Www.bankwatch.org Gold mining cyanide attempts in Bulgaria “Water protection – endangering activities” Conference – Budapest, 01-02.02.2011.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
SOCRATES PROGRAMME BULGARIA Correspondence between the Socrates programme objectives and the Bulgarian policy in the field of education : European education.
Advertisements

Integra Consulting Services Ltd. Implementing the SEA Directive: Experience from the new EU Member States Martin Smutny.
Legal issues on shale gas activities raised in petitions received by the European Parliament Committee on Petitions.
EC PHARE project EU IMPACT - Academic network for communicating integration impacts in Croatia Effective networking: Case study EU IMPACT: Academic network.
Ministry of Health Anna Starzewska-Sikorska, Ph.D. Coordinator of environmental part of Programme Institute for Ecology of Industrial Areas, Katowice POLISH.
© European Communities, 2007 Purpose The European Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control Bureau (European IPPC Bureau) of the JRC/IPTS was set up.
USE OF NEW PUBLIC PARTICIPATION MECHANISMS ESTABLISHED IN MOLDOVA AS A TOOL FOR PP IN DECISION MAKING Ilya TROMBITSKY ‘Eco-TIRAS’ NGO, MOLDOVA.
EBRD's Mining Strategy (MS) The Bank recognizes that mining can cause significant adverse environmental and social impacts, including.
HR 09 IB EN 02 – German Proposal, Zagreb, 10 June 2011 Page 1 April 12, Strengthening the Ministry of Nature Protection of the Republic of Armenia.
Romanian experience on the transposition and implementation of the IPPC, LCP, Seveso II, Waste Landfill, VOC Directives – experience and lessons learnt.
Prof. Jan H. Jans EU and Aarhus Jurisdictional Cmpetition?
BlueLink Information Network. E-voting platform for Civil Society in Bulgaria Milena Bokova Executive Director BlueLink Information Network June 2008,
Bosnia and Herzegovina and P ublic P articipation in I nternational F orums 5 th Task Force Meeting on Public Participation in International Forums Geneve,
ORGANISED LOCAL GOVERNMENT IN SOUTH AFRICA (SALGA) PRESENTATION TO CNM Scope of the relationships between local governments of IBSA July 2009.
1 MINISTRY OF REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTORATE GENERAL PROGRAMMING OF REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT Operational Programme Regional Development.
“Building Effective Public Participation in Environmental Impact Assessment in a Transboundary Context” in Bulgaria Institute for Ecological Modernisation.
NGO coalition for a sustainable use of the EU funds 1.EU regulations 2.EU strategic guidelines 3.National programming European.
"Integrity Pacts - Civil Control Mechanism for Safeguarding EU Funds"
Learning and development - consultancy - research EIPA 2010 © European Institute of Public Administration - Institut européen d’administration publique.
Accountability of European Investment Bank. How can Hungarian civil society take advantage. Anna Roggenbuck CEE Bankwatch Network
Greening the ENP, Ukraine Implemented by EPL in cooperation with WWF- EPO and Hbf.
EuropeAid 1 ACP-EU Water Facility 4th World Water Forum MEXICO March 2006 Mr Antonino Crea Head of Water and Sanitation Sector Infrastructure Unit.
The Sevilla process for supporting the implementation of the IPPC Directive Michael Parth Tallinn – Estonia 27 – 28 March 2008.
Implementing the Second Pillar of the Aarhus Convention: Problems Identified in the National Implementation Reports Magda Tóth Nagy, Senior Expert Geneva,
DIGITALIZATION & E-GOVERNMENT 14th November, 2013 Bulgarian Economic Forum Nikolay Nedyalkov, Executive Director Information Services Plc.
ENVI / LOCAL COMMUNITIES IN ENVIRONMENTAL ACTION.
WOMEN IN POLITICS: the situation in Bulgaria Slaveia Hristova Balkan Assist Association More Women in European Politics – More Women in 2014 First Steering.
Advocacy The practice of the European and the Hungarian Anti-Poverty Networks Kunbábony, 21 June 2011.
Project “Development of Transnational Network for Supporting Children and Families and for Deinstitutionalization of Child Care” EUROPEAN SOCIAL FUND 2007.
The framework for much environmental regulatory legislation Dr Yvonne Scannell.
Implementation of IPPC and its application to sectors in different industrial scales – Experience of Czech Republic Jan Slavík, IPPC Unit - MoE of Czech.
Green Courts and Environmental Protection in Thailand: Perspectives on the Map Ta Phut Case SRISUWAN JANYA ( ทษ. บ., ศศ. บ., นบ., ศศ. ม., วท. ม., พปป.)
Ministry of Waters and Environmental Protection, ROMANIA 1 BERCEN 1 st Exchange program – November 2002 Croatia PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS IN COOPERATION.
MINIMUM CRITERIA Project Manager Marianne Lindström, Bulgaria SYKE, Expert Services, Environmental Management Division.
IPPC transposition and experience with its implementation in the Czech Republic ?? …!! AjPíPíSí ??
4 th Exchange Programme Cluj Napoca, October, 2005 REPUBLIC OF CROATIA Updates in the Transposition and Implementation of IPPC directive Updates.
1 Workshop on the Directive 96/61/EC concerning (IPPC) Integrated pollution prevention and control INFRA Public participation & access to environmental.
European Ombudsman The role of the European Ombudsman Presentation to the CEE Bankwatch conference on accountability mechanisms for environmental protection.
Gf A few points of the Hungarian Dissemination Strategy A few points of the Hungarian Dissemination Strategy Erzsébet Schmuck Hungary, Country Manager.
SEVESO II transposition and implementation – possible approaches and lessons learned from MS/NMS SEVESO II transposition and implementation – possible.
Enforcing Civil and Political Rights: Lessons from Europe Basak Cali and Anne Koch, The European Court of Human Rights Project, Department of Political.
Benchmarking and Indicators- Tools to help Strengthen Environment Institutions ECENA Workshop- March 2007 Karin Shepardson, World Bank.
FEAD ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2008 Future Challenges for the Waste Management Industry Paris, 19 September 2008.
Situation in the Kyrgyz Republic related to access of the public to environmental information in area of natural resources management and territory planning.
Strengths and weaknesses of the permitting system and enforcement process in RIEW – Veliko Turnovo Regional Inspectorate of Environment and Water - Veliko.
EU INITIATIVES ON MINING WASTE. Why an initiative on Mining Waste ? Key environmental issues: l Potential environmental risks during disposal m Safety.
The campaigning NGO for greater environmental and social justice, with a focus on forests and forest peoples rights in the policies and practices of the.
The European Network for Rural Development The Hungarian National Rural Network and their cooperation opportunities.
SEA in the Czech Republic Prague, 24 September 2008.
How to start with the implementation of IPPC Directive Czech Republic Czech Environmetal Inspectorate.
Zero Waste International Alliance, Naples, Italy 19 th February 2009 Zero Waste in Central and Eastern Europe? Where does EU money go? Ivaylo Hlebarov,
Common borders. Common Solutions. Grant Contract No , MIS-ETC 2674 MANAGE.EDU: Efficient Education Management Network for LLL in the Black.
CROATIA Country Report IPPC Directive: implementation, problems, constraints, open questions,… Anita Pokrovac Patekar, B. Sc. Pharm. Ministry of Environmental.
TISZA RIVER BASIN SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM (TRB-SDP) Challenge for Transboundary Cooperation Kálmán MORVAY & Péter VARGA PhD Tisza-Szamos Public.
Early public participation In Decision-Making Process Nana Aghlemashvili Chief Specialist of the Legal Department.
ECENA 4 th Exchange Programme Cluj Napoca, October, 2005 Ministry of Environment and Spatial Planning of Kosovo Mr. Muhamet Malsiu, Acting Head.
New approach in EU Accession Negotiations: Rule of Law Brussels, May 2013 Sandra Pernar Government of the Republic of Croatia Office for Cooperation.
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 5 – Public Procurement Bilateral screening:
Advocacy Activity of the Eastern Partnership Territorial Cooperation Support Programme November 5, 2014 Tbilisi, Georgia Lyubov Palyvoda, Advocacy Expert.
Western Balkans Climate Resilience Workshop, Vienna, 11 – 12 May 2016.
Lobbying the EU Institutions Building Natura 2000 in candidate countries and potential candidates: the role of civil society Brussels, 16 September 2010.
Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety, Germany Environment Agency (UBA), Germany Federal Agency for Nature Conservation.
Access to environmental justice in Spain: State of the art
INTEGRATED PERMITTING IPPC DIRECTIVE: BEST PRACTICE
Czech Republic Mining Association (Těžební unie)
OFFICE FOR THE PROTECTION OF COMPETITION
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW.
Public procurement oversight
DIRECTORATE GENERAL FOR INTERNAL POLICIES
Cohesion Policy and Biodiversity
Presentation transcript:

Gold mining cyanide attempts in Bulgaria “Water protection – endangering activities” Conference – Budapest,

Projects background Canadian Dundee Precious Metals (DPM) with his Bulgarian company “Chelopech mining” at Chelopech gold and copper mine Bulgarian company “Gorubso” at Kurdjali Bulgarian company KCM, Plovdiv Other attempts for cyanide leaching like village Popinci, Krumovgrad 37 proven, economically viable deposits of gold and several old tailings dam from copper mines

violations of the Bulgarian Environmental Act and other relevant legislation underestimation of the potential risks and low quality of the EIA’s pro forma public consultations contradiction and non-compliance of the EU directives Main problematic issues (apart from the cyanide use as such)

Contribution of the “responsible” state authorities to these problems choosing the scope of the public consultations incl. the administrative division issue issuing an EIA permit for an already built illegal cyanide leaching installation total rejection of any attempt of the civil society to influence the cyanide projects deliberate elimination of the civil society from discussions and legislative initiatives

Cyanide Free Bulgaria coalition non-formal body from around 10 environmental NGO’s, mining NGO’s and local communities since 2005 (the first investment proposal for cyanide leaching)

What we have done… Statements and participation at the EIA and IPPC procedures Protests against the lack of reaction to our statements and the low quality of the EIA’s Communication with the relevant governmental bodies – European and national

What we have done… Subscriptions and petitions Court cases Legislative proposal for cyanide ban Media work Work with the relevant financing institutions like EBRD

Achievements local resistance to the cyanide technology public intolerance to the cyanide technology alerts to the financing institutions, EP and EC growing media coverage of our position

Achievements DPM positive EIA cancelled by the Supreme Administrative Court – the company has gave up the cyanide technology at Chelopech and Krumovgrad initial attempts at Popinci and Chepelare stopped by a strong local resistance provoked increase of the numbers and the amounts of the penalties

Lessons learned A very low quality EIA report has been granted with positive decision Number of violations of the Bulgarian and EU legislation hasn’t been “noticed” by the Company and State experts The public interest has been neglected by the “responsible” national authorities The cyanide leaching technology is NOT a BAT !!!

Daniel Popov Centre for Environmental Information and Education National coordinator of CEE Bankwatch network Thank you for the attention!