The evaluation of quality of the training offer at territorial level The evaluation of quality of the training offer within territorial systems Isfol –

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Antonio Mocci External evaluation Ede - the Netherlands, 11 December 2009.
Advertisements

1 The new ESF Investing in your Future -
Slovenian experience MEASURES TO STRENGHTEN THE CIVIL DIALOGUE AND PARTNERSHIP Irma Mežnarič Brussels - 10 October 2006.
Commission européenne The European Social Fund Investing in your Future.
The LAZIO 2020 White Paper Regional Strategic Plan for the strengthening of local labour markets. Speaker: Mariella Zezza Councillor of Training and Labour.
Samuele Dossi DG for Regional Policy - Evaluation
Community Strategic Guidelines DG AGRI, July 2005 Rural Development.
Western Balkans and Europe 2020 Western Balkans and Europe 2020 Towards Convergence and Growth – Draft Conclusions Brussels, March 2011.
Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions.
Dorotea Daniele, Facilitator. The members Polish Ministry of Regional Development ESF Council in Sweden Lombardy Region Ministry of Labour and Social.
European Social Fund Evaluation in Italy Stefano Volpi Roma, 03 maggio 2011 Isfol Esf Evaluation Unit Human Resources Policies Evaluation Area Rome, Corso.
QUALITY ASSURANCE SYSTEM IN VET LUGANO MEETING
ECVET WORKSHOP 2 22/23/24 November The European Quality Assurance Reference Framework.
LEADER -The acronym ‘LEADER' derives from the French words "Liaison Entre Actions de Développement de l'Économique Rurale“ which means, ‘Links between.
CONTACT SEMINAR November 2008 Project management tools.
Luis Vives Foundation STRUCTURAL FUNDS AND SOCIAL COHESION CII – Coalition Buildings Among Third Sector Organizations Speaker: José Manuel Fresno Luis.
Standards and Guidelines for Quality Assurance in the European
Linking the European Youth Strategy to the YOUTH IN ACTION opportunities Hans-Georg Wicke JUGEND für Europa – NA for YOUTH IN ACTION in Germany Rotterdam,
Central management of training Program development Local implementation of programs Government orientations, policies and structures Components of the.
Leonardo da Vinci Project BLENDED LEARNING TRANSFER Rationalising, Learning and Transferring the use of technological platforms to enterprise-based learning.
Quality assurance in IVET in Romania Lucian Voinea Mihai Iacob Otilia Apostu 4 th Project Meeting Prague, 21 st -22 nd October 2010.
Preparation of Bulgaria for future use of EU Structural Instruments Lyubomir Datzov Deputy Minister of Finance.
TORINO PROCESS. TORINO PROCESS 2014 THE TORINO PROCESS 2 THE TORINO PROCESS IS a participatory process leading to an evidence-based analysis of VET policies.
Riga – Latvia, 4 & 5 December 2006
Local authorities’ role in implementing European Employment Strategy - case Finland Mr. Lauri Lamminmäki, Senior Adviser Association of Finnish Local and.
Integrated Growth Pillar 1 of the SEE 2020 Strategy SEEIC Meeting Sarajevo, 19 June 2013.
Strategic Framework for European cooperation in education and training
University of Bologna, Italy TEMPUS LV-TEMPUS-SMHES – HESDESPI
EQARF Applying EQARF Framework and Guidelines to the Development and Testing of Eduplan.
FLLLEX – Final Evaluation
EQAVET Supporting European quality assurance in Vocational Education and Training European Quality Assurance in Vocational Education and Training.
1 Analysing the contributions of fellowships to industrial development November 2010 Johannes Dobinger, UNIDO Evaluation Group.
Leonardo da Vinci Partnerships: an opportunity to work together Italian National Agency for LLP - Leonardo da Vinci Sectoral Programme.
Regional Policy Common Strategic Framework The Commission's revised proposal for the CPR - COM (2012) 496 of 11 Sept.
The new EU cohesion policy ( ) EASPD Project Development Workshop May 10th – Sofia (BG) Jelle Reynaert – Policy Officer.
The Tuscan System for Environmental Education: a model of integration and participation.
Institutional structures for Structural Funds assistance Ministry of Finance September 10, 2003.
Regional Policy EU Cohesion Policy 2014 – 2020 Proposals from the European Commission.
Richard Walther, TVSD: the role of NGOs “ 10 main points to consider as an NGO designing a TVSD program’. ” BU-net, January 2010 Richard Walther, AFD.
CHE Business Plan Mission The mission of the CHE is to contribute to the development of a higher education system that is characterised by.
ROMANIA MINISTRY OF EDUCATION, RESEARCH AND INNOVATION National Center for Development of Technical and Vocational Education and Training Programme Implementation.
Project financed under Phare EUROPEAN UNION MERI/ NCDTVET - PIU Material produced under Phare 2006 financial support Phare TVET RO RO2006/
ROMANIA MINISTRY OF EDUCATION, RESEARCH AND INNOVATION National Centre for Development of Vocational Education and Training Implementation Unit of Phare.
International Conference on
Fondo Social Europeo Regions for Economic Change – Sharing Excellence Brussels, February 2008 IMPLEMENTATION OF STRATEGIES AND TOOLS FOR BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT.
Changes in the context of evaluation and assessment: the impact of the European Lifelong Learning strategy Romuald Normand, Institute of Education Lyon,
LLP Multilateral Comenius Partnership FUTURE EUROPEAN TEACHERS:TRAINING KIT ACCORDING TO THE LISBON STRATEGY ESkillsKit.
Quality Assurance in HE and VET May, 2006 Graz Workshop 7 QIBB – Qualitätsinitiative Berufsbildung The Austrian Approach to Quality in VET Part 1:
REGIONAL POLICY EUROPEAN COMMISSION The contribution of EU Regional/Cohesion programmes Corinne Hermant-de Callataÿ European Commission,
Material produced under Phare 2006 financial support Phare TVET RO 2006/ Project financed under Phare EUROPEAN UNION MERI/ NCDTVET-PIU.
The Structural Funds in the EU are intended to help increase economic and social cohesion between Member States and constitute an important instrument.
Future needs for capacity building and recommendations to the OIE Dr Sarah Kahn Consultant to the OIE
EUROPEAN NEIGHBOURHOOD AND PARTNERSHIP INSTRUMENT - ENPI CROSS-BORDER COOPERATION PROGRAMMES.
Social Protection Global Technical Team Retreat,
TRAINERS AND TRAINING PROCESSES
Measuring social added value Italian experiences
Strategic Planning for Learning Organizations
Programme Review Dhaya Naidoo Director: Quality Promotion
ESF and IB New ESF priority which recognises the need to support the strengthening of institutional and administrative capacity in Convergence regions.
Supporting Kenya and Uganda in developing and strengthening environmental-economic accounting for improved monitoring of sustainable development Alessandra.
Employment and Social Affairs Platform
The European Social Fund
“Monitoring and evaluation of Italian Youth Guarantee Implementation Plan” A joint project of Italian Ministry of Labour and Social Policies and ISFOL.
Introduction to CPD Quality Assurance
…and still actual for a post-2010 strategy!
Sectoral Operational Programme Human Resources Development
Social Dialogue on Education and Training ESF Committee 10 March 2011
Future of Cohesion Policy
ESF EVALUATION PARTNERSHIP
ESF evaluation partnership
Presentation transcript:

The evaluation of quality of the training offer at territorial level The evaluation of quality of the training offer within territorial systems Isfol – Area for the evaluation of policies in the field of Human Resources

A model for evaluating the quality of the training offer ISFOL has elaborated a model representing an instrument for self-evaluation – destined to all administrations responsible of professional training and educations policies – aiming at improving the different dimensions of systems quality, having regard of mutual connections. Its application, at regular intervals within a self-diagnosis process, permits to each administration to obtain a check list of areas of sections inside the system which could be improved and have to be kept under observation in order to increase the qualitative level.

The definition of quality by typology of approach to training Training as a didactic activity Training as a service to a beneficiary Training as a service of public utility Training as an enterprise function Training as an economic activity Training as a policy Quality = optimising the teaching – learning process Quality = satisfying the client Quality = conforming to a standard Quality = Total Quality Management Quality = improving results and performances Quality = reaching the objectives

The model Approach The model: Refers to a training offer system at territorial and institutional level; Considers policies and professional education and training interventions as subjects for evaluation, as regards: - programming / planning - implementation processes; - achievements, results, impacts.

The model review The model takes into account: The necessary conditions for achieving Lisbon objectives; The European Recommendations as regards the creation of a reference framework for quality assurance within professional education and training systems; The approach to the evaluation of human resources development policies within the National Strategic Framework (NSF); The results of experimentations.

The European Strategy for Education and Training 2010 Among the 8 policy sectors identified by the European Strategy, the model contributes to evaluating: The equity within education and training systems; The efficiency within education and training systems; The employability of those who have participated in training activities

The approach to quality within the NSF The general objective of the first NSF Priority (improving and valorising human resources) is to “strengthen, integrate and improve the quality of education, training and labour systems, as well as their connections with the territory. It is articulated in the following specific objectives: Improving the quality of education and training offer, as well as learning results, and facilitating the recognisability of competences; Improving the implementation process governance and the integration among the education, training and labour systems, as well as their relationship with the territory

The characteristics of the model 4 criteria for defining the quality of the training offer have been identified; Each criteria refers to a variable number of dimensions and sub-dimensions that can be evaluated through a set of indicators; The model takes into account the declination of dimensions and sub-dimensions for specific training sectors.

Quality dimensions by criteria Criteria 1 – The relevance of strategic planning: strategic planning reflects a vision that is agreed among stakeholders and answers to the needs of professional profiles within the territory. Needs’ analysis as regards professional profiles and training or as regards structured mechanisms for demand revealing / analysing Implementing integrated education, training and labour programming processes.

Quality dimensions by criteria Criteria 2 - The equity of training as compared to the beneficiaries’ needs: consists in the capacity to identify potential beneficiaries and to offer a training respondent to individuals’ needs, by integrating education, training, labour and social inclusion policies. Diffusing information. Identifying beneficiaries that are under conditions of distress Adapting the training offer to the beneficiaries’ typology Certifying competences Targeted accompaniment actions Individual training demand and, in general, individual systems for accessing and utilising training services. Mechanisms and instruments of conciliation Integrating professional guidance, training and education.

Quality dimensions by criteria Criteria 3 – The relative effectiveness of training interventions and policies Asset profile of proposals presented and approved for financing Recognition of competencies Evaluating the learning process of trainees Trainees’ success rate Employees’ gross employment insertion Observing participants’ satisfaction

Quality dimensions by criteria Criteria 4 – Sustainability: is defined by strengthening capacity building of administrations responsible of training and labour policies Existing system actions Training of trainers activity Governance of interventions didactic dimension Policies and interventions in support of training bodies’ evaluation / self – evaluation Strengthening the governance system

Experimentations The model for evaluating the training offer quality has been experimented in two regions: Liguria and Toscana Regions (Province Lucca and Pistoia). Each experimentation represents a possible modality to apply / develop the same model.

The European Reference Framework Isfol – National Structure for the evaluation of ESF Area for the evaluation of policies in the field of Human Resources Isfol model and the European Reference Framework have in common the overall approach to quality, because: it considers “evaluation” as an instrument to support the decision making process as well as an instrument for improving programming and implementation; it valorises “participated” evaluation; it refers to self-evaluation; it considers quality evaluation as a system evaluation of processes, products, realisations, results and impacts.