The Dynamics of Zipf John Nystuen (UM) Michael Batty (UCL) Yichun Xie (EMU) Xinyue Ye (EMU) Tom Wagner (UM) 19 May 2003 Presented at the China Data Center.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Correlation and regression
Advertisements

Population and Culture
1 Dr. Michael D. Featherstone Introduction to e-Commerce Network Theory.
Chapter 13 Key Issue #1.
Ch. 12 Services Why are consumer services distributed in a regular pattern?
PPA 501 – Analytical Methods in Administration Lecture 8 – Linear Regression and Correlation.
Chapter 10 Relationships between variables
BA 555 Practical Business Analysis
The 4th International Conference on Population Geographies The Chinese University of Hong Kong Topic : Effects of Budgetary Policies on Population Migration.
Migration process in small towns of Latvia Maris Berzins PhD student University of Latvia.
Centre for Advanced Spatial Analysis and the Bartlett School Emergence and Extinction in Cities & City Systems Michael Batty University College London.
Unit 14: Networks of Cities Two examples of network flow between cities in the US: internet connectivity (top), and recorded business travel flow (bottom)
Chapter 12 Services.
THE URBAN SYSTEM CENTRAL PLACE THEORY and RELATED CONCEPTS.
Ch.6 Locations, spacing, size and functions of urban settlements
Chapter 13 Urban Patterns
Basic Statistics. Basics Of Measurement Sampling Distribution of the Mean: The set of all possible means of samples of a given size taken from a population.
Dr Jianfa Shen Department of Geography and Resource Management
Overview of Urban Economics
BPS - 3rd Ed. Chapter 211 Inference for Regression.
© 2011 Pearson Education, Inc. Chapter 12: Services The Cultural Landscape: An Introduction to Human Geography.
Models and Algorithms for Complex Networks Power laws and generative processes.
© 2011 Pearson Education, Inc. Chapter 12: Services The Cultural Landscape: An Introduction to Human Geography.
Agronomic Spatial Variability and Resolution What is it? How do we describe it? What does it imply for precision management?
-SAN ANTONIO and TEXAS -. 1.Geography: Nature and Perspective Key Concepts –Location, Space, Place, Pattern, Regionalization and Globalization Key Skills.
Why Is It There? Getting Started with Geographic Information Systems Chapter 6.
Economic Growth IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA A County-level Analysis.
BY DUFFUS, KIRCH & SKIV INTODUCED POLICY IN 1979 AFTER WITNESSING EXPONENTIAL POPULATION GROWTH WHICH THREATENED FOOD AND WATER SUPPLY CHINA WILL PRESS.
The Land Leverage Hypothesis Land leverage reflects the proportion of the total property value embodied in the value of the land (as distinct from improvements),
Geography of Canada Urban Landscapes. Urban and Rural Landscapes 1.Population Distribution 2.Settlement Patterns 3.Urbanization 4.Urban Hierarchy.
Summarizing Bivariate Data
Y X 0 X and Y are not perfectly correlated. However, there is on average a positive relationship between Y and X X1X1 X2X2.
Categorical vs. Quantitative…
© 2011 Pearson Education, Inc. Where Are People Distributed in Urban Areas? Models of urban structure –Are used to explain where people live in cities.
Population and Culture Bell Task: Read Ch. 3 Sec. 1 pp
The Dynamics of Zipf John Nystuen Michael Batty Yichun Xie Tom Wagner 19 May 2003.
Urban Geography: overview
Copyright © Cengage Learning. All rights reserved. 1 Functions and Models.
Correlation – Recap Correlation provides an estimate of how well change in ‘ x ’ causes change in ‘ y ’. The relationship has a magnitude (the r value)
Chapter 12 Services Key Issue 2. Distribution of Consumer Services  Central place theory  Market-area of a service  Size of market area  Market area.
Dr Shen Jianfa CUHK Geography1 A-Level Geography Seminar Central Place Theory: The Theory, its limitations and Applications Dr Jianfa Shen Department of.
The Effects of Agro-clusters on Rural Poverty: A Spatial Perspective for West Java of Indonesia Dadan Wardhana, Rico Ihle, Wim Heijman (Agricultural Economics.
© 2011 Pearson Education, Inc. Chapter 12: Services The Cultural Landscape: An Introduction to Human Geography.
PPA786: Urban Policy Class 1: Introduction. Urban Policy: Introduction Class Outline ▫Review Course Requirements and Readings ▫Introduce Census Urban.
FUNCTIONS AND MODELS Exponential Functions FUNCTIONS AND MODELS In this section, we will learn about: Exponential functions and their applications.
1 Dr. Michael D. Featherstone Introduction to e-Commerce Network Theory 101.
World Geography Population and Culture. What are things that humans do to arable land that make it more vulnerable to erosion:  Deforestation  Over-Farming.
CANADA POP. DISTRIBUTION. CENSUS METROPOLITAN AREA (CMA) CENSUS METROPOLITAN AREA: An urban area including all villages, towns, and smaller cities near.
(Unit 6) Formulas and Definitions:. Association. A connection between data values.
Chapter 12 Section 2 Why are consumer services distributed in a regular pattern?
Describing Data Week 1 The W’s (Where do the Numbers come from?) Who: Who was measured? By Whom: Who did the measuring What: What was measured? Where:
CHAPTER 13 LECTURE OUTLINE URBANIZATION & URBAN NETWORKS Human Geography by Malinowski & Kaplan 13-1 Copyright © The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission.
Integration of peripheral regions in collaborative science: A bibliometric analysis of scientific activity and co-authorship at U.S. county level Presentation.
The History Behind Census Geography Michael Ratcliffe Geography Division US Census Bureau Alabama State Data Center Meeting Tuscaloosa, Alabama May 26,
Christaller – Central Place Theory
Chapter 4 More on Two-Variable Data. Four Corners Play a game of four corners, selecting the corner each time by rolling a die Collect the data in a table.
Sustainable Urban Energy Systems A Science of Cities Approach Lorraine Sugar PhD Candidate, University of Toronto ONSEP 2016.
The World Wine Web: The Structure of the Global Wine Trade
Population and Culture
BIO 1A – Unit 3 Notes.
Population and Culture
Chapter 12 Key Issue 3: Services
Chapter 17: Networks of Cities
Services Chapter 12 An Introduction to Human Geography
Population and Culture
Chapter 12 Services.
6c. Know how fluctuations in population size in an ecosystem are determined by the relative rates of birth, immigration, emigration, and death.
Advanced Algebra Unit 1 Vocabulary
CENTRAL PLACE THEORY -Walter Christaller,1933
Presentation transcript:

The Dynamics of Zipf John Nystuen (UM) Michael Batty (UCL) Yichun Xie (EMU) Xinyue Ye (EMU) Tom Wagner (UM) 19 May 2003 Presented at the China Data Center University of Michigan

Knowledge Gap Studies of urbanization are often focused on individual cities or towns, or sub-divisions of cities and towns. Understanding “systems of cities” – how urban entities are distributed, connect, and interact -- may be increasingly important in a globalizing world, e.g. 9/11, SARS. Most analytical techniques don’t consider the dynamic, non-linear behavior of urban system processes.

Purpose of this Seminar 3 rd and final seminar of the Series Highlight the complementary analyses of the authors regarding a common interest in the dynamical aspects of Zipf’s law. Illustrate: –the nature of city-size distributions over time and space and the use of power-law approximations –the use of current and historical US census data to show city-size transitions and patterns –the use of China census data to show urban changes and the likely impacts of dramatic urban policies on city development patterns

Is there an ideal city size? Throughout history, many people have postulated the existence of an ideal size of city – one with a population and physical area that maximizes human productivity and the quality of life (e.g. Aristotle, Karl Marx, Ebenezer Howard) Observation suggests that no such ideal exists or can exist: all sizes flourish and occasionally die. Efforts to create news cites (e.g. in the Soviet Union, China) have been at a high cost and often fail.

If an optimal size city existed, all small towns would grow toward that mean but no larger. There would be no increasing economies of scale.

However, there may be an optimal city-size distribution within “systems of cities”. Large systems tend toward a log-normal distribution with a few very large cities and many many small cities.

National population maps usually show this uneven distribution of city sizes “… differences in the kind and degree of benevolence of soil-climate-contour are capable of inducing differences in the density of the population throughout the entire territory, but only if all persons pursue the advantages inherent in their locations.” George Kinsley Zipf (p. 6, National Unity & Disunity: The Nation as a Bio-Social Organism; 1941)

George Kingsley Zipf ( ) documented the skewed distribution of city sizes for many countries as a power law with an exponent very close to -1 proposed that this skewed distribution resulted from a natural human process he called the “Principle of Least Effort” started a 50 year search by social scientists for an explanation for this very precise distribution which became known as “Zipf’s law”

Zipf’s Law Takes many forms K = r X P a –K is the population of largest city –r is the rank (from the largest city) –P is the city population –a is a scaling factor ~ -1 log K = log r – a log P

Linear (curving) and log-log (straight line) illustrations of Zipf’s power law RANKSIZE

Using census data, Zipf showed the remarkably constant straight line log-log distributions of US city-sizes between

Many social scientists have tried to explain the precision of Zipf’s Law across space and over time. None have been entirely successful. Paul Krugman: “…we have to say that the rank-size rule is a major embarrassment for economic theory: one of the strongest statistical relationships we know, lacking any clear basis in theory.” [p.44, Development, Geography, and Economic Theory, 1994]

Zipf dynamics: The rank-size rule is static but Zipf clearly recognized the dynamic nature of its underlying processes. Zipf stated: –“Specialization of enterprise, conditioned by the various advantages offered by a non-homogeneous terrain, naturally presupposes an exchange of goods…” –“with a mobile population, less productive districts will be abandoned for more productive districts”

Departures from the Zipf exponent of -1 (red curve on left graphs) indicate variations in city-size distributions and different urbanization processes.

Departures from a Zipf exponent of -1 Exponents between 0 and -1 (level slopes): even distributions of city sizes, relatively little urban diversity, characteristic of immature systems or perhaps managed efforts to promote inter-urban equity. Exponents greater than -1 (steep slope): diverse city-sizes, mature dynamic systems, large sample sizes.

List of U.S. Census data to illustrate Zipf’s law Incorporated towns ( ) Standard Metropolitan Statistical Areas ( ) Minor Civil Divisions ( ) Urbanized Areas >50,000 & Urban Clusters >2,500 ( ) Named Places (including unincorporated locations)

Primary MSAs (major central cities) Concave distribution, Zipf exponent = -1.2

U.S. Urban Areas + Urban Clusters Concave distribution Zipf exponent = -1.32

Distribution of named U.S. places for Census recognized places (same as civil divisions for upper portion) Log-log distribution is linear in upper part, exponential in lower part

MCD Change

Extent of Zipf’s Law Zipf’s Law is useful for illustrating distribution of cities in the upper or fat tail of its log-normal distribution. Krugman suggests it applies only to U.S. cities of 200,000 people but we consider that it extends to smaller cities as well. Here is data for the US urban system from 1970 to 2000 based on populations of 22,500 ‘places’ which shows that the Law extends over at least 3 orders of magnitude Using just the upper (fat) tail, it is be seen that the distribution is remarkably stable between 1970 and 2000

Parameter/Statistic R Square Intercept Zipf-Exponent

Zipf Dynamics Reworked: The US Urban System: 1790 to 2000 We have taken the top 100 places from Gibson’s Census Bureau Statistics from 1790 to 1990 and added the 2000 city populations We performed log-log regressions to fit Zipf’s Law We then looked at the way cities enter and leave the top 100 giving a rudimentary picture of the dynamics of the urban system We may visualize these dynamics in many different ways

In this way, we have reworked Zipf’s data (from 1790 to 1930) Yearr-squaredexponent

Total Population in the Top 100 US Cities Population in Millions Population NY City

Here we look at the half lives of cities: the average number of years cities remain in the list of largest 100 cities Here is a plot

Applications of Zipf’s law to China China has the world’s largest urban population and one of the most dynamic of large urban systems. During the past half century, urban areas in China have undergone phenomenal changes that reflect both severe restrictions on large city growth and dramatically enforced decentralization policies. These Zipf calculations are, to some extent, constrained by limitations in data consistency and periodicity.

China census data Two categories of urban census data: Provincial- and Prefecture-level cities (n = 234 in 1996); County-level cities (n = 400 in 1996). Provincial- and Prefecture-level are highly urbanized and have a time- series since We used the total population living within the boundary of cities’ districts (shi qu) as the urban size. The total numbers of P&P cities: 1949: 56 cities; 1957: 60 cities; 1965: 63 cities; 1978: 95 cities; 1985:100 cities. Time series: 1949/1957/1965/1978/1985/1988/1992/1996. Starting with 1949, the largest 56 cities of each year were examined in rank-size space.

Map of all P&P cities in 1996 Map of the 56 largest cities in 1949 Map of the 56 largest cities in 1996

Zipf exponents for China’s 56 largest Prefecture and Provincial-level cities: Decreased from in 1949 to a low of in 1992 and then started to increase to in Suggests the effects of stringent measures taken during the Maoist period, , to limit urban migration, large city growth, and the concentration of coastal cities. Indicates independently functioning urban regions not well integrated into a single national system.

Thoughts about urban systems: Old assumptions –Cities emerge independently of other cities within rural landscapes –Cities form vertical (Christaller) hierarchies –Big cities threaten environments New ideas –Cities have many horizontal links that build networks and strengthen economies –Urban networks have unique stabilities and vulnerabilities –Better human environments may result from a better understanding of how “systems of cities” work

Questions for further research: How do urban systems organize themselves in space and time? What defines an “urban system” and what provides the basis for its stability and its vulnerabilities? What can we do to protect and enhance the quality of our urban systems and environments?