Drinking Water Contaminants and Child Health in Woburn and Tom ’ s River EH757 October 11, 2011 Richard Clapp, D.Sc., MPH Professor Emeritus Boston University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Community Meeting Pompton Lakes, NJ April 21, 2010 Joe Eldridge, MPH Consumer, Environmental and Occupational Health Service Pamela K. Agovino, MPH Cancer.
Advertisements

– Forensic Geology The Woburn Toxics Case A Civil Action.
Bureau of Environmental Health Assessment Massachusetts Department of Public Health February 13, 2002 Public Meeting: MDPH Activities in South Weymouth.
A Civil Action 1982 – Jan Richard Schlichtmann, a lawyer specialized in medical malpractice cases, filed a lawsuit against two multinational corporations.
1 Health Outcomes in the Communities Surrounding the Inglewood Oil Field Angelo J. Bellomo, REHS Director of Environmental Health County of Los Angeles.
Achievements of the WHO NEHAP in Hungary as a pilot country of the progamme A. Pintér, A. Páldy, T. Málnási, E. Erdei National Center for Public Health,
Ellen F. Heineman, Ph.D. National Cancer Institute Epidemiology & Genetics Research Program The GIS for the Long Island Breast Cancer Study Project.
Environmental exposures  Cancer risks:  Tobacco smoke  Radon in homes  Arsenic.
GRACE CHEN18 TH OCTOBER, OCCUPATIONAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL RISK FACTORS FOR MOTOR NEURONE DISEASE IN NZ Case - Control Study.
Case-Control Studies (Retrospective Studies). What is a cohort?
1 Recent Observational Studies of Antidepressants (ADs) and Suicidal Behavior Diane K. Wysowski, Ph.D. Office of Drug Safety FDA.
Allison Derrick Masters of Public Health Candidate UW School of Medicine and Public Health Regional Distribution of Orofacial Cleft Defects in Wisconsin.
Journal Club Alcohol, Other Drugs, and Health: Current Evidence July-August 2007.
Journal Club Alcohol and Health: Current Evidence March-April 2007.
Environmental Health III. Epidemiology Shu-Chi Chang, Ph.D., P.E., P.A. Assistant Professor 1 and Division Chief 2 1 Department of Environmental Engineering.
Journal Club Alcohol and Health: Current Evidence May-June 2006.
Environmental Public Health Tracking: Some Records are Vital Suzanne K. Condon, Director Bureau of Environmental Health Massachusetts Department of Public.
Significance Tests and Two Proportions
Evaluation of Childhood Cancer Incidence in Sandwich, MA: Present Massachusetts Department of Public Health Center for Environmental Health Community.
Critical Appraisal of an Article by Dr. I. Selvaraj B. SC. ,M. B. B. S
COHORT STUDY DR. A.A.TRIVEDI (M.D., D.I.H.) ASSISTANT PROFESSOR
The Environment and Human Health
Nuclear Weapons: The Final Pandemic Preventing Proliferation and Achieving Abolition Health Status of Indigenous People Around Jadugoda Uranium Mines Shakeel.
Groundwater Arsenic Concentrations and Cancer Incidence Rates: A Regional Comparison in Oregon Harmony Fleming, MS Anna K Harding, PhD Department of Public.
General Types of Water Pollution
ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH (2) By Dr. Khalid El Tohami.
Introducing HealthStats Eleanor Howell, MS Manager, Data Dissemination Unit State Center for Health Statistics February 2, 2012.
Cohort Study.
Crestwood, Illinois The story of a local Mom. Crestwood, Illinois Crestwood, IllinoisLocation.
Comparing Two Population Parameters Comparing two- population proportions.
Section 7.1: Chance and Probability. Probability Chance behavior is unpredictable in the short run (you probably can’t guess what number will be drawn,
Health Consultation: Evaluation of Cancer Incidence in Census Tracts of Attleboro and Norton, Massachusetts: Suzanne K. Condon Associate Commissioner.
ATSDR’s approach to site assessment and epidemiologic considerations for multisite studies Steve Dearwent, PhD, MPH Chief, Health Investigations Branch.
A growing number of diseases in children from rural and urban areas are linked to unsafe, degraded environments. However, many health care providers are.
Health registers as a ressource for research Preben Bo Mortensen Director, Professor, DrMedSc National Centre for Register-based Research Aarhus University.
MARC Project 4: Australian Children of Alcoholic Female Twins.
Brownfields Health Risks & Remediation Diogo Cadima Topic ‘A’ Term Project CET 413.
ARSENIC CONTAMINATION OF WATER IN BANGLADESH SENGE NGALAME MPH 583 DR. WHEELER.
Groundwater Contamination What kind of contamination is it? How can we clean it up? How did it get there? How does it hurt living organisms? Copy and Fill.
Healthy People 2010 Focus Area 8: Environmental Health Progress Review February 2, 2007.
Woburn Health Studies Massachusetts DPH, 1979 reviewed mortality statistics Massachusetts DPH, 1981 cancer incidence and environmental hazards.
Delmar Learning Copyright © 2003 Delmar Learning, a Thomson Learning company Chapter 22 Care of Infants, Children and Adolescents.
General Types of Water Pollution Water Quality Notes.
Water Treatment: Introduction Suzette R. Burckhard, PhD, PE Civil and Environmental Engineering South Dakota State University Engineering the Future 2014.
MARC Project 4: Australian Children of Alcoholic Female Twins Wendy S. Slutske, Valerie S. Knopik, Theodore Jacob, Michael T. Lynskey, & Anne Glowinski.
A short introduction to epidemiology Chapter 4: More complex study designs Neil Pearce Centre for Public Health Research Massey University Wellington,
AP Statistics Section 13.2 B. An observed difference between two sample proportions can reflect a difference in the populations or it may just be due.
12.2 (13.2) Comparing Two Proportions. The Sampling Distribution of.
Reading Health Research Critically The first four guides for reading a clinical journal apply to any article, consider: the title the author the summary.
By Brittney Janard. Faber & Krieg. In "Unequal Exposure to Ecological Hazards: Environmental Injustices in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts," Daniel.
Chapter 21 Water Pollution. Types of Water Pollution  Water pollution  Any physical or chemical change in water that adversely affects the health of.
Chapter 15.3 Risk Assessment 2002 WHO report: “Focusing on risks to health is the key to preventing disease and injury.” risk assessment—process of evaluating.
Epidemiological Research. Epidemiology A branch of medical science that deals with the incidence, distribution, and control of disease in a population.
EHS 507 Food Exposures: Fruits and Vegetables  Fruits and vegetables may become contaminated by multiple pathways –Purposeful spraying or soil treatment.
A CIVIL ACTION – It’s Debatable Movie Study and Gathering of Debate Evidence.
A short introduction to epidemiology Chapter 2: Incidence studies Neil Pearce Centre for Public Health Research Massey University Wellington, New Zealand.
The Environment and Human Health
Questions.
Environmental Pollution -any addition of undesirable substances to the soil and air, and both surface and groundwater by human activities -can spread far.
Section 5.1.  Cars  Refrigerators  Plastics  Pesticides  Gasoline,  Jelwelry  Cosmetics.
Hazardous Waste.
Science in the Courtroom
The Environmental Movement
Chapter 24 Section 4 Notes The Birth of Modern Environmentalism
Recognize and respond to physician distress and suicidal behavior
Disease Detective Team!
Recognize and respond to physician distress and suicidal behavior
Transformation by the legal system
Hold Your Breath—Ohio EPA’s TCE Initiative
A Civil Action 1982 – Jan Richard Schlichtmann, a lawyer specialized in medical malpractice cases, filed a lawsuit against two multinational corporations.
Presentation transcript:

Drinking Water Contaminants and Child Health in Woburn and Tom ’ s River EH757 October 11, 2011 Richard Clapp, D.Sc., MPH Professor Emeritus Boston University School of Public Health

Major Types of Water Pollution Microbiological –Ex: cholera, cryptosporidium, Giardia, Hepatitis A Heavy metals –Ex: lead, arsenic Radiation –Ex: radium, radon Chemicals –Ex: disinfection byproducts, solvents, fluoride, –pesticides

Drinking Water Pollution Improper treatment of surface water –Lack of filtration, inadequate filtration –Underchlorination, overchlorination Groundwater pollution –Geological deposits of radium, arsenic, uranium –Improper disposal of chemicals Faulty distribution system –Lead pipes and lead solder –Leaks and intrusion

Epidemiologic Studies Birth outcomes studies –Silicon Valley, CA (Swan, et al.) –Tucson, AZ (Goldberg, et al.) Cancer studies –Woburn, MA –Tom ’ s River, NJ

Woburn Citizens ’ Concerns Years of toxic waste dumping from leather tanneries, chemical plants Strong odors in East Woburn Water tasted bad periodically Apparent cluster of childhood leukemia in East Woburn neighborhood Local and State officials unresponsive

Citizen Action Created grassroots organization called FACE (For A Cleaner Environment) Called for health and environmental studies Demanded clean-up of contaminated properties Several families filed lawsuit (subject of book and movie, “A Civil Action”)

Results of 1981 Study Case-control study of 12 childhood leukemia cases diagnosed No association with any particular exposure, family history, medical history Elevated Standardized Incidence Ratio SIR=2.3, p=.007 (see Cutler JJ, et al. Childhood Leukemia in Woburn, Massachusetts. Public Health Reports 101(2): , 1986)

Woburn Childhood Leukemia Cases

Harvard/FACE Study Citizens and researchers conducted town- wide telephone survey Used Woburn water distribution model from Dept. of Env. Quality Engineering Estimated exposure to contaminated wells G & H was two-fold higher in childhood leukemia cases diagnosed (see Lagakos SW, et al. J Am Stat Assoc 81: , 1986)

Lagakos, et al. survey Volunteer interviewers (235), scripted telephone interviews, random batches Introductory text said purpose was to examine environmental influences on health –5,010 completed interviews (57% of residences) Analyzed 20 leukemia cases using Cox proportional hazards model Discussed biases, misclassification of exposure Criticized by Chair of Epidemiology

Lagakos, et al. additional results Eye/ear birth anomalies, and increased CNS/chromosomal/oral cleft anomalies associated with water from Wells G & H. –Authors referred to these as “ environmental ” birth defects Perinatal deaths since 1970 also associated Increased childhood lung/respiratory tract and kidney/urinary tract disorders associated

DPH Case-control Study Used more detailed water distribution model with estimates of G & H exposure by month Used same method as in 1981 study, but with more cases; estimated prenatal exposure Case-control study of childhood leukemia cases diagnosed

Wells G and H Water Distribution

Costas, et al. conclusions “ Consistently positive association between exposure and risk, a statistically significant dose-response relationship, and a decrease in risk after removal of the pathway of exposure. ” Major finding: association of “ fetal exposure(s) to contaminated water and childhood leukemia ”

Number of Cases of Childhood Leukemia Diagnosed by Year of Diagnosis in Woburn, MA Jan. 1, Aug. 1, 1999 Contaminated Wells Closed

Groundwater Treatment Process

Tom ’ s River study Role of Ocean of Love support group –Recognition of cases, calls for investigation –Political support from Gov. Whitman, Sen. Lautenberg Preliminary studies by NJDHSS –Childhood cancer incidence –Decision to conduct case-control study of 22 children with leukemia and 18 with nervous system cancer Water contaminated with TCE, PCE, radium, Styrene-acrilonitrile trimer

Childhood cancer incidence Tom ’ s River childhood cancer all sites SIR (24 cases) = 1.7 (95% CI ) –Females age 0-4 all sites SIR = 6.5 (95% CI ) –Female age 0-4 brain cancer SIR = 11.3 (95% CI ) –Female age 0-4 ALL SIR = 9.4 (95% CI )

Case-control study methods Interviews inquired about family history, residential history, diet, medical history, etc. Included children born in Tom ’ s River but diagnosed when living elsewhere; controls met same criteria Detailed estimates of exposure to well water, other contamination sites –Attempted to estimate radiation from Oyster Creek nuclear power plant; unlikely very substantial

Tom ’ s River Main Results Parkway well field high prenatal exposure associated with leukemia in females (OR = 6.0; 95% CI ) Ciba-Geigy high-medium air exposure associated with leukemia in females under age 5 (OR = 7.5; 95% CI ) Other findings regarding brain cancer not highlighted (see vol. ii of final report)

Legal case Mediation between plaintiffs and defendants for 18 months –Compiled evidence and testimony that would be used in trial –Settlement agreed to just prior to NJDHSS results announced Sixty plaintiffs agreed not to sue in subsequent class actions