A: Overview of project analysis and workshop contributions July 3, 2013 3:00 pm to 3:30 pm David Purkey, SEI Robert Lempert, RAND 1.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
WEAP Water Evaluation & Planning System
Advertisements

AFRICAN DEVELOPMENT BANK GROUP TOM DOWNING Climate Safeguard System: Screening projects in the African Development Bank.
Addressing the Climate Vulnerability of African Infrastructure Introduction Raffaello Cervigni and Marcus Wishart (World Bank) July 3, 2013.
David Purkey, SEI Rob Lempert, RAND
Lesson 3 ODOT Analysis & Assessment. Analysis & Assessment Learning Outcomes As part of a small group, apply the two- part analysis by generating exposure-
Boise State University Siân Mooney, Professor Boise State University EPSCoR Senior Lead, Economics and Policy Dept. Economics 10 th Annual Climate and.
E: Track II Project level analyses Robert Lempert, RAND 1.
Recommended by the 2010 Duncan Review and subsequently supported by the WA government structured as an overarching aspirational plan for the region Inter-related.
Scenario Discovery Robert Lempert Director RAND Pardee Center on Longer-Range Global Policy and the Future Human Condition CEDM Project Meeting May 21,
ASSESSMENT IN HIAs Elizabeth J. Fuller, DrPH, MSPH Georgia Health Policy Center.
1 Measuring Performance of Resource Management Responses Rich Juricich (DWR) David Groves (RAND)
Enhancing the Climate Resilience of Africa’s Infrastructure ACPC Role.
Risk and Resilience: A Canadian Perspective on Climate Change Adaptation Donald S. Lemmen, PhD Climate Change Impacts and Adaptation Directorate Natural.
Vulnerability and Adaptation Assessments Hands-On Training Workshop
Africa and National Communications under UNFCCC : A Means To An End Dr. George Manful Senior Task Manager, Climate Change Enabling Activities, UNEP.
Capacity Building in Analytical Tools for Estimating and Comparing Costs and Benefits of Adaptation Projects in the Berg River Basin, South Africa AIACC.
Introduction to the Session 6 - Theme 4 – on “Water Resources Management and Governance”
1 “Adaptation to the consequences of Climate Change: Progress achieved and capacity building needed” Budapest, November 19-20, 2007 Strategic Environmental.
Harnessing the Power of Environmental Data for Decision-Making IABIN Phase II.
© 2009 UNDP. All Rights Reserved Worldwide. Proprietary and Confidential. Not For Distribution Without Prior Written Permission. Overview of GEF’s STRATEGIC.
IWRM as a Tool for Adaptation to Climate Change
Overview of the Colorado River Basin Water Supply and Demand Study Urban Water Institute 19 th Annual Water Policy Conference August 22-24, 2012 San Diego.
Stakeholder-driven, multi-sectoral climate adaptation in small urban areas ASP Colloquium - 6 th August 2014, Boulder Amanda Edelman, Pardee RAND Graduate.
Adressing Floods and Drought in GEF supported TDA/SAPs IWC-7 October 2013 Peter Bjornsen, UNEP-DHI Centre.
1 Improving Analytical Capabilities of the California Water Plan Rich Juricich, California Dept. of Water Resources.
What Climate Information Do Water Managers Need to Make Robust, Long-Term Plans? Robert Lempert Senior Scientist RAND US CLIVAR Mini-Symposium July 14,
AN INTEGRATED ASSESSENT OF IMPACTS, ADAPTATION AND VULNERABILITY IN WATERSHED AREAS AND COMMUNITIES IN SOUTHEAST ASIA Juan M. Pulhin Ekawati S. Wahyuni.
Methods for Developing Robust Climate Adaptation Plans in the Energy Sector David Groves Water and Climate Resilience Center.
Information Needs for Developing Robust Adaptive Strategies Robert Lempert Director, RAND Pardee Center for Longer Range Global Policy and the Future Human.
UNDP-GEF Adaptation 0 0 Impact of National Communications on Process of Integrating Climate Change into National Development Policies UNFCCC Workshop on.
MUS pilot project in Honduras Testing guidelines for planning and implementation of multiple use services.
Creating a Shared Vision Model. What is a Shared Vision Model? A “Shared Vision” model is a collective view of a water resources system developed by managers.
SMART Workshop Hammamet September Universidade Atlântica - Portugal WP 10 Comparative policy analysis.
New Methods to Bridge Long-Term Policy Analysis and Robust Decision Making Robert Lempert Director RAND Frederick S. Pardee Center for Longer Range Global.
Guidelines for Impact and Adaptation Assessment Design versus Implementation Issues RICHARD J.T. KLEIN POTSDAM INSTITUTE FOR CLIMATE IMPACT RESEARCH (PIK)
Deeper Insights from System Dynamics Models Mark Paich Lexidyne Consulting 10/9/08.
OPTIMA October 2004 WP01 Requirements and constraints.
FAOCGIARWMO. How will Global Environmental Change affect the vulnerability of food systems in different regions? How might food systems be adapted to.
CLIMATE CHANGE AND WATER MAKING RIVER BASIN MANAGEMENT PLANS “CLIMATE PROOF” IN SPAIN.
BFP grant – GECAFS Objectives 1.Improve understanding of vulnerability of food systems to the stresses induced by GEC 2.Document food systems and analyze.
Agricultural and environmental indicators and models por Rubén De la Sierra Rosario Peyrot.
PP 4.1: IWRM Planning Framework. 2 Module Objective and Scope Participants acquire knowledge of the Principles of Good Basin Planning and can apply the.
Environmental Infrastructure Needs Assessment: GIS Based Decision Support System Southwest Center for Environmental Research and Policy Presented by Rene.
Draft GEO Framework, Chapter 6 “Architecture” Architecture Subgroup / Group on Earth Observations Presented by Ivan DeLoatch (US) Subgroup Co-Chair Earth.
SANREM TOP Framework GECAFS Interpretation. SEE Conditions (Social, Economic, Environmental) Assessed Practices Changed KASAC (Knowledge, Attitudes, Skills,
Community Based Adaptation Project Inception Workshop Overview of the CBA Project Presented by Stephen Gitonga, GEF Small Grants Programme CBA Preparatory.
1 Scenarios and More California Water Plan Advisory Committee Meeting April 14 th, 2005.
Vulnerability and Adaptation Assessment Hands-on Training Workshop Integration of V&A Analysis.
Relevance and utility of AIACC PROJECT AF07 for stakeholders and decisionmakers and for informing policy choices George Green Water Research Commission,
Global Environmental Change and Food Systems Scenarios Research up to date Monika Zurek FAO April 2005.
Improving Decisions in a Complex and Changing World: New Approaches to Climate Change Decisionmaking Under Uncertainty Robert Lempert, Debra Knopman, and.
© OECD/IEA 2011 Energy Efficiency in Central Asia: Challenges and Opportunities VII KAZENERGY EURASIAN FORUM World in Transition Shaping Sustainable Energy.
IEc INDUSTRIAL ECONOMICS, INCORPORATED Proposed Methodology and Action Plan to Develop the Impact Assessment and Menu of Adaptation Options for Uzbekistan.
1 Scenario formulation Scenario-based planning is a structured way of thinking about what might happen in the future Scenarios are descriptions of possible.
Water Management and Climate Change in the US- Mexico Border Region Robert Lempert Senior Scientist RAND September 27, 2008.
1 Recommended Next Steps For Improving Quantitative Information California Water Plan Advisory Committee Meeting August 17, 2005.
Harmonization and Use of Standard Analytical Tools for Water Resources Management as an approach towards Regional Cooperation Abdulkarim H Seid Head, Water.
Organizations of all types and sizes face a range of risks that can affect the achievement of their objectives. Organization's activities Strategic initiatives.
Alan Matheson State Planning Coordinator November 19, 2013 Preparing for an Uncertain Future: Developing a Utah Water Strategy Alan Matheson Executive.
4/16/2010 Regional Planning Group Meeting Long-Term Planning Study of the ERCOT Interconnection Warren Lasher Manager, System Assessment.
Using Analysis and Tools to Inform Adaptation and Resilience Decisions -- the U.S. national experiences Jia Li Climate Change Division U.S. Environmental.
Introduction and Overview
Article by Caroline Moser
Sarah Opitz-Stapleton
Rodel D. Lasco Professor University of the Philippines
Liana Prudencio and Sarah E. Null
Monitoring and Evaluation of Sustainable tourism
Introduction and Overview
Inception Phase.
Overview of Bank Water Sector Activities
Presentation transcript:

A: Overview of project analysis and workshop contributions July 3, :00 pm to 3:30 pm David Purkey, SEI Robert Lempert, RAND 1

Specific Project Objectives 1.Evaluate (in physical and cost terms) the impacts of climate change on a subset of infrastructures (roads, hydro‐power and irrigation) 2.Develop and test a framework for investment decision-making that can be ‘robust’ under a wide range of climate outcomes; 3.Formulate actionable recommendations for decision makers to enhance climate resilience of infrastructure development. 2

Our Project Team SEI RAND KTH University of Cape Town Rhodes University International Institute for Water and the Environment The Nile Basin Initiative 3

Project Focuses on Continent-Wide Analysis Orange-Senqu Nile Zambezi Congo Volta Niger Senegal Seven Water Basins Four Power Pools + Five project level studies 4

Components of Project Analysis How to address uncertainty in climate projections (and other trends)? Infrastructure Investment Plans Climate projections and other uncertainties Impacts Potential Reponses 1.Use PIDA+ plans 2.Develop WEAP and GAMs models of the basins and power pools 3.Use models to assess impacts of climate and other trends on infrastructure and system performance 5

Use Robust Decision Making (RDM) Approach, Which Runs the Analysis “Backwards” 1.Start with a proposed strategy 2.Use multiple model runs to identify conditions that best distinguish futures where strategy does and does not meet its goals 3.Identify steps that can be taken so strategy may succeed over wider range of futures Proposed strategy Identify vulnerabilities of this strategy Develop strategy adaptations to reduce vulnerabilities “RDM Process” 6

RDM Uses Analytics to Facilitate New Conversation with Decision Makers 1. Participatory Scoping 2. System Evaluation across Many Cases 3. Vulnerability Assessment 4. Adaptation Tradeoffs Scenarios and strategies Outcomes Vulnerabilities and leading strategies Vulnerabilities Robust Strategy New insights Iterative Analysis facilitates deliberation among stakeholders Suggests scenarios and robust strategies

Participatory Scoping: Work with Decision Stakeholders to Define Objectives/Parameters 1. Participatory Scoping Deliberation with Decision Stakeholders Metrics that reflect decision makers’ goals Management strategies (levers) considered to pursue goals Uncertain factors that may affect ability to reach goals Relationships among metrics, levers, and uncertainties Information needed to organize simulation modeling Also called “XLRM” 8

System Evaluation: Evaluate Strategy in Each of Many Plausible Futures 2. System Evaluation across Many Cases Modeling Futures Large database of model results (each element shows performance of a strategy in one future) Strategy Plausible assumptions Potential outcomes 100s/1000s of cases 9

Vulnerability Assessment: Mine the Database of Cases to Identify Policy-Relevant Scenarios Scenarios that illuminate vulnerabilities of proposed strategy 3. Vulnerability Assessment Uncertain input variable 2 1.Indicate policy-relevant cases in database of model results 2.Statistical analysis finds low- dimensional clusters with high density of these cases 3.Clusters represent scenarios and driving forces of interest to decision makers Uncertain input variable 1 Parameter 1 Parameter 2 Strategy successful Strategy less successful 10

Tradeoff Analysis: Allow Decision Makers to Compare Tradeoff Among Strategies Robust strategy or information to enable decision-makers to make more robust strategy 4. Tradeoff Analysis Visualization helps decision makers compare strategies 11

La Paz/El Alto Bolivia Case Study 12

Current Water Supply System for the Cities of La Paz and El Alto, Bolivia 13

New Khara Kkota (14M) dam Increase Taypichaca (8M) dam to 18M m 3 New 400 l/s Khara Kkota canal to El Alto New 400 l/s Taypichaca canal to El Alto Infrastructure Alternative No. 1 14

Increase Taypichaca dam capacity from 8M to 18M m 3 New water capture structures in Janchallani and Jacha Waquiwina watersheds to the Taypichaca Dam New 800 l/s Taypichaca canal to El Alto Infrastructure Alternative No. 2 15

New Kaluyo dam of 10.6M m 3 New water capture structure in the Chacaltaya watershed to the Kaluyo Dam New 1000 l/s Kaluyo canal to La Paz New 800 l/s Milluni canal to El Alto Infrastructure Alternative No. 3 16

Modeling the alternatives in WEAP 17

“XLRM” Framework to support problem formulation and analytical design Uncertainty Factors (X)Response Packages (L) Uncertain factors outside of the control of water managers which form the basis of scenarios analysis. Management strategies available to water managers: -Current system -Planned strategies Models (R)Performance Metrics (M) Models to produce metrics of performance (M) for each strategy (L) in the face of ensembles of uncertainties (X) Results of interest, metrics used to evaluate the performance of strategies under consideration 18

Resulting XLRM table Uncertainty Factors (X) Response Packages (L) 1.Climate change and vulnerability 2.Population growth 3.Per capita water use 4.Changes in water allocation policy 5.Growth in irrigated areas Infrastructure Alternatives 1, 2 and 3 Source watershed conservation plans Increased irrigation efficiency Reduce losses in potable water distribution system Model (R) Performance Metrics (M) 1.Satisfaction of potable water demands 2.Satisfaction of irrigation water demands 3.System losses 4.Reservoir storage 19

Frequency of failure to meet at least 80% of potable water demand in El Alto 20

Bringing it all together, in Spanish 21

Outcome of the Effort In an iterative cycle of modeling, analysis, and interaction with decision makers, arrived a preferred alternative. The preferred alternative included elements of Alternative 1 and 2, along with investments in source watershed rehabilitation and irrigation improvements investments. This preferred alternative is now the focus of environmental documentation, design, and financial planning efforts. 22