S ETTING THE R ULES FOR N ATIVE G AMING The Political Frame By Shalin Hai-Jew 1 Native Gaming: The Political Frame.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Association on American Indian Affairs The Federal Trust Relationship, Tribal Sovereignty, and Self-Determination Prepared by Jack F. Trope, Executive.
Advertisements

Michigan Supreme Court Controversies and Cases: The Indigenous Peoples of Michigan.
Chapter 2: Indian Peoples are Nations, not Minorities Soc 338.
Native Americans and the Denial of Treaty Rights Political Science 61 / Chicano/Latino Studies 64 October 16, 2007.
Social Studies Chapter 4 California’s Indians Today By Mr. Mallory.
Ways We (The MOWA Choctaw Indians of Alabama) Have Exercised Our Tribal Sovereignty Chief Framon Weaver.
HEALTH CARE AND TRUST RESPONSIBILITY. FOUNDED IN HISTORY From colonial times to present, Tribes have been recognized as sovereign governments, with a.
Indian Gaming in Montana One step to opening the door to new opportunities for the First Montanans.
Hashimoto: Casino Management: A Strategic Approach © 2008 Pearson Education, Upper Saddle River, NJ All Rights Reserved. Hashimoto: Casino Management:
Part 3: Selecting the Colors Historical, Legal and Political Perspectives.
©2001 West Legal Studies in Business. All Rights Reserved. 1 Chapter 1: Business and Its Legal Environment.
American Indian Political Activism Political Activism in the 60s and 70s Treaty Rights in Wisconsin Indian Gaming (Casinos, etc.)
The National Indian Gaming Commission From Legal Bingo to Illegal Class II / III Casinos by Misusing the IGRA.
Basic notions and sources of law
The Supreme Court/ The Supreme Court at Work
Weijian, Ienash, Nick. Native Americans in the United States are on Indigenous peoples from the regions of North America, including continental Untied.
Chapter 5 Vocabulary.
I NDIAN G AMING IN THE US A Broad Introduction (Preface to the Triptych Case Studies) By Shalin Hai-Jew 1 Indian Gaming in the US.
History of Constitutional Law in Canada
Gaming and Gambling (L32) Dr. Anton Treuer Bemidji State University.
S MALLPOX OR N EW B UFFALO What’s the Right Analogy for Indian Gaming? By Shalin Hai-Jew 1 Smallpox or New Buffalo?
The Political Influence of Indian Gaming
A LL IN ? E CONOMIC F ACTORS TO C ONSIDER IN N ATIVE A MERICAN G AMING By Shalin Hai-Jew 1 Native Gaming: The Economics Frame.
ARE 309Ted Feitshans04-1 ARE 309 Unit 2 Sources of Law Constitutional government –Highest source of law Federal government North Carolina government –Relationship.
I. Principles of the Constitution A. Popular Sovereignty – ‘authority of the people’, the people hold the final power in government 1. Indirect Rule due.
Structure and Principles
5 Basic principles of the u.s. constitution
Office of Indian Gaming 1849 C Street, NW MS 3657 MIB Washington, DC Troy Woodward Senior Policy Advisor 25 USC 2710 (d)
An exploration of the Judicial, Legislative, and Executive Branches By: Lauren Zecca.
Articles of Confederation Philadelphia Because the Articles of Confederation were weak, delegates from 12/13 states met in Philadelphia in 1787 to revise.
By Stephanie Cran. In the 1820s and 1830s, Georgia conducted a relentless campaign to remove Cherokees who held territory within the boundaries of Georgia,
LAW AND POLITICS The aim of this tutorial is to help you learn to identify and evaluate the foundations of the American legal and political system.
The Constitution Organization, Foundations and The Bill of Rights.
Chapters 1and 2 Thinking about Politics and the American Creed.
THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION AND FEDERALISM UNIT 3.
The Principles of the United States Constitution.
LEARNING OBJECTIVES/ GOALS/ SWBAT
Chapter 1: Ethics and Law. Four Sources of Law 1. Constitutional Law 2. Statutory Law 3. Case Law 4. Administrative Law * English Common Law.
Chapter 5.  It creates the three branches of government  Executive  Legislative  Judicial  It allocates powers to these branches  It protects individual.
T HE P OLITICAL F RAME D ISCUSSION Q UESTIONS Shalin Hai-Jew 1 Native Gaming: The Political Frame Discussion Questions.
Treaties. Pre-European Contact Facts Scientists believe these people first migrated to the Americas more than 10,000 years ago, before the end of the.
Key Control Consequences of not Returning Keys: Automatic STEP 3 offense Moved to non-key carrying position Gaming License suspension Possible Termination.
Chapter 3: The Constitution Section 3. Copyright © Pearson Education, Inc.Slide 2 Chapter 3, Section 3 Objectives 1.Identify how basic legislation has.
FEDERALISM: DIVIDING THE POWER Chapter 4 Section 1.
THE SOCIAL-CULTURAL FRAME DISCUSSION QUESTIONS By Shalin Hai-Jew 1 The Social Cultural Frame Discussion Questions.
APUSH Themes Identity Work, exchange, and technology Peopling
The Paralegal Professional Part II: Introduction to Law Chapter Five American Legal Heritage & Constitutional Law.
We The People… Learning about the three branches of our National Government.
The Supreme Court. The Supreme Court stands at the top of the American legal system. Article III of the Constitution created the Supreme Court as one.
2 pt 3 pt 4 pt 5pt 1 pt 2 pt 3 pt 4 pt 5 pt 1 pt 2pt 3 pt 4pt 5 pt 1pt 2pt 3 pt 4 pt 5 pt 1 pt 2 pt 3 pt 4pt 5 pt 1pt Civics I Civics IICivics III Civics.
An Evolving Profile of Indian Americans Since 1860 when American Indians were counted in census, discrepancies were apparent – in 1900 U.S. census stated.
PRESENTATION REGARDING CALIFORNIA TRIBES AND LYTTON RANCHERIA FEE-TO-TRUST FOR TOWN OF WINDSOR by Nancy Thorington August 25, 2015.
Federalism is a system of government in which a written constitution divides the powers of government on a territorial basis between a central, or national,
The Constitution By Mr. Hunt. Structure and Principles Article I Creates Congress Legislative Branch Describes the two Houses How to make laws.
Seven Fascinating Court Decisions Affecting Indians and Tribes
5 Basic principles of the u.s. constitution
Regulations put upon gambling state and nation wide.
ARE 309 Unit 2 Sources of Law Constitutional government
Canada’s Recognition and Implementation of Indigenous Rights Framework
Was this legal? Was this OK?
Was this legal? Was this OK?
The Principles of the United States Constitution
Jurisdictional Relationships
Jurisdictional Relationships
Was this legal? Was this OK?
Principles of Government
Confederated Tribes of Grand Ronde Government
The Principles of the United States Constitution
Indian Gaming fun and games?.
Rights of Indigenous Peoples Under International Law
Presentation transcript:

S ETTING THE R ULES FOR N ATIVE G AMING The Political Frame By Shalin Hai-Jew 1 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

A BSTRACT : The political frame uses a legal, policy and procedure focus to approach the regulation of Indian gaming. With relevant external laws and internal tribal ones, this political frame asks readers to consider important tribal leadership structures and policies to support effective Indian gaming. 2 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

L EARNING O UTCOMES Understand the long-term view of where Indian gaming may be headed Consider the possibilities of global Indian gaming Explore the principles of sovereignty and land use in Native gaming Understand some of the legal issues at play with Indian gaming (restrictions, land use, etc.) 3 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

L EARNING O UTCOMES ( CONT.) Explore the tribal decision-making process in starting and maintaining casinos See the need for the “engineering of consent” with the larger population through lobbying and surveying; understand the lobbying efforts of the Native American gaming lobby Understand the three classes of gaming (Class I, Class II, and Class III). 4 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

L EARNING O UTCOMES ( CONT.) Describe leadership structures on reservations in terms of tribal governance; understand how these structures may have evolved with the advent of tribal gaming Understand the principle-based rationales by the various stakeholders in Indian gaming. Project where governance issues re: Indian gaming may go in the future 5 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

L EARNING O UTCOMES ( CONT.) Understand the litigation issues around Native American gaming Describe some policy needs and changes once casinos open. 6 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

N ATIVE A MERICAN S OVEREIGNTY “Tribes’ ability to govern their members and territories stems from their inherent powers as pre-constitutional sovereign nations. As the original inhabitants of North America, indigenous peoples governed themselves without external influence. The federal government’s establishment of a legal relationship with the tribes meant that they continued to exercise extra- constitutional authority over their members. This authority translated into the right of self-governance. Under the doctrine of reserved rights, tribes maintain rights they have not specifically ceded to the federal government through treaty or agreement. Because it implies such broad powers, ‘the right of self-government may be (tribes’) most valuable reserved right’” (Light and Rand, 2005, p. 19). 7 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

I NDIAN G AMING R EGULATORY A CT (IGRA) The Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA). In 1988, the Supreme Court passed the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA, or Public Law ) in response to a court case California v. Cabazon and Morongo Bands of Mission Indians. This ruling was widely seen then as the preemption of state law by the federal government’s interest in tribal self-sufficiency and economic development. 8 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

E XPENSIVE B IDS FOR F EDERAL R ECOGNITION Documentation by lawyers, anthropologists, linguists, and others 9 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

C HANGE IN N ATIONAL C ULTURE TOWARDS G AMING “benign prohibition” by the federal government limited allowances through IGRA 10 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

T HREE C LASSES OF G AMBLING : C LASS 1 Class I “Traditional”: Includes social games played for low-value prizes and traditional forms of tribal gaming associated with native American ceremonies (exclusive tribal jurisdiction and not subject to IGRA requirements) 11 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

T HREE C LASSES OF G AMBLING : C LASS 2 Class II “Bingo”: Includes bingo and other games similar to bingo, such as lotto, pull-tabs, and punch boards, if played in the same location as bingo, and non-banked card games (within tribal jurisdiction but with NIGC oversight, subject to IGRA requirements) 12 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

T HREE C LASSES OF G AMBLING : C LASS 3 Class III “Casino-Style”: Includes all games not within either Class 1 or Class II, such as slot machines, banked card games, and casino games (within tribal and state jurisdiction, with NIGC oversight and negotiated tribal-state compact / agreement, subject to IGRA requirements) 13 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

U NIQUE C HALLENGES FOR T RIBAL L EADERSHIP Stable institutions and policies Fair and effective dispute resolution Separation of politics from business management A competent bureaucracy Cultural “match” (Cornell and Kalt, n.d., Sovereignty and nation building…, p. 12) 14 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

R OLE P LAYING Scenario: The scenario is Washington, DC. A tribal lobbying group is meeting before the Senate or the House that is considering a bill to rollback (or greatly restrict / redefine legal) Native gaming. The lobbyists need to present their various arguments:  Historical  Legal (principle and case precedence)  Economic  Policy, and others. 15 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

R OLES AND S TANCES Have learners choose various roles. Have them research what an individual or group in their role may think, and have them argue a coherent stand. Allow room for changes and shifts in ideas if particular aims are met. Have them keep the aims private generally unless they feel it’s strategically helpful to share that with the group. See what sort of final agreement the various individuals may come to. 16 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

R OLES Identify which groups (without stereotyping) may fit into the anti-Indian gaming lobby. Identify which groups (without stereotyping) may fit into the pro- Indian gaming lobby. Anti-Indian Gaming Lobby: Pro-Indian Gaming Lobby: 17 Native Gaming: The Political Frame

C ONCLUSION 18 Native Gaming: The Political Frame