Powerful Proven Results Reading Recovery Powerful Proven Results UNDER VIEW MENU, SELECT SLIDE SHOW Slide 1 — Reading Recovery CLICK Powerful Proven Results Talking Points Every 6-year-old is eager to learn to read. Their families and teachers are equally anxious for them to succeed. But each classroom has a few children who struggle with beginning reading. Unfortunately, researchers have found that among the very lowest children in first grade, 9 of 10 will still be at the bottom of their class in fourth grade, too! [NOTE 1] These are the children who are likely to be retained and likely to be referred to special education. Without special help they fall farther and farther behind and may even drop out of school. But early intervention can make a difference. Reading Recovery changes the future for the majority of the lowest first graders who have a complete series of lessons. This brighter future is possible because Reading Recovery teachers are specially trained to build on each child’s strengths and to accelerate their learning.

Reading Recovery Success Slide 2 — Reading Recovery Success (A local story might have more impact; this is just an example.) Talking Points This photo shows Dante Marshall — one of the first children trained in Reading Recovery when it began in Ohio in 1984 — now a practicing attorney in Atlanta. This is the kind of successful future that parents and teachers dream of when they think about their youngsters. As a 6-year old, no one would have predicted this future for Dante because he had very limited literacy skills—so limited that he was among the lowest children in his first grade in the Columbus Public Schools. Fortunately for Dante, Reading Recovery was being piloted as an intervention. He was chosen to work individually with a Reading Recovery teacher-in-training, Rose Mary Estice. After just 15 weeks of daily 30-minute lessons, Dante reached grade-level standard. And even though he was enrolled in a different elementary school each year, he continued to achieve; graduating from law school at The Ohio State University in 2003. Oh, and those people with Dante in the photo… That’s Marie Clay, the founder of Reading Recovery on his left, and Rose Mary Estice, his Reading Recovery teacher from first grade. Dante’s story is compelling, but is it typical? CLICK Here are Reading Recovery’s results from other students.

Reading Recovery Results 1.7 million American first graders Tens of thousands of teachers trained in Reading Recovery Data collected on every student 75% of students with a full series of lessons reached grade-level standard Slide 3 — Reading Recovery Results Talking Points CLICK Since Reading Recovery began in the U.S. in 1984–85, more than 1.7 million first graders have had Reading Recovery lessons and tens of thousands of teachers have had the yearlong Reading Recovery professional development. One of the remarkable features of Reading Recovery is that outcome data have been collected on every student since the beginning. No other beginning reading intervention has this kind of individual, long-term information. Nationally, of the students who have a complete intervention, 75% reach grade-level standard. These are amazing results considering that Reading Recovery always starts with the lowest 10–20% of students. [NOTE: You may want to adapt the information on success rate based on your local experience.] This evaluation evidence is backed up by scientific studies demonstrate that Reading Recovery works!

Reading Recovery Works What Works Clearinghouse independent review of research High ratings across all 4 domains 1. Alphabetics 2. Fluency 3. Comprehension 4. General Reading Achievement No other intervention measures up For more information go to http://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc// Slide 4 — Reading Recovery Works Talking Points CLICK Evidence of Reading Recovery’s effectiveness comes from an independent review of research by the U.S. Department of Education’s What Works Clearinghouse, an online resource to help educators select proven programs. Reading Recovery received high ratings across all four domains studied: Alphabetics which includes phonemic and print awareness, letter knowledge, and phonics; Fluency; Comprehension; and General Reading Achievement. No other intervention received high ratings across all four areas studied. And of the 153 beginning reading interventions studied in this first wave of What Works Clearinghouse reports, only Reading Recovery received a positive effects rating—the highest rating possible—in General Reading Achievement. [SEE NOTE 2 FOR INFORMATION] You can compare ratings among all the interventions studied and download detailed reports at the What Works Clearinghouse website. You might think it would take a long time to achieve such highly successful results with children at the bottom of their class.

Measurable Results in Weeks 30-minute daily lessons for just 12-20 weeks, not years One-to-one teaching Reading Recovery teacher works closely with classroom teacher Slide 5 — Measurable Results in Weeks Talking Points Reading Recovery produces measurable results in weeks—not years. CLICK First graders have individual 30-minute lessons each school day for 12 to 20 weeks—that’s just 30 to 50 hours in all. The child works one-to-one with a Reading Recovery teacher who has had a full academic year of training in how to work with the lowest literacy achievers. The Reading Recovery teacher works closely with the classroom teacher. The two study the child’s progress in Reading Recovery and in the classroom. They discuss any adjustments that may be needed. The child’s progress is measured by the Observation Survey of Early Literacy Achievement, a 6-task assessment developed by Dr. Marie Clay. Let’s take a look at the results from the beginning to the end of a typical child’s series of lessons.

Reading Recovery at White Oak

Intervention Status of All Recovery Students Served: White Oak Elementary School, 2008-2009 Total Discontinued Recommended Incomplete Moved None of Above Building n row % row% White Oak ES 18 72% 3 12% 1 4% 0% 25 TOTAL

Complete Interventions Intervention Status of Reading Recovery Children with Complete Interventions: White Oak Elementary School, 2008-2009 Complete Interventions Total Discontinued Building n row % White Oak ES 21 18 86%

Writing Vocabulary Beginning of lessons After a series of lessons Slide 6 — Writing Vocabulary [You may want to substitute your own examples and narrative here.] Talking Points The Writing Vocabulary Task shows how the child is building a personal resource of words that he can write in every detail. The child is asked to write as many words as he can in a 10-minute time period. CLICK At the beginning of this child’s Reading Recovery lessons, she knew how to write her name (Taylor) and the words to, yes, I, and go. Although she wrote MaMa, she said it was mom. At the end of her Reading Recovery intervention, Taylor was able to write more than 50 words in every detail. Many were high-frequency words and words that she could use to learn new words. Beginning of lessons After a series of lessons

Hearing and Recording Sounds in Words After a series of lessons Slide 7 — Hearing and Recording Sounds in Words [You may want to substitute your own examples and narrative here.] Talking Points The Hearing and Recording Sounds in Words task on the Observation Survey assesses phonemic awareness by determining how well a child represents sounds in graphic form. The teacher reads a short sentence or two for the child to write. The score represents every sound recorded accurately, whether or not the word is spelled correctly. CLICK When this child began Reading Recovery, he was asked to write, “The bus is coming. It will stop here to let me get on.” As you can see, he represented a few sounds in the words and correctly wrote the word stop. In a matter of weeks, at the end of his Reading Recovery lessons, this child represented all 37 sounds accurately, even though a couple of words were inaccurately spelled. Remember, this is not a spelling test; it is hearing and recording sounds. Beginning of lessons

Reading Level Level 2 - Beginning of lessons Slide 8 — Reading Level Talking Points An important task in the Observation Survey is a record of text reading that yields a reading level. The child reads books that escalate in levels of difficulty. CLICK As you can see, at the beginning of this child’s lessons, he was able to read a Level 2 book with a single line of text. After his lessons, he was able to read a much more-challenging Level 16 book, which represents the standard for his grade level. How do Reading Recovery teachers help children achieve these results over just a few weeks? Level 2 - Beginning of lessons Buffy by Lucy Lawrence Level 16 - After a series of lessons Stone Soup retold by Annette Smith

Powerful Professional Development-Continuing Contact for Trained Teachers Includes: 7 sessions per year 2 “Behind the Glass” lessons per session Non-profit, university-school partnership Reading Recovery’s highly skilled teachers fill other roles that are an integral part of White Oak’s School Improvement Plan A key literacy component of Responsiveness to Instruction (RtI) Slide 9 — Powerful Professional Development Talking Points Reading Recovery provides powerful professional development. CLICK The initial yearlong professional development happens on the job—usually in after- school classes that occur 1 day a week at a university training center. Classes include use of a one-way mirror so that teachers can observe and discuss Reading Recovery lessons with actual students. Teachers who receive the training also receive graduate credit from [INSERT THE NAME OF YOUR LOCAL UNIVERSITY OR COLLEGE GRANTING CREDIT FOR READING RECOVERY TRAINING HERE.] Reading Recovery is a non-profit, university-school partnership that includes more than 20 U.S. universities that train teacher leaders. The teacher leaders then conduct teacher professional development and provide school-based support. Reading Recovery teachers typically fill a variety of other roles, too. They work half a day with Reading Recovery students and the other half-day, they bring their expertise to other children. They may teach kindergarten, small literacy groups, or special education classes. Across the U.S., the typical Reading Recovery teacher serves 8.1 Reading Recovery students each year and 41.5 other students. This makes a highly skilled reading teacher available to a wider number of students. Reading Recovery teachers become literacy leaders in their schools. [ADD LOCAL DATA HERE – SEE NOTE 3] In some schools, administrators purposefully rotate their good early-grade teachers through Reading Recovery training in order to develop a broad base of expertise for their students.

Edenton-Chowan Reading Recovery Training Site Serves: Beaufort Chowan Currituck Gates Hyde Northampton Pasquotank Perquimans

Intervention Status of All Reading Recovery Students Served: Edenton-Chowan SITE, 2008-2009

Intervention Status of Reading Recovery Students with Complete Interventions: Edenton-Chowan SITE, 2008-2009

2009-2010 Training Class

Reading Recovery Initial Training includes: Three Day Summer Institute Weekly Classes On the job training 6 “Behind the Glass” sessions teaching students 6 hours graduate credit in Reading from UNC-W

Site Coordinator Role General administrative support for teacher leader Assist with recruitment of new Reading Recovery teachers and teacher leader training Contact between participating districts and university Assist teacher leader in reporting student progress data to the eight counties served Provide information and promote Reading Recovery Oversee budgeting & report to superintendent Collaborate with school leadership to ensure standards and implementation requirements are met

Cost for Initial Training Training Fee : $1,800.00 per Teacher Three Day Summer Institute Weekly Training Class (3 Hrs.) 4 On-Site visits Professional Materials (Textbooks) Annual Site Report National Data Fee

Costs for Ongoing Support $700.00 Per Teacher Professional development for Trained Teachers (Six Sessions) 1-2 on-site visits by teacher leader Annual Site Report National Data Fee

Costs Paid by LEA Instructional Materials & Supplies for Children $1,000.00 Annual Affiliation Fee to UNCW $400.00 per District per year UNCW Tuition $900.00 (6 Graduate Credit Hours) Subject to change by Legislature

Long-Term Cost Benefits All children make progress School receives a diagnostic history for children who need additional screening or services Majority of children reach grade-level standard in just 12-20 weeks Slide 10 — Long-Term Cost Benefits Talking Points CLICK Another reason why thousands of elementary schools have chosen Reading Recovery is because they see long-term cost benefits. Reading Recovery’s high success rate reduces referrals and placements in special education. All children make progress; even those who do not reach grade-level standard make great strides. In addition, each child has received an early intervening service that provides a full diagnostic history for children who need more long-term literacy support. After a period of Reading Recovery teaching, the school knows a lot more abut a child’s strengths and challenges and can recommend future support services. [ADD LOCAL DATA HERE – SEE NOTE 4] The majority of these formerly lowest-achieving students do reach grade-level standard in 12 to 20 weeks. And although the individual tutoring with an expert teacher requires extra staff resources, those costs are less than a year of retention or several years in special education. Even the children who do not reach grade-level standard in Reading Recovery DO make progress. In addition, they have received an early intervening service, a requirement under the federal IDEA funding to reduce unnecessary testing and referrals to special education.

Average Time in Program Per Pupil Cost over Time Compare the Alternatives (Based on average teacher salary and benefits - $60,000 annually) Question: How many children in each option reach grade level proficiency? Intervention Annual per Pupil Cost Average Time in Program Per Pupil Cost over Time Retention $9,200 1 year Title 1 $2,400 5 years $12,000 Special Education $3,700 $18,750 Small Group 3 years $7,200 Reading Recovery $3,750 12-20 weeks

The Bottom Line: — P.M. Cunningham & S.R. Allington "When you compare the success rate of Reading Recovery with other programs that keep children for years and never get them reading on grade level, Reading Recovery® is a bargain!" — P.M. Cunningham & S.R. Allington

with Reading Recovery Success is Within Reach! Slide 11 — With Reading Recovery, Success is Within Reach! Talking Points With Reading Recovery, CLICK literacy success is within reach for most of our lowest literacy learners in first grade. With a skilled Reading Recovery teacher we CAN prevent literacy failure. Literacy failure is costly for schools, for the community, and most critically for a child’s future ability to succeed in school and later life. NOTES 1 — The study that found lowest first graders were likely to still be lowest in fourth grade is Juel, C. (1988). Learning to read and write: A longitudinal study of fifty-four children from first through fourth grades. Journal of Educational Psychology, 80(4), 437–447. 2 — Positive effects is the highest rating possible. To see a chart with General Reading Achievement ratings for beginning reading interventions, visit http://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/reports/beginning_reading/topic/tabfig.asp#tbl2 Note just 25 interventions are listed with research evidence supporting effectiveness; 130 other programs were reviewed and listed as having no evidence of effectiveness in any area. 3 — Adapt these points to reflect how your school divides time for Reading Recovery teachers. One of the typical arguments in cost cutting is that teachers serve just 8 first graders. To counter this argument, it’s important to emphasize the other roles and contributions of Reading Recovery teachers. 4 — Here’s the place to use your local data if your implementation has reduced retention or special education referrals. Still another possible data use is to look at your Reading Recovery students’ results on standardized tests or state tests. Without Reading Recovery, the performance would likely be lower. For more information and specific research studies on cost benefits, see the research section of the RRCNA website, http://www.readingrecovery.org/research/cost/index.asp.