___________________________________________________________.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Telecom Regulatory Authority of India An introduction.
Advertisements

Policy and Regulatory Challenges – Technology Providers View February 14 Challenges for Successful Implementation of ICT Projects Challenges for Successful.
TRA Roadmap for the Liberalization of Telecommunications Broadband Workshop In cooperation with the Partnership for Lebanon January 17, 2008 Beirut, Lebanon.
On Techno-Economics of Mobile Internet THE ECONOMICS OF INFORMATION NETWORKS AND FUTURE INTERNET Economicum Heikki Hämmäinen TKK Comnet April, 2009.
Trade Rules in Services: Issues and Problems Carsten Fink, The World Bank EU-LDC Network Annual Conference Trade and Poverty Reduction Rotterdam, 30 and.
1 Chutima Bunyapraphasara Deputy Director-General Department of Trade Negotiations Free Trade Successes & Thailand Automotive Industry.
Basics of Spectrum Workshop on Spectrum Management India International Centre, New Delhi
RadComms 2014: Innovations in Spectrum Management Lynne Fancy Senior Director Spectrum Development and Operations Industry Canada September 2014.
Institute for Transport Studies FACULTY OF EARTH AND ENVIRONMENT VERTICAL SEPARATION OF RAILWAY INFRASTRUCTURE - DOES IT ALWAYS MAKE SENSE? Jeremy Drew.
Key Policies Improving Business and Investment Climate Presenter: Governor CBBH: Kemal Kozarić, MA.
2013 EDITION Mr. Pierre Vigier Head of Unit Economic Analysis and Indicators.
Slide 1 Helsinki University of Technology Networking Laboratory Market Analysis of Mobile Handset Subsidies ITS Conference, Berlin, Sep 5-7, 2004 F.Daoud,
Page 1 15th ITS World Conference September 2004 Dr. Jan Krancke T-Mobile International Who is afraid of Market Dynamics ? The Regulatory Leviathan.
Helsinki University of Technology Networking Laboratory MOBILE VIRTUAL NETWORK OPERATORS: CASE FINLAND Annukka Kiiski Helsinki University of Technology.
Model of business intelligence maturity levels for mobile operators Mikael Ojala Thesis Seminar on Networking Technology Helsinki University of Technology.
1 Competition in the Telecommunications Sector in Mexico April 2008.
A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF S MART G RID DEVELOPMENT IN DEVELOPED AND DEVELOPING COUNTRIES ­­­­ CMI Conference 2014: Mobile communications in developing countries.
Energy Tom Howes DG Energy European Commission Europe's renewable energy strategy.
Yangon, Myanmar, November 2013 Broadband price regulation Matthew O’Rourke Partner, Incyte Consulting
Opportunities of ICT sector The Ministry of Information Technologies & Communications Ms. Dona ŞCOLA, Deputy Minister.
TDD-LTE Rollout Strategies for Telecom Service Provider in India
Chapter 9 New Business Development
Scenario Planning on LTE mobile network Virtualization
Mobile Number Portability: Case Finland
Digital Dividend and the Internal Market The “Information Society Parliament” Conference June 2, 2011 | Budapest.
Influence of foreign direct investment on macroeconomic stability Presenter: Governor CBBH: Kemal Kozarić.
ITU-T Workshop All Star Network Access Geneva, 2-4 June 2004 International Telecommunication Union Worldwide, Regional and National Unlicensed and Unprotected.
International Regulatory Trends Sector specific independent regulators separate from line ministries Competition authorities have been given an enhanced.
World Experience in Railway Restructuring Clell Harral, John Winner, Richard Sharp, Jonathan Klein HWTSK, Inc 15 December 2009.
How to foster investments in the European telco sector? Sverre Holt-Francati, SVP, Telenor Group NMHH Investment/Regulatory Conference, Budapest 4 December.
Presentation 1 Impact of Internet to Wireless Network Construction Business – Case Finland Master’s thesis presentation Jim Mäkelä Supervisor:
Aid for Trade Needs Assessment Ukraine: Trade and Human Development Igor Burakovsky, Institute for Economic Research and Policy Consulting (Ukraine) 14.
ROLE OF PTA IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF TELECOM SECTOR VISION Fair Regulatory Regime to Promote Investment, Encourage Competition, Protect Consumer Interest.
Telecom Reforms: Achieving Higher Growth ASSOCHAM Interaction with TRAI on New Policy Initiatives 18 Oct 2004: New Delhi S C Khanna Secretary General Association.
Association of Basic Telecom Operators welcomes H.E. Ambassador David Gross, US Coordinator for International Communications & Information Policy; Mr Michael.
TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGES IN GLOBAL ECONOMY PRESENTED BY: BIJAY SHARMA SECTION: A PGDM 1 st SEM.
Infrastructure for eInclusion – Regulation and Policy Initiatives Marianne Røgeberg Ministry of Transport and Communication Norway.
1 Highlights of the OECD’s Communications Outlook 2007: Focus on Mexico Dimitri Ypsilanti Directorate for Science, Technology and Industry, OECD.
Private and Public Sectors’ Roles in Establishing Effective and Sustainable Measures Towards Solving the Digital Divide Satoshi Fujita NTT Communications.
Internet Policy Day 3 - Workshop Session No. 5 The impact of telecomms regulation Prepared for CTO by Link Centre, Witwatersrand University, South Africa.
Natural Gas – Some Regulatory Issues Oil & Gas Industry Practice.
How can Liberalization maximize the Benefits from the Telecommunications Sector to the Caribbean Lisa Agard VP Legal Regulatory and Carrier Services TSTT.
Telecoms Review Institutional aspects European Parliament, 5 March 2008.
Slide 1 Helsinki University of Technology Networking Laboratory Bundling of Handset and Subscription Mathias Tallberg October 13,
Organization Development and Change
Erkki Liikanen - Date The Challenges for the Mobile Sector The European Commission’s perspective Pearse O’Donohue European Commission DG INFSO.
1 MTN PRESENTATION TO THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS Hearings on Telecoms Policy Directions 3 April 2001 Irene Charnley – Chairperson, M-Cell.
Helsinki University of Technology Networking Laboratory Mobile Data Service Industry Structure: Walled Garden vs. Horizontal Integration Annukka Kiiski.
The Ministry of Information &Communication Technologies Ms. Violeta EPUREANU, Minister’s advisor Mr. Viorel MUNTEANU, Director Moldova ICT overview. Accomplishing.
An overview of the critical issues underlying interconnection The views expressed in this paper are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect.
International Telecommunication Union ITU-T Workshop All Stars Access Network Geneva, 2-4 June 2004 Session 7: Regulatory issues, their status and resolution.
Electricity Regional Initiative Central Eastern European Region Convergence & Coherence Sven Kaiser E-Control CEE Stakeholder Group Meeting 7 th November.
International Trade Chapter #4.
Thomas G. Cummings Christopher G. Worley Chapter Twenty Three : Organization Development In Global Settings Organization Development and Change.
Amman October 1-2, 2003 Presentation Evolution of Saudi Telecom During Sector Reform 3 rd Annual Private Sector Cooperation Meeting in the Arab Region.
1 The 7 th Annual International Industrial Organization Conference April 3-5, 2009 Boston, MA, USA Measuring the Barriers to Trade and Investment in Telecoms.
11 th Report on European Electronic Communications Regulation and Markets 2005 Viviane Reding – Commissioner DG Information Society and Media 20 February.
Telecom Regulatory Environment Indian Case Payal Malik.
Bundle Regulation: The CMT’s approach to margin squeeze in bundled offers Workshop on EU telecommunications regulation Iván Santos Esteras Comisión del.
Licensing Rules for Communications Networks and Services CONSULTATION DRAFT FEBRUARY 2014.
( Mobile Virtual Network Operator)
NEXT-GENERATION REGULATION OF ELECTRONIC COMMUNICATIONS
Eastern European Partner countries
Globalization.
Radio Spectrum Policy in Europe
Telecom Circle India Telecom Market Telecom Circle
Session 4: Commercial Opportunities Panel Discussion: Reviewing spectrum pricing mechanisms & relationship with spectrum efficiency Bashir Patel
19 December 2016 Institute for Trade Studies and Researches(ITSR)
An overview of the critical issues underlying interconnection
FOV Round Table Agenda for Action
Presentation transcript:

___________________________________________________________

Systematic Assessment of Spectrum Policy and Mobile Market Structure Özkan Demirbilek Supervisor : Prof. Heikki Hämmäinen MSc. in Communications Ecosystem Comnet Research Team – Instructor : Arturo Basaure Master’s Thesis Presentation June 13, 2013

Agenda o Background o Research Goals o Methods o Studied Mobile Markets o Market Analysis o Spectrum Policy o Market Structure o Results and discussion o Conclusions and Recommendation for Future Work 3

Background Open Industry Decentralized Spectrum Licensing Policy 1.Number of licenses for mobile services (<3) 2.Level of liberalization of usage rights 3.Service/ Technology neutrality Industry Structure Policy 1.Switching Costs 2.NO/SO separation 3.MNP and SIM-locking 4.Roaming and interworking between systems 5.Unbundling of services Source: Basaure et al. (2012)

Research Goals o Development of quantitative metrics to phase diagram for mobile telecom regulations o Applying the metrics to multiple mobile markets 5

o Literature review o Theoretical frameworks o Data collection on mobile markets o Data sources  Regulator, mobile operator and consultancy company websites o Combination of theoretical frameworks with state-of-art mobile market situation 6 Methods

Studied Mobile Markets

o Spectrum-HHI o Market-based approaches are the most common o Finland, only market with symmetrical spectrum distribution o Japan, China  only beauty contests o Australia, USA, India  regional licenses 8 Spectrum Policy Analysis (1)

Spectrum Policy Analysis (2) 9 Reselling RightsNot AvailablePartly AvailableAvailable Mobile MarketsChile, Turkey, India, Japan, China FinlandSweden, UK, USA, Australia, New Zealand o Reselling Rights o Auctions  Effective spectrum allocation o Sustaining the efficiency over time? o Regulator intervention or re-assigning of spectrum by market forces? o Technology Neutrality / Harmonization o What is the driver? Let the market decide or coordinate the market? Technology FrameworkHarmonizationNeutrality (regulator), Harmonization (market) Neutrality Mobile Markets Finland, Turkey, China*Chile, New Zealand, Australia, Sweden, UK USA, India, Japan

Spectrum Policy Analysis (3) 10 o Market-HHI o China; incumbent 66% market share o India very fragmented 13+ MNO o Sweden, UK, US, India > 3 MNO o Chile, just accepted two more MNO Mobile MarketsMarket HHI China4952 New Zealand3883 Turkey3839 Japan3653 Chile3608 Australia3514 Finland3346 Sweden2951 United Kingdom2610 United States2540 India1360

Market Structure Analysis (1) Existence of multinational MNO YesNo Mobile MarketsUK, US, Turkey, New Zealand, Australia, Finland, Sweden, India, Chile China, Japan 11 o Multinational MNOs o Foreign direct investment (FDI) o Managerial expertise and breaking protectionism o Macro-economic environment should be suitable for entry  PESTEL o Investment o Persistent level of investment based on o Technological innovation, spectrum fees and market development o Prices o One of the marketing mix element o Different pricing schemes available: flat, block, unit based

Market Structure Analysis (2) 12 Mobile Markets Investments/ Subscriptions (€) Japan96 Australia57 Chile49.8 United States48.4 New Zealand35.08 Sweden26.13 UK23.9 Finland23.8 China20.2 Turkey15.9 India10.1 Mobile MarketsMobile Tariffs Japan0,81 Australia0,64 New Zealand0,55 Turkey0,40 United Kingdom0,31 Chile0,29 United States0,25 China0,15 Sweden0,08 Finland0,07 India0,06

Market Structure Analysis (3) 13 o ARPU o Tracking revenue growth o Market development in India  rural areas Mobile Markets Monthly ARPU ($) Japan84 Australia48 United States47 Finland32 New Zealand21 Sweden18 United Kingdom17 Chile16,36 Turkey11 China9.82 India1.6 Mobile marketsPrepaid Ratio (%) Finland13 Chile71 Sweden31 Turkey63 United Kingdom50 China87 India95 New Zealand66 Australia38,3 United States25 Japan2,0 o Switching costs o Prepaid ratio o Mobile Number Portability o Except China, available in the rest

Market Structure Analysis (4) 14 o Churn rate o Closely linked to switching cost o Fluctates based on dynamics o India the highest, Japan the least o Network Operator / Service Operator Separation o Increased market competition o Hit and escape Countries Monthly churn rate (%) Finland1.20 Chile1.50 Sweden1.10 Turkey3.38 United Kingdom2.9 China3.5 India6 New Zealand0.83 Australia1.8 United States1.10 Japan0.62 NO / SO separationYesNo Mobile marketsFinland, Sweden, United Kingdom, New Zealand, Australia Chile, Turkey, China, India, United States, Japan

Results (1) 15 o Spectrum policy explaining factor o Spectrum-HHI o Spectrum holdings in different bands possess differences o Reselling rights o Secondary trading markets not roll-out yet o Technology neutrality /harmonization o determines service offerings, influences market shares o Spectrum has clear effect on competitiveness (Lungborg)  Market shares o The spectrum policy explaining factor is market-HHI

Results (2) 16

Results (3) 17 o Market structure explaining factor o Prepaid subscriptions  lower switching costs, high churn rate

Results (4) I 18 o ARPU correlates with investment per subscriber

Results (5) 19 o Market Structure explaining factor o Industry unbundling framework  improve ( price/quality ) ratio o Vertically disintegrated  competition in retail  reduction in prices o Vertically integrated  High level of investment o Prices  Present situation in the industry o Investments  Future direction of the industry  Prices and Investments per Subscriber is the explaining factor

Results (6) 20 Spectrum policy Market Structure

Conclusions and Recommendation for Future 21 o Explaining factors: o Spectrum policy  market-HHI o Market structure  Prices and Investments per Subscribers o Highlights from the markets o The most open and decentralized market is India o The most closed industry is Japan o European markets are more open than American market o Recommendation for future research o Enhancing the database o Developing the theoretical framework

Thank you ! 22 Questions?