Forensic Science and the Law

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Psychology of Homicide Unit III Lecture
Advertisements

Identification and Individualization
ADMISSIBILITY OF TRACE EVIDENCE: A WHOLELISTIC APPROACH-- DESPITE DAUBERT Kenneth E. Melson.
August 12,  Crime-scene investigators (police) arrive to find, collect, protect, and transport evidence. (More on this later!)
Introduction to Forensic Science Chemistry 300 sci·ence n. a.The observation, identification, description, experimental investigation, and theoretical.
Expert Testimony. What’s the expert’s role FOC Proffered Evidence Evidentiary Hypothesis P thumb numb Thumb numbness makes it SML that spine was injured.
OPINION EVIDENCE. OPINION EVIDENCE FRE Evid. Code §§
COEN 252 Computer Forensics Writing Computer Forensics Reports.
Forensic Science Final Exam Review IntroHistoryCrime LabsDuties
Expert Witnesses Texas Rules of Evidence Article VII. Opinions and Expert Testimony Judge Sharen Wilson.
1 What Is Scientific Evidence? Scientific evidence is most often presented in court by an expert witness testifying on expert opinions. It also includes.
1. Evidence Professor Cioffi 2/22/2011 – 2/23/
The Nature of Evidence A Guide to Legal Evidence & the Courts.
Why do we need good forensic science ? A Jamieson.
Introduction to Forensic Science The Science Behind Catching Criminals.
 Forensic science is the application of science to criminal and civil laws.  Forensic science owes its origins to individuals such as:  Bertillon 
Unit 3 Seminar! K. Austin Zimmer Any question from Unit 2! Please make sure you have completed your Unit 1 & 2 Papers!
Bell Ringer 9/16 Place your HW into the appropriate folder. Clear your desk with the exception of something to write with.
Litigating a DNA Case.
Forensic Science Unit 1 Introduction to Forensic Science.
1-1 ©2011, 2008 Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, NJ FORENSIC SCIENCE: An Introduction, 2 nd ed. By Richard Saferstein Forensic Science.
FORENSIC SCIENTISTS, EXPERT TESTIMONY Notes 1.3. Objectives 1. Explain the role and responsibilities of the expert witness. 2. Compare and contrast the.
Class Name, Instructor Name Date, Semester Chapter 1: The Crime Lab.
Skills of a Forensic Scientist & Frye vs. Daubert Standards
The Fraud Report, Litigation, and the Recovery Process McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2012 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights.
Criminalistics An Introduction to Forensic Science CHAPTER Criminalistics: An Introduction to Forensic Science, 11e Richard Saferstein Copyright © 2015.
Introduction to Forensics September 7, 2005 Mr. Schildknecht SUPA Forensics The Science Behind Catching Criminals.
What is Forensic Science? the study and application of science to matters of law… it examines the associations among people, places, things and events.
Cross examination Is the DNA a mixture of two or more people? How did you calculate the match statistic? What is the scientific basis of that calculation?
1-1 ©2011, 2008 Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, NJ FORENSIC SCIENCE: An Introduction, 2 nd ed. By Richard Saferstein INTRODUCTION Chapter.
1 What Is Scientific Evidence? Scientific evidence is most often presented in court by an expert witness testifying on expert opinions. It also includes.
Evidence and Expert Testimony. Expert Testimony  Two Types of Witnesses: Fact and Expert  Fact -- have personal knowledge of facts of case  Cannot.
Professor Guy Wellborn
Evidence 9/9/13. Evidence: What is it? Direct evidence in the form of a statement made under oath-also known as testimonial evidence. Physical evidence-any.
Introduction to Forensics What it encompasses. Forensics application of science to law.
September 10, 2012 Warm-up: Use pg. 13 in your text book to answer the following question: 1.What was the most significant modern advance in forensic science?
Admissibility. The Frye Standard  1923 – became the standard guideline for determining the judicial admissibility of scientific examinations. To meet.
The Law & Forensics Chapters 1-3 (Some information not found in textbook)
Forensic Science- application of science to legal questions (criminal or civil) T. Trimpe 2006
Crime Scene Investigations Chapter 2. Chapter 2.1 Crime Scene Evidence.
Forensic Science: Fundamentals & Investigations, 2e Chapter 1 1 All rights Reserved Cengage/NGL/South-Western © 2016.
Chapter 2: Types of Evidence. 1. Testimonial Evidence – statement made under oath by a competent witness Juries are heavily influenced by eyewitness accounts.
Who’s Daubert?.
All rights Reserved Cengage/NGL/South-Western © 2016.
Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION.
Chapter 1: The Crime Lab 1.
Introduction to Forensic Science
Introduction Forensic science begins at the crime scene.
Laying the Foundation: Expert Witnesses
All rights Reserved Cengage/NGL/South-Western © 2016.
What Is Scientific Evidence?
Class Name, Instructor Name
Lauren A. Warner, Counsel, CCLB Leanne Gould, CPA/ABV/CFF/ASA, Aprio
Causation Analysis in Occupational and Environmental Medicine
All rights Reserved Cengage/NGL/South-Western © 2016.
Introduction to Forensic Science
Introduction to Forensic Science
EVIDENCE—BASES OF OPINION TESTIMONY BY EXPERTS
Class Name, Instructor Name
Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION FORENSIC SCIENCE: An Introduction by Richard Saferstein.
Introduction to Forensic Science
Ethical Standards in Forensic Science
Growth in Recent years is due to:
EVIDENCE—BASES OF OPINION TESTIMONY BY EXPERTS
Important court decisions
Get Started Immediately!
Class Name, Instructor Name
Types of Evidence.
1-3 Functions of a Forensic Scientist
Introduction to Forensic Science and the Law
Presentation transcript:

Forensic Science and the Law

Forensic Scientist Ethics As with other witnesses, forensic scientists obliged to tell the truth. Must attempt to state facts without distortion Omission of relevant information (statistics) Allowing incorrect inferences to be made A witness’s expertise allows them to properly present the evidence.

Law > Forensic Science Ethics Bad: Sherlock Holmes type witness that makes conclusions without considering other possible explanations. Makes an impressive witness, but can unfairly influence jury.

Identical scientific results can be presented differently in court. Law > Forensic Science Ethics Identical scientific results can be presented differently in court. Must avoid being overly definitive or overly inconclusive.

“The gunshot was fired at a distance of 48.2 cm from the victim.” Law > Forensic Science Ethics Example: “The gunshot was fired at a distance of 48.2 cm from the victim.” Problem: This is overly specific. We know that it is not possible to measure the distance that accurately.

“The gun appeared to be 2.2 meters from the wall.” Law > Forensic Science Ethics Example: “The gun appeared to be 2.2 meters from the wall.” Problem: This is overly inconclusive. If it was measured to be 2.2 meters, just say that.

Evidence generated through science is called forensic evidence. Law > Forensic Evidence Evidence generated through science is called forensic evidence. Forensic evidence is circumstantial evidence. Finding a suspect’s blood at a crime scene implies the suspect was also at the crime scene.

Evidence left at crime scene Evidence collected by investigators Law > Forensic Evidence The amount of evidence that makes it into court is a portion of the total evidence. Evidence left at crime scene Evidence collected by investigators Evidence that can be tested and produces results Evidence allowed into court according to rules of evidence

Admissibility of Evidence Law > Forensic Evidence Admissibility of Evidence In order for scientific evidence to be useful, the method must be reliable. Three slightly varied tests are used to determine admissibility.

Admissibility of Evidence Law > Forensic Evidence Admissibility of Evidence Frye test (1923) Is the scientific theory generally accepted in the scientific community? Is the scientific method used generally accepted in the scientific community? Has the technique been applied correctly?

Admissibility of Evidence Law > Forensic Evidence Admissibility of Evidence Daubert test (1993) Has the scientific theory or technique been tested? Has the scientific theory or technique been subjected to peer review and publication? What are the known or potential error rates of the theory or technique when applied?

Admissibility of Evidence Law > Forensic Evidence Admissibility of Evidence Daubert test (1993) Do standards and controls exist and are they maintained? Has the theory or technique been generally accepted in the relevant scientific community?

Admissibility of Evidence Law > Forensic Evidence Admissibility of Evidence Revised Rule 702 If scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will assist the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue, a witness qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education, may testify thereto in the form of an opinion or otherwise, if (1) the testimony is based upon sufficient facts or data, (2) the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods, and (3) the witness has applied the principles and methods reliably to the facts of the case.

Polygraph