BEIJING BRUSSELS CHICAGO DALLAS FRANKFURT GENEVA HONG KONG LONDON LOS ANGELES NEW YORK SAN FRANCISCO SHANGHAI SINGAPORE TOKYO WASHINGTON, D.C. How Foreign.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
© Hogan & Hartson LLP. All rights reserved. Second CIS Local Counsel Forum Park Inn Azerbaijan Hotel, Baku, Azerbaijan Tomasz Dobrowolski, Partner
Advertisements

International investment agreements: key issues and features
FDI TRENDS AND POLICY OPTIONS IN LDCs: TRAINING AND CAPACITY-BUILDING 25 September 2007 INVESTMENT PROMOTION IN INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENT AGREEMENTS AND.
Presented by Ucheora Onwuamaegbu * Arent Fox LLP Washington, DC| New York, NY | Los Angeles, CA| San Francisco, CA * Admitted in the United Kingdom and.
International and foreign Investment Law Part I Introduction, history and sources Azar Aliyev LL.M. (University of Heidelberg)
Comprehensive Volume, 18 th Edition Chapter 7: The Legal Environment of International Trade.
Fundamentals of International Energy Transactions Shay Kuperman January 24, 2008 © Vinson & Elkins LLP Shay Kuperman January 24, 2008 ©
International Political and Legal Environments. Doing business abroad is risky. Political risk Economic risk Commercial risk Regulatory risk Legal risk.
Developed by Cool Pictures and MultiMedia Presentations Copyright © 2004 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning, Inc. All rights reserved.
Towards a Model Investment Contract Making Agricultural Investment Work for Africa, 4-5 October 2012, Cotonou, Benin Henrique Suzy Nikiema and Carin Smaller,
Conflict Resolution.
THE WORLD BANK World Bank Group Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency 1 Investment Policy, Legal Framework, & Promotion Investment Facilitation Sector.
“Why do business in Panama?” A Survey of Certain Legal Aspects David M. Mizrachi This document is not meant to be relied upon in place of seeking independent.
International Commercial Arbitration Lec1: Introduction & Overview (part 1)
China’s Investment Treaty Policy ---Recent Changes and Future Direction Wenhua Shan Xi’an Jiaotong University, China Oxford Brookes University, UK.
Richard M. Franklin Chicago, Illinois Baker & McKenzie International is a Swiss Verein with member law firms around the world. In accordance with the common.
September 23, 2011 World Bank Annual Meetings International Law Institute CSO Forum ICSID Arbitration Paul-Jean Le Cannu Counsel - ICSID.
Agricultural Investments and International Arbitration Joe Zang, Marquita Davis and Carin Smaller March, 2015.
Investment: TRIMS and Bilateral Investment Provisions October- 1 November 2007, International Training Centre of the ILO, Turin.
Investment Treaties University of Miami School of Law September 10, 2008 Mark Anderson Counsel — Latin America & the Caribbean Caterpillar Inc.
The Political, Legal, and Regulatory Environments of Global Marketing Chapter 5.
BEIJING BRUSSELS CHICAGO DALLAS FRANKFURT GENEVA HONG KONG LONDON LOS ANGELES NEW YORK SAN FRANCISCO SHANGHAI SINGAPORE SYDNEY TOKYO WASHINGTON, D.C. The.
Key Issues (and Concerns) of Foreign Investors in the Energy Sector Protection under Investment Treaties Willibald Plesser 9 June 2008, Tirana.
International standards related to foreign investment James Graham.
BEIJING BOSTON BRUSSELS CHICAGO DALLAS FRANKFURT GENEVA HONG KONG HOUSTON LONDON LOS ANGELES NEW YORK PALO ALTO SAN FRANCISCO SHANGHAI SINGAPORE SYDNEY.
International Investment Treaties in South America November, 2008.
The Impact of the TTIP on Europe’s Investment Arbitration Architecture Dr. Roland Kläger10. DAJV Fachgruppentag - 21 March 2014.
The IISD Model International Agreement on Investment for Sustainable Development: 1 st ANNUAL FORUM OF DEVELOPING COUNTRY INVESTMENT NEGOTIATORS Singapore.
Second Annual Forum of Developing Country Investment Negotiators 2-4 November 2008 “Linkages Between Investment Treaties and Host Government Agreements”
Introduction to Investment Treaties and Health Benn M c Grady, PhD O’Neill Institute for National and Global Health Law Georgetown University Law Center.
International Legal Environment Bases for legal systems Jurisdiction How to settle disputes Protection of intellectual property Bribery & Foreign Corrupt.
ZIEMONS & RAESCHKE ‑ KESSLER RECHTSANWÄLTE BEIM BUNDESGERICHTSHOF.
CHAPTER 13 International Transactions. 2 INTRODUCTION This chapter introduces the student to the increasingly complex legal environment of international.
International Law in a Global Economy Chapter 24.
ICSID and the Investor-State Dispute Settlement System (ISDS) to be or not to be for African states ? 2015 Annual Conference of the Chartered Institute.
1 The Political, Legal, and Regulatory Environments of Global Marketing Global Marketing Chapter 5.
PUA Annual Conference The Energy Charter Jerusalem 30 November 2015 Ernesto Bonafé Regulatory expert Energy Charter Secretariat.
INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENT AGREEMENTS AND INVESTOR-STATE ARBITRATION LECTURE 1. IIAs: types, features and trends Sergey Ripinsky International Investment.
I N S U R I N G I N V E S T M E N T S E N S U R I N G O P P O R T U N I T I E S Coverage of Sovereign and Sub-sovereign Risks in Infrastructure Multilateral.
INVESTMENT TREATY ARBITRATION Current Practices, Challenges and Future Paths duensingkippen.com Olaf Duensing, FCIArb DUENSING KIPPEN, LTD DUENSING KIPPEN.
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 30 –External Relations Bilateral screening:
ZHANG Jiao 17 March  Preliminary study and rationale - background - problem statement and focus  Research question(s)  Literature review  Research.
International Investment Law (10) ZHANG Jiao
Foreign Investment in Agricultural Lands and the Human Right to Water Carmen G. Gonzalez Seattle University School of Law.
 Negotiation  Conciliation / mediation  Arbitration  Litigation.
Protecting Russian Investments Abroad Opportunities and constraints Anatole Boute.
Bouchemla Lanouar & Associés - BL&A In association with the Algerian law firm of Me Fatima-Zohra Bouchemla 1 Algeria - UK Investment Forum El Aurrassi.
ENFORCEMENT OF AWARDS- EMERGING TRENDS Talat Ansari Kelley Drye & Warren LLP New York March 16, 2013.
ROMANIA NATIONAL NATURAL GAS REGULATORY AUTHORITY Public Service Obligations in Romanian Gas Sector Ligia Medrea General Manager – Authorizing, Licensing,
MOST FAVORED NATION TREATMENT OF SUBSTANTIVE RIGHTS & INVESTMENT ARBITRATION IN CHINA.
ZHANG Jiao International Investment Law (5). Review ICSIDNAFTABITFDIIIAs.
张皎 ZHANG Jiao 3 March International investment and international investment law International investment law regime Standards of protection (1)
International Commercial Arbitration - Introduction - Dr. V. Lazic, Associate professor Molengraaff Institute Utrecht University
International Investment Law (12) ZHANG Jiao
Chapter 7 The Legal Environment of International Trade Twomey, Business Law and the Regulatory Environment (14th Ed.)
WTO 2015 Public Forum FABRIZIO SARDELLI PANZINI INTERNATIONAL NEGOTIATIONS UNIT NATIONAL CONFEDERATION OF INDUSTRY BRAZIL - CNI GENEVA, 1ST OF OCTOBER,
International Commercial Arbitration
A Leading PRC Law Firm Foreign Investment Dispute Resolution Between Chinese and European Parties Peiming Yang
INTERNATIONAL AND CONTRACTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR SEE CROSS-BORDER PIPELINE PROJECTS Ana Stanič 23 June 2010.
the Protection and Promotion of Investment Bill
Intellectual Property & Investment disputes
University of Warwick – GLOBE Seminar – 24 October 2017
Brussels International Energy Charter Forum
Investment Arbitration as a Method of Enforcing Arbitral Awards in India Anirudh Wadhwa Advocate.
International Investment Law (6) & (7)
The Brazilian model of Bilateral investment treaties
Investment Arbitration as a Method of Enforcing Arbitral Awards in India Anirudh Wadhwa Advocate.
INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENT ARBITRATION: AN OVERVIEW
Dispute Settlement under the Indian Model BITs
Alexander Uff | November 18, 2018
Presentation transcript:

BEIJING BRUSSELS CHICAGO DALLAS FRANKFURT GENEVA HONG KONG LONDON LOS ANGELES NEW YORK SAN FRANCISCO SHANGHAI SINGAPORE TOKYO WASHINGTON, D.C. How Foreign Investors Use Investment Treaty Protections prepared for the Andrew W. Shoyer with support from the GE Foundation July 2009

2 Overview ▪ Investment treaties – powerful protection against political risk for international investments ▪ How to use investment treaties - in structuring investments - in dealing with host governments

3 Investment Treaties: The Basics Over 2800 International Investment Agreements (IIAs) in force today, including: ▪ Bilateral Investment Treaties (BITs) ▪ Free Trade Agreements (FTAs) ▪ Economic Partnership Agreements (EPAs) ▪Energy Charter Treaty (ECT)

4 Investment Treaties: The Basics Core objectives: ▪ To provide foreign investors with broad protection against adverse government actions: - Any level of government - Variety of government actions ▪ To provide investors with direct right of action to enforce treaty rights against governments ▪ To provide investors and host States with neutral, international fora to arbitrate disputes

5 Investment Treaties: The Basics Investment treaties provide a broad range of investments and investors with: ▪ Substantive standards of protection for investments and investors ▪ A powerful arbitration mechanism that allows investors to seek monetary compensation if the host country falls short of its obligations

6 Broad Definitions of Investment and Investor Covered foreign investments typically include : ▪ Company or enterprise ▪ Shares, stock, and other forms of equity, as well as bonds, debentures, and other forms of debt interests, in a company ▪ Contractual rights ▪ Tangible and real property ▪ Intangible property: rights such as leases, mortgages, liens and pledges ▪ Intellectual property: copyrights, trademarks, patents and trade secrets ▪ Rights conferred by law: licenses and permits

7 Broad Definitions of Investment and Investor Covered investors typically include: ▪ National of a State that is party to the treaty ▪ Legal entity organized in a State that is party to the treaty ▪ Subsidiary, wherever located, of entity organized in a State that is party to the treaty

8 Typical Substantive Protections General standards of treatment commonly include: ▪ Fair and Equitable Treatment ▪ Full Protection and Security ▪ National Treatment ▪ Most-Favored-Nation Treatment ▪ Protection against Expropriation ▪ Additional guarantees against any impairment of the management, maintenance, use, enjoyment or disposal of investment through unreasonable or discriminatory measures

9 Typical Substantive Protections Fair and Equitable Treatment: ▪ Legitimate expectations of the investor ▪ Non-discrimination ▪ Transparency ▪ Due process ▪ Non-arbitrariness

10 Typical Substantive Protections Full Protection and Security: ▪ Government protection from harmful acts by non-governmental actors ▪ More than just protection from criminal or violent acts ▪ Closely connected to the Fair and Equitable Treatment standard

11 Typical Substantive Protections Non-Discrimination: ▪ Treatment no less favorable than domestic investors (National Treatment) ▪ Treatment no less favorable than investors from third States (MFN Treatment) ▪ Typically measured by discriminatory effect, not intent.

12 Typical Substantive Protections Protection against Expropriation and Equivalent Measures: ▪ What constitutes an expropriation? - Direct seizure of property - Nationalization - Arbitrary termination of a contract or concession - Regulatory taking - Creeping expropriation ▪ What generally does not constitute an expropriation? - Bona fide, non-discriminatory use of police power

13 Typical Substantive Protections Protection against Expropriation and Equivalent Measures: Expropriation is permitted only if it is: ▪ Non-discriminatory ▪ For a public purpose ▪ Accompanied by compensation - Compensation must be prompt, adequate, and effective - Compensation shall reflect the fair market value of the investment prior to its expropriation

14 Typical Substantive Protections Prohibited performance requirements: ▪ Local content requirements ▪ Export requirements ▪ Foreign exchange requirements

15 Typical Substantive Protections Umbrella Clause: ▪ Governments must meet their contractual obligations ▪ Governments must not abuse their sovereign powers to invalidate their obligations ▪ Breaches by governments of their contractual obligations may give rise to a treaty claim

16 Resolution of Investment Disputes Common contexts of investment disputes: ▪ Expropriation – Nationalization ▪ Creeping expropriation through series of measures destroying the value of the investment ▪ Repudiation or wrongful termination of government contracts and concessions ▪ Discrimination de jure or de facto ▪ Regulatory measures impairing arbitrarily the value of an investment

17 Resolution of Investment Disputes Consent of the parties: ▪ State parties consent to dispute settlement by signing the BIT: This constitutes a standing offer to arbitrate disputes with the other state’s investors ▪ Investors consent through submission of claim in the forum of their choice

18 Resolution of Investment Disputes Enforcement of Awards: ▪ Awards usually consist of money damages but can include reparation or specific performance. ▪ Arbitral awards can be enforced all over the world through the New York Convention. ICSID awards are enforced pursuant to a special mechanism contained in the ICSID Convention. ▪ Different reviewing mechanism of the awards exists. Usually, the scope of annulment proceedings are narrower than appeals. ▪ Track record of government compliance with investment treaty awards is very good.

19 How to Use Investment Treaties When making an investment: Due diligence and structuring ▪ How strong are the treaties available to us? What standards of protection are offered under each? ▪ What kinds of adverse government action are most probable, or pose the greatest risks to the investment? Are they actionable under the available treaties? ▪ Are there other treaties that would offer a stronger or better- suited level of protection, if the investment is structured differently (through other jurisdictions)? ▪ How do investment treaty protections line up with tax treatment issues, double taxation treaties, etc.? What is the optimal structure from both investment and tax perspectives?

20 How To Use Investment Treaties Importance of structuring investments: ▪ Investor’s “home” country may not be a party to a BIT with the foreign country in which the investor is active ▪ The investor may be able to structure its investments through subsidiaries in countries that do have BITs with the target country ▪ The investor may also increase its level of protection by selecting the most suitable BIT

21 How To Use Investment Treaties Protection of Indirect Investment: ▪ Treaties may allow: - Investors from a non-treaty State to structure investment through subsidiary in a treaty State -Investors from a treaty State to structure investments through subsidiary in a non-treaty State ▪ Caution: some treaties restrict coverage of such investments

22 How To Use Investment Treaties Structuring an Investment Investors from a non-treaty State can structure investment through subsidiary in a treaty State State C State A State B BIT Local Company C Company A Subsidiary B

23 How To Use Investment Treaties Structuring an Investment Investors from a treaty State can structure investments through subsidiary in a non-treaty State State C State A State B BIT Local Company C Company A Subsidiary B

24 How to Use Investment Treaties After a dispute arises: Are we protected by one or more investment treaties? ▪ Nationality of the investing entity ▪ Nature of the investment (may restrict the protection offered by an investment treaty) ▪ Is there an investment treaty in force between the investor’s home State and the host State? ▪ If not, is there an investment treaty in force between the host State and any other State in the investor’s corporate chain?

25 How to Use Investment Treaties After a dispute arises: Is a State or a State-controlled entity involved? ▪ Has the investor or investment been harmed by acts or omissions of a State agency or a State-controlled entity? ▪ Harmed by a regulatory action? ▪ Harmed by a contractual breach by a State or a State entity?

26 How to Use Investment Treaties After a dispute arises: Negotiating with the government ▪ Knowing your investment treaty rights can provide powerful tool in negotiations with the host State ▪ A foreign investor can use rights provided under investment treaties as leverage in negotiations before invoking dispute settlement proceedings ▪ Once dispute settlement proceedings have been invoked, foreign investor can seek to settle the case based on the strengths of its claims

27 How to Use Investment Treaties After a dispute arises: Moving to a better suited forum ▪ When the investor faces a claim initiated by State entities in the host State’s courts ▪ When the investor’s contract with the host State provides for litigation in the host State’s courts, or less attractive arbitral fora CASE STUDY: GE & Bechtel v. India (Dabhol)

28 How To Use Investment Treaties Think about investment treaties ▪ When structuring investments ▪ When problems arise with government actions