Be mindful of your feelings

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Legal Capacity, Personhood and Supported Decision Making
Advertisements

KEY CONCEPT Humans appeared late in Earth’s history.
Disability Studies Conference, Lancaster July 2004 Normative ethics and non-normative embodiment Jackie Leach Scully Unit for Ethics in the Biosciences,
Introduction to Ethics Lecture 19 Regan & The Case for Animal Rights
Race, Language and Culture My role is to introduce the biological aspect of the course. So, I will discuss: What is the nature of human races? Are there.
Review for Final Exam. Exam Format multiple choice questions multiple choice questions Three essay questions from a choice of five Three essay.
HUMANS AND NON-HUMANS A Spectrum “ Western ” paradigm emphasizes gulf between humans and animals ■ Religious traditions: humans as “the crown of creation”,
SESSION-4: RESPECTING OTHERS AS HUMAN BEINGS. What is “respect”? Respect has great importance in everyday life Belief: all people are worthy of respect.
The Hawaii Elder Abuse Prevention Forum July 25 th, 2014 Deborah Merrill, Senior Policy Director Page 1.
KEY CONCEPT Humans appeared late in Earth’s history.
Classification of Organisms. Categories of Biological Classification Scientists Assign Organisms Two-Word Names 2,000 yrs ago, Aristotle grouped plants.
Non-relative Virtues, An Aristotelian Approach
Question One Describe why Alan Gewirth’s position is anthropocentric.
Animals singer’s arguments. consciousness The Consciousness Account: Humans have special value because they alone are conscious. Something is conscious.
Visual Cognition II Object Perception. Theories of Object Recognition Template matching models Feature matching Models Recognition-by-components Configural.
Environmental Ethics. Definitions Moral Agents –Those who have the freedom and rational capacity to be responsible for choices –Those capable of moral.
Towards a consistent animal rights ethics Stijn Bruers.
CLASSIFICATION: The process and practice of describing, defining and ranking taxa within a hierarchical series of groups; permits organizing and ordering.
Introduction to Ethics Lecture 19 Regan & The Case for Animal Rights By David Kelsey.
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE FAIRNESS AND CULTURAL CONSIDERATIONS
Language, Mind, and Brain by Ewa Dabrowska Chapter 6: Biological underpinnings.
A possible scenario for human evolution
Evolution and Natural Selection MCAS Biology Ms. Mahoney.
Reporting Category
Taxonomic Units What is it that we are trying to do? Determine relationships among…? What do the terminal nodes represent? Often, they are supposed to.
Historical and Cultural context Describe and evaluate the cultural context and development, the conceptual framework, the methodology, and the application.
26.3 Human Evolution.
CLASSIFICATION: The process and practice of describing, defining and ranking taxa within a hierarchical series of groups; permits organizing and ordering.
Classifying the Diversity of Life Targets: 17. State the goals of taxonomy. 18. Describe how evolutionary biology and molecular biology influence classification.
Predation versus transplantation Is the animal rights ethic consistent? Stijn Bruers, IARC Esch,
Bloom’s Taxonomy Ceanlia Vermeulen.
Evidence for Evolution
How do dogs relate to other animals? What do we know about dogs? Animals (not plants) Mammals (fur, live young, milk) Carnivores (eat meat) But what SPECIFIC.
EVOLUTION Darwin’s theory of evolution by natural selection – On the Origin of Species – Organisms produce more offspring than can survive (Malthus)
BIOLOGY CONCEPTS & CONNECTIONS Fourth Edition Copyright © 2003 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Benjamin Cummings Neil A. Campbell Jane B. Reece Lawrence.
Psychology Contemporary Perspective (1:4). Six Perspectives ► Biological ► Cognitive ► Humanistic ► Psychoanalytic ► Learning ► Sociocultural.
Sociological Perspectives on Social Reality
Strategies of Life.  Biology –branch of science dealing with living systems –How do we define life? What do all living things have in common? How do.
KINGDOM ANIMALIA roundworm flatworm Snail Segmented worm Sea Sponge
The Pro-Skills’ background theory & philosophy. Pro-Skills’ background philosophy World rapid change requiring more special competences + Global financial.
Chapter 13 Modern Human Diversity. Chapter Outline  What are the causes of physical variability in animals?  Is the biological concept of race useful.
Copyright © 2008 Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Benjamin Cummings Evolution, Biodiversity and Extinctions.
Evolution on a short time scale Guppies are red or gray Killifish is green Pike cichlid is blue Doesn’t eat much Does eat.
An act is moral if it brings more good consequences than bad ones. What is the action to be evaluated? What would be the good consequences? How certain.
Animals and Persons. Ethical status for animals Kantian and utilitarian ethics traditionally extended to all people, but only people Kant: all rational.
Unit 2.  Biological Anthropology seeks to understand the role of biology in understanding human culture.
An Introduction to Classification November 29, 2010.
CLASSIFICATION: The process and practice of describing, defining and ranking taxa within a hierarchical series of groups; permits organizing and ordering.
The History of Evolutionary Thought. Aristotle ( B.C.) Ladder of Life »2 types of animals – those w/ blood & those w/o Animals classified by their.
Chapter 8, Processes of Macroevolution Key Terms.
MODERN UTILITARIANISM AND GENETIC ENGINEERING IS IT WRONG TO INTERFERE WITH NATURE? CAN WE JUSTIFY THE SACRIFICE OF A FEW LIVES TO SAVE MANY? DO ANIMALS.
Biological Classification Terminology, Methods and Representative Systems.
University of Sunderland Professionalism and Personal Skills Unit 11 Professionalism and Personal Skills Reflection Exercise.
Standards and Competences for Social work Education for working with children and youth Prof dr Nevenka Zegarac Ass MA Anita Burgund.
Evidence of Evolution and Natural Selection. Evolution The development of new types of organisms from preexisting types of organisms.
What causes the "struggle for existence"? Which animal has INCREASED fitness? Living in a dry, wooded area in the fall season….. Living in north Canada…in.
Chapter 8 Thinking and Language.
Philosophical approaches to animal ethics
The Moral Hand Stijn Bruers Ghent University.
Bloom’s Taxonomy of Learning
Michael Lacewing Eating animals Michael Lacewing © Michael Lacewing.
The Moral Hand Stijn Bruers, IARC 2013.
How moral illusions make us less effective
Animals and Persons.
Two Species or Not Two Species?
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE FAIRNESS AND CULTURAL CONSIDERATIONS
Moral Reasoning 1.
Lecture 09: A Brief Summary
Kant, Anderson, Marginal Cases
All Animals are Created Equal
Presentation transcript:

Be mindful of your feelings Speciesism as a moral illusion Stijn Bruers, IARC, Esch, sept-2012

Overview What are moral illusions? Analogy with optical illusions How to detect moral illusion? Do moral illusions exist? Yes: the trolley problem Can speciesism be a moral illusion?

Moral illusions Moral illusions are obstinate but incorrect intuitive judgments, comparable to the famous optical illusions. Method to detect them: Coherentism (reflective equilibrium): mutual support of intuitions and principles Universalism: translating strong moral intuitions into universalized ethical principles Consistency Knowledge about moral psychological mechanisms

Coherentism More than merely consistency Crossword puzzle (white boxes = situations) Universalism: words (=universal principles) instead of separate letters (=situational intuitions/rules) Consistency: 1 letter per box

Optical illusions Translation-invariance: measure sticks never change length when shifted in any direction

Optical illusions Translation-invariance Context-independence: influence of environment is arbitrary, artificial, fuzzy: never important

Optical illusions Translation-invariance Context-independence Optical mechanism 3D->2D perspective adaptation (heuristics, D.Kahneman) Lateral inhibition (contrasts) Coherent

Moral illusions: the trolley problem

Moral illusions: the trolley problem

Moral illusions: the trolley problem Action allowed: 90% of people A

Moral illusions: the trolley problem Action allowed: 50% of people B

Moral illusions: the trolley problem Action allowed: 10% of people C

Moral illusions: the trolley problem A versus B and C: victim is not used as merely means A and B versus C: victim is not send to threat What distinguishes B from C? The locus of intervention (at victim or at threat): “throwing bomb on a person or throwing person on a bomb?”

Moral illusions: the trolley problem Translation invariance All individuals have Right not to be killed Right not to be used as merely means Moral status of individual is independent from locus of intervention

Moral illusions: the trolley problem Context independence: erase irrelevant details B C

Moral illusions: the trolley problem Psychological mechanism Intervention myopia: “people who are evaluating the morality of options may give victims in the background less weight than victims in the attentional spotlight.” (Waldmann & Dieterich, 2007) Moral heuristic: attribute substitution (Kahneman, 1982; Sunstein, 2005)

Can speciesism be a moral illusion? 5 arguments against speciesism (context independence) 5 arguments pro sentience (translation invariance) Essentialism and heuristics (psychological mechanism)

Against speciesism Who am I? I am: white (population), a Homo sapiens sapiens (subspecies), a Homo sapiens (species), a Homo (genus), a great ape (family), a Hominoid (super family), a simian (infraorder), a dry nosed primate (suborder), a primate (order), a placental (infra class), a mammal (class), a vertebrate (phylum), an animal (kingdom) Too arbitrary

Phylum of chordata and vertebrates Kingdom of animals Phylum of chordata and vertebrates Class of mammals Infra class of placentals Order of primates Suborder of dry nosed primates Infraorder of simians Super family of Homonoids Family of great apes Genus Homo Species of Homo sapiens Subspecies of Homo sapiens sapiens Population of whites

Against speciesism What is a human? What about humanzee hybrids? human-animal chimera? ancestors (Homo habilis, Australopithecus,…)? genetically modified humans,…?

Against speciesism How is a species defined? Interbreeding and fertile offspring? All species are connected into one “temporal ring species”. Is the accidental death of intermediates relevant? Cfr. context independence: speciesism is arbitrary, artificial, intrinsically fuzzy

Against speciesism Genes and bodily properties are not relevant in situation A (e.g. racism), so should not be relevant in situation B (speciesism). Speciesism is a violation of the merit principle

Sentience Well-being and impartiality. Cfr. consequentialist (Singer) and contractualist (Rowlands) ethics: veil of ignorance Empathy is a virtue to be developed (virtue ethics and ethics of care) Cfr translation invariance, using empathy or the veil of ignorance to put yourself into the position of the other

Sentience Rights ethics: the connection between feelings, interests and rights is not farfetched Feelings detect interests (e.g.: pain -> bodily integrity) Rights protect interests Consciousness is special (complex, vulnerable,…) and should be protected Sentience is the only mental capacity that mentally disabled humans share with us

Essentialism The psychological explanation Children and adults (from different cultures and backgrounds) intuitively describe biological entities in essentialist terms. They think that biological categories have invisible essences (Gelman, 2003; Bloom, 2010) Studies about racism also demonstrates that racists think of races or ethnic groups as being essentialized natural groups (Gil-White, 2001) But essentialism is in contradiction with Darwinism and current biology

Speciesism as a moral illusion Moral status of animal Moral status of human (Morally) irrelevant properties The ten arguments are coherent with each other There is no “essence” related to lines with inward pointing arrowheads

Speciesism as a moral heuristic Daniel Kahneman, Cass Sunstein Attribute substitution Target attribute: rationality, self-consciousness,… Heuristic attribute: human Based on Pattern recognition skills: a human is easier to detect than a rational being Most humans have the target attribute Heuristic ‘misfires’ at mentally disabled humans Should people keep this heuristic?