‘Estimating with Confidence’ and hindsight: Population estimates for areas smaller than districts, revisions to levels of 1991 Census non-response Paul.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Constructing population time series with an ethnic breakdown for sub-national areas in England and Wales, Albert Sabater PhD student at CCSR.
Advertisements

What are Geographical Information Systems (GIS) & ArcView GIS software? What is a Geographical Information System (GIS)? Introduction to ESRI ArcView 3.x.
Methods to allow analysis of change over time at small area level using census, vital statistics and other administrative data Paul Norman Centre for Census.
Adding geographical detail to social surveys: Estimating local disability prevalence Alan Marshall ESDS Government 15 th April 2010.
Does it matter what estimation method I use to provide small area populations at risk in standardised mortality ratios? CCSR Seminar: 16th December 2003.
Methods for investigating zoning effects Mark Tranmer CCSR.
Vital Statistics an invaluable resource for health, demographic & population geography research Paul Norman.
The Samples of Anonymised Records: Understanding Individual differences Mark Brown.
The Census Area Statistics Myles Gould Understanding area-level inequality & change.
QMSS2 Immigration & Population Dynamics: Summer School PROJECTION METHODS FOR ETHNICITY AND IMMIGRATION STATUS The estimation of ethnic fertility Paul.
Household Projections for England Yolanda Ruiz DCLG 16 th July 2012.
1 Combining migration data from multiple sources: Applications to internal movements in England, James Raymer with Peter W.F. Smith and Corrado.
The micro-geography of UK demographic change Paul Norman School of Geography, University of Leeds Understanding Population Trends and Processes.
Internet access to UK Census interaction data: that's WICID! John Stillwell Centre for Computational Geography University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT
Population Estimates 2012 Texas State Data Center Conference for Data Users May 22, 2012 Austin, TX.
Availability of population estimates and projections Project EASY nowfuture -2-3 ONS Borough Ward LSOA EASY ONS EASY GLA Social Infrastructure Planning.
Developments with ONS’ Small Area Population Estimates Project Andy Bates.
Sample of Anonymised Records: User Meeting Propensity to migrate by ethnic group: 1991 & 2001 Paul Norman 1, John Stillwell 2 & Serena Hussain 2 School.
Migration, methodologies and health inequality SEED Group
Which influences the self-reporting of health: country of birth or country of residence? A British analysis using individual-level data Paul Norman 1,
DESIGN OF A SUBNATIONAL POPULATION PROJECTION MODEL FOR ETHNIC GROUPS AND FOR DEALING WITH UNCERTAINTY IN INTERNAL MIGRATION Philip Rees BSPS Day Meeting.
Access to UK Census Data for Spatial Analysis: Towards an Integrated Census Support Service John Stillwell 1, Justin Hayes 2, Rob Dymond-Green 2, James.
The micro-geography of UK demographic change Paul Norman School of Geography, University of Leeds understanding population trends and processes.
Economics and Statistics Administration U.S. CENSUS BUREAU U.S. Department of Commerce 1 The U.S. Census Bureau’s 2010 Demographic Analysis Estimates:
ASDC Annual Meeting Carolyn Trent, Socioeconomic Analyst Alabama State Data Center Center for Business and Economic Research November 2, 2012 Culverhouse.
11 The American Community Survey Steve Murdock, Ph.D. Director, Hobby Center for the Study of Texas Rice University.
Understanding Population Trends and Processes WHAT HAPPENS WHEN INTERNATIONAL MIGRANTS SETTLE? ETHNIC GROUP POPULATION TRENDS AND PROJECTIONS FOR UK LOCAL.
The micro-geography of UK demographic change Paul Norman School of Geography, University of Leeds understanding population trends and processes.
Computing SubLHIN Population Projections in the South East Region August 2014 Update.
Internal migration of Britain’s ethnic populations Serena Hussain and John Stillwell School of Geography University of Leeds Presentation for the UPTAP.
Population projections: Uncertainty and the user perspective Presentation to INIsPHO Seminar Newry, 2 December 2008 Tony Dignan.
Monitoring UK internal migration in the twenty-first century John Stillwell Centre for Interaction Data Estimation and Research (CIDER), School of Geography,
POPGROUP Slide 1 The Derived Forecasts module of the POPGROUP software Ludi Simpson, University of Manchester BSPS day meeting on household projection.
1 Measuring Quality Issues Associated with Internal Migration Estimates Joanne Clements, Amir Islam, Ruth Fulton & Jane Naylor Demographics Methods Centre.
Methodology for producing the revised back series of population estimates for Julie Jefferies Population and Demography Division Office for.
Sustainable rural populations: the case of two National Park areas Alan Marshall Ludi Simpson Cathie Marsh Centre for Census and Survey Research.
1 Measuring Uncertainty in Population Estimates at Local Authority Level Ruth Fulton, Bex Newell, Dorothee Schneider.
U.S. Census Bureau’s Population Estimates Program Victoria Velkoff Population Division U.S. Census Bureau APDU 2010 Annual Conference Public Data 2010:
 Using Data for Demographic Analysis Country Course on Analysis and Dissemination of Population and Housing Census Data with Gender Concern October.
Estimating migration flows in Northern Ireland by health characteristics measured in the Census: using the NI Longitudinal Study James Brown (University.
New and easier ways of working with aggregate data and geographies from UK censuses Justin Hayes UK Data Service Census Support.
Internet Access to Census Migration and Journey-to-Work Data John Stillwell and Oliver Duke-Williams Centre for Computational Geography University of Leeds,
Web Access to Census Interaction Data John Stillwell and Oliver Duke-Williams Centre for Computational Geography University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT Paper.
1 ◄ ◄ Maternal and Infant Health data for California Choose one vital records indicator:  Preterm birth (birth prior to 37 weeks of pregnancy among singletons)
1 Using the Cohort Studies: Understanding the postponement of parenthood to later ages Ann Berrington ESRC Centre for Population Change University of Southampton,
1 Research Methods Festival 2008 Zhiqiang Feng 1,2 and Paul Boyle 1 1 School of Geography & Geosciences University of St Andrews 2 The Centre for Census.
Demographic change at small area level Small area statistics to develop public policy Paul Norman School of Geography, University of Leeds ESRC RES
Design of the 2011 Census Coverage Survey Owen Abbott (ONS) James Brown (Institute of Education)
Updating Household Projections for England Bob Garland.
Data Management and Analysis 29 th February 2008 John Hollis BSPS Meeting at LSE Data Management and Analysis Projections for London Boroughs.
The micro-geography of UK demographic change Paul Norman School of Geography, University of Leeds Understanding Population Trends & Processes.
United Nations Workshop on Revision 3 of Principles and Recommendations for Population and Housing Censuses and Evaluation of Census Data, Amman 19 – 23.
Population Projections – Local Authority Usage Greg Ball.
The dynamics of Britain’s ethnic group populations: the roles of natural change and net migration in producing the ethnic mosaic Nissa Finney and Ludi.
School of Geography FACULTY OF ENVIRONMENT ESRC Research Award RES What happens when international migrants settle? Ethnic group population.
The micro-geography of UK demographic change Paul Norman Cathie Marsh Centre for Census & Survey Research (CCSR), University of Manchester ESRC.
Estimating segregation and diversity of ethnic groups over time in England and Wales, Albert Sabater Cathie Marsh Centre for Census and Survey.
Guide to CCG Data Profiles Version Version information and PDF production date The main part of the profile uses information on CCGs’ proposed practices.
Residential ethnic segregation for age cohorts in England and Wales, Centre for Census and Survey Research (CCSR)
Exploring Microsimulation Methodologies for the Estimation of Household Attributes Dimitris Ballas, Graham Clarke, and Ian Turton School of Geography University.
The micro-geography of UK demographic change Paul Norman School of Geography, University of Leeds understanding population trends and processes.
The micro-geography of UK demographic change Paul Norman School of Geography, University of Leeds understanding population trends and processes.
Measuring ethnic group population change for small areas using census microdata and demographic population estimates ESRC Research Methods Festival St.
The Labour Market and the New Budgetary Framework Thomas Conefrey Irish Fiscal Advisory Council DPER Labour Market Policy Symposium 19 May 2015.
GOVERNMENT OFFICE FOR THE SOUTH WEST South West Public Health Observatory Day 2: Datasets Jennie Mussard, Croydon PCT James Hebblethwaite, Kensington &
Jo Watson sepho South East Public Health Observatory Solutions for Public Health Day 2: Session 2 Populations and geography.
Calculating Ward Level Life Expectancy Peter Fryers Public Health Information Specialist West Midlands Public Health Observatory.
South West Public Health Observatory Populations, ethnicity and geography.
Developments with ONS’s Small Area Population Estimates Project Andy Bates, Office for National Statistics.
Social Infrastructure Planning
Presentation transcript:

‘Estimating with Confidence’ and hindsight: Population estimates for areas smaller than districts, revisions to levels of 1991 Census non-response Paul Norman 1, Ludi Simpson 2 & Albert Sabater 2 1 School of Geography, University of Leeds 2 Cathie Marsh Centre for Census and Survey Research (CCSR), University of Manchester

Micro-geography of UK demographic change Aim: “Quantify and map changes in population size and social characteristics which occurred in UK’s small geographical areas between the 1991 and 2001 Censuses” Challenges: calculating population change Make 1991 and 2001 mid year populations comparable: Adjust populations to a consistent geography  Boundary changes both EDs/OAs & ‘wards’ Ensure student location & age-groups compatible Allow for post-2001 view of 1991 Census undercount Paul Norman: ESRC RES for

‘Estimating with Confidence’ and hindsight: Population estimates for areas smaller than districts, revisions to levels of 1991 Census non-response 1990s view  Official (local authority)  Estimating with Confidence small area population estimates for mid year 1991 Post-2001 official revised adjustments for 1991 Revising EwC small area estimates Implications of revised estimates

‘Estimating with Confidence’ (EwC) 1991 small area MYEs (original) Following Official Mid-Year Estimates (MYEs) for 1991 districts Area-specific application of official district level adjustments Raw 1991 Census counts with enhancements for: ‘Other’ Student term-time address Demographic change between census and mid-1991 Modification adjustment (table consistency) ‘Non-response’ Armed forces postings Residual non-response by age & sex (Simpson et al. 1997)

EwC 1991 adjustments (original) Bradford Metropolitan District, wards Non-response adjustments Other adjustments

After 2001 Census 1991 MYEs revised Adjustments Non-response revised downwards (E&W & Sc) Simple location of sex ratio mid-way between 1981 & 2001 Other adjustments remain the same Populations Males Females

Revising 1991 EwC small area MYEs Post-2001 viewpoint (revised) Adjust EwC populations & components to allow for 1991 to 2001 boundary changes Revise original EwC non-response enhancements No revisions to other adjustments (student, timing or modification) Output definitions Demography: Single year of age (to 90+) & sex Geography: 2001 OAs & ‘wards’ for all UK Ensure small area data sum hierarchically to the 1991 revised district MYEs

Revising the original 1991 EwC estimates Broad steps: By five year age (to 85+) and sex … Calculate total non-response for each 1991 ED Constrain ED Census, non-response & other components to ward equivalents Convert ED data to 2001 OA geography Scale original non-response enhancements by change at district level Sum components to be a revised 1991 estimate Estimate single year of age detail using available information for within five-year groups & above 85+

Converting between geographies (ED/OA) (Simpson 2002; Norman et al. 2003)

Revising the non-response (ward)

Estimating single year of age by IPF (ward) Estimate initial m0 = (Births + (‘0-4’ / 5) ) 2 m1, 2, 3, 4 = ‘0-4’ / 5

Assessing EwC (revised) outputs Relationships should be maintained Correlation 0.89 Correlation 0.48

Implications of EwC revisions Analyses of population change Use of census year estimates as a base population  Projections of future populations  Estimates for post-censal years Use of populations as the denominators in rates  Numerators stay the same but denominators reduce  This implies increased rates

Population change Pattern of change very similar Growing wards do not experience the same level of growth Wards reducing have reduced even more Different conclusions on natural change & migration balance

Population projections & estimates Projections from 1991 using original & revised as the base Curves are parallel After 2001, difference due to fertility variation larger than differences due to base Estimates for 1996 using original & revised as the base At extremes same wards growing or contracting Middle ground estimates based on original, wards increasing. Revised base leads to reduced, static or small growth Considerable divergence in estimates over 5 years

Population used as a denominator Male unemployment, 1991 Male SMRs, 1991 More variation using 1996 estimates

‘Estimating with Confidence’ and hindsight 1990s view, substantial undercount in 1991 Census Post-2001 official view revised adjustments for 1991 Revised EwC small area estimates for geography and non-response Revised estimates now used in various projects Implications of revised estimates Re-worked research affects demographic, health and social indicators, especially the ranking of areas’ population and population change The extent of the revisions may often not result in different conclusions being drawn about trends and patterns EwC is now more useful to more people: internally consistent, on 2001 geography & for any age-groups

‘Estimating with Confidence’ and hindsight Estimates by OA & single year of age are estimates! Data availability to other researchers? Currently: on request Future, via ~ Data Archive? ~ Dedicated website? References Norman P, Rees P, Boyle P (2003) Achieving data compatibility over space and time: creating consistent geographical zones. International Journal of Population Geography. 9(5): Norman P, Simpson L & Sabater A (2007) ‘Estimating with Confidence’ and hindsight: new UK small area population estimates for Population, Space & Place (submitted) Simpson L (2002) Geography conversion tables: a framework for conversion of data between geographical units. International Journal of Population Geography 8: Simpson S, Cossey R, Diamond I (1997) 1991 population estimates for areas smaller than districts. Population Trends 90: 31-39