Crafting A Climate Science Classroom Strategy For Dealing With Cultural Identities Peter Buckland Postdoctoral Fellow, Sustainability Institute Penn State.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Advanced Placement United States History
Advertisements

Using Digital Media to Engage Young Citizens ~ Lance Bennett Center for Communication and Civic Engagement University of Washington, Seattle, USA ~ Prepared.
Clearly Communicating with the Public about Climate Change Teresa Myers Center for Climate Change Communication George Mason University.
Using Digital Media to Engage Young Citizens ~ Lance Bennett Center for Communication and Civic Engagement University of Washington, Seattle, USA ~ Prepared.
Prof. K. Sivapalan.. Sex Education Sex education is the process of acquiring information and forming attitudes and beliefs about sex, sexual identity,
Gallup Q12 Definitions Notes to Managers
Ethical Treatment of Employees: Worker Safety
Show-Me 4-H Character Module Two Character Development Theory.
A workshop for STEM subjects on Sustainable Development The Higher Education Academy Session 3: STEM and ESD THE SUSTAINABLE PRACTITIONER.
Michael G Fullan Michael Fullan is Professor Emeritus of the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education of the University of Toronto. Recognized as a.
Understanding the Bilingual Education Controversy Let us remember: Goals of Bilingual Education: Subject matter knowledge, i.e., the development of academic.
An Exploration of Who You Are and Who You Want to Be! Henrico High School 2011.
Organizational Behaviour Individual and Social Behaviour
Weather and Water Unit Unit Portfolio Presentation Facilitator: Mary Trent Sixth Grade Science.
An Interactive Teaching Circle: Measuring Learning Outcomes in a Core Curriculum Linda Anstendig Barbara Pennipede Adelia Williams Association of American.
Social Conservatism Lecture 5 May 22. Deals with Moral Order Right and Wrong Moral and Immoral True and False.
You and Early Childhood Education
Beliefs, values, opinions, evidence and facts: a role for policy informatics? Global Talk Seminar Series Centre for Global Studies University of Victoria.
Reflective Pathways from Theory to Practice Brewton-Parker College Education Division.
The dreamkeepers: Successful teachers of African American children
Education Bachelor’s Degree in Elementary Education Began the Master’s of Special Education program in January of 2011 Professional After graduation Sorensen.
The strength of your argument
Classroom experiences are consistently characterized by surprising, emergent behavior and high quality discussions. Issues concerning leadership, transparency,
One Republic—Two Americas?
Comments for the Symposium on Climate Change Education: Policies and Implications Annual meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching.
1.  Engineers point to socio-political reasons  Why challenge is so formidable (Victor)  Carbon lock-in  science-policy dilemma  Mooney (2) 2.
GA Regional UN Conference on Sustainable Development By: Emma Bunting and D’Andra Brown.
Science Case Network GAPS IN REACHING DIVERSE AUDIENCES Aditi Pai Networking Conference August 6-7, 2012 RCN-UBE Project #
Social Studies/Middle School. Why Social Studies? Although civic competence tends to be the ultimate goal of an entire school curriculum, it is more central.
Chapter 1 Defining Social Studies. Chapter 1: Defining Social Studies Thinking Ahead What do you associate with or think of when you hear the words social.
Community Board Orientation 6- Community Board Orientation 6-1.
Education That Is Multicultural
Knowledge of the Audience (KA). NASA Earth Science Education & Public Outreach Retreat Communicating with Global Warming’s Six Americas: Message Strategies.
MYP Global Contexts. IB/MYP Organization that works with schools and shares educational values and beliefs –Student-centered education –The conscious.
(1) Bridging research, policy and politics the RAPID+ framework This presentation is based on: Court, J., and Young, J Bridging research and policy.
Susan Buhr Director, CIRES Education and Outreach University of Colorado, Boulder
Maryland’s Six Climate Audiences – Communication Suggestions Consortium Webinar Wednesday, July 30, p.m.
Welcome to Grade 8 Social Studies! Open House, Sept. 1, 2015.
By: Nicole Oldham. Effectively planned, well-paced, relevant, and interesting instruction is a key aspect of effective classroom management. For schools.
Valley View Secondary School The content of the Research Project comprises the:  Capabilities  Research framework.  In the Research Project students.
Climate Change in the Mind of a College Student A Cross-Sectional Study on Climate Change Perceptions at the University of Oklahoma Benjamin Ignac, Aparna.
The climate-science literacy measurement problem—and how to fix it Dan M. Kahan Yale University.
Character Education in Ontario Schools Dr. Douglas Fleming Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa Faculté d’éducation, Université d’Ottawa
ISTE Standards for Teachers Anja Whitehead IDT 3600 Fall 2015.
Fundamentals of Case Management Practice: Skills for the Human Services, Third Edition Chapter Four Applying the Ecological Model: A theoretical Foundation.
Peter Buckland Penn State’s Sustainability Institute Curator of The Field Guide to Teaching Sustainability Resolved:
Module 3 Ethics and Social Responsibility. Module 3 How do ethics and ethical behavior play out in the workplace? How can we maintain high standards of.
Welcome to MT140 Introduction to Management Unit 10 Seminar Reflection.
Ideas, Evidence and Argumentation. Learning Objectives To revisit/extend aspects of the nature of science To consider what ‘evidence’ is To explore.
Minding the Gap How engineering can contribute to a liberal education.
MASTER CURRICULUM DESIGN PROGRAMME - curriculum proposal of the University of Niš - TEMPUS IV MASTS Niš, 30 th November-1 th December 2011.
How do Sudanese's educators approach cultural diversity within the Turkish Universities settings? Dr. Amani A. Elfaki Department of Anatomy/ Faculty of.
How Might Classroom Climate Support Mathematical Discourse? Productive Struggle? Reasoning? Physical Space?
Clean Energy Action January 17, 2013.
Political Beliefs and Behaviors. I. American Political Culture - Americans’ shared beliefs about politics and economics (Our core democratic values)
Deliberative communication in school - obstacles and potential.
What makes Healthcare Leadership Different? Or Is It? CASBHC Brenda Morrison Engaged Public 5 May 2016.
AN INTRODUCTION Ethics + Ethical Reasoning & Social Justice.
Selective Exposure News Literacy.
Dissensus on Scientific Consensus: Who Perceives What and Why
Public Views on Climate, Energy and Environment Issues
Being as disciplined in our engagement with society as we are in our scientific research Dr. Keith L. Seitter Executive Director American Meteorological.
“Lessons Learned Teaching Difficult Subjects in Contentious Times”
Some of Psychology’s Contributions to Understanding the Climate Crisis Kathleen Wells EEE Seminar, October 17, 2016 Sources: American Psychological.
Education That Is Multicultural
Climate Calamity: Reflections from a religious activist
Chapter 16 Persuasive Speaking.
Affective Factors Chapter 6.
The Global Dimension in Science Education
VicSkeptics Presentation, 20th Jan 2014
Presentation transcript:

Crafting A Climate Science Classroom Strategy For Dealing With Cultural Identities Peter Buckland Postdoctoral Fellow, Sustainability Institute Penn State

Today 1. Me 2. The 3. “Resolved: Climate change is not a ‘crisis’”

Who am I?

Ecology Class at Kiski Course Purposes SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE: I designed the course for ecological concept mastery which requires developing literacy of scientific methods, philosophy of science, sociology of science, and knowledge discovered through the scientific enterprise. DEMOCRATIC CITIZENSHIP: Create possibilities for my students to become better ecological citizens, people who “recognizes the importance and interconnectivity of all living beings, human and non-human...[who] understands that she or he is responsible to all beings and actively seeks sustainable futures for them” (Kissling and Barton, 2013). To my mind this required: 1. Accuracy of scientific information and discourse. 2. Opportunities to develop their own views on the matter regarding risk and moral evaluations. 3. Forums to discuss different points of view.

The dreaded parent… Dear Mr. Buckland, I am…

Climate change belief

Concerns: Climate change & its discounters

Climate change & its discounters The Doubtful (13%) are uncertain whether global warming is occurring or not, but believe that if it is happening, it is attributable to natural causes, not human activities. They tend to be politically conservative and to hold traditional religious views. The Disengaged (9%) have given the issue of global warming little to no thought. They have no strongly held beliefs about global warming, know little about it, and do not view it as having any personal relevance. They tend to have the lowest education and income levels of the six groups. Dismissive (8%), who are very certain that global warming is not occurring. Many regard the issue as a hoax and are strongly opposed to action to reduce the threat. About one in nine have contacted an elected representative to argue against action on global warming. Yale Project on Climate Change Communication, Global Warming’s Six Americas, September 2012

Cultural Cognition “Cultural cognition refers to the tendency of individuals to fit their perceptions of risk and related factual beliefs to their shared moral evaluations of putatively dangerous activities. The cultural cognition thesis asserts that individuals are psychologically disposed to believe that behavior they (and their peers) find honorable is socially beneficial, and behavior they find base socially detrimental.” Kahan, Braman, & Jenkins-Smith. Cultural Cognition of Scientific Consensus. Journal of Risk Research.

Cultural Cognition Framework: Risk. Risk. Risk.

Motivated Reasoning “The unconscious tendency of individuals to process information in a manner that suits some end or goal extrinsic to the formation of accurate beliefs. ” “They Saw a Game” example ~Dan Kahan, Cultural Cognition Project of the Yale Law School On climate change this will mean we will…

Motivated Reasoning

Cultural Cognition and Motivated Reasoning Motivated Reasoning & Smart Idiots “What accounts for the “smart idiot” effect?” Chris Mooney, The Republican Brain 1. News & information consumption. 2. Familiarity with claims & counterarguments. 3. Threats to identity/ies. 4. The desire to argue and protect whatever is threatened. Chris Mooney, The Republican Brain

Science Literacy & Ecological Citizenship 1. KNOWLEDGE 2. CITIZENSHIP THERE WOULD BE CONFLICTS BETWEEN MY GOALS AND MY STUDENTS’ IDENTITIES. HOW COULD I GET AROUND THEM? THE ING PARENT PRESENTED ME WITH A CHALLENGE

The dreaded parent… Dear Mr. Buckland, I am… Dear Mr. Kiskidad, I am… not the arbiter of your son’s values.

Strategy: Careful Deliberation “Open-minded public engagement with scientific information requires a deliberation environment in which no group of citizens is forced to see assent to sound evidence as hostile to its defining commitments. In cultivating such an environment for deliberations over the problem of climate change, the diverse cultural resonances associated with the full range of potential responses is a resource to be exploited in science communication.” [Emphasis mine.] Kahan et al, “Geoengineering and Climate Change Polarization: Testing a Two-channel Model of Science Communication.” Annals of American Academy of Political & Social Sci.

“Resolved: Climate change is not a ‘crisis’”

Strategy: Intelligence Squared Debate The series is based on the traditional Oxford-style debate format, with one side proposing and the other side opposing a sharply-framed motion.

Why this format? Risk. Risk. Risk. Strengths 1. Not “Is climate change real? Yes or no?” Hoax arguments fenced out and emphasis on established peer-reviewed science through secondary sources and other vetted sources (World Bank, IEA, IPCC, Science Daily). 2. By using “not a crisis” avoid the affirmation of the “Alarmed” position. 3. Equal numbers of students would be on one side or the other. Deliberate assignment into one group or another put the Alarmed into Cautious or Discounter positions and vice versa. 4. I avoided language about being “objective,” “rational,” “unbiased,” or “open-minded” because such language prompts more motivated reasoning. Potential Pitfalls 1. Editing could out hoax arguments is a form of censorship. 2. “Far from counteracting [cultural entrenchment], deliberation among diverse groups is likely to accentuate polarization. By revealing the correlation between one of another position and one or another cultural style, public debate intensifies identity- protective pressure on individuals to conform to the views dominant within their group.”

Results “…not a crisis.” Compared to other things like wars (Crimea and Syria as examples), global poverty (African examples), or AIDS pandemic (Africa again), climate change is not a crisis. Technological optimism for advances in solar technology that will displace fossil fuel technologies (Ray Kurzweil) “…is a crisis.” Insurance and reinsurance costs are rising as more intense storms, droughts, heatwaves, and floods and rising sea levels do more damage to human and natural systems. Threats to the carbon cycle have already been so severe that major disruptions to ecosystem services and biodiversity are present and accelerating.

Results: Exploration of risk perception. “…not a crisis.” Compared to other things like wars (Crimea and Syria as examples), global poverty (African examples), or AIDS pandemic (Africa again), climate change is not a crisis. Technological optimism for advances in solar technology that will displace fossil fuel technologies (Ray Kurzweil) “…is a crisis.” Insurance and reinsurance costs are rising as more intense storms, droughts, heatwaves, and floods and rising sea levels do more damage to human and natural systems. Threats to the carbon cycle have already been so severe that major disruptions to ecosystem services and biodiversity are present and accelerating.

Ecology Class at Kiski Course Purposes SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE: I designed the course for ecological concept mastery which requires developing literacy of scientific methods, philosophy of science, sociology of science, and knowledge discovered through the scientific enterprise. DEMOCRATIC CITIZENSHIP: Create possibilities for my students to become better ecological citizens, people who “recognizes the importance and interconnectivity of all living beings, human and non-human...[who] understands that she or he is responsible to all beings and actively seeks sustainable futures for them” (Kissling and Barton, 2013). To my mind this required: 1. Accuracy of scientific information and discourse. 2. Opportunities to develop their own views on the matter regarding risk and moral evaluations. 3. Forums to discuss different points of view.

The Future Is it possible to devise teaching and communication strategies that increase science literacy without forcing people to choose between what they know and who they are? Is that a good goal when so many are so alarmed? Are there times when forcing that choice on students and the public is more important than not when a risk is really high? Is that time now? Is it moral? Can we devise teaching and communication strategies that sidestep one part of who someone to get at another part of who they are?

Two Projects Improving the Science of Climate Change and Evolution Education (ISCCEE) PIs: David Long, George Mason Dan Kahan, Yale University Connie Bertka, Smithsonian Facilitators: Peter Buckland, Penn State Tim Brown, Yale Joseph Henderson, Rochester Brianna Pobbiner, Smithsonian Pennsylvania Environmental Risks Communication Initiative Based on some unpublished work on communities threatened by sea level rise, can we use place-based or activity-based identities to increase scientific literacy and civic action on climate-related issues? In Pennsylvania what opportunities are there? Black- legged ticks and Lyme disease? Tiger mosquitoes and West Nile virus?

Questions? Peter Buckland Penn State Sustainability Institute