Pizza Hut, Inc. v. Papa John’s International U.S. Court of Appeals 5 th Circuit 2000 1.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Trip to Pizza Express Miss. Jenkins Class. First we washed our hands and put our aprons on.
Advertisements

Copyright 2007 Thomson Delmar Learning. All Rights Reserved. STATE OF OKLAHOMA ex rel. OKLAHOMA BAR ASSOCIATION v. TWEEDY, Supreme Court of Oklahoma 2000.
12 Misleading or Deceptive Conduct © Oxford University Press, All rights reserved.
PUFFERY, DECEPTION & TRUTH TELLING
 Inform  Obama Obama  Biden Biden  Entertain  E-Trade E-Trade  Random Mix Random Mix  Rav4 Rav4  Entice  Beef Beef.
Are we done in China yet? Presented by Richard Jia Ex Zarpac Inc. Executive.
Papa John’s Pizza by Michael Suchy & Eric Utne. How We Found Papa John’s Taking a bottom-up approach, we ran a stock screen using a minimum 15% ROE, 1.
Regulations and Ethical Concerns Chapter 14 Copyright © 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall 14-1.
MAKE AN ITALIAN PIZZA Ingredients: ½ package of active dry yeast 2/3 cup of warm water 3 cups of flour 1 teaspoon of fine salt Tomato sauce Mozzarella.
An Introduction to American Courts Judge Tom C. Rawlings Judge, Juvenile Courts Middle Judicial Circuit Sandersville, GA USA
Team 6 Caitrin Dolan Will Davis Brittany Irvin Jeremiah Woolwine.
ECONOMIC EDUCATION FOR CONSUMERS ○ Chapter 1 LESSON 1.5 Advertising and Consumer Decisions GOALS ► Describe different types of advertising. ► Explain how.
25-1 Chapter 44 Consumer Protection and Product Safety.
Advertisements Advertising is designed: To make people buy what the advertiser has for sale. Advertisements have a common goal: to influence people’s opinion.
Persuasive Writing. The art of convincing? Can you convince me to…..
Papa John’s Pizza Update. Introduction Papa John’s is a relatively small growth company that fits the investment policy statement like a glove. The company.
Pearson Education, Inc., Longman © District Courts.
Sabina Dossaliyeva Brianna Gilstrap Blair Lawrence Pizza Hut vs Domino’s (860) :Ate pizza for the 3rd time today, can't decide if that's disgusting or.
Project PIZZA An exercise in contemplating the wonders of project design, management and life cycle.
Ingredients on a Pizza What do you like on your pizza? Extended Activity PPT41.
Marketing Research.
 Brand Advertising  Goal is to make you remember a particular brand name.  Slogans, Jingles  Product Placement Product Placement  Informative Advertising.
Account Planning Concepts and Definitions. Account planners….. Discover how to connect with consumers and inspire them to respond. Identify behavior patterns.
Going Back to Basics. What are the basics? Calls Face to Faces Campaigns Cards and letters.
ADVERTISING. It’s everywhere!!! What is it? Form of Promotion An element in the Promotional Mix Promotional Campaigns are used to advertise Product Promotion.
PIZZA WAREHOUSES Manufacturing Unique Marketing Solutions.
Literally True Deception. Deceptive Ads  A statement (or omission) that is  Likely to mislead  A reasonable consumer  About a material fact.
Lesson 4: Promotion. Objectives Compare different promotional strategies and the benefits of a promotional mix Discuss the advantages of publicity and.
CHAPTER 3 Court Systems 3-1 Forms of Dispute Resolution
14 Chapter Fourteen Regulations and Ethical Concerns 14-1 Copyright © 2010 by Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall.
All About Pizza. Questions #1 Americans eat approximately how much pizza per day? A. 100 slices per second B. 150 slices per second C. 275 slices per.
Can the First Amendment Save Controversial Packaging? Janet M. Evans Federal Trade Commission Presentation for NABCA Legal Symposium March 12, 2013.
Permission Marketing Part Two Turning Strangers Into Friends, and Friends Into Customers Summarized by Bob Griffin By Seth Godin.
©2005 Pearson Education Canada Inc.4-1 Chapter 4 Advertising: Creative Planning.
I hate my life Stay in school kids Start What is 6+2? Help the Pizza Hut delivery boy find the pizza.
For use only with Duncan texts. © 2005 McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. McGraw-Hill/Irwin Social, Ethical, and Legal Issues.
Contracts one accepts all terms of a contract agreed to, weather read or not. Kaitlyn and Lindsey.
By: Lissette Colón PUR 3000 Case Study: Domino’s Turn-Around Campaign.
INTRO Q & A.  Proofread for spelling, mechanical, or grammatical errors.  If a sentence doesn’t make sense or is unclear, tell them so!  Look at the.
Regulatory Factors Affecting Advertising
Forget Gamification Try Writing a Humanized Survey Annie Pettit Source: Quirk’s Article , February 2014Quirk’s Article , February 2014.
Chapter 19 Lesson 1 Personal Finance. Consumer Rights  As a consumer you have many rights.  Consumerism is a movement to educate buyers about the purchases.
Media Influences Level 2.  Target market  Consumer  Manipulate  Deceptive Vocabulary.
The Federal Courts and the Judicial Branch. Section 2: Lower Federal Courts Chapter 8: The Federal Courts and the Judicial Branch.
Chapter 10- The Judicial Branch. JUDICIAL BRANCH  The Judicial Branch was created to help balance the powers of the other two branches.  It played a.
3.03 Components of Advertising. Parts of a Print Advertisement Headline: Large text at top of ad Headline: Large text at top of ad Illustration: picture/graphic.
PIZZA What is pizza?. Pizza is a flat bread base with a tomato sauce topping and a variety of other ingredients. It has become popular all over the world,
36 Hot Sandwiches and Pizza Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Objective Recognize various types.
Author’s Purpose Modes of Writing. Three Reasons for Writing 1.To Inform (Expository) 2.To Persuade (Persuasive) 3.Entertain (Narrative or Poetry) You.
2/14/2006Class 161 Class 16, Tuesday, Feb. 14 Announcements Thursday Friday Today’s agenda Problem 3-4 Problem Set 3 Hill v. Gateway 2000.
Process Design and supply chain matrix. Process Design Matrix The process design is the most important part of a company. The process design can begin.
Colors & Lines Lists Graphics Random 1pt 1 pt 1 pt 1pt 1 pt 2 pt 2 pt
HOW TO MAKE PIZZA by Jaydan
Lesson 3 Media Influences
U.S. Court System.
ADVERTISING & PROPAGANDA
Reverse Engineering By: Shaquille Thomas.
DOMINO’S PIZZA 9/17/2018. DOMINO’S PIZZA 9/17/2018.
Place your screenshot here
CHAPTER 2: CUSTOMER-BASED BRAND EQUITY
The Fundamentals of Food Advertising Law
Pre – Placement Talk IIT Bombay
DOMINO’S PIZZA 11/11/2018.
Which type of claim does this represent?
Which type of claim does this represent?
Consumer By: debshoganteaching
13 Kelsey, Katie, and Lauren decided to have pizza party. They are trying to decide which pizza restaurant has the best deal. The local pizza places.
Recommendation / Feasibility Reports
The Supreme Court of the
Promotional Mix Advertising Media Television Ads Outdoor Ads
Presentation transcript:

Pizza Hut, Inc. v. Papa John’s International U.S. Court of Appeals 5 th Circuit

Facts 2

Pizza Hut –False claim of superior ingredients –Undertook campaign to improve its pizza using more and better quality ingredients 3

Papa John’s –further emphasized message of superiority by focusing on specific ingredients Claimed “fresh pack” method of producing tomato paste was superior to “most big chains” and “most pizza delivery chains” Adopted new method of manufacturing dough (using ozonated filtered water) specifically for purpose of drawing negative comparisons to Pizza Hut 4

Papa John’s –continued to use “Better Ingredients, Better Pizza” in connection with more specific claims about sauce and dough 5

Pizza Hut –sued to enjoin Papa John’s from deceptive claims regarding sauce and crust using slogan 6

District Court Sauce and dough superiority claims false –“ambiguous and self-laudatory, consistent with the legal definition of non-actionable puffing” –By combining it with other, false claims, slogan became tainted –Made claim of superiority quantifiable Enjoined its use 7

Court of Appeals –“Best Pizza Under One Roof” (Pizza Hut) –“Nobody Delivers Better” (Dominos) –“Best Pizza on the Block” (Donatos) –“Best Pizza Ever” (Pizza Inn) 8

–“The Best Beer in America” –“The most advanced home gaming system in the universe” 9

Held: Ads making misleading claims about superiority of dough and sauce tainted general claim of superiority 31 of 278 ads Rejected claim that misleading specific claims became “encoded” in consumers’ mind Reversed 10