Back to the Rough Ground Community participation and ethics guidance for HIV prevention trials Kathleen M. MacQueen, PhD, MPH Family Health Intenational.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Estyns New Common Inspection Framework Outcomes Provision Leadership.

Advertisements

US Office of Education K

Greater Involvement of People Living with HIV (GIPA)

The Role of Community Engagement in Translational Research

1 Questions on Ethical Responsibilities in STD Research in Resource-Limited Settings Personal Perspectives Salaam Semaan 1, DrPH and Kate MacQueen 2, PhD.

Stakeholder Engagement and Good Participatory Practices for Global Clinical Trials: Developing Tools and Models for the 21st Century Kathleen M. MacQueen,

National Prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission of HIV (PMTCT) Training Package Course Overview.

Setting the Stage for CBPR: Theories and Principles

Practicing Community-engaged Research Mary Anne McDonald, MA, Dr PH Duke Center for Community Research Duke Translational Medicine Institute Division of.

Good Participatory Practice (GPP) Guidelines for Biomedical HIV Prevention Trials Second Edition 2011.

Local Government & Community Participation

RTI International RTI International is a trade name of Research Triangle Institute. Stigma-Reduction Scale Up: It Can Be Done Building on Practice-Based.

Outcomes Participants will… Family-school connections and partnerships are important.

Institute for Health and Society Institute for Health and Society Improving Health and Advancing Health Equity Through Community and Academic Partnerships.

Spreading and Scaling Prevention and Treatment Approaches: Centers of Excellence Model Janet E. Farmer, PhD School of Health Professions University of.

INSTRUCTIONAL LEADERSHIP FOR DIVERSE LEARNERS Susan Brody Hasazi Katharine S. Furney National Institute of Leadership, Disability, and Students Placed.

Building the Foundations for Better Health Health Services Organization.

Community Level Models; Participatory Research and Challenges

Community Level Models; Participatory Research and Challenges Alexandra Varga H571.

Steve Delaronde, MSW, MPH University of Connecticut Health Center The Governor’s Prevention Initiative for Youth July 16, 1999 Identifying Community Resources.

EVOLVING PUBLIC HEALTH AND HEALTH CARE LANDSCAPE AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR CANCER COMMUNICATION NCI Health Communication and Informatics Research Branch CPCRN.

Understanding Community-Academic Partnerships

Outcomes of Public Health

Public Health Systems Research: What We Know and Need to Learn Glen P. Mays, PhD, MPH Department of Health Policy & Management UAMS College of Public Health.

HIV Prevention Trials Network Update Africa Regional Working Group 20 May 2003.

Community Based Coalitions, Collaborations and Partnership: Pointers for Strengthening, Describing, and Tracking Them Beth Baker, PhD and Amy Estlund,

Community Representation Structure. Site Coordinating Centers (SCC) Community Advisory Boards (CABs) Leadership Level Cross-Network Level Network Level.

Children, Young People and Families Early Intervention Fund Children’s Rights and Wellbeing Gita Sharkey Team Leader Rights and Participation Team.

Healthy Start A Collective Impact Model to Address Poor Birth Outcomes Charlotte M. Parent, RN, MHCM March 27 th, 2015 SACIM Meeting.

Introduction to Research Ethics Africa RWG Workshop 21 May 2003 Stella Kirkendale Wayne Wilson.

HPTN Future Directions January 22, 2003 Bethesda, MD.

Katharine Kripke, Ph.D. Assistant Director, Vaccine Research Program, Division of AIDS, NIAID AIDS Vaccine 2011 Journalist Training Program September 11,

National Health Services Planners Forum, Melbourne, Thursday 7 April 2011 Population health planning: prospects and possibilities Professor.

COMMUNITY CONSULTATION: LESSONS LEARNED IN HIV COMMUNITY-BASED RESEARCH Ronald P. Strauss, D.M.D., Ph.D. University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

Cross Cultural Health Care Conference Community Collaborations and Interventions: Models of Community Engagement October 8, 2011 Angela Sy, DrPH Assistant.

How to Enhance Private Sector Participation in Achieving Public Health Goals: What We Can Learn from India Suneeta Sharma, PhD, MHA August 26, 2010.

“Standard of Care” The term “Standard of care” refers to the nature of the prevention and/or care that will be provided to participants.

Why a CPCRN? CDC Expectations Katherine M. Wilson, PhD, MPH CPCRN Technical Monitor Division of Cancer Prevention and Control CDC.

New Tools New Visions W.K. Kellogg Foundation Grant Community Partners HBCU Partners.

1 PREVENTION RESEARCH ADVOCACY COMMUNITY PREPAREDNESS IN HIV PREVENTION TRIALS AND USE OF EXISTING METHODOLOGIES MDP 301 trial in Mwanza, Tanzania Charles.

TRUE PATIENT & PARTNER ENGAGEMENT HOW IS IT DONE?.

Report back from CWG Strategic Planning Strategic Planning Workshop February 2002 Janet Frohlich Steve Morin CWG International CWG US Co-Chair Co-chair.

Ryan White All Grantees Meeting Washington, DC November, 2012 Supporting National HIV/AIDS Strategies: the domestic experience and the AETCs.

HOW ARE MDP PREPARING COMMUNITIES AT TRIAL SITES? MDP301.

The Importance of a Strategic Plan to Eliminate Health Disparities 2008 eHealth Conference June 9, 2008 Yvonne T. Maddox, PhD Deputy Director Eunice Kennedy.

The HIV Vaccine Trials Network is supported through a cooperative agreement with the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. Social Media.

Presentation V A Discussion with School Boards: Raising the Graduation Rate, High School Improvement, and Policy Decisions.

Thorny Issues in HIV Vaccine Trials Saul Walker Policy Advisor IAVI.

Amy Alexander. Analyzing Effectiveness Participants’ Reactions Participants’ Learning Organization Support and Change Participants’ Use of New Knowledge.

Country and community preparedness: Community Involvement in Clinical Trials Global Campaign for Microbicides.

Primary Care Improvement Infrastructure: The Role of Practice Facilitation Michael L. Parchman, MD MPH MacColl Center for Health Care Innovation AHRQ Annual.

Bridging the Worlds of Science, Community and Policy Communicating HIV Prevention Research with Strategies and Tools to Convey Your Message, Manage Controversy.

HPTN Ethics Guidance for Research: Community Obligations Africa Regional Working Group Meeting, May 19-23, 2003 Lusaka, Zambia.

International Partnership for Microbicides Approach to HIV Treatment and Care in Future IPM Microbicide Trials Pam Norick, Chief of External Relations.

Rhode Island PK-16 Partnerships for Success Service-Learning Project May 2011 Prepared by Jill Glickman, Workshop Leader Rhode Island Campus Compact With.

INTRODUCING THE PSBA-GTO ACT FOR YOUTH CENTER OF EXCELLENCE IN CONSULTATION WITH HEALTHY TEEN NETWORK Planning for Evidence-Based Programming.

Patient and Community involvement in TB control – Approaches and Challenges in reaching the poor Presented by Pervaiz Tufail Ted Torfoss.

Implementation Science: Finding Common Ground and Perspectives Laura Reichenbach, Evidence Project, Population Council International Conference on Family.

Something old, something new: community-centred approaches and health assets Professor Jane South, Professor of Healthy Communities, Leeds Beckett University.

(Intervention-Level) (Presenter names and sites).

12/26/2017 From Clinical Trial Research to Reality: Recruitment, Retention, and Community-Engaged Research Sherrie Flynt Wallington, PhD Assistant Professor.

NATIONAL outreach Network

Community Advocacy & Education to End Stigmatizing HIV/TB Language

Visioning with CBPR Model

The Community Involvement Community of Practice: A Model for Collaboration in the Field Katherine West Slevin1, Nomampondo Barnabas2, Stella Kirkendale3,

Community Advisory Board: a definition

African perspective on ethical guidelines Salim S Abdool Karim

Introduction Center for family health and community development

Karen Hacker, MD MPH Director

Presentation transcript:

Back to the Rough Ground Community participation and ethics guidance for HIV prevention trials Kathleen M. MacQueen, PhD, MPH Family Health Intenational June

HPTN Ethics Guidance for Research  Kathleen M. MacQueen (FHI)  Jeremy Sugarman (Duke University)  On behalf of the HPTN Ethics Working Group Quarraisha Abdool Karim (Chair), Ronald Bayer, Solomon R. Benatar, Marge Chigwanda, Dennis Dixon, Deborah Donnell, Laura Guay, Stella Kirkendale, Bernard Lo, Kathleen MacQueen, Sophia Mukaso Monico, Vasantha Muthuswamy, Katharine Shapiro, Ronald Strauss, Steve Wakefield, and Cynthia Woodsong

HIV Prevention Trials Network  Worldwide collaborative clinical trials network More than two dozen international sites Leadership group (FHI, FHCRC, Hopkins/Univ of Pittsburgh)  Develops and tests the safety and efficacy of non-vaccine interventions designed to prevent the transmission of HIV  Established in 1999 by the DAIDS/NIAID/NIH

HPTN Working Groups  Antiretroviral Therapy  Behavioral  Microbicides  Perinatal  STDs  Substance Use  Community  Ethics Gary Lewis, JHU/CCP, South Africa 1999 JHCCP Photoshare

HPTN Structural Challenges  Wide range of research > Flexibility  Diverse local contexts > Responsive  Collaboration > Procedural, not prescriptive  Compatibility with existing HPTN & DAIDS procedures  Prevention & public health perspective

HPTN Ethical Challenges  What are acceptable standards of care?  What are researchers’ responsibilities for moving research into policy & practice?  How should stigma be dealt with?  When are placebo controlled trials justified?  How can informed consent be assured?  Is research on new interventions ethical if existing knowledge is not being used?

HPTN Ethics Guidance for Research  Participants and communities  Obligations Process not prescription Do what is doable, achieve the achievable Creativity, persistence, partnership

What is Community? A group of people with diverse characteristics who are linked by social ties, share common perspectives, and engage in joint action in geographical locations or settings. MacQueen KM, et al. What is community? An evidence-based definition for participatory public health. AJPH 2001;91:1929–1938

Community Representation  Representatives should be actively connected to diverse people in their local communities and empowered to function in ways that are meaningful to their community base.  A cookbook approach to participatory programs and research will not work because the experience of community differs from one setting to another.  Each research collaboration must reconcile the differences and similarities among the participating communities. MacQueen KM, et al. What is community? An evidence-based definition for participatory public health. AJPH 2001;91:1929–1938

Participants / Communities Poor community health care Enhanced care for participants Two-tiered health system The Lucky Few The Unlucky Many Disparity Inducement Beneficence  Stigma?  Brain drain?  Sustainability?

Participants + Communities Poor community health care Partner to improve care Enhanced care for participants Improved community health care Beneficence  Capacity building  Equity  Stigma?