Zeno’s Paradoxes. What is a paradox? Anything that is/leads to a logical contradiction –A “square circle” –The notion of a “set of all sets”

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

The First Metaphysicians The “Axial Period:” Period, around 600 to 500 BCE, during which people around the world first came to the conviction that the.

Advertisements

Athens as it might have looked at the height of its power.

Philosophy and Science

The Pythagorean Society, II The Pythagoreans regarded numbers spatially: One is the point, two is the line, three is the surface, four is the solid or.

Ghosts of Departed Errors: Early Criticisms of the Calculus of Newton and Leibniz Eugene Boman, Assoc. Prof. of Mathematics Penn State, Harrisburg campus.

Zeno’s Paradoxes. by James D. Nickel Copyright 

ON CHANGE Zeno. The Dichotomy Zeno’s arguments about motion which provide trouble for those who try to resolve them are four in number. The first.

Beyond Counting Infinity and the Theory of Sets Nate Jones & Chelsea Landis.

F OR OUR GUESTS … This is a Liceo, which is not a vocational school This is a scientific Liceo, so our students focus upon sciences So, we don’t study.

Definition of Calculus

The Eleatics: Parmenides & Zeno.

Zeno’s Paradoxes Can I move?. Zeno The Arrow Paradox Y ou cannot even move. If everything when it occupies an equal space is at rest, and if that which.

EECE Hybrid and Embedded Systems: Computation T. John Koo, Ph.D. Institute for Software Integrated Systems Department of Electrical Engineering and.

Archimedes Quadrature of the Parabola Archimedes ( B.C). –Lived in Syracuse on Sicily. –Invented many machines which were used as engines of war.

Early Greeks (the pre-Socratics) I.Three forms of philosophy II.Problem with the gods III.6 TH century revolution in natural philosophy IV.The pre-Socratic.

Mathematical Ideas that Shaped the World Calculus.

The First Philosophers of Ancient Greece Prof. Rose Cherubin Department of Philosophy George Mason University

Euclid’s Plane Geometry

The hare and the tortoise decide to race Since I run twice as fast as you do, I will give you a half mile head start. Thanks!

Pre-Socratic Philosophers

2 Mathematicians Pythagoras and Zeno Comparison of their discoveries

TaK “This was one of the great events of my life, as dazzling as first love. I had not imagined that there was anything so delicious in the world” Bertrand.

Greek Philosophers. What is Philosophy? Means “love of wisdom” The rational investigation of the truths and principles of being, knowledge, or conduct.

Greek Ontologies Democritus, atoms discrete (things in void) Aristotle, continuum, (stuff, no void) Zeno’s paradox continuum vs discrete (presages wave.

Beyond Practicality George Berkeley and the Need for Philosophical Integration in Mathematics Joshua B. Wilkerson Texas A&M University

Parmenides of Elea ( ).

Shaping Modern Mathematics Raymond Flood Gresham Professor of Geometry.

8.8 Improper Integrals Math 6B Calculus II. Type 1: Infinite Integrals  Definition of an Improper Integral of Type 1 provided this limit exists (as a.

Phil 1102: Critical Thinking Mysteries, Paradoxes, and barriers to inference.

Short history of Calculus. Greeks Numbers: - Integers (1, 2, 3,...) - Ratios of integers (1/2, 8/7,...) The “number line” contains “holes” - e.g. they.

So, you think you know your philosophers?

PARADOXES Zeno's Paradoxes One can never reach the end of a racecourse, for in order to do so one would first have to reach the halfway mark, then the.

What is the Fabric of the Cosmos? The Immaterial Edition

The infinite endless: a route between cognitive philosophy, logic, mathematics and art.

Early Greek Philosophers. Before the Greeks Animism Anthropomorphism Early Greek Religion Dionysiac religion Orphic religion.

Democritus & Aristotle George Olvera Karina Garcia Cade Winquest Katy Blake.

What is philosophy? philos = loving sophia = wisdom

Pre-Socratic Presentation

What Place Does Philosophy Have in Teaching Mathematics? Preliminary report. Martin E Flashman Department of Mathematics Humboldt State University Arcata,

Copyright © Curt Hill A Brief History of Logic Some Background.

Zeno’s Paradox By: Deborah Lowe and Vickie Bledsoe.

Do Things Move? Spacetime and the Problem of Modern Science.

Sets and Size Basic Question: Compare the “size” of sets. First distinction finite or infinite. –What is a finite set? –How can one compare finite sets?

History of Philosophy Pre-Socratics a “meze” of Greeks.

Georg Cantor and Infinity An introduction to set theory and transfinite numbers.

The Goal of Science To create a set of models that describe the measurable universe. These models must – Fit previous verified measurements applicable.

Parmenides and the Eleatics Using logic alone to derive startling metaphysical conclusions.

1 Top Down Perception And What it’s Like to Be Ancient Look at the old woman Or is it a young woman? Is perception shaped by prior belief? –Compare persistent.

To Infinity and Beyond!. Paradox A paradox is a seemingly consistent, logical argument that nonetheless ends with a ridiculous conclusion Like the story.

In mathematics, zero, symbolized by the numeric character O, is both: In mathematics, zero, symbolized by the numeric character O, is both: 1. In a positional.

Philosophical Problems January 13, 2015 Zeno's Paradoxes.

Zeno. Zeno’s arguments about motion which provide trouble for those who try to resolve them are four in number. The first [the dichotomy argument]

The Natural Philosophers The Pre-Socratics. Pre-Socratic Philosophers  Asked two main questions:  Of what is the natural world made?  To what degree.

Philosophy and History of Mathematics

Pre-Socratics Philosophers prior to Socrates

Parmenides By Troy and Ken.

What it’s Like to Be Ancient

(1888 PressRelease) Chiropractor Proves Pi is Finite

What it’s Like to Be Ancient

Zeno’s Paradox and the Concept of Limit

ZENO’S PARADOX The hare and the tortoise decide to run a race.

Infinity and Beyond! A prelude to Infinite Sequences and Series (Ch 12)

Zeno's Paradoxes Zeno of Elea (c. 490 BC BC)

Infinity and the Theory of Sets

Infinity and Beyond! A prelude to Infinite Sequences and Series (Ch 12)

1.2 Propositional Equivalences

WHAT IS A PARADOX ?.

Paradox An argument where the premises, if true, infer a conclusion that is a contradiction.

Everything is an Integer Countable and Uncountable Sets

Presentation transcript:

Zeno’s Paradoxes

What is a paradox? Anything that is/leads to a logical contradiction –A “square circle” –The notion of a “set of all sets”

Who is Zeno? Greek philosopher 5 th Century BCE Elea (Greek colony) Student of Parmenides

What are Zeno’s Paradoxes? Arguments to support the teachings of Parmenides –Everything that exists is one –Change is illusory –Motion is illusory Based largely on limiting processes and definitions

Example 1: Unity/Plurality Paradox of the “heap of grain”

Example 2: Motion The Dichotomy Achilles and the Tortoise

Mathematics? Zeno’s Paradoxes were not developed as mathematical problems Some of them (e.g., dichotomy) seem to be able to be resolved with modern tools (e.g., infinite series) But is this the point?

Modeling Reality Logic: “Truth” as system-relative In order to resolve the paradoxes with modern math, we have to make certain assumptions about physical reality. –Cf. “Zeno processes” –Is matter discrete or continuous? Your model may “work”, but does it accurately reflect reality? –(Does this even matter?) –Ex. John& Jane, Diogenes

Berkeley & the Calculus Newton/Leibniz: Fluxions & infinitesimals “And what are these Fluxions? The Velocities of evanescent Increments? And what are these same evanescent Increments? They are neither finite Quantities nor Quantities infinitely small, nor yet nothing. May we not call them the ghosts of departed quantities? “ -George Berkeley (ca. 1734)