 starter activity Each picture refers to a different model of representation. Can you guess which one? Choose 2 models you think are best and be prepared.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Voting Systems Explained
Advertisements

Electoral systems used in the UK
Electoral Systems Women and Elections
Pros and Cons of the Additional Member System (AMS)
“The Additional Member System provides greater choice and is more responsive to the will of the electorate than First-Past-The- Post.” Discuss 15 marks.
UK electoral systems Fotolia.
The case for and against PR FPTP or PR?. Possible criteria for a new system Ease of voting Does each vote have an equal weight? High level of proportionality.
Electoral Systems - Proportional Representation
STAGE ONE: Begins in the Scottish Parliament STAGE TWO: Moved to the committee STAGE THREE: Back in parliament.
 starter activity Why do we have elections?  Do you think it’s possible to impose democratic voting systems on developing nations?
Alternative Electoral Systems Read and précis notes will be checked before this Lecture is delivered … 1.
Alternatives to FPTP DO NOW Read through the extract about the first-past-the-post voting system and bullet point answers to both the 5 and 10 mark questions.
Elections, Electoral Reform, and 2010 The Purpose of Elections  They allow the ‘will of the people’ to be expressed  They provide for voter choice.
Section A: Political Issues in the UK Study Theme 1D: Electoral Systems, Voting and Political Attitudes. A selection of essays 5_AMS Essays.
Plurality/Majority System vs. Proportional Representation
 starter activity Why do you think the US have an electoral college system rather than direct elections?
Electoral Systems.
Elections and Electoral Systems
The role of elections in democracy The nature of representation
VOTING SYSTEMS IN THE UK and 2010 Election Results Comparison Election Results- Conservatives 306 seats (share of the vote, 36.1%) Labour.
The Additional Member System
 starter activity In 2011, in the 5th ever referendum in UK politics, the electorate voted against a reform to the voting system. Read the article and.
Objective Assess the reasons for the two-party system in the U.S., and decide whether there should be reforms fostering 3 rd parties. Assess various electoral.
Electoral systems: How much do we know? Organise yourselves into groups of no more than three. You will need to answer 20 questions on electoral systems.
Democracy- Lesson 2 Different types of voting systems.
What are its main advantages and disadvantages?
The role of elections in a democracy Do elections guarantee democracy? Unit 1.
Electoral Reform Students should read & précis Chapter 3 of ‘AS UK Govt & Politics’ by Garnett and Lynch.
The Single Transferable Vote electoral system provides for better representation than First Past the Post. Discuss.
The Mathematics of the General Election Dr Justin Greaves Department of Politics University of Warwick.
Political Parties AS Politics. Political Parties and the need for them What are political parties? What are political parties? Why are parties important.
Quick quiz How big was the Labour majority in 1997 & 2005? How big was the Labour majority in 1997 & 2005? What is the term to describe a large majority.
Electoral Reform in Britain The Jenkins Commission.
Electoral Reform AV referendum and PR Joy Johnson week 5.
 starter activity How successful has the Con-Dem coalition been? If you were to write a progress report, what would be the successes for each side? 
 Reformed number of seats from 785 to 736 MEPs  Britain returns 72 seats  Reformed system in 1998, implemented.
Other Voting Systems Although FPTP and AMS are used in British Parliamentary elections, there are other voting systems you should be aware of 1.Alternative.
AMS Additional Member System. Type of System AMS is a mix of both a proportional system and a majoritarian system. It is a hybrid (mixed) voting system.
Electoral Reform week 5 Will it mend a broken system? Joy Johnson.
First past the post. What is First past the post? FPTP is the voting system used for the election of MPs to 'seats' in the UK Parliament. It is a system.
Voting Systems – Scotland – Additional Member System (AMS)
Proportional Representation (Additional Member System) Arguments For & Against.
SA1: Living in a Democracy Electoral Systems. Proportional Representation Aims: Define Proportional Representation (PR) Examine different types of PR.
 starter activity How many different types of elections can you name? What voting system is used?  Does having variety help or hinder democracy?
M E B C A S N P F J O U W I G R H T L D Click to startClick for rules.
Electoral Systems and Reform How democratic is our democracy?
Objective State the implications and consequences that an electoral system can have on creating a two-party system or a multiparty system. Assess various.
Electoral Systems Answering an essay question. Types of questions Questions will focus on FPTP and systems of PR (AMS and/or STV) You will be asked to.
Voting in Scotland LI: To find out about different voting systems and their advantages and disadvantages.
Elections, Parties, and the Party System Malcomlson & Myers, Chapter 9 & 10 Elections & the Electoral System Elections, Parties, & Representation Canada’s.
Part Three (continued): Electoral Systems & Linkage Institutions “Our political institutions work remarkably well. They are designed to clang against each.
AS Government and Politics REVISION Paper 1 ELECTIONS.
Timings 5 mark- 5 minutes 10 mark- 10 minutes 25 marks- 25 minutes START: 9 END: 9.45.
Arguments FOR and AGAINST AMS
First Past the Post the true title of the system is ‘plurality within single-member constituencies’, and the term ‘first past the post’ really refers.
CFE Democracy First Past the Post
Key Features of FPTP.
Additional Member System
Lesson 4: The Single Transferable Vote (STV)
Voting Systems in the UK –
Proportional Representation
Additional Member System
Higher Modern Studies Essay Prep
Voting Systems in the UK –

Over the next several periods we will…
Elections and Electoral Systems
Lesson Starter Explain, in two sentences or less, the difference between PLURALITY electoral systems and PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION electoral systems.
Voting Systems in the UK –
Over the next several periods we will…
Presentation transcript:

 starter activity Each picture refers to a different model of representation. Can you guess which one? Choose 2 models you think are best and be prepared to explain your answer with evidence.

 starter activity Each picture refers to a different model of representation. Can you guess which one? Choose 2 models you think are best and be prepared to explain your answer with evidence. Trustee - Burke Party – mandate from manifesto Constituency – Go FSG! Delegate –e.g. ambassadors Descriptive /Functional

What electoral systems are used in the UK? TBAT explain 4 main electoral systems & key features of FPTP  Learning objectives  Key words: district magnitude majoritarian plurality PR mixed

 Your task Read Bennet, p and take notes on the 4 main electoral systems: Read Bennet, p and take notes on the 4 main electoral systems: Majoritarian Majoritarian Plurality Plurality Proportional Representation Proportional Representation Mixed Mixed  In a different colour begin to note down the problems with each system  In a different colour begin to note down the problems with each system

Electoral systems Majoritarian – absolute majority, e.g. London Mayor Majoritarian – absolute majority, e.g. London Mayor Plurality – e.g. FPTP Plurality – e.g. FPTP PR – seats in proportion to result, e.g. European elections PR – seats in proportion to result, e.g. European elections Mixed – elements of some/all above, e.g. AMS Mixed – elements of some/all above, e.g. AMS  Problems with these voting systems?

 Your task Read about FPTP in Bennett, p and complete the spider diagram chart your teacher provides. Read about FPTP in Bennett, p and complete the spider diagram chart your teacher provides.  With all its faults why do you think 68% of the electorate vote against electoral reform in the 2011 referendum on AV?  With all its faults why do you think 68% of the electorate vote against electoral reform in the 2011 referendum on AV?

Key characteristics Plurality system Plurality system Used for local & general elections Used for local & general elections 650 constituencies 650 constituencies Roughly 70,000 constituents Roughly 70,000 constituents

Two-party system Favours 2 main parties (Lab & Cons) Favours 2 main parties (Lab & Cons) Smaller parties disadvantaged, e.g. in 2010 Lib Dems won 57 seats with 23% whilst Lab won 258 seats with 29% Smaller parties disadvantaged, e.g. in 2010 Lib Dems won 57 seats with 23% whilst Lab won 258 seats with 29%

Winner’s bonus Landslide effect, e.g. Cons (1983 & 1987) & Lab (1997 & 2001) – 2001 Lab won 40% of vote but 413 of seats in Parliament Landslide effect, e.g. Cons (1983 & 1987) & Lab (1997 & 2001) – 2001 Lab won 40% of vote but 413 of seats in Parliament

Bias to Labour Differences in sizes of constituencies – Lab constituencies have fewer voters, so need smaller margin to win Differences in sizes of constituencies – Lab constituencies have fewer voters, so need smaller margin to win Differential turnout – turnout is lower in Lab seats, so fewer votes are cast for Lab Differential turnout – turnout is lower in Lab seats, so fewer votes are cast for Lab Tactical voting – anti-Conservative tactical voting is more common than anti-Labour Tactical voting – anti-Conservative tactical voting is more common than anti-Labour

Discrimination against smaller parties No rewards for coming second No rewards for coming second Votes are spread thinly across the country Votes are spread thinly across the country

Single Party Government Working majorities Working majorities Coalitions rare Coalitions rare 1974 Lab minority govt 1974 Lab minority govt 2010 Con-Dem Coalition 1 st since National Government of WWII 2010 Con-Dem Coalition 1 st since National Government of WWII

 Your task Read p and in your own words summarise the key advantages and disadvantages of FPTP as a ‘scales chart’ Read p and in your own words summarise the key advantages and disadvantages of FPTP as a ‘scales chart’  Lord Hailsham once said FPTP created an ‘elective dictatorship” Explain what he meant and whether you agree.  Lord Hailsham once said FPTP created an ‘elective dictatorship” Explain what he meant and whether you agree. Qintin Hogg, Lord Hailsham

This house believes that FPTP is unfair and needs to be abandoned in UK elections

 Homework Read the article on FPTP from Politics Review and answer the exam focus questions Read the article on FPTP from Politics Review and answer the exam focus questions Visit the BBC website and note down the reasons for the vote against AV in 2011 (use the film clips & links as well) Visit the BBC website and note down the reasons for the vote against AV in 2011 (use the film clips & links as well)

What electoral systems are used in the UK? TBAT explain 4 main electoral systems & key features of FPTP  Learning objectives  Key words: district magnitude majoritarian plurality PR mixed