Michael J. Ritter.  Legal Disclosure. I hereby disclose that this session will include a discussion about law.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Chapter 12: Supreme Court Decision Making
Advertisements

Unit A: Basics of the Law Objective 01.01
Sources of Law Chapter 1.2.
NEXT How a Bill becomes a Law The Art of Debating Types of Court Civil & Criminal Cases The People’s Court
Secondary Sources BLS Winter 2005 Kristy Moon, Cheryl Nyberg, Mary Whisner.
CS 5060, Fall 2009 Digital Intellectual Property Law u Class web page at: u No textbook. Online treatise at:
Business Law Unit 1 Law, Justice, and You
Expanding the Awesomeness of Your Legal Research Abilities with Secondary Resources.
The Judicial Branch Chapter 12 Civics – Mr. Blough.
The Federal Courts Agenda Quiz Overview of the Judicial Court System
Government.
Chapter 7 The Judicial Branch
1)Types: Primary Secondary Helpers 2)Library Books 3)Internet NY Courts Website Tanbook Citation Services 4)Computer Assisted Legal Research Resources.
2014 Georgia Debate Institutes. RESOLUTION OF FACT  Resolutions that you should assume is a fact. The purpose of the debate is to prove whether or not.
Introduction to Legal Information Jason R. Sowards Massey Law Library April 25, 2010 Management 599c.
The Judicial Branch Chapter 12 Civics – Mr. Blough.
The Trinity of American Government Declaration of Independence –A document that is used to separate a country from another country. EXAMPLE: Texas from.
The Judicial Branch Chapter 7.
Judicial Branch #1 The Federal Court System. Dual Court System State Courts: have jurisdiction over the majority of cases Federal Courts: have jurisdiction.
Chapter 12 The Judiciary. Common Law Tradition  Common law = judge-made law; originated in England; derived from prevailing customs  Precedent = court.
Chapter 7 Authority: Law Books
Questions What are three types of jurisdiction? What are two types of juries? When is each used? What is senatorial courtesy and when is it used? How many.
THE US CONSTITUTION Chapter 4 - A CLOSER LOOK. THE CONSTITUTION 1.Based on six principles: a. The rule by the people – democracy! b. Limited powers –
- STYLES OF DEBATE - LEVELS OF COMPETITION - TOURNAMENTS! Westwood Debate COMPETITION OVERVIEW.
- STYLES OF DEBATE - LEVELS OF COMPETITION - TOURNAMENTS! Westwood Debate COMPETITION OVERVIEW.
Lincoln Douglas Debate RJ Pellicciotta, Cary Academy Dogwood Speech & Debate League.
Six Basic Principles of the Constitution
I. Introduction A. Law definition B. Law in business.
George H. Pike Director of the Barco Law Library University of Pittsburgh School of Law September 29, 2010.
Preamble The Preamble states the purpose of the Constitution.
Objective 1.00 Understand the Origins of Law SOURCES OF AMERICAN LAW.
Democracy and Constitutions Texas Constitutions p
The Structure of the Constitution The Constitution has three main parts: preamble, seven articles, and 27 amendments.
LS100 Eight Skills Prof. Jane McElligott.  There are many sources of law such as cases, statutes, federal and state constitutions, federal administrative.
Prof. Emily Ryan PA 101.  Primary sources are actual statements of the law.  Enormous amounts of primary source materials available are issued chronologically.
Chapter 1 U.S. Legal System. Chapter Objectives After reading this chapter, you will know the following: The primary sources of law in the U.S. legal.
Intro to Public Forum Debate. What is Public Forum Debate? Partner debate Purpose- for the “common man” Much easier to understand, and thus to judge,
Legal Reference Questions in a Non-Law Library May 17, 2016 Joan Shear, Boston College Law Library Suzanne Hoey, Massachusetts Trial Court Libraries.
Intro to the Appellate Process When a party loses at trial they have the right to appeal the decision. An appeal is always about whether the law was correctly.
Types of Laws Chapter 1-2. Sources of Law What’s Your Verdict? (pg. 10) The federal constitution guarantees the citizens of the U.S. many rights. These.
Chapter 2: Legal Research Presented by: Alexis Saperstein.
Structure and Function of the American Judiciary.
Understanding legal authority for research purposes What is LAW? How do we define it?
Types of Laws Created by The University of North Texas in partnership with the Texas Education Agency.
Chapter 1 U.S. Legal System.
Chapter 12: Supreme Court Decision Making
The U.S. Constitution Is the nation's highest law
Intro to public forum: A layman’s debate
BELLRINGER.
Unit A: Basics of the Law Objective 01.01
Unit A: Basics of the Law Objective 01.01
Chapter 1 Overview Part 1: Process of Ethical Decisions
Unit 4 The Judicial Branch
How Laws are Made: The Courts.
The Principles of the United States Constitution
Separation of Powers / Checks and Balances
A2: The Judicial Branch Basics Notes
Intro to Public Forum Debate
A2: The Judicial Branch Basics Notes
Constitution Articles
Three Branches of Government
AP U.S. Government Chapter 14
Sources of Law Legislature – makes law Executive – enforces law
Explain the significance of the landmark decision Marbury vs. Madison
United States Legal System
The Principles of the United States Constitution
Chapter 12: Supreme Court Decision Making
The Principles of the United States Constitution
Chapter 7 The Judicial Branch
Judicial Branch #1 The Supreme Court.
Presentation transcript:

Michael J. Ritter

 Legal Disclosure. I hereby disclose that this session will include a discussion about law.

 About Me. S/K/A “Mikey” and “Ritter” Policy Debater – RRHS & Trinity University Assistant Debate Coach: St. Mary’s Hall, Stony Point, etc. Now a lawyer…

 Students who debate at TFA and UIL tournaments almost always debate law.

 “Congress is an individual contest [that] models the legislative process of democracy, specifically, the United States Congress.” University Interscholastic League, UIL Congress Pilot Contest (2014), available at

 “The United States federal government should....”

 A little less law, a little more current events.  But still law: Resolved: On balance, public subsidies for professional athletic organizations in the United States benefit their local communities. Resolved: The Supreme Court rightly decided that Section 4 of the Voting Rights Act violated the Constitution. Resolved: Immigration reform should include a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants currently living in the United States.

 Legal Topics Right to be Forgotten (Civil Rights), “In the criminal justice system,” Compulsory Voting, etc.  Policy Topics Organ Procurement, Humanitarian Aid, Security vs. Digital Privacy  Philosophical Topics Oppressive Governments v. Anarchy, Rawls vs. Nozick, Killing Innocents

 Lawyer secret: A law is just a rule.  Rules are everywhere. *Hugh Grant, Love, Actually (2003) (slightly modified for purposes of this presentation).

 The process of thinking about the rules of debate is the same as thinking about the rules of TSCA/TFA/UIL. And that’s the same process of thinking about “law” rules.

 Laws: Constitutions, Statutes, “Rules” & Regulations, Interpretations, Case Law  “Generally speaking, there are five sources of law: constitutions, statutes, rules, agency interpretations, and case law (listed in order of importance, except for case law interpretations of constitutions).” -Michael J. Ritter, “Don’t Threaten to Sue Your Judge”: An Overview of the Legal Obligations of Judges, Schools & Organizations, National Journal of Speech & Debate, October 2,  Rule-Making Institutions *Haddaway, “What is Love” (1993) (slightly modified for purposes of this presentation).

 Secondary Sources of Law Legal Treatises (Empirical) Law Reviews & Law Journals (Normative) Law Blogs (Both & More)

 Expensive, Non-Lawyer Unfriendly Resources LexisNexis Westlaw  Free, Non-Lawyer Friendly Resources Legal Information Institute: Texas Legislature Website: Google Scholar: scholar.google.com

 Free, Non-Lawyer Friendly Resources - Secondary Search Engines (Google, DuckDuckGo) American Bar Association – Free Full-Text Online Law Review/Journal Search Black’s Law Dictionary

 Search Engines  American Bar Association – Law Journal Search #omgbeckylookwedontneedlexis

 Black’s Law Dictionary: thelawdictionary.org

 It depends! (Lawyers love this answer.)  Depends on: Type of Debate Type of Topic Topic Wording The Type of Argument

 Public Forum Debate Depends on the Topic – Non-Current Events Topics Did the Supreme Court rightly decide that section 4 of the Voting Rights Act violated the constitution?  Shelby County v. Holder  Majority vs. Dissent

 Cross-Examination (Policy) Debate Topicality  Black’s Law Dictionary Inherency  Is the plan actually a change to the law? Harms  N/A Solvency  Constitutionality, Perceived Unconstitutionality & Fiat

 LD Debate See Last Slide Using law in value/criterion development Case Clash

 Step I: Brainstorm and Identify Potential Topic Subareas

 Step II: Do preliminary search engine research (e.g. Google, Bing, etc.) and “Just add ‘Law’” And “law blog” And “law review”

 Step III: Start Developing Argument and Case Ideas Identify and confirm topic areas for which there is literature See relevant results from qualified authors

 Step IV: Quickly Check Supreme Court Cases After 1986 & Law Reviews Articles Cites will be found in the search results; cross reference with the free sources. For Law Journals: focus on policy articles advocating for a policy change in specific sub- areas; For cases: Look at Supreme Court cases justifying the ruling; and FEDERAL court of appeals cases; you find the debate in those courts

 Step V: Incorporate & Bolster—“Prefer My Evidence”  (1) Qualifications: This topic is about the legal issue of. My evidence is authored by: a federal judge who has been deemed an legal expert by the U.S. a attorney who studied the law in the area and applies the law every day.  (2) This provides a more real world education.  Richard Colling, terrible driver, 2013: Richard J. Colling, The Truth- Testing Paradigm as a Straw Man, B.A., University of Houston (400 B.C., Director of Forensics, Stony Point High School, N ATIONAL J OURNAL OF S PEECH & D EBATE 2013: “The legalistic model is as real world as the legislative model, as cases are considered daily by the courts. It could even be considered more ‘real world’ considering the great frequency of court cases resolved compared to legislation passed by Congress, and more debaters end up lawyers than the debaters that end up legislators.”

 Step VI: Save the statutes/constitutions for cases on straight-up legal topics and responses to cases and counter- arguments. Sometimes even lawyers and courts have issues trying to understand what the laws mean, shouldn’t be your go to, but they can be the best evidence against a case. But they frequently can be the most persuasive argument

 Let’s try it out: Threatening Speech Topic Steps I–VI

 You Ask Questions.  Like an attorney, I will try to avoid them.