Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

8621 Georgia Avenue Silver Spring, MD

Advertisements

Riverview Heights Darren K. Howard Structural Option Architectural Engineering Spring Thesis 2005 Advisor: Dr. Ali Memari.

1 Sikandar Iqbal Graduate Trainee Engineer Civil Engineering Township Comparison & Analysis of Township Buildings.

Michael Hopper – Structural Option AE Senior Thesis 2009 John Jay College Expansion Project New York, NY The John Jay College Expansion Project New York,

Residence Inn by Marriott Stamford, Connecticut David Walenga -Structural Option AE Senior Thesis – April 14, 2004.

Wilkes-Barre/Scranton International Airport Avoca, PA Adam G. Weis Construction Management Option 2006 Senior Thesis Presentation.

Carl Hubben – Structural Option Ae senior thesis Office Building-G EASTERN UNITED STATES.

Final Report Terminal X McCarran International Airport.

Penn State Hershey Medical Center Children’s Hospital Hershey, Pennsylvania Matthew Vandersall Structural Option AE Senior Thesis Dr. Richard Behr.

The University Sciences Building Northeast, USA Final Presentation Chris Dunlay Structural Option Dr. Boothby.

OVERLOOK TOWERS AT DULLES CORNER HERNDON, VIRGINIA Anthony Perrotta AE Senior Thesis – Structural Option.

C AMPUS S QUARE H ARRISBURG, P ENNSYLVANIA A NDREW M ARTIN | C ONSTRUCTION M ANAGEMENT | A PRIL 12, 2010.

Daniel Bellay Lancaster County Bible Church Structural Option Lancaster County Bible Church.

Courtesy of Holbert Apple Associates Georgia Avenue Building Introduction Statistics Gravity System Lateral System Problem Statement & Solution.

Samuel M. P. Jannotti Structural April 14, 2008 American Eagle Outfitters Quantum III: South Side Works.

AE SENIOR THESIS APRIL 14 th, 2014 CHRIS DUARTE – STRUCTURAL Dr. THOMAS BOOTHBY ORCHARD PLAZA.

George Read Hall The University of Delaware

Reading Structural Drawings

Hershey Research Park Building One Jonathan Krepps Structural Option Senior Thesis 2013 Faculty Advisor: Dr. Hanagan.

Kenneth G. Langone Athletic and Recreation Center Kyle Oberdorf Structural Option Thesis April 2007.

Senior Thesis Structural Option Ryan Friis Spring Morgan St. Chicago, IL 111 Morgan St. Chicago, IL Ryan Friis Structural Option.

All Hakuna Resort photos in courtesy of LMN Development LLC Young Jeon Structural Option Advisor: Heather Sustersic Hakuna Resort AE Senior Thesis 2015.

GARY NEWMAN STRUCTURES OPTION ADVISOR: DR. HANAGAN SENIOR THESIS PRESENTATION SPRING 2008.

First Baptist Church of Doylestown Senior Thesis Structural Emphasis James Chester Preliminary Phase II Design.

AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS Quantum II Corporate Headquarters Michael Sandretto Spring – 2007 Structural Option.

BRYAN DARRIN SENIOR THESIS PRESENTATION MILLENNIUM HALL DREXEL CAMPUS PHILADELPHIA, PA.

Final Thesis Presentation Washingtonian Center Lee ResslerApril 15, 2008 Faculty Advisor: Dr. Memari.

Duquesne University Forbes Expansion

SEAN BEVILLE STRUCTURAL OPTION ADVISOR: PROF. BOOTHBY APRIL 13, 2009 TEMECULA MEDICAL CENTER “STRUCTURAL SYSTEM OPTIMIZATION” THE DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTURAL.

Gateway Plaza Wilmington, DE Elizabeth Hostutler Structural Option.

Caitlin Ferrell Structural Option Senior Thesis Presentation Spring 2006 The Erie Convention Center and Sheraton Hotel Erie, Pennsylvania Architectural.

1.  S.T.E.P.S.: Science, Technology, Environment, and Policy Building  Education, laboratory, and research  Owner: Lehigh University  Location: Bethlehem,

Helios Plaza Houston, TX Advisor - Dr. Hanagan Kevin Zinsmeister Structural Option.

Seth M. Moyer Office Buildin g Sayre, PA Structural OptionAdvisor: Dr. Thomas E. Boothby.

The Towers at the City College of New York Robin Scaramastro - Structural Option - Advisor: Dr. Memari Senior Thesis Final Presentation – Spring 2007.

Traci Peterson Structural Option Senior Thesis Presentation The Del Monte Center at The North Shore The Pennsylvania State University Department of Architectural.

Whiteland Village Mary Longenecker Structural Option Senior Thesis August 7, 2007.

Welcome to Daniel Painter’s Architectural Engineering Senior Thesis Presentation of Two Freedom Square April 16, 2003 Pennsylvania State University.

Rensselaer, NY Meral Kanik Structural Option Advisor: A.M. Memari April 14, 2008.

T IMOTHY H P ARK – S TRUCTURAL O PTION. Building Summary Current Systems Proposal Description Gravity Lateral Other Structural Factors Breadth Options.

Adam Love Structural Senior Thesis Presentation 2010 The Pennsylvania State University FDA OC/ORA Office Building Silver Spring, MD.

Brad Oliver – Structural Option Advisor – Professor Memari.

Oklahoma University Children’s Medical Office Building Oklahoma City, Oklahoma AE Senior Thesis Final Report April 14, 2014 Jonathan Ebersole Structural.

Fordham Place Bronx, NY Aric Heffelfinger Structural Option Spring 2006.

Justin Purcell Structural Option Advisor: Dr. Hanagan.

151 First Side William J. Buchko introduction overview proposal structural depth acoustics breadth cm breadth conclusions 151 First Side Pittsburgh, PA.

Introduction 120,000 SF 10 Stories (90ft) $40 Million Aug – Dec.2011 Presentation Outline Introduction Base Steel Redesign Progressive Collapse Tie.

Park Potomac Office Building “E” Kyle Wagner l Structural Option AE Senior Thesis l Spring 2010 Faculty Consultant l Prof. Kevin Parfitt.

Eastern USA University Academic Center Alexander AltemoseIStructural Option.

SteelStacks Performing Arts Center Sarah Bednarcik | Structural BAE/MAE Faculty Advisors: Dr. Linda Hanagan & Dr. Ali Memari Spring Thesis 2013Bethlehem,

200 Minuteman Drive New Design for Additional Floors and Vibration Sensitive Equipment Brent Ellmann Structural Option Dr. Linda Hanagan - Consultant.

Michael A. Troxell Structural Option Senior Thesis 2006 The College of Business Administration Northern Arizona University Flagstaff, Arizona.

Biobehavioral Health Building The Pennsylvania State University Daniel Bodde Structural Option Advisor – Heather Sustersic.

THE NORTHBROOK CORPORATE CENTER Redesign of the Lateral Load Resisting System.

John Pillar Hampton Inn & Suites National Harbor, Md Advisor: Dr. Memari Distinguished Speaker Series, Spring 2007.

William W. Wilkins Professional Building Columbus, Ohio Michelle Benoit Senior Thesis Presentation Spring 2007 Structural Option.

Hunter Woron Spring 2012 Structural Professor Parfitt.

ECMC Skilled Nursing Facility - Buffalo, NY - Brian Brunnet Structural Option AE 482 – Senior Thesis Dr. Ali Memari.

CBD Chemical Production Building Virginia, USA Christina DiPaolo │ Structural Option.

R. Bryan Peiffer– Structural Option AE Senior Thesis 2011 Three PNC Plaza, Pittsburgh Pa.

Mountain State Blue Cross Blue Shield Headquarters

Pearl Condominiums Philadelphia, PA

Introduction James W. & Frances G. McGlothlin Medical Education Center

Acterna Headquarters John M Sekel, EIT Germantown, Maryland

Outline Introduction Structural Redesign Gravity System

JAKE POLLACK NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY STRUCTURAL OPTION

Justin Pennycoff AE Senior Thesis 2008 Construction Management

Rutgers University Law School Building Addition and Renovation Nathan E. Reynolds Advisor: M. Kevin Parfitt Structural Option The Pennsylvania State.

North Shore at Canton The Pennsylvania State University

Mitre III Building McLean VA Debra Schroeder Structural Option.

Presentation transcript:

Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Presentation Order Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Project Info Depth Topic I Lateral Force Resisting System Breadth - CM Evaluation Depth Topic II Foundations Breadth - CM Evaluation Depth Topic III Long Span Options Breadth - Architectural Impact Breadth - Mechanical Impact Conclusions & Recommendations Questions Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Project Info Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006 (

Project Info Building Statistics 3 Stories + Partial Basement 102,000 ft 2 Building Uses Construction Team Einhorn Yaffee Prescott Architecture & Engineering P.C. Turner Construction Construction Schedule November 2005 – June 2007 Total Project Cost Approx. $40 Million Structural Systems Superstructure Foundations Lateral Force Resisting System Vierendeel Truss Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Depth Topic I – Lateral Force Resisting System Existing System 10 Steel Braced Frames Analysis Methods 2-D Models: SAP2000 Equivalent Lateral Force Method: ASCE7-02 Frame Forces: MS Excel Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Depth Topic I – Lateral Force Resisting System Existing System Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Depth Topic 1 – Lateral Force Resisting System New Streamlined System Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Depth Topic I – Lateral Force Resisting System New Streamlined System 6 Steel Braced Frames Streamlined System Evaluation System Strength Capacity Total Drift Limit: L/400 Raw Material Quantities & Cost Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Breadth Topic – CM Evaluation Lateral Force Resisting Systems Raw MaterialsConstruction Cost Structural Steel Savings: 7.7 tons Weld Material Savings: 43.1 lbs Cost Savings: $18,000 Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Depth Topic II – Foundations Existing System - Shallow Spread Footings Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Depth Topic II – Foundations Subsurface Conditions Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Depth Topic II – Foundations Subsurface Conditions Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Depth Topic II – Foundations New System - Drilled Concrete Piers Design Procedure: Principles of Foundation Engineering, 5 th Ed. New System Evaluation: Cost & Raw Material Quantities Foundation Loads: 1.2D + 1.0E + 0.5L + 0.2S Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Breadth Topic – CM Evaluation Foundation Systems Raw Material Quantities Existing SystemNew System Concrete Savings: 400 yd 3 Steel Rebar Savings: 55.5 ft 3 Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Breadth Topic – CM Evaluation Existing SystemNew System Additional Cost: $162,000 Foundation Systems Construction Costs – R.S. Means 2006 Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Depth Topic III – Long Span Options Existing System – Vierendeel Truss Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Depth Topic III – Long Span Options New System – Long Span Steel Joists System Design RAM Structural System New Columbia Joist Catalog New System Evaluation Architectural Impact Mechanical Impact – HVAC Ducts Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Breadth Topic – Architectural Impact Vierendeel Truss System Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Breadth Topic – Architectural Impact Long Span Steel Joists Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Breadth Topic – Mechanical Impact HVAC Duct Sizes Partial HVAC Ductwork Plans First Floor Second Floor Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Conclusions & Recommendations The lateral force resisting system can be safely reduced from 10 frames to 6 frames for a estimated savings of $18,000. A drilled pier foundation system is not a cost efficient replacement for the spread footing system. The Vierendeel truss is extremely effective and efficient for carrying significant loads over a large span. Ann & Richard Barshinger Life Science & Philosophy Building Franklin & Marshall College – Lancaster, PA Michael A. Hebert Structural Option Spring 2006

Questions???

Thank You

Welded Brace Connections Existing System New System