Entrainment Technologies › Audio Entrainment › Audio-Visual Entrainment Questions Heart Rate Variability Biofeedback › Live Demonstration › Questions
Using auditory signals to influence brainwaves “relaxation” CD’s 2 (or more) parts › Frequency tones › Masking music
Presentation of a sound (click) Brain responds in consistent way If sounds are evenly spaced Can induce specific frequency
Isochronic Tones › Evenly spaced tones › Turn on and off quickly › Produce strong evoked response › Psychologically appealing › Tone frequency entrains brainwaves “Frequency following response”
2 different tones at slightly different pitches into separate ears Brain subtracts difference and perceives as sound within head “phantom sound”
Binaural is unlikely to produce significant BWE, but can by hypnotic and relaxing Isochronic tones are strongly entraining
Mixed-Bag Audio used binaural rather than isochronic Small sample size Varied frequencies (3 hz vs. 10 hz) Single Session studies See Huang, T. & Charyton, C. (2008). A comprehensive review of the psychological effects of brainwave entrainment. Alternative Therapies Sep/Oct, Vol. 14, No. 5.
Randomized, double-blind 104 patients undergoing general anesthesia for surgery When listening to music CD with binaural beats, anxiety decreased by 26.3% (p=.001) compared to control Patients that listened to CD without BB, anxiety decreased by 11% (p=.15) Control group (TV or read), anxiety decreased 3.8%
Easily available › downloadable Cost effective › Costs generally range from free to $20 Portable › iPod › Smart phone Applications › Test preparation › Sleep
Internet search › “relaxation CD’s using isochronic tones” › Hemi-sync.com › Eoinstitute.org › Musicmefree.com Phone apps › Brainwave Tuner › Brain Booster
Light and Sound Stimulation Glasses flash lights at specific frequency Tones in headphones at same frequency Brain waves match these frequencies › Entrainment › Increases or decreases nervous system arousal.
Audio Visual Entrainment
Eyes-closed 18.5 hz photic entrainment › Increased 18.5 hz EEG by 49% Eyes-open 18.5 hz auditory entrainment › Increased 18.5 hz EEG by 27% Eyes-closed 18.5 hz auditory entrainment › Increased 18.5 hz EEG by 21% Frederick, Lubar, Rasey, Brim, & Blackburn (1999). Effects of 18.5 Hz Audiovisual Stimulation on EEG Amplitude at the Vertex. Proceedings AAPB Thirteenth Anniversary Annual Meeting,
Gently turn off mental chatter › Stimulus overload leading to mental “confusion” › Possibly hypnotic induction › The brain “let’s go” Apply BWE later in session
Beta (14-30)-stimulating, good for ADHD Alpha (8-13)-use first, best entrainment, good for deep relaxation Theta (4-7)-forming new habits, repressed memories, sleep Delta (1-3)-going to bed Dual Stimulation-left/right hemisphere Ganzfeld Stimulation-passive, non- entraining, repetitive
NFB and AVE to increase alpha and decrease high beta for anxiety
Adult Woman, Excessive Worry, Strong Emotional Reactions
Relaxation Training ADHD and Learning Depression Anxiety Autism Spectrum Disorders Seasonal Affective Disorder TMJ Chronic Pain/Fibromyalgia
Comprehensive Review of Research: Consistent, positive findings: › Verbal Skills › Attention › Memory › Stress/Anxiety › Pain › Behavior (in children)
113 college students 4 groups: worry exposure, expressive writing, AVE, control Each practiced 3x/week Worry exposure and AVE showed significant improvements in all measures compared to other groups AVE had best follow-through
The process of measuring and displaying physiological processes with the goal of increased awareness and control. › Increased awareness of physiological processes › Voluntary control over body and mind
Muscle activity (EMG) Skin Temperature Electrodermal Activity (GSR, SCR) Respiration/Capnometry Heart Rate Variability Blood Pressure Brain Electrical Activity (EEG) Brain Blood Flow (HEG)
HRV = heart rate changes with every heartbeat. HRV should not be confused with heart rate HRV is associated with autonomic nervous system functioning › Balance between SNS and PNS = High HRV › Sympathetic activation = Low HRV
HRV is an important indicator of both physiological resiliency and behavioral flexibility. Low HRV is associated as an independent predictor of future health problems. HRV can be thought of as a general measure of adaptability › Diminished HRV a sign of vulnerability to stress
5-8 breaths per minute for balanced nervous system Paced diaphragmatic breathing restores synchrony between respiratory and cardiovascular systems (Gervitz, 1999) › 6 breaths per min seems ideal for synchrony Should feel comfortable and not forced Advanced: exhale longer than inhalation
Externally Paced › 6 breaths/minute › Coherence Coach › DoAsOne ( Phone Apps › BreathBiofeedback (Free) › Breath Pacer Lite (Free) › MyCalmBeat (Free) › DoAsOne (Free through iTunes)
Reduced anxiety immediately after 10 minute practice in college students (Tarrant, 2011) Reduced anxiety improved mood in highly anxious college students after 4 weeks (Henriques, et. al., 2011) 15 min. of RSA biofeedback resulted in significant shifts in brain functioning in areas associated with stress response (Sherlin, et. al., 2010)
Self-service Individual sessions Biofeedback Lab Classes (3-weeks) Embedded in existing classes For credit class (1 credit hour)
› (emWave)
Audio Programs › › › Audio Visual Entrainment › › HRV and RSA Biofeedback › › ›