CARDIFF UNIVERSITY UK Cardiff School of Social Sciences.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The people Look for some people. Write it down. By the water
Advertisements

Over. new sound take only little work know.
Turing’s Test, Searle’s Objection
A.
CONSIDERING IDENTITY THROUGH QUALITATIVE IMITATION GAME DATA LOCAL UNDERSTANDINGS OF SEXUALITY, RACE, AND OTHER SOCIAL IDENTITIES Andrew Bartlett
Reflective Listening Lawyers Assistance Program Facilitated by Robert Bircher.
BROWNSBURG BASKETBALL
©Marian Small, 2011 When you can hear and speak, please click on the If you cannot hear or speak, please click on the Microphone On/Off There are only.
Using.  Purpose ▪ What question were the authors trying to answer? ▪ What was the primary relationship being studied?  Methods ▪ Subtitles: Participants;
St. Luke’s Children’s Advocacy and Community Education Implement Plan The focus of this internship included children’s awareness and injury prevention.
How to measure things you can’t see Particle physics Dr. Julie Roche I will tell you: -What I study (really small particles you can’t see with your eyes)
Miss Kabanuck What is an adjective? An adjective describes or modifies a noun by telling 1) what kind, 2) how many, or 3) which one.
Loser’s Defenses To identify defensive behaviors individuals use to keep themselves from losing.
Good writing Media Writing I.
This program is provided with compliments from By Doug Steward.
{ What is Social Health? By Alex Seymour, Milan Bacovic, Remi Whyte & Tex Chapkoun.
4 Things that affect your pictures… ISO Aperture Shutter Speed LIGHT.
I DON ’ T WANT TO TICK THE BOX : N OT BEING STRAIGHT IN THE NEW GENERATION Tiffany Apaitia-Vague Western Institute of Technology at Taranaki, New Zealand.
Page 22. Writing Page 22 A. 1. Have you ever watched a quiz show on television? What did you think of it? 2. Would you ever participate in a quiz show?
Combining Language Elements Turn computer speakers on while watching video.
Habit 5: Seek First to Understand, Then to Be Understood
What is the Imitation Game? Robert Evans and Harry Collins Centre for the Study of Knowledge, Expertise and Science (KES) Cardiff School of Social Sciences.
HOW TO STUDY ENGLISH EFFECTIVELY
Friday, 3/21 Get out independent reading material and read silently.
Three’s company – an experimental proposal for AAC Norman Alm School of Computing University of Dundee ? !
100 Years of Service in 2014 United Way of the Greater Dayton Area Collaboration is a team sport ……a tale of one county.
Authors write for a reason. This reason may be to: ___________________.
References - I used this site to look at the videos of each ident and get a brief understanding.
Media.* 3:45 - 5:15 *Create exciting change, and make sure everyone knows it.
1 SUBMITTED BY:- PRABINA BISWAL OUTLINE 1. Introduction 2. History 3. How It Works 4. Visual representation 5. Accuracy 6. Applications 7. Further Developments.
The Game of TENNIS. Tennis The Game: Tennis is an individual racket sport played on a court divided by a 3’ net. A person can play singles or with a partner.
Financial Women’s Association Survey Results January 2002 Padilla Speer Beardsley.
The Monologue Project The project you’ll remember years from now!
I am ready to test!________ I am ready to test!________
Sight Words.
Art 315 Lecture 5 Dr. J. Parker AB 606. Last time … We wrote our first program. We used a tool called GameMaker. The program we wrote causes a ball to.
Fry Sight Word Inventory Second 100 Words New Sound.
Sight Words - List B Words over new sound.
Information provided by Microsoft CYBERETHICS.
Violence In The Media By: Frankie Belford. Psychologist P.O.V On Violence In The Media Summary—Research on violent television and films, video games,
UMPIRE MANAGERS BRIEFING FOR YOUNG UMPIRES 2006 © England Hockey.
Science Andrea’s Student Led Conference. Cover Letter This year in science I have learned about many things. We learned a ton of important information.
1 SUBMITTED BY:- PRABINA BISWAL OUTLINE 1. Introduction 2. History 3. How It Works 4. Visual representation 5. Accuracy 6. Applications 7. Further Developments.
Three Cs Clarity Conciseness Consistency. Clarity Being clear is our main priority when communicating. What might prevent us from communicating clearly?
The S.B.R.L. Caller Guide The Best Methods for How to Get Completions.
Elements of Communication 6 Elements of Communication 1. Verbal messages 2. Nonverbal messages 3. Perception 4. Channel 5. Feedback 6. Context.
CARDIFF UNIVERSITY UK Cardiff School of Social Sciences.
 Web 2.0 site lets people interact and help each other in in the media dialogue as creators that put the information in the virtual community.
Moving from one place to another Often will not see anything, just passing time between places or just being taken from one place to the next. Nothing.
 News article. OzP0QqsRg&feature=related.
DO NOW: 1.State whether you agree or disagree with this statement-and tell me WHY- “Everyone learns the same way.” Be prepared to justify your answer.
False Positives Sensitive Surveys Lesson Starter A bag contains 5 red marbles and 4 blue marbles. Two marbles are drawn without replacement. What.
Using language---- Speaking & Writing Unit 5 Music 制作老师 : 李胜文.
Unit 5 Do you have a soccer ball?. Teaching procedures Step 1 Warming up At the end of last period, students were asked to bring some sports things they.
Sight Words.
My Dream Careers By Jacob Tupper My Dream Career Sports Career The sports that I am good at is soccer and wrestling. I have a good chance at these sports.
High Frequency Words.
1 Welcome to CASSEL Welcome to the CASSEL Lab, and thank you for participating in today’s experiment. It is very important that you do not touch the computer.
BIG SIGHT WORDS Use as flash cards for sight words Use to make big cards to laminate for games and manipulative activities Use to make slides that show.
Sight Words List B. over new sound take only.
The Social Network Revolution 2015
CHAPTER 9 ANNISA FAIZAH( ) RAHAJENG H. RARAS( ) ANA CLARISTI( ) DAMARINA( ) ASKING AND EXPLAINING.
Data Link Layer. Data link layer The communication between two machines that can directly communicate with each other. Basic property – If bit A is sent.
My Discourse Community Professional Athletes Personal Team.
1 Which of the things below are the most important to you in life? Circle three things. be happy travel around the world go to college make a lot of money.
Created By Sherri Desseau Click to begin TACOMA SCREENING INSTRUMENT FIRST GRADE.
New Technology used in sports B y R.Abishek K.Chaithanya Kumar.
Table Tennis and Badminton
How to measure things you can’t see Particle physics Dr. Julie Roche
Presentation transcript:

CARDIFF UNIVERSITY UK Cardiff School of Social Sciences

Interactional Expertise Interactional expertise is acquired via long immersion in the talk of the practising community but without physically practising The spoken discourse that belongs to a practising community is their ‘practice language’

A new way of measuring expertise COMPUTER JUDGE HUMAN PARTICIPANT MAN PRETENDS TO BE WOMAN JUDGE? WOMAN HARRY COLLINS PRETENDS TO BE GW PHYSICIST JUDGE ALSO GW PHYSICIST GW PHYSICIST

NATURE 6 July 2006

Blind Sighted Experimental configurations JUDGES IMITATES Sighted Blind

2 12 Don’t know equivalents Net right guesses Net wrong guesses CHANCE IDENTIFY Blind p= Imitation Game tests with the blind The blind Proportion net correct guesses (right-wrong) Remainder 0.86

RESPONDENT 1JUDGERESPONDENT 24 PHASE 2 JUDGES I watch Wimbledon a little bit on the television and occasionally the Australian Open in January So let me start with sport. Are you interested in tennis and do you ever watch it on the television? I like tennis but only watch big tournaments like Wimbledon 1) I think respondent 1 gives himself away when he discusses the human judgments on the flight of a tennis ball. 2) I cannot believe a sighted person saying that Hawk- eye does not alter the viewing. 3) The Hawk-Eye questions reveal some quite specific information that I don’t think was published in audio media. Also, the story wasn’t that important that I’d expect it to be picked up by the audio news services provided to the blind. 4) person 2 seems really unfamiliar with hawk-eye, given that they say they watch Wimbledon Not being a tennis professional it is not for me to say if it should or should not be used. It does not really alter viewing So tell me what you think about the Hawk-Eye line judging system It adds an other element to the game which could make it more interesting I assume it’s the same technology in cricket and in cricket, Hawk- Eye is between two and four mm out. If it is the same for tennis, then it is probably still more accurate than the human eye. If the players are happy with it and the umpires are happy with it then they should continue using Hawk-Eye But I want to know whether you think that the umpire or the players could ever make a better judgment than Hawk-Eye There is always a degree of uncertainty with both people and technology I think often a tennis player is not in a position to judge accurately as they are not usually parallel with the line. I think that if you set up a test for a line judge with two balls one which landed on the line and one which landed 1mm away from the line, I don't think they could tell the difference. If you think how small 1mm is then it would be so hard for them to judge. How accurately would you say a human can judge the flight of a tennis-ball? I mean, would you say they could tell the difference between touch the line and 1mm out 2mm out 1 cm out, 2 cm out, or what, and what would it depend on? it would depend on the speed the ball was travelling and the position of the judge relative to the line and obviously the closer the ball is the line the harder it would be to make a judgement. So you would have to judge each call on an individual bases as there are a lot of factors. Qualitative data

IR = Identify condition on right COLOR- BLIND P’FECT PITCH BLIND SEX- UALITY RELIGION GENDER f m GENDER old young Chance IR Identify IR Effect Size Fisher Test New method for comparative social analysis + ethnicity IMGAME

JUDGE has target expertise How we play the game now Step 1 Judge Pretender Non-Pretender If you are player A you start by playing the judge role and then you switch between all three roles as convenient You play with B as Pretender C as Non- Pretender D as Judge E as Non- Pretender F as Pretender G as Judge You communicate with a computer program which controls the games and links all the right players together as they switch from role to role. Dashes mean no visible communication. PARTICIPANT has target expertise PARTICIPANT pretends to have target expertise

Player screen: Judge tab

Non-pretender tab

Player screen: Judge tab

The ‘Stasi’ screen

Network crash and recovery

Seating plan

How we play the game now PARTICIPANT has target expertise JUDGE has target expertise PARTICIPANT pretends to have target expertise X c24 c200 NEW PRETENDER ANSWERS 24 SETS OF NON- PRETENDER ANSWERS 24 sets of questions c200 NEW DIALOGUES DISCARD c200 NEW JUDGMENTS S1 S2 S3 S4 FILTER

What we had done on ERC grant at turn of the year

Religion results Palermo, Wroclaw, Budapest, Cardiff, Helsinki, Trondheim, Rotterdam

South Africa results 66% 95% W->B B->W

At Step1 each role now taken by small group Judge Pretender Non-Pretender If you are player A you start by playing the judge role and then you switch between all three roles as convenient You play with B as Pretender C as Non- Pretender D as Judge E as Non- Pretender F as Pretender G as Judge You communicate with a computer program which controls the games and links all the right players together as they switch from role to role. Dashes mean no visible communication. PARTICIPANT has target expertise JUDGE has target expertise PARTICIPANT pretends to have target expertise

Group Games Effect Pass rates 57% 84%

Group Games Effect Pass rates 36% 70% As of now, confirmed by two further results

Masquerade

END