Recruitment success and variability in marine fish populations: Does age-truncation matter? Sarah Ann Siedlak 1, John Wiedenmann 2 1 University of Miami,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Today’s Lecture One more test for normality Testing variances
Advertisements

Differential Impacts of Climate Change on Spawning Populations of Atlantic cod in U.S. Waters Lisa Kerr, Steve Cadrin (UMass School for Marine Science.
Fish Population Assessment How many fish do we have?
MSFD Indicators and Reference Points for Data-Limited Stocks Rainer Froese GEOMAR ICES MSFD Workshop, Copenhagen 13 January 2014.
Covariation in Productivity of Mid-Columbia Steelhead Populations S.P. Cramer & Associates, Inc. 600 N.W. Fariss Road Gresham, OR
C3: Estimation of size-transition matrices with and without molt probability for Alaska golden king crab using tag–recapture data M.S.M. Siddeek, J. Zheng,
Black Sea Bass – Northern Stock Coastal-Pelagic/ASMFC Working Group Review June 15, 2010.
Analysis of the relationship between the frequency and method of natural mortality estimates of flatfishes Nathan K. Ramsey 1, Olaf P. Jensen 2, and Kenneth.
Comparative Analysis of Statistical Tools To Identify Recruitment-Environment Relationships and Forecast Recruitment Strength Bernard A. Megrey Yong-Woo.
Methods I  Weekly larval fish tows were conducted in Little Sheepshead Creek from 1989 into the present. Examining the Correlation between Spawning Stock.
LONG-TERM EFFECTS OF SIZE- SELECTIVE FISHERIES & HATCHERY MATING PRACTICES ON AGE & SEX COMPOSITION OF CHINOOK SALMON RETURNING TO HATCHERIES David Hankin.
Clupeid and Gadoid Fisheries
Chronicles of catches from marine fisheries in the Eastern Central Atlantic for Luca Garibaldi and Richard Grainger Fishery Information, Data.
Biodiversity of Fishes Stock-Recruitment Relationships Rainer Froese,
Johan Hjort Symposium, Bergen, NO7 Oct Do eggs collected in surveys accurately reflect adult fecundities? Hannes Höffle 1, Frode B. Vikebø 1, Olav.
Marine Fisheries Terms to Know Fishery – Refers to aspects of harvesting and managing aquatic organisms. Can refer specifically to a species being harvested,
Simple Approaches to Data-Poor Stock Assessment Rainer Froese March 9, 2011, Troutdale, Oregon.
Using U.S. and Canadian Atlantic Research Trawl Surveys to Lead Development of a Standards Based Ocean Observing System R. Branton 1, J. Black 1, J. McRuer.
An overview of the 2014 Gulf of Maine cod stock assessment Michael Palmer Northeast Fisheries Science Center National Marine Fisheries Service 166 Water.
MSFD Indicators and Reference Points for Data-Limited Stocks Rainer Froese GEOMAR EU-BON Workshop, Leipzig 18 February 2014.
State of the Marine Environment Rainer Froese Leibniz Institute of Marine Sciences, Kiel IfM-GEOMAR
Revisiting Stock-Recruitment Relationships Rainer Froese Mini-workshop on Fisheries: Ecology, Economics and Policy CAU, Kiel, Germany.
Megan Stachura and Nathan Mantua University of Washington School of Aquatic and Fishery Sciences September 8, 2012.
60º Introduction and Background ù The Barents Sea covers an area of about 1.4 x 10 6 km 2, with an average depth of 230 m. ù Climatic variations depend.
BPS - 3rd Ed. Chapter 211 Inference for Regression.
Jo King: The Implications of Warming Climate for the Management of North Sea Demersal Fisheries R.M. Cook and M.R. Heath FRS Marine Laboratory, P.O. Box.
Investigating the Accuracy and Robustness of the Icelandic Cod Assessment and Catch Control Rule A. Rosenberg, G. Kirkwood, M. Mangel, S. Hill and G. Parkes.
Pacific Hake Management Strategy Evaluation Joint Technical Committee Northwest Fisheries Science Center, NOAA Pacific Biological Station, DFO School of.
CPT Overfishing Working Group Crab Plan Team Presentation, September 2005.
Centre for Ecological and Evolutionary Synthesis ICES/NAFO Decadal Symposium Santander, Spain May 12th 2011 The serial recruitment failure to North Sea.
Biological and environmental factors influencing recruitment success of North Sea demersal and pelagic fish stocks Alan Sinclair Fisheries and Oceans Canada.
PCB 3043L - General Ecology Data Analysis. OUTLINE Organizing an ecological study Basic sampling terminology Statistical analysis of data –Why use statistics?
FTP Yield per recruit models. 2 Objectives Since maximizing effort does not maximize catch, the question is if there is an optimum fishing rate that would.
Harvesting and viability
Economic impacts of changes in fish population dynamics: the role of the fishermen’s behavior Dipl.-Geogr. Peter Michael Link, BA Research Unit Sustainability.
Extending GIS with Statistical Models to Predict Marine Species Distributions Zach Hecht-Leavitt NY Department of State Division of Coastal Resources.
Jennifer M. Marsh M.S. Fisheries Student School of Fisheries and Ocean Sciences University of Alaska Fairbanks.
The management of small pelagics. Comprise the 1/3 of the total world landings Comprise more than 50% of the total Mediterranean landings, while Two species,
PCB 3043L - General Ecology Data Analysis.
M.S.M. Siddeeka*, J. Zhenga, A.E. Puntb, and D. Pengillya
Is there a ‘cryptic biomass’ of relatively old and large red snapper in southeast US continental shelf-break waters?
SEDAR 42: US Gulf of Mexico Red grouper assessment Review Workshop Introduction SEFSC July , 2015.
Biodiversity of Fishes Stock-Recruitment Relationships
Do environmental factors affect recruit per spawner anomalies in the Gulf of Maine - Southern New England region ? Jon Brodziak and Loretta O’Brien NOAA.
Age and Growth of Pacific Sardine in California During a Period of Stock Recovery and Geographical Expansion By Emmanis Dorval Jenny McDaniel Southwest.
1 Federal Research Centre for Fisheries Institute for Sea Fisheries, Hamburg Hans-Joachim Rätz Josep Lloret Institut de Ciències del Mar, Barcelona Long-term.
Incorporation of Climate-Ocean Information in Short- and Medium Term Sprat Predictions in the Baltic Sea Acknowledgements: ICES Baltic Fish. Assess. WG.
Upstream passage success rates and straying of returning adults Presenter: Jack Tuomikoski CSS Annual Meeting Apr 2 nd 2010.
1 Climate Change and Implications for Management of North Sea Cod (Gadus morhua) L.T. Kell, G.M. Pilling and C.M. O’Brien CEFAS, Lowestoft.
MSE Performance Metrics, Tentative Results and Summary Joint Technical Committee Northwest Fisheries Science Center, NOAA Pacific Biological Station, DFO.
Empirical comparison of historical data and age- structured assessment models for Prince William Sound and Sitka Sound Pacific herring Peter-John F. Hulson,
The influence of climate on cod, capelin and herring in the Barents Sea Dag Ø. Hjermann (CEES, Oslo) Nils Chr. Stenseth (CEES, Oslo & IMR, Bergen) Geir.
December 3, Fisheries & Marine Reserves. 1. Problems with fisheries. 2. Video on fisheries in New England. 3. Marine reserves - pros and cons.
For 2014 Show the line of R producing SSB, and SSB producing R, and how they would spiderweb to get to equilibrium R. Took a long time, did not get to.
Consequences of changing climate for North Atlantic cod stocks and implications for fisheries management Keith Brander ICES/GLOBEC Coordinator.
MSE on the East Coast Mike Wilberg Chesapeake Biological Laboratory University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science May 8, 2015.
Clark’s Method for Estimating F% proxy for Fmsy Clark’s maximin method of estimating F% is determined by the intersection of the least productive and most.
Current Problems in the Management of Marine Fisheries by J. R. Beddington, D. J. Agnew, and C. W. Clark Science Volume 316(5832): June 22, 2007.
Proposed Regulations for the Commercial Herring Fishery Proposed Regulations for the Commercial Herring Fishery Presented by the Department.
PRINCIPLES OF STOCK ASSESSMENT. Aims of stock assessment The overall aim of fisheries science is to provide information to managers on the state and life.
When is Spawning Biomass a Good Proxy for Stock Reproductive Potential? A Case Study of Red Snapper (Lutjanus campechanus) in the Gulf of Mexico SEFSC.
MARAM International Stock Assessment Workshop
PCB 3043L - General Ecology Data Analysis.
Combining Ocean Observing Systems with Statistical Analysis to Account for a Dynamic Habitat Collin Dobson1,John Manderson2,Josh Kohut1,Laura Palamara1,Oscar.
MSFD Descriptor 3 population age and size distribution indicative of a healthy stock Gerjan Piet & Thomas Brunel.
MSFD Indicators and Reference Points for Data-Limited Stocks
Biodiversity of Fishes Stock-Recruitment Relationships
Lakes & Large Impoundments Chapter 22
Volume 21, Issue 18, Pages (September 2011)
MSFD Indicators and Reference Points for Data-Limited Stocks
Presentation transcript:

Recruitment success and variability in marine fish populations: Does age-truncation matter? Sarah Ann Siedlak 1, John Wiedenmann 2 1 University of Miami, Coral Gables, FL 33146, 2 Institute of Marine and Coastal Sciences, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ To explore the effects of age-truncation on the population dynamics of marine fishes. Use information collected from stock assessments to test the hypotheses that populations with greater age- truncation (i.e., those comprised disproportionately of younger fish) will have less successful and more variable recruitment as suggested by Palumbi (2004) and Hsieh et al. (2006), respectively. 45% of stocks analyzed show either a positive (9%) or negative (36%) relationship, where the age of spawners significantly impacts recruitment success (Figure 3a). No apparent trend of relationship patterns across species or families. Therefore, managing for age structure may not be as important as managing for sustainable harvest rates. Recruitment variability does not appear to be affected by age-truncation for the majority of stocks we explored (Figure 3b). Figure 3. a) Relative slopes of recruitment deviations vs. mean spawner age for all 33 stocks, colored by family. b) Ratio of recruitment variability between young and old spawners varied greatly across populations, especially for Gadidae and Pleuronectidae families. Significant for 4 different populations. * = statistically significant result, with significance for the variance ratio determined using Levene’s test (Levene 1960). Figure 2. a) Example spawning biomass vs. recruitment plot for Gulf of Maine haddock showing the recruitment models (lines) fit to the data (colored circles). Model comparison was done using Akaike Information Criterion (AIC), and the best-fitting model is the one with the highest AIC weight (shown in parentheses; in this case the Beverton-Holt model). b) Relative deviations from the best-fitting model from a) as a function of the mean age of the spawning biomass. The red line represents the linear fit, with significance determined using AIC. Sustainable management of marine fisheries requires a better understanding of the factors controlling reproductive success (recruitment) and variability. Most fisheries typically remove the largest (and oldest) individuals in the population, resulting in a truncation of the population age structure. In this study, the effects of this age-truncation on the recruitment success and variability were explored for 33 populations in the North Atlantic using information from stock assessments. For most populations we explored, age-truncation is not predicted to affect recruitment success and variability, suggesting that calls to change harvest practices across fisheries to protect older fish are likely unwarranted. To determine the effects of age-truncation on recruitment success and variability we used the following steps: 1)Collect stock assessment reports for North Atlantic fish populations in U.S. and European waters for our analyses (NEFSC 2008; ICES 2011). 2)Compile annual estimates of recruitment, total spawning biomass, and spawning biomass-at-age from reports. 3)Determine the best fitting model predicting recruitment as a function of spawning biomass (Figure 2a). 4)Calculate the relative recruitment deviations from 3) and the mean age of the spawners each year. 5)Fit linear model to relationship predicting recruitment deviations as a function of spawner age (Figure 2b). 6)Calculate the variability in recruitment for young and old spawners (young = lower 50%; old = upper 50%). Methods Hsieh, C.H., Beddington, J.R., Hunter, J.R., May, R.M., Reiss, C.S., Sugihara, G. (2006). Fishing elevates variability in the abundance of exploited species. Nature 443, ICES (2011). Report of the Fisheries Working Group, 28 April–4 May ICES CM 2011/ACOM:05. Levene, H. (1960). In Contributions to Probability and Statistics: Essays in Honor of Harold Hotelling, I. Olkin et al. eds., Stanford University Press, pp Abstract Conclusions Objectives Figure 1. Example of age-truncation in a population. With no fishing (top), the proportion of spawning biomass remains high at older ages (62% of biomass is age 6 or older). Under heavy fishing (bottom), the oldest fish are removed, and the spawning biomass is dominated by younger fish (only 5% of the biomass is age 6 or older). Modified from Wiedenmann and Mangel (2007). ReferencesAcknowledgments We thank the National Science Foundation for the opportunity to participate in the Research Internships in Ocean Sciences Program at Rutgers University. Many thanks to all faculty and staff at the Rutgers University Marine Field Station Spawning biomass R e c r u i t s linear(0.006) Beverton-Holt (0.793) Ricker(0.201) Mean age of spawning biomass R e c r u i t m e n t d e v i a t i o n s Gulf of Maine Haddock ab a b NEFSC (2008). Assessment of 19 Northeast groundfish stocks through Report of the 3rd Groundfish Assessment Review Meeting (2008 GARM III). Woods Hole, Massachusetts, Northeast Fisheries Science Center. Palumbi, S.R. Why mothers matter. Nature, 430, (2004). Wiedenmann, J. and M. Mangel Rebuilding Fisheries. Phase 2. Identifying Situations of Special Concern. Final report to the Lenfest Ocean Program. Results