Thin Film Measurement Facilities Flavio Travasso N.i.p.s laboratory - Università di Perugia and INFN Perugia Flavio Travasso N.i.p.s laboratory - Università.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 News in the thermo-mechanical measurement in the Firenze facility Gianpietro Cagnoli a,b), Enrico Campagna a,c), Elisabetta Cesarini a), Matteo Lorenzini.
Advertisements

ILIAS 5-6/11/2004 WG T2 Task T2 (WG 11) AIM: exact definition (theoretical and experimental) of photo-thermal noise PARTICIPANTS INFN (AURIGA group; also.
WP4 Organic crystal deposition Mojca Jazbinsek Rainbow Photonics AG SOFI meeting Karlsruhe
T1 task- update Mike Plissi. 2 Collaboration Groups actively involved INFN-VIRGO MAT IGR-Glasgow Groups that have expressed interest INFN-AURIGA CNRS-LKB.
Low temperature dissipative behavior in uncoated fused silica slabs Flavio Travasso Dip. Fisica – Università di Perugia and INFN Perugia Virgo - Perugia.
April 27th, 2006 Paola Puppo – INFN Roma ILIAS Cryogenic payloads and cooling systems (towards a third generation interferometer) part II: the Vibration.
Work Package 4: Development of low loss dielectric coatings for advanced detectors Scientific motivation: Mechanical dissipation from dielectric mirror.
Coating-reduced interferometer optics Resonant waveguide gratings S. Kroker, T. Käsebier, E.-B. Kley, A. Tünnermann.
NOVEL PROCESSES FOR SOI-BASED MEMS AT VTT
Review on thermal noise related activities in Perugia
Victoria04 R. Frey1 Silicon/Tungsten ECal Status and Progress Ray Frey University of Oregon Victoria ALCPG Workshop July 29, 2004 Overview Current R&D.
Thermally Deformable Mirrors: a new Adaptive Optics scheme for Advanced Gravitational Wave Interferometers Marie Kasprzack Laboratoire de l’Accélérateur.
PEALD/CVD for Superconducting RF cavities
GWADW, May 2012, Hawaii D. Friedrich ICRR, The University of Tokyo K. Agatsuma, S. Sakata, T. Mori, S. Kawamura QRPN Experiment with Suspended 20mg Mirrors.
GWADW 2010 in Kyoto, May 19, Development for Observation and Reduction of Radiation Pressure Noise T. Mori, S. Ballmer, K. Agatsuma, S. Sakata,
Overview of Research in the Optics Working Group Gregory Harry, on behalf of the OWG Massachusetts Institute of Technology July 25, 2007 LSC Meeting –
Status of LCGT and CLIO Masatake Ohashi (ICRR, The University of TOKYO) and LCGT, CLIO collaborators TAUP2007 Sendai, Japan 2007/9/12.
Alban REMILLIEUX3 rd ILIAS-GW Annual General Meeting. London, October 26 th -27 th, New coatings on new substrates for low mechanical loss mirrors.
STREGA WP1/M1 mirror substrates GEO LIGO ISA Scientific motivation: Mechanical dissipation from dielectric mirror coatings is predicted to be a significant.
Test mass dynamics with optical springs proposed experiments at Gingin Chunnong Zhao (University of Western Australia) Thanks to ACIGA members Stefan Danilishin.
Overview of coatings research and recent results at the University of Glasgow M. Abernathy, I. Martin, R. Bassiri, E. Chalkley, R. Nawrodt, M.M. Fejer,
Thermal noise from optical coatings Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - on behalf of the LIGO Science Collaboration - 25 July
The investigation of thermal and non- thermal noises in fused silica fibers for Advanced LIGO suspension Moscow State University Bilenko I.A. Lyaskovskaya.
T1 task- update Mike Plissi. 2 Motivation  Thermo-elastic noise is higher than the ‘intrinsic’ noise in crystalline materials  There are several sources.
Creative Research Initiatives Seoul National University Center for Near-field Atom-Photon Technology - Near Field Scanning Optical Microscopy - Electrostatic.
LISA October 3, 2005 LISA Laser Interferometer Space Antenna Gravitational Physics Program Technical implications Jo van.
Gravitational Wave Detection Using Precision Interferometry Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - On Behalf of the LIGO Science Collaboration.
PeTeR: a hardware simulator for LISA PF TM-GRS system 23/05/ th LISA Symposium May 2012, BnF Paris L. Marconi and R. Stanga Università degli.
LIGO-G D LIGO and Industry Capability/ProductCompany Ultra-high Vacuum TechnologyCB&I Passive Seismic IsolationHytec Inc. Active Seismic IsolationBarry.
12/12/2014L. Proserpio – AXRO meeting, Prague  Definition of terms  Description of the problem wrt the x-ray thin mirrors technologies.
Low temperature dissipation in coating materials S. Reid 1, I. Martin 1, H. Armandula 3, R. Bassiri 1, E. Chalkley 1 C. Comtet 4, M.M. Fejer 5, A. Gretarsson.
Flat-Top Beam Profile Cavity Prototype
LIGO-G0200XX-00-M LIGO Scientific Collaboration1 First Results from the Mesa Beam Profile Cavity Prototype Marco Tarallo 26 July 2005 Caltech – LIGO Laboratory.
Last coating Q measurements at MIT Flavio Travasso Gregg Harry Matt Abernathy LIGO – G Z.
Improvement of Infrared Lights Sensitivity on PZT EMITER Daisuke Takamuro, Hidekuni Takao, Kazuaki Sawada and Makoto Ishida.
Status of Surface Sensitive Bolometers University of Insubria – Como, Italy INFN – Milano, Italy Prague, Chiara Salvioni.
2009/1/16-18 ILD09 Seoul 1 Notes for ILD Beam Pipe (Technical Aspect) Y. Suetsugu, KEK Parasitic loss Vacuum pressure profile Some comments for beam pipe.
Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena Institute of Solid State Physics – Low Temperature Physics Christian Schwarz19 th May GWADW Kyoto 1 Losses in.
1st Advanced Virgo Review – November 3-4, 2008 – L. Pinard 1 Mirrors Sub-System Overview  Introduction  Scope of the subsystem, main tasks  Substrates.
PRELIMINARY DATA ON THE COATING AT THE LIQUID NITROGEN TEMPERATURE Flavio Travasso Virgo-Perugia Group.
Virgo-Material “macro” group M.Punturo. VIRGO-MAT2 VIRGO-MAT components Virgo-MAT is composed by three INFN groups –Firenze/Urbino M.Lorenzini, G.Losurdo,
Yb:YAG Regenerative Amplifier for A1 Ground Laser Hut Rui Zhang ACCL Division V, RF-Gun Group Nov 20, 2015 SuperKEKB Injector Laser RF Gun Review.
Thermoelastic dissipation in inhomogeneous media: loss measurements and thermal noise in coated test masses Sheila Rowan, Marty Fejer and LSC Coating collaboration.
Investigation of effects associated with electrical charging of fused silica test mass V. Mitrofanov, L. Prokhorov, K. Tokmakov Moscow State University.
Janyce Franc-Kyoto-GWADW1 Simulation and research for the future ET mirrors Janyce Franc, Nazario Morgado, Raffaele Flaminio Laboratoire des Matériaux.
Thermal Noise in Thin Silicon Structures
ACIGA High Optical Power Test Facility
Charles University Prague Charles University Prague Institute of Particle and Nuclear Physics Absolute charge measurements using laser setup Pavel Bažant,
The importance of Coatings for Interferometric Gravitational Wave Observatories Riccardo DeSalvo for the Coating group
Some Ideas on Coatingless all-reflective ITF Adalberto Giazotto & Giancarlo Cella INFN- Pisa.
1 DC readout for Virgo+? E. Tournefier WG1 meeting, Hannover January 23 rd,2007 DC vs AC readout: technical noises Output mode cleaner for DC readout.
LIGO-G Z Silicon as a low thermal noise test mass material S. Rowan, R. Route, M.M. Fejer, R.L. Byer Stanford University P. Sneddon, D. Crooks,
Heinert et al Properties of candidate materials for cryogenic mirrors 1 Properties of candidate materials for cryogenic mirrors D. Heinert,
LIGO Scientific Collaboration
Optical Coatings for Gravitational Wave Detection Gregory Harry Massachusetts Institute of Technology - On Behalf of the LIGO Science Collaboration - August.
1/16 Nawrodt, Genoa 09/2009 An overview on ET-WP2 activities in Glasgow R. Nawrodt, A. Cumming, W. Cunningham, J. Hough, I. Martin, S. Reid, S. Rowan ET-WP2.
The coating thermal noise R&D for the 3rd generation: a multitechnique investigation E. Cesarini 1,2), M.Prato 3), M. Lorenzini 2) 1)Università di Urbino.
Measurement of coating mechanical loss Junko Katayama, K.Craig, K.Yamamoto, M.Ohashi ICRR 0.
Department of Physics & Astronomy Institute for Gravitational Research Scottish Universities Physics Alliance Brownian thermal noise associated with attachments.
The Proposed Holographic Noise Experiment Rainer Weiss, MIT On behalf of the proposing group Fermi Lab Proposal Review November 3, 2009.
STREGA WP4 coating development GEO LIGO ISA Scientific motivation: Mechanical dissipation from dielectric mirror coatings is predicted to be a significant.
Yb:YAG Regenerative Amplifier for A1 Ground Laser Hut Rui Zhang ACCL Division V, RF-Gun Group Nov 20, 2015 SuperKEKB Injector Laser RF Gun Review.
Peter Beyersdorf TAMA300 Results from the Stanford 10m all-reflective polarization Sagnac interferometer Peter Beyersdorf TAMA300.
The Proposed Holographic Noise Experiment
Development of Large-Area Photo-detectors:
Overview of Advanced LIGO Coating Status
Flat-Top Beam Profile Cavity Prototype: design and preliminary tests
Jim Hough for the GEO collaboration
First Results from the Mesa Beam Profile Cavity Prototype
Flat-Top Beam Profile Cavity Prototype
Presentation transcript:

Thin Film Measurement Facilities Flavio Travasso N.i.p.s laboratory - Università di Perugia and INFN Perugia Flavio Travasso N.i.p.s laboratory - Università di Perugia and INFN Perugia

Introduction The measurement of losses in coating materials is a great challenge. A lot of different techniques and facilities are used around the world to improve our understanding of them. Our idea is to perform a direct measurement of the thermal noise of thin membranes (~100 nm) using 2 facilities : 1) Michelson Morley interferometer 2) Non stationary facility : stabilized Fabry-Perot cavity We aim at obtaining the following data: - Direct measurement of the coating thermal noise - Difference between the coating with and without the substrate: skin- deep stress and annealing behavior - Dynamics of a system out of stationary condition (relaxation to equilibrium) In this talk I'll present the idea, the status of the facilities, the different material we would use in the future, the data we would find and the problems we have to overcome.

Sample Si-wafer: diameter 10 cm (4") thickness ~ 500 µm Al2O3 film (both sides)/membranes: thickness nm (a bit rough) Holes etched through the Si-wafer: diameter ~ 500 µm Chip size: square, ~ 2.5 mm x 2.5 mm; chips defined by etching the borderlines half way through the wafer Supplier: VTT - Technical Research Centre of Finland on Micro and Nanoelectronics...with ALO the process is easy - just coating, patterning and etching; no annealing. ALD ALO is rather uniform; it should have less than 1% thickness variation over the wafer and rather small surface roughness. As the surface roughness of ALO on substrate is the same as in the membranes, you can easily measure it with AFM if interested. ( from VTT)

1 – Michelson Thermal Noise Facility

Very simple optical scheme with a good sensitivity: very fast measurements to increase our statistics about a parameter we would study Why a Michelson?

Estimated RMS for the membranes FEM Simulation: rms ~ m at about 7kHz

Measurements in progress “Direct measurement” of the thermal noise Correlation between the coating stress and the thermal noise : the original coating is not annealed. We can divide the Si-wafer in different pieces and anneal them with different process in order to see how the TN changes. This idea is suitable for whatever process you can imagine Use of different materials : tantala and silica For the etching process the use of tantala or the use of silica could be ok. To avoid any dubt the VTT laboratories could check it the next future In the past the VTT labs tested the SiN and the a-Si:H

2 – Non stationary Thermal Noise Facility

X Electro-optical Modulator Test Cavity Pbs Segnal in riflection Nd-Yag /4 /2 Pico-motor Schema ottico P=10 -6 mbar 12.5 MHz 1064 nm Non-stationary thermal noise Purpose To understand the dynamics of a perturbed system at thermal equilibrium or rather: - read directly the thermal noise of a thin slab - reduce a TN peak with a sine in counter-phase with the oscillation of the slab - see how the peak comes back to the equilibrium: it should absorb energy from the other modes reducing the thermal noise - see if the system changes its dynamics - to improve the sensibility of an optical system driving the dynamics of the optics

Frequency [Hz] Displacement [m] Not stabilized cavity Electronic Noise Stabilized Cavity New sensitivity

Displacement

Results for the thin silica slab With the past setup (thin slab and non stabilized cavity) we reduced the peak amplitude (mechanical cooling) in order to see how the system comes back to the thermal equilibrium: there is a crosstalk between the modes => it's very hard to understand if the perturbed peak is stealing energy from the slab and so if it’s improving the TN on the other region: new exciter the rigidity of the slab seems to change: if we could understand how to change this parameter we could move the peaks in order to reduce the thermal noise in a region of the spectrum with a particular interest Work in progress: Conclude our study on the thin silica slab : test of the stabilized cavity and the new exciter Apply all we learned and all we are going to learn on the thin slab to the membranes in order to obtain the needed data on the substrate and on the coating to control both of them Check the maximum radius for the hole: it depends on the coating material => different skin-deep stress

Summary Advantage of the membranes – Coating without substrate – A lot of samples (that we can work as we desire) just with a single coating run – No so complex as the NEMS..you can use the traditional facilities just paying more attention Facilities – Michelson: very fast measurements – Fabry-Perot cavity: Long and hard measurements to study the non stationary dynamics of the substrates and of the coating

Facilities Status Michelson: optics, vacuum, electronics are ok…we are waiting for the new laser (I broke the old one the last weekend) Fabry-Perot cavity: we test the stabilized cavity but we have some manpower problem

The End

1064 nm 12.5 MHz X X Nd-Yag Modulatore Elettro-ottico /2 Pico-motore Cavità Misura /4 telescopio Pbs Cavità stabilizzazione  Segnale in trasmissione Segnale in riflessione Segnale in riflessione P=10 -6 mbar  Cella peltier Non-Stationary Thermal Noise: stabilized cavity

Abstract.. The measurement of losses in coating materials is a great challenge. A lot of different techniques and facilities are used around the world to improve our understanding of them. Our idea is to use a very focused Michelson interferometer to read directly the thermal noise of a thin membrane. The thickness of these membranes is 100 nm (very similar to the thickness of a single layer in a standard coating: nm), the diameter is about 0.5mm while the material is sapphire. The membrane is obtained by etching a coated silicon substrate. In this way we have a little free coating without any substrate or rather a little membrane. Performing a FEM simulation we evaluated the rms, about m - a value comparable with the sensitivity of a good Michelson interferometer. We plan to obtain the following data: 1) Direct measurement of the coating thermal noise 2) Difference between the coating with and without the substrate: skin-deep stress and annealing behavior In this talk I'll present the idea, the status of the facility, the different material we would use in the future, the data we would find and the problems we have to overcome.