbalances may therefore be perpetuated by the Courts.

Prevalence of Children’s Views Being Taken by formal means in the Court Data Set (n.299 children)