Intentionally Blank Slide. System, Construction and Integration Issues for Long Distance, High Capacity, Ceramic HTSC dc Cables Paul M. Grant Visiting.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The SuperCable: Dual Delivery of Chemical and Electric Power
Advertisements

SuperGrid As SuperTie Paul M. Grant Visiting Scholar in Applied Physics, Stanford University EPRI Science Fellow (retired) IBM Research Staff Member Emeritus.
Superconducting Lines for the Transmission of Large Amounts of Power over Great Distances Paul M. Grant Visiting Scholar in Applied Physics, Stanford University.
Concept Design Review (CoDR) Shore Station DC Breaker Cable model Transient Analysis Components.
So Far: Conservation of Mass and Energy Pressure Drop in Pipes Flow Measurement Instruments Flow Control (Valves) Types of Pumps and Pump Sizing This Week:
SCDC Cables Pitfalls and Potential (or vice versa) Paul M. Grant W2AGZ Technologies DOE Wire Development Workshop, Panama.
Solid Targets for the Neutrino Factory J R J Bennett Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Chilton, Didcot, Oxon, OX11 0QX, UK
Outline Simulations of DC circuits SimulationsSimulations AC circuits Power transmission and losses Power generation methods.
Electrify Me! Electricity Basics.
Chemical, Biological and Environmental Engineering Generating Electricity.
Superconducting Large Bore Sextupole for ILC
In this section you will:
Powering Progress EPRI P.M. Grant DOE Peer Review 23 July 1997 Superconductivity and Electric Power: Several Future Scenarios Paul M. Grant EPRI DOE Peer.
Possible topics for last 2 weeks (votes on first day of class) (1 point for first, 2 for second etc.) Hydrogen economy (128) Nuclear Power (fission/fusion)
Suppose that a voltage surge produces 140 V for a moment in a 120 V-line. What will temporarily be the output of a 100 W lightbulb assuming its resistance.
2005/08/03 dc Superconducting Power Transmission Line in Chubu University Presented by S. Yamaguchi
DC Superconductor Cables for Long Distance Transmission 2009 Mid-America Regulatory Conference Traverse City, MI June 14-17, 2009.
Power Lines The power transmission line is one of the major components of an electric power system. Its major function is to transport electric energy,
Frankfurt (Germany), 6-9 June 2011 Alex Geschiere Liandon member of Alliander Alex Geschiere – Netherlands – Session 1 – 1256 Superconducting cables A.
SuperGrid Update (Milwaukee, 3 April 2003).1. SuperGrid Update (Milwaukee, 3 April 2003).2 SuperGrid Update EPRI Superconductivity Working Group 3 April.
Heat Transfer Equations For “thin walled” tubes, A i = A o.
Activities and Plans in the US Paul M. Grant W2AGZ Technologies San Jose, CA USA “A Sober Assessment of Opportunities and Realities”
High-Capacity Superconducting dc Cables Paul M. Grant Visiting Scholar in Applied Physics, Stanford University EPRI Science Fellow (retired) IBM Research.
Superconducting Lines for the Transmission of Large Amounts of Power over Great Distances Paul M. Grant Visiting Scholar in Applied Physics, Stanford University.
EPRI SCDC Cable Review Meeting Palo Alto 24 th October 2006 Meeting May 22-26th Sevenoaks UK Progress since.
Superconducting Fault Current Limiters
Intentionally Blank Slide. The EPRI SuperGrid Initiative -Update- Paul M. Grant Visiting Scholar in Applied Physics, Stanford University EPRI Science.
The SuperGrid: Combined Delivery and Storage of Electricity and Hydrogen Paul M. Grant 26 Juin 2003 Meudon, France P. M. Grant, (Electric Power Research.
NATO ASI Applications of Superconductivity Loen, Norway - June, 1997 Cables for Power Systems P. M. Grant Cables for Power Systems Paul M. Grant Electric.
Superconductivity: Power in the Fast Lane
Intentionally Blank Slide. Superconductivity & Power Cables Paul M. Grant Visiting Scholar in Applied Physics, Stanford University EPRI Science Fellow.
P. M. Grant 8 December 1998 Superconductivity: Energy Pipeline for the 21st Century Paul M. Grant
MgB 2 wire application to high power superconducting dc cables Paul M. Grant R1.039: 13:30 5 March March 2002 Austin, TX Austin, TX R1 – Poster.
Magnet for ARIES-CS Magnet protection Cooling of magnet structure L. Bromberg J.H. Schultz MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center ARIES meeting UCSD January.
P. M. Grant 17 November 1998 The Energy-Environment Problem and Superconductivity Technology Paul M. Grant.
Superconductivity and Electric Power P. M. Grant 27 November 1997 Superconductivity and Electric Power Paul M. Grant Strategic Science & Technology Electric.
The SuperGrid: Symbiosis of Nuclear, Hydrogen and Superconductivity Paul M. Grant EPRI Science Fellow (retired) IBM Research Staff Member Emeritus Principal,
MgB 2 and its application to electric power Paul M. Grant AME4-E-o1-2002: 9:15 1 May 2002 (228) St. Louis, MO 28 April – 1 May 2002.
Super. Cable Combined Storage & Delivery of Electricity & Hydrogen.
SuperCable: Combined Delivery and Storage of Electricity and Hydrogen
SuperCities and SuperGrids: A Vision for Long-term Sustainable and Environmentally Compatible Energy Paul M. Grant EPRI Science Fellow (retired) IBM Research.
Cryo-Delivery Systems for the Co-Transmission of Chemical and Electrical Power Paul M. Grant Visiting Scholar in Applied Physics, Stanford University EPRI.
Heat Transfer Equations For “thin walled” tubes, A i = A o.
Cooling System Solutions
The SuperGrid: Combined Delivery and Storage of Electricity and Hydrogen Paul M. Grant 2 July 2003 Oak Ridge, TN P. M. Grant, (Electric Power Research.
1 Small Coolers for MICE Michael A. Green University of Oxford Department of Physics Oxford OX1 3RH, UK MICE Collaboration Meeting RAL.
Superconducting Technologies for the Next Generation of Accelerators CERN, Globe of Science and Innovation 4-5 December Superconducting Links for the Hi-Lumi.
E. Todesco, Milano Bicocca January-February 2016 Appendix C: A digression on costs and applications in superconductivity Ezio Todesco European Organization.
EPRI P. M. Grant ISTEC Mission Visit 21 November 1997 ISTEC Mission Visit Paul M. Grant Strategic Science & Technology Electric Power Research Institute.
5 K Shield Study of STF Cryomodule (up-dated) Norihito Ohuchi KEK 2008/4/21-251FNAL-SCRF-Meeting.
ASC 98 Poster P. M. Grant & T. P. Sheahen Monday, 14 September 1998 Cost Projections for High Temperature Superconductors Paul M. Grant & Thomas P. Sheahen.
Potential Electric Power Applications for MgB 2 Paul M. Grant 26 November 2001 Boston, Nov 2001 E1: New Superconductors I – MgB 2.
Energy Modeling Forum Potential Transformations Through Science - The SuperGrid Vision - Paul M. Grant Visiting Scholar in Applied Physics, Stanford IBM.
PHYSICS – Electromagnetic effects (1). LEARNING OBJECTIVES Core Show understanding that a conductor moving across a magnetic field or a changing magnetic.
Efficient Energy Transmission using HVDC
HVDC Transmission.
P. M. Grant14 July 1999 HTS Wire C/P UpdateMontreal Cost/Performance Update on HTS Wires & Tapes Paul M. Grant
Design for a 2 MW graphite target for a neutrino beam Jim Hylen Accelerator Physics and Technology Workshop for Project X November 12-13, 2007.
High Temperature Superconducting (HTS) Cable Project
The SuperCable: Dual Delivery of Chemical and Electric Power Paul M. Grant EPRI Science Fellow (retired) IBM Research Staff Member Emeritus Principal,
Announcements Please read Chapters 4 and 5 (skim 4.7, 4.11, 4.12)
Devices used for Grid scale AC-DC and DC-AC power conversion
Small Coolers for MICE MICE Collaboration Meeting RAL Michael A. Green
RED Which circuit above is a parallel circuit? Draw!
Electric Potential.
HVDC Transmission Systems:
RED 3. Switch 4. Series 5. Decreases
High Current Direct Current (HCDC) Superconductor Cable
Intentionally Blank Slide
S8P5 [details] Students will recognize characteristics of gravity,
Presentation transcript:

Intentionally Blank Slide

System, Construction and Integration Issues for Long Distance, High Capacity, Ceramic HTSC dc Cables Paul M. Grant Visiting Scholar in Applied Physics, Stanford University EPRI Science Fellow (retired) IBM Research Staff Member Emeritus Principal, W2AGZ Technologies 6 th Pacific Rim Conference on Ceramic & Glass Technology 11 – 16 September 2005, Maui, HA PACRIM-S , 12 September, 4:10 PM Garwin-Matisoo Revisited!

“A Thread Across the Ocean” “The Story of the Trans-Atlantic Cable (1854 – 1866)” John Steele Gordon

Atlantic Cable Timeline & Designs 1857 “Broke” 1858 “Worked for a Month” 1865 “Parted” (Recovered in 1866) 1866 Success! 2 $/m (2005) $/kA  m

Cable Laying by Ship

What Kept Them Going? The investors knew, that if communications with Europe could be cut from 2 weeks to 2 minutes, they’d all get… FILTHY RICH! –Estimates are that the total cost of the project in 2005 dollars was $100 M –1867 revenue in 2005 dollars was $10 M –Go figure…

The After-Story

Could dc Cables be the HTSC “Thread?” Advantages of dc –Only dc can go long distances –Allows asynchronous connection of ac grids –Power flow can be controlled quickly (HTSC?) Advantages of HTSC dc –Can wheel enormous amounts of power over very long distances with minimal loss

dc Transmission Lines 101 (for “policy makers”)

dc vs. ac: ABB Itaipu Study

Sayerville, NJ → Levittown LI, NY MW (+/- 250 kV, 1200 A) - 65 miles (105 km) - $400 M Pirelli (GS) Energy Cables $190 M T 77 K C/P $/kA×m Cost ($M) Cu71.8 HTSC Financials 40 4%: $ 20M LOM: 1 M NOI (100%): 5 M

Financials $750 M ($400 M “VC”, $350 M “Futures”) Loan Payment (4%, 40 yrs, 750 M$) =35 M$/yr Labor, Overhead, Maintenance = 5 M$/yr Tariff = 0.5 ¢/kWh Profit 50% Capacity = 4 M$/yr Profit Full Capacity = 48 M$/yr Specifications MW HVDC Bipolar Circuits Circuit 1: 130 miles, Greene County → Bronx County Circuit 2: 140 miles, Albany County → New York County Each Circuit: +/- 500 kV, 1000 A Bipolar (2 cables ea.) Why didn’t it go forward? HTSC Cost = $87 M

Two IBM Physicists (1967) Nb 3 Sn (T C = K 100 GW (+/- 100 kV, 500 kA) 1000 km Cost: $800 M ($8/kW) (1967) $4.7 B Today!

G-M Specs

LASL SPTL ( ) Specifications 5 GW (+/- 50 kV, 50 kA) PECO Study (100 km, 10 GW)

BICC HTSC dc Cable (1995) Design Target 400 MW, 100 km Flowing He, 0.2 kg/s, 2 MPa, 15 – 65 K Cooling Losses: 150 kW Prototype Specs 400 MW –+/- 20 kV, 10 kA Length: 1.4 m Diameter: 4 cm He (4.2 – 40 K)

e-Pipe

e-Pipe Specs (EPRI, 1997) Capacity 5 GW (+/- 50 kV,50 kA) Length1610 km Temperature Specs: - 1 K/10 65 K - 1 W/m heat input kliters LN 2 /hr kW coolers gal/min Vacuum: – torr - 10 stations - 10 km spaced kW each

e-Pipe/Gas/HVDC Cost Comparison US cents/kWh Miles HTSC 65 K) beats HVDC and Gas!

I I HV Insulation “Super- Insulation” Superconductor Liquid Nitrogen DODO D cryo t sc HTSC SuperCable Garwin – Matisoo Revisited ! Why Monaxial? - Simple - Known Dielectric - Easy to Install & Service

SuperCable Parameters Power = 5 GW Voltage = 25 +/- kV Current =100 kA Jc = A/cm^2 Dcryo = 5 cm A* = cm^2 t(sc) = cm R* = cm B = 0.8 T

AMSC Tape Jc(T, B) Parallel De-rating Factor 0.8 T I’m not going to show you the perpendicular data!

High Amplitude Transient Current Losses (ac & energize) Io (A)F (Hz)H (W/m) 100, × ,0001/hour ,0001/day0.01 Possibly could reverse line in one hour! “Bean Model”

Small Amplitude Losses (Load Fluctuations) Δ (%)ΔI (A)ΔP (MW)H (W/m) × × × × Load Fluctuation Losses over a 1 hour period OK, as long as changes occur slowly!

Small Amplitude Losses (Load Fluctuations) …and sometimes even when they’re fast! Consider 1 MW worth of customers coming in and out every millisecond, (e.g., 10,000 teenagers simultaneously switching 100 W light bulbs on and off) resulting in ΔI = 20 A, but a heat load of only 10 μW/m

Small Amplitude Losses (Ripple) Δ (%)ΔI (A)ΔP (MW)H (W/m) Phase Converter: F = 360 Hz

Radiative Heat In-Leak W R = 0.5εσ (T 4 amb – T 4 SC )/(n-1), where W R = Power radiated in as watts/unit area σ = 5.67× W/cm 2 K 4 T amb = 300 K T SC = K ε = 0.05 per inner and outer tube surface D SC = 5 cm n = number of layers of superinsulation (10) Then W R = 0.2 W/m

Fluid Dynamics of Liquid Nitrogen Flow through a 5-cm Diameter Pipe at 1 bar TKTK  kg/m 3   Pa×s  2 /  ndyne V m/s Re Thus, it takes about dynes “push” on an object to overcome viscous forces exerted by the liquid nitrogen

Friction Losses arising from pumping LN 2 through a 5-cm pipe at a flow rate of 4 m/s W loss = M P loss / , Where M = mass flow per unit length P loss = pressure loss per unit length  = fluid density  = mm (stainless steel) W loss (W/m) 77 K K4.05 Colebrook- Weymouth Equation

Heat to be Removed by LN 2 dT/dx = W T /(ρvC P A), where dT/dx = Temp rise along cable, K/m W T = Total Heat Generated per unit Length ρ = Density v = Flow Rate (4 m/s) C P = Heat Capacity A = Tubular Area (D = 5 cm) TKTK  kg/m 3 C P J/kg × m W T W/m dT/dx  K/km To offset a 1 K temperature increase, refrigeration stations would be needed every 2.5 km – way too close!

To-Do List Fine-Tune All Parameters –Diameter, Flow Rate, Temperature, Pressure, Power –Site Preparation, Materials Delivery and Construction Magnetic Field Issues – Anelastic losses (conductor tapes) –Spacing of Monopoles (2 100,000 A cables 1 m apart experience a mutual force of 2000 N/m!) Engineering Economy Study –How important really is wire cost? –How big a project for a reasonable NOI (size matters!)? Find a Commercial Opportunity!

Take-Home Reading Assignment 1.Garwin and Matisoo, 1967 (100 GW on Nb 3 Sn) 2.Edeskuty, 1972 (LASL dc SPTL, 5 GW, PECO) 3.Lasseter, et al., 1994 (HTSC dc Networks) 4.Beale, et al., 1996 (BICC HTSC dc, 400 MW) 5.Grant, 1996 (Promises, promises…ASC 96) 6.Schoenung, Hassenzahl and Grant, 1997 (5 GW on LN 2, 1000 km) 7.Proceedings, SuperGrid Workshops, 2002 & Neptune HVDC Cable, Grant, “London Calling,” Nature review of “Thread Across the Ocean.” …and there will be a quiz next time I see you all!