Promoting Shared Decision Making Jack Fowler Informed Medical Decisions Foundation.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Don Kemper Comments on Patient Engagement March 5, 2010 Alliance for Health Reform Our health care system is perfectly designed….

Advertisements

©PPRNet 2014 Designing a PPRNet PCORI Application to Improve Adherence to USPSTF Grade D Recommendations for Cancer Screening.

Winchester Medical Center Bariatric Program SF-36 Quality of Life Survey OR What has Bariatric Surgery Done for Me Lately?

Cancer Screening Saves Lives 40-50% of Ontarians will develop cancer in their lifetime. Many of these cancers can be prevented. GTA Cancer Prevention and.

Mammogram’s Role as Savior Is Tested TARA PARKER-POPE New York Times, October 24, 2011

The Role of Shared Decision Making in Reducing Unwarranted Variation in Health Care A Talk by Jack Wennberg A Talk by Jack Wennberg Implementing shared.

Opt-in HIV Testing: Counterpoint Douglas G. Fish, MD Asst. Professor of Medicine Head, Division of HIV Medicine Albany Medical College, Albany, NY November.

Policy Research Shop Support for the Policy Research Shop is provided by the Ford Foundation and by the Fund for the Improvement of Postsecondary Education,

Breast cancer and medical second opinion

Local Patient Participation Group ‘A centre of excellence delivering high quality care where patients and staff choose to be’ 21 st January 2015.

North East of England MAGIC Team Making Good Decisions in Collaboration 3 hour V Shared Decision Making Extended Skills Training Workshop.

- Being hospitalized can be a very intimidating experience. - Patients find themselves thrown into a foreign environment and often feel that they.

The National Mastectomy and Breast Reconstruction Audit Key findings of the Third Annual Report Slides produced by the MBR Project Team. © The National.

Proposed Cross-center Project Survey of Federally Qualified Health Centers Vicky Taylor & Vicki Young.

Assessment of Colon & Prostate Cancer Screening in WA Peggy Hannon, PhD, MPH Alliance for Reducing Cancer NW.

Implementation of Patient Decision Aids: Lessons from North America Dawn Stacey RN, PhD University Research Chair in Knowledge Translation to Patients.

ACRIN 6657/CALGB Consent for Research Study Contrast-Enhanced Breast MRI and MRS: A Correlative Science Studies to Characterize Tumor Response in.

Better Shared Decision Making in Practice

 You can participate if :  You have cancer, including breast, ovarian, and other cancers, or  Your family members have cancer including breast, ovarian,

Training Module 2: Respondent Eligibility Criteria.

Decision Support as a Clinical Skill Module III: Decision aids designed for specific decisions Last update: September 2008.

Personalize. Empower. Improve. Learn how to earn healthy rewards every step of the way “It pays to know your score!”

Shared Decision Making An Overview of Knowledge, Policy and Quality Measurement Michael J. Barry, MD President March 2, 2011 Medical Directors Meeting.

The Health Seeking Behaviors of Young African American Males and Their Thoughts About Prostate Cancer Veronica A. Clarke-Tasker, Ph.D., RN, MBA, MPH, Professor.

“We are a compassionate team of healthcare professionals providing excellent personal care to Central Minnesota.”

1 How to Talk To Your Doctor Marj Bernstein & Cathie Duncan Bridges Program.

Explanation and planning. What are the objectives of explanation and planning?

Silent Voice Survey A survey of prostate cancer patients in Europe OVERVIEW OF RESULTS.

Medication Adherence The following module is designed as a basic overview of medication adherence for providers of healthcare, particularly those in a.

:Kenyans Easter  In order to be an Anesthesiologist you have to go to college for a total of 12 yrs.

A GENERAL OVERVIEW OF PROSTATE CANCER. PROSTATE CANCER 101 SPONSORED BY THE CALIFORNIA STATE PROSTATE CANCER COALITION AND THE NATIONAL ALLIANCE OF STATE.

Dave Tomson Shared Decision Making.

Quality of care Patient-centred primary and specialist care Medication reviews Chronic condition management and disease prevention 1.

Assessment of Patient Knowledge Regarding Drugs Prescribed and Dispensed in Some Health Insurance Outpatient Clinics in Alexandria.

Genomic Health, Inc. Yuko Soneoka, Ph.D., J.D. Senior Corporate Counsel, IP Director of Intellectual Property January 31, 2013.

The 2011 Iowa Dialogue on Colorectal Cancer Iowa Colorectal Cancer Focus Groups: What We Learned Iowa Dialogue on Colorectal Cancer September 16, 2011.

John Santa MD MPH Medical Director Consumer Reports Health January 24, 2014 Making Evidence Work For Consumers Presentation and Dissemination.

BHCAG Summit Minneapolis, MN February 23, 2012 Shannon Brownlee, MS Instructor, The Dartmouth Institute Acting Director, New America Foundation Health.

Internet educated patients, the patient-physician relationship, and cancer screening Yuliya Shneyderman.

"The Effects of Health Care Financing Arrangements on Consumer Utilization Decisions in Harris County." Presented at the Healthcare Safety Net Initiatives.

A /01 Evaluation of English and Spanish Health Information on the Internet Gretchen Berland, M.D. The RAND Corporation.

Do patient decision aids reduce wait times and improve quality of decisions for patients considering TJA? A randomized controlled trial University of Ottawa,

HW215: Models of Health & Wellness Unit 7: Health and Wellness Models Geo-political Influences.

A Computer-Tailored Decision Aid to Promote Informed Decision-Making for Prostate Cancer Screening Jennifer D. Allen. Deborah Bowen, Gary Bennett, Alton.

Shared Decision Making in the NHS Sue Kennedy National Shared Decision Making Programme Manager.

Tested Messages to Reach the Unscreened 80% by 2018 Forum Mary Doroshenk, MA, NCCRT Director 1.

Becoming an Activated Patient – Part 1 Kenneth Brummel-Smith, MD Charlotte Edwards Maguire Professor of Geriatrics Florida State University College of.

Financial Literacy. Why am I presenting this? Uh………

MBCG Project Primary Results MEDICALSURVEYS-17 RESEARCH GROUP IN COLLABORATION WITH THE EASO.

5 Tips for Getting the Most Out of Your Doctor Visit.

Assessing Colorectal Cancer Screening in Appalachia PA William Curry, MD, MS Mark Dignan, PhD Gene Lengerich, VMD Alan Adelman, MD, MS.

Be a Partner with Your Physician Stephen TePastte M.D. Medical Director MESSA.

Shared Decision Making at Dartmouth Kate Clay, MA, BSN, RN Program Director Center for Shared Decision Making Dartmouth Hitchcock Medical Center Lebanon,

Models/ Health Experts

Promoting Patient Involvement in Medication Decisions David H. Hickam, MD, MPH Professor, Dept. of Medicine Oregon Health & Science University Portland,

OZAUKEE COUNTY COMMUNITY HEALTH SURVEY – March 2012 Commissioned by: Aurora Health Care Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin Columbia St. Mary’s Health System.

University of Texas System, Clinical Safety and Effectiveness Conference Building the Bridge: Maintaining Quality in the Face of Change September 20-21,

Finding Answers Online Comprehensiveness and accuracy in online information about breast cancer Kim Walsh-Childers, PhD Heather M. Edwards, MA University.

The Interface between Primary Care and Specialty Care in Primary Treatment of Cancer Jonathan Sussman Supportive Cancer Care Research Unit Laura-Mae Baldwin.

Shared Decision Making in a Family Medicine Clerkship—Five Years of Teaching and Outcomes Vince WinklerPrins MD, Pete Ziemkowski MD, Ken Yokosawa MD, Stephen.

Do Decision Aids Promote Shared Decision-Making for Prostate Cancer Screening? Alex Krist MD Steven Woolf MD MPH Robert Johnson PhD Department of Family.

Society of Teachers of Family Medicine Conference on Practice Improvement November 23, 2013 Michael J Barry, President SHARED DECISION MAKING THE PINNACLE.

Choosing a Spine Surgeon. SPINE SURGEON Are physicians who have completed additional years of medical training in the treatment and diagnosis of spinal.

Mammograms and Breast Exams: When to start /stop mammograms

Current Legal and Ethical Controversies in American Health Care

Consent to Medical Care

David was told that hip replacement surgery was his only option

Member Dysfunction: What It Is and How Doctors Diagnose It.

Worthen Medical Practice

Provider comparison reveals no difference between training levels

Presentation transcript:

Promoting Shared Decision Making Jack Fowler Informed Medical Decisions Foundation

Shared decision making means 1. Patients are told about all reasonable options 2. Patients are told about pros and cons of options 3. Patients share goals, concerns and preferences with providers

4 Reasons Not to Increase Efforts to Do Shared Decision Making 1. We already do it 2. Patients don’t want it 3. Patients can’t understand 4. Doctors should make decisions

We already do it?

National Survey of Medical Decisions Cancer screening tests: – Colorectal Cancer – Breast Cancer (mammography) – Prostate Cancer (PSA testing) Prescription medication decisions: – Hypertension – High Cholesterol – Depression Surgical interventions: – Knee/hip replacement – Cataracts – Lower back pain

Mean Proportion of Knowledge Items Answered Correctly Medication Initiation: Cancer screening: Elective surgery:

Discussion of Pros and Cons- “some” OR “A lot” Medication Initiation: Screened for Cancer: Underwent surgery:

Did HCP Offer an Opinion and Ask for Patient’s Own Opinion? Medication Initiation: Screened for Cancer: Underwent surgery:

PATIENTS DON’T WANT IT?

Testing our First 30- Minute BPH Program How would you rate the amount of information?

One Universal Truth Every time we ask, people (particularly physicians) underestimate how much patients value getting information about their medical conditions and being involved in decisions.

At Dartmouth-Hitchcock Patients routinely see decision aids for at least 11 different decisions They are surveyed after they see them

Who Should Make Decisions? Dartmouth patient data collected between July 2005 and July 2009

Would You Recommend DA for Others Dartmouth patient data collected between July 2005 and July 2009

Patients can’t understand?

Findings with Respect to Literacy Compared understanding of risk reduction for samples of college students and senior citizens recruited from community centers Both groups were stratified by score on a numeracy test

Percent of Respondents Who Understood Risk Reduction by Numeracy Level and Quality of Data Presentation

Doctors should make decisions?

Top Three Goals and Concerns for Breast Cancer/Herniated Disc Decisions Condition: GoalPatientProviderp Surgery: Keep your breast? Chemotherapy: Live as long as possible? Reconstruction: Look natural without clothes Reconstruction: Avoid using prosthesis 7% 59% P< % 71% 96% 80% 0% 33% P=0.01 P=0.05 P<0.01

We are not doing it now

Patients do want it But many perceive their doctors do not welcome questions and patient participation in decision making

Patients can absorb complex information However, it has to be presented well

Decisions should not be delegated to physicians Because most medical decisions involve trade offs and quality of life issues Providers will not know what patients care about unless they ask At the moment, they do not routinely ask

SO THAT IS WHY WE ALL NEED TO WORK TO PROMOTE THE IDEA THAT PATIENTS ROUTINELY SHOULD BE INFORMED ABOUT THEIR OPTIONS AND THEIR PROS AND CONS HAVE A VOICE IN MEDICAL DECISIONS

THANK YOU.