Preparing an organisation for electronic clinical information systems: Does culture matter? Dr Joanne Callen Senior Research Fellow Health Informatics.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
School of Medicine FACULTY OF MEDICINE AND HEALTH Does interprofessional education and working have any impact on perceptions of professional identity.
Advertisements

Department of Graduate Medical Education (GME) Overview of the ACGME Core Competencies.
C3 Goals Students will: 1.acquire teamwork competencies 2.acquire knowledge, values and beliefs of health professions different from their own profession.
Applying Talent Management To Nursing NHS Inclusive Talent Management Conference 6 March 2014 Birmingham ICC Sue Haines Assistant Director of Nursing,
SSM Health Care Category 5: Staff Focus. Our Workforce …
Measurement. T EAM STEPPS 05.2 Mod Page 2 Measurement Objectives  Describe the importance of measurement  Describe the Kirkpatrick model of training.
Joanne Smith University of Bolton.  To reflect upon this project and give some of the background  To examine the initial vision and look at how this.
Personal Assessment of the College Environment (PACE)
Shared decision making and Australian general practitioner training Dr Ronald McCoy, Education Strategy Senior Advisor, Royal Australian College of General.
The Health Roundtable 3-3b_HRT1215-Session_MILLNER_CARRUCAN_WOOD_ADHB_NZ Orthopaedic Service Excellence – Implementing Management Operating Systems Presenter:
Why don’t innovation models help with informatics implementations? Rod Ward University of the West of England Medinfo 2010.
Diversity Assessment and Planning with members of the October 14, 2005.
The Impact on Practice (ImP) Project: A framework to maximise the impact of continuing professional education on practice Liz Clark, Jan Draper and Shelagh.
HEALTHCARE OCCUPATIONS AND COMPETENCIES Pam Frugoli Employment and Training Administration U.S. Department of Labor.
NHS Highland Quality and Patient Safety Framework
Oregon Institute of Technology Health Informatics: An Emerging Health Care Occupation Dr. Michael Kirshner Program Director Health Informatics OIT Oregon.
Current and Emerging Use of Clinical Information Systems
Consultant Pharmacists
Is there a Doctor in the house? Then take me to your leader. Engaging medical and clinical staff in Post Graduate accredited workbased leadership development.
Training and development Education Evaluation: Benefits to Trust and its Learners Learning Beyond Registration Education Quality Team May 2014 Training.
Staff Perception Survey before and after EHR/CPOE Implementation Jean Loes Marcia Ward, Douglas Wakefield, John O’Brien.
Teaching for Diversity Dr Gill Cooke 15 February 2013 HEA STEM Workshop for Postgraduates who Teach.
L o g o Safety climate and motivation toward patient safety among Japanese nurses in hospitals of fewer than 250 beds Industrial Health 47 (2009), 70–79.
Sue Huckson Program Manager National Institute of Clinical Studies Improving care for Mental Health patients in Emergency Departments.
Understanding How Organizational Culture Really Works.
Page 1 Delivering Progress, Passion & Peace: An Evidence-Based Model Dr Peter Langford Voice Project Macquarie University Sydney, Australia CSR Summit,
Leadership saves lives Navigating the seas ahead – Clinical Leadership and teams Julia Petherbridge RM RN MSC Dip OD.
ENLIGHTENED LEADERSHIP ENLIGHTENED LEADERSHIP Dr. Thomas Saavedra.
Extending Cultural Competence to (Mid-Level) Leadership  Dr. Rani H. Srivastava  Chief of Nursing & Professional Practice  Centre for Addiction & Mental.
Chinese Medical Professionalism Forum-Beijing, China October 16, 2009.
An overview of the Shared Governance structure at Lutheran “I AM Shared Governance”
COGITA is made possible by Bologna, 23 October 2014 European Public Policies on CSR: The perceptions SMEs Eleni Apospori, Ph.D. Assistant Professor of.
Client Centred Practice and Management of Risk Falls Prevention Forum for People with Dementia in Gippsland Monday 15 th September 2014 Nicole Tierney.
Learning Outcomes of the SCPHN Programme & How they Link to Practice.
University – University Hospital Interactions: the AMSE Lisbon Declaration David Gordon President, AMSE.
Whiteboard Icons to Support the Blood- Test Process in an Emergency Department: An Observational Study of Temporal Patterns Arnvør á Torkilsheyggi a, Morten.
The BC Clinical Care Management Initiative as a Case Study in Large Scale Change CARES International Conference on Realist Approaches, October 29,
Wessex LETB The Changing Landscape Paul Holmes, Managing Director.
Jill A. Marsteller, PhD,MPP August 10, 2011 CSTS: The Cardiovascular Surgical Translational Study Assessing Culture.
Clinical Nurse Leader Impact on Microsystem Care Quality Miriam Bender PhD(c), MSN, RN, CNL National State of the Science Congress on Nursing Research.
PATIENT- AND FAMILY-CENTERED CARE: Partnerships for Safety & Quality Staff Physician & Resident Physician Toolkit.
Copyright 1994 Human Synergistics International. All Rights Reserved. Organizational Culture Inventory (OCI) 1 Strengthening Organizations through Individual.
Organizational Culture Creating an Ideal Culture Group Activity Your group task is to develop an Ideal Organizational Culture. Through consensus discussion,
Precepting New Graduate Nurses A Guide from the WV Center for Nursing.
The University of Western Australia working life survey July 2009 high-level results Voice Project Survey Report, (c) Voice Project Pty Ltd, Page 1.
Clinical Decision Support Systems Paula Coe MSN, RN, NEA-BC NUR 705 Informatics and Technology for Improving Outcomes in Advanced Practice Nursing Dr.
Organizational Culture, Socialization, & Mentoring
1 Presentation to the Academy Health Annual Research Meeting 2006 Brandeis University Schneider Institute for Health Policy June 26, 2006 Research supported.
Teacher competencies. Professional competence with ICT Draw on appropriate ICT applications to enhance personal and professional effectiveness  Using.
Susan B. LeGrand Cleveland Clinic Taussig Cancer Institute, Cleveland Ohio, USA Inova Health System, Fairfax Virginia, USA PALLIATIVE MEDICINE FELLOWSHIP:
Cultural Competency and Patient Satisfaction: A Pilot Training Project September 24, th National Conference on Quality Health Care for Culturally.
HEALTHCARE QUALITY CONCEPTS Chapter 1 Changing Perspectives in Quality Participants can identify 3 types of disruptive behavior. Participants can identify.
Developing networked learner support in UK higher education Perspectives from the NetLinkS project Phil Levy, UK-Nordic Conference 1997.
{ NOPH Unit Council Program Partnering for Excellence.
Effective Teams What are the characteristics of effective healthcare teams?
Introducing Improving Quality Together. Purpose Improving Quality Together aims to support a change in mindset in NHS Wales, where each individual demonstrates.
C2ME Main findings Jeanine Suurmond, AMC, dept of Public Health, Project leader C2ME 18 September 2015 ‘Culturally Competent In Medical Education’ Amsterdam.
Why Has it got to be Multi Professional ? The extent to which different healthcare professionals work well together can affect the quality of the health.
©2012 THE ADVISORY BOARD COMPANY ADVISORY.COM Gaining Provider Feedback In February – March 2014, we administered a medical staff survey to employed &
Awareness of the National Standards for Culturally and Linguistically Appropriate Services (CLAS) at an Academic Health Center Dr. Genny Carrillo Department.
Today’s presentation  Background and context  Rationale  Aim and objectives  Design and method  Impact  Reflective commentary  Transferability.
The Holistic Approach to the Design and Meaningful Use of Electronic Health Records: A Nursing Experience Frances Beadle, MSc Health Informatics Nurse.
1 The Holistic Approach to the Design and Meaningful Use of Electronic Health Records: A Nursing Experience Frances Beadle, MSc Health Informatics Nurse.
T Relationships do matter: Understanding how nurse-physician relationships can impact patient care outcomes Sandra L. Siedlecki PhD RN CNS.
Overview for Placement
Research for all Sharing good practice in research management
Organizational Culture
Emotional Intelligence Can Create A Culture of Safety and Leadership
Presentation transcript:

Preparing an organisation for electronic clinical information systems: Does culture matter? Dr Joanne Callen Senior Research Fellow Health Informatics Research and Evaluation Unit The University of Sydney

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Overview of presentation Organisational culture – what is it? Sub-cultures in large organisations Is there a relationship between culture and clinical information systems? Models to assist with implementing information systems

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Background Organisational culture has been identified as a significant factor for successful implementation of clinical information systems Gosling et al. Int J Med Inf. 2003; Aarts et al. JAMIA, 2004; Callen et al. Soc Sci & Med 2007

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 What is organisational culture? “the basic pattern of shared assumptions, values and beliefs governing the way employees within an organisation think about and act on problems and opportunities” McShane & Von Glinow, 2000, p. 498

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Subcultures Pronounced in health care organisations Based on professional, occupational, gender, functional distinctions Can reflect or differentiate organisation- wide culture Can draw values from outside (example medical sub-specialties)

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Research study Is there a relationship between hospital sub-cultures and attitudes to, and satisfaction with, clinical information systems? Callen et al. The importance of medical and nursing sub- cultures in the implementation of clinical information systems. Methods of Information in Medicine (2):

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Methods Research setting  Two clinical units: Emergency Department and Haematology/ Oncology Ward  400 bed metropolitan public teaching hospital

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Clinical information context  Computerised physician order entry system used to order and view all laboratory and radiology tests

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Survey design Two survey instruments  Organisational culture inventory  User satisfaction survey Population (n=103) All doctors (n=42) and nurses (n=61) in two clinical units

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Organisational culture inventory (OCI) Constructive culture work cooperatively; high motivation; teamwork Passive/defensive culture please those in authority; wait for others to act first Aggressive/defensive culture oppose new ideas; compete; appear competent and independent

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Culture and cultural styles in OCI Constructive culture o Achievement style o Self-actualising style o Humanistic/ encouraging style o Affiliative style Passive/defensive culture o Approval style o Conventional style o Dependent style o Avoidance style

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Culture and cultural styles in OCI Aggressive/ defensive culture  Power style  Competitive style  Perfectionistic style  Oppositional style

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 User satisfaction survey Impact of CPOE on:  work practices  patient care  satisfaction with CPOE  attitudes to CPOE

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Results: Population and Respondents Population – 103 Response Rate – 73% Population – 103 Response Rate – 93% OCI User satisfaction survey

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Doctors & Nurses Perception of Culture

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Constructive Culture Styles

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Passive-Defensive Cultural Styles

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Aggressive-Defensive Cultural Styles

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Attitudes to CPOE system Attitudes Doctors n=36 Nurses n=60 Using computerised test management systems: Agree % Neutral % Disagree % Agree % Neutral % Disagree % p-value Results in cookbook medicine Depersonalises medicine Helps in deciding which tests to order Improves the practice of medicine Results in over ordering of tests Alienates doctors from patients Makes my work more interesting

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Discussion Cultures are not uniform in large hospitals Constructive culture of nurses – support CPOE Aggressive-defensive culture of doctors – discourage uptake of new innovations High perfectionist style of doctors – counterproductive to implementation of new technologies

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Implications of the results Examine sub-cultures prior to implementation Strategies for moving to a constructive culture can be employed

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Strategies to move to constructive culture Individual level  Goal setting; job design; motivational processes Unit level  Performance appraisal; inclusive meetings Organisational level  Communication; respect for staff; employee involvement

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Models to assist with implementing information systems Change management models Rogers EM Diffusion of Innovations, 1995 Ash’s principles Ash et al. Proc AMIA 2003 Contextual Implementation Model Callen et al. JAMIA 2008

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Contextual Implementation Model Grounded in data Core theme of ‘contextual differences’ Diversity at 3 contextual levels –Organisational level –Clinical or departmental level –Individual level Dimensions for consideration within each level (organisational culture, unit leadership, diverse ways of working)

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Contextual Implementation Model Organisational Context Clinical Unit Context Individual Context Use of clinical information systems Government policyEconomy IT industryProfessional groups

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Value of models and theories To realise the potential benefits of I&CT to patients, clinicians and government we need to develop and test models of evaluation and implementation

14 th October 2009HIMAA National Conference Perth 2009 Role of the health informatics specialist in implementation Health Information Managers function at the core of the change process in healthcare Play a major role in implementing, managing, and leading IT adoption to improve health care Change theories and implementation models provide a framework for understanding and supporting these large scale IT implementations

Thank you