Ontario Sustainable Electricity Project The Pembina Institute and The Canadian Environmental Law Association April 2005.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
California Energy Commission 1 Energy Workshops for W&WW Agencies UTILITY STRATEGIES FOR SHIFTING PEAK DEMAND PERIOD WATER & ENERGY USE REGIONAL STRATEGIES:
Advertisements

BG&E’s PeakRewards SM Demand Response Program Successful Approaches for Engaging Customers August 20, 2014.
Sustainable Energy Policies for British Columbia BC Sustainable Energy Association April 2005.
NARUC 2015 Winter Meeting February 16, 2015 Combined Heat and Power and the Clean Power Plan Bruce Hedman Institute for Industrial Productivity.
A 2030 framework for climate and energy policies Energy.
Overview of Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) Program San Antonio Office of Environmental Policy December 16, 2009.
Tenth Annual Midwest Energy Conference March 7, 2007 How Best Satisfy Midwest Electric Load Growth? Thomas R. Casten Chairman Recycled Energy Development.
1.  Purpose  To present Staff’s Preliminary Findings on the 2012 Integrated Resource Plans of:  APS – Arizona Public Service Company  TEP – Tucson.
1 WGA Clean and Diversified Energy Advisory Committee Briefing Brian Horii Energy and Environmental Economics, Inc
Energy Efficiency and Arizona’s Energy Future Jeff Schlegel Southwest Energy Efficiency Project (SWEEP) April
STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTION OF ENERGY EFFICIENT AND CLEANER TECHNOLOGIES IN THE POWER SECTOR Synthesis Report Issue 1: Implications of Carbon & Energy Taxes.
Understanding Ontario’s Electricity System
Connecticut’s Energy Future Removing Barriers to Promote Energy Sustainability: Public Policy and Financing December 2, 2004 Legislative Office Building.
State Incentives for Energy Efficiency Commercial and Industrial New Jersey Board of Public Utilities Office of Clean Energy Mona L. Mosser Bureau of Energy.
Potential Impacts of an Advanced Energy Portfolio Standard in Pennsylvania Ryan Pletka, P.E. Black & Veatch April 12, 2004 Supported by: Heinz Endowments.
Environmental Fundamentals of Alternatives Presentation for CEA/NRCan Workshop: Diversifying the Mix - Alternatives to Conventional Generating Technology.
EU Energy Strategy
SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REGULATION AND POLICY-MAKING FOR AFRICA Module 14 Energy Efficiency Module 14: DEMAND-SIDE MANAGEMENT.
E NERGY, E NVIRONMENT AND S USTAINABILITY Gaurav Shukla CUTS International.
World Bank Experience with Power Sector Baselines Workshop on CDM Methodologies for Grid-Connected Power Projects Buenos Aires, 8 December 2004 Fernando.
Environment and Energy Htun Paw Oo 1 June Content Environment and Energy Ecosystem services The role of energy Myanmar energy context Way forward.
Rory McIlmoil, Downstream Strategies. Introduction to distributed energy The case for distributed renewable energy Opportunities for developing distributed.
E.ON on the Romanian Energy Market ZF Power Summit Bucharest, February 27, 2013 Frank Hajdinjak CEO E.ON România.
National Renewable Energy Laboratory Innovation for Our Energy Future * NREL July 5, 2011 Tradeoffs and Synergies between CSP and PV at High Grid Penetration.
April 29, 2015 Lucinda Smith Climate Action Plan Process.
Sixth Northwest Conservation & Electric Power Plan Discussion of Proposed Generating Resource Action Items Jeff King Northwest Power and Conservation Council.
RENEWABLE ENERGY POLICY. Renewable energy is energy that comes from resources which are continually replenished such as sunlight, wind, rain, tides, waves.
Renewable Energy: Legal and Policy Issues Frank Prager Vice President, Environmental Policy Xcel Energy November 20, 2009 Frank Prager Vice President,
Status: Karsten Brinkmann PowerMex-CHP_CO2 bensheim engineers CHP – one Possibility to reduce CO 2 Karsten Brinkmann Promotion for CHP Berlin.
1 EIA’s Electricity Forecasting for the U.S. and the South By: Marilyn Brown, Matt Cox, Alex Smith, and Xiaojing Sun Georgia Institute of Technology July.
COPYRIGHT © 2010 BALLARD POWER SYSTEMS INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED B A L L A R D P O W E R S Y S T E M S PUTTING FUEL CELLS TO WORK NOVEMBER 2010 Utilizing.
WIND ENERGY Is there a Latvian Master Plan? CHRISTIAN KJÆR Chief Executive Officer European Wind Energy Association SSE Riga, 4 December 2008 © EWEA/L.
Panel on Water, Food and Energy Overview of the Water & Energy issues and their linkages with food Richard Taylor, Executive Director, International Hydropower.
Renewable Energy in New Jersey’s Clean Energy Program Scott Hunter Renewable Energy Program Administrator, Office of Clean Energy in the New Jersey Board.
Oregon Renewable Energy Action Plan April 2005 with Geothermal Energy highlights by Carel DeWinkel Senior Policy Analyst.
Presentation to the: Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Demand-Side Response Working Group December 8, 2006 Gas Utility Decoupling in New Jersey A.
Developing and Integrated Energy Conservation and Renewable Strategy Renewable Energy Leadership Summit June 7, 2005 Lenox, MA.
[Legislative] [American policy] Passing of the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act (PURPA) in Introduced competition within the supply sector.
Energy efficiency in buildings Monga Mehlwana Tuesday, 05 October 2010.
Solar Energy John Holecek ESP Global Energy production Total Energy Production (Wh) (1.1 E17) Electricity Production (Wh)
Creating and Sustaining Clean Energy Markets Sustainable Energy Fund Energy Service Provider Conference Hershey, PA January 29, 2011.
Selecting Renewable Projects at Colorado Springs Utilities APPA Conference John Romero GM Acquisition, Engineering and Planning October, 2009.
Renewable Energy Policies: China’s Scale-Up Story Dr. Xiaodong Wang Senior Energy Specialist EASIN, the World Bank SDN Week, Energy Day February 23, 2012.
COMMUNITY CHOICE AGGREGATION: TECHNICAL STUDY RESULTS Peninsula Clean Energy September 24,2015.
A Year’s Progress and Promise for the Future. State Leadership Center for Climate Strategies.
Net Metering and Embedded Generation NB Climate Action Change Hub Advisory Committee Meeting – October 1, 2008 Saint John, NB Linda Berthelot.
RDL Utility Based Financial Incentives for Renewable Energy & Energy Efficiency in New Zealand EGNRET Workshop Honolulu, Hawaii, USA 30 March – 1 April,
“Demand Response: Completing the Link Between Wholesale and Retail Pricing” Paul Crumrine Director, Regulatory Strategies & Services Institute for Regulatory.
DG Toronto Hydro’s Perspective Task Force on Distributed Generation Richard Lü VP, Environment, Health & Safety March 5, 2003.
Weathering the Change Action Plan 2 ACT Climate Change Council 8 November 2011.
September 17, 2002 Van Jamison, POWAIR and Global Environment and Technology Foundation POLLUTION PREVENTION TEMPLATES WESTAR Technical Conference Snowbird,
The Power to Reduce CO 2 Emissions The Full Portfolio National Association of Utility Regulatory Commissioners Winter Committee Meetings Committee on Electricity.
The Canadian Approach To Compiling Emission Projections Marc Deslauriers Environment Canada Pollution Data Division Science and Technology Branch Projections.
What do we mean by “Energy?
Sixth Northwest Conservation & Electric Power Plan CHP in the Sixth Plan?? Jeff King Northwest Power and Conservation Council Generating Resources Advisory.
11/4/02 NW Energy Coalition Clean Electricity Options for the Pacific Northwest: An Assessment of Efficiency and Renewable Potentials through the year.
Presentation to Select Committee on Economic Development
Philippine Feed-In Tariff System Implementation 1.
Renewable Energy Act of 2008
CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION Page 1 Energy Policy Report Proceeding Docket 02-IEP-01 Staff Workshop Paper Publication F Sylvia Bender Demand.
CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION Why Peak Demand Offset Measures Are Necessary When There Is “Enough” Energy Lorraine White Advisory to Vice Chair Pfannenstiel.
Draft Seventh Power Plan Meets RTF. Key Finding: Least Cost Resource Strategies Rely on Conservation and Demand Response to Meet Nearly All Forecast Growth.
Institutional Support Vladimir Koritarov Argonne National Laboratory April 2016.
11 Regional Renewable Energy Study Review of Findings and Forecasts Presented to: Climate, Energy and Environment and Policy Committee Metropolitan Washington.
Renewables Readiness Assessment -Background Jensen Shuma IRENA - local consultant Dar es Salaam, 9 March 2016.
RENEWABLE ENERGY REGULATION IN KENYA KENYA-SPAIN MULTILATERAL PARTNERSHIP MEETING HELD AT CROWNE PLAZA Presented by Caroline Kimathi Asst Manager, Licensing.
Restructuring Roundtable March 24, 2017 Boston, MA

City Council April 30, 2018 Item 13
India Energy Congress 2013 Sustainable Sources of Energy February 2013.
Presentation transcript:

Ontario Sustainable Electricity Project The Pembina Institute and The Canadian Environmental Law Association April 2005

Ontario’s Electricity Situation Demand-Supply Plan and Collapse of DSM efforts Ontario Hydro Restructuring and Market Experiments NAOP and reliance on coal Health and Environmental Impacts Difficulties bringing nuclear facilities back on-line August 2003 blackout and reliability/security of supply concerns

Ontario’s Electricity Situation Projected end-of-life for existing nuclear and coal facilities Projected business as usual growth in demand

Pembina/CELA Project Four Questions: Potential contribution from end-use efficiency, cogeneration, fuel switching and demand response Potential contribution from low-impact renewables (wind, hydro, biomass) Supply options for remaining grid demand Policy framework for implementation

CIMS Analysis Developed by EMRG at Simon Fraser University Designed for the purpose of testing the macro and micro impact of energy policy options

CIMS Analysis Incorporates most detailed information available on current end-use technologies on a jurisdictional basis Considers cost and performance commercially available high efficiency technologies

CIMS Analysis CIMS used to project impacts of three types of policies against ‘business as usual’ projected demand Remove constraints on cogeneration Provide financial incentives for purchase of efficient technologies Provide innovative financing measures to reduce payback time on efficiency investments

CIMS ‘Business as Usual’ Outlook Projects grid demand of 180,000 GWh by 2020 Similar to IMO and ECSTF projections Uses Stats Can and NRCan energy price forecasts

CIMS Results

Reduction of 2020 demand to 107,000 GWh 73,500 GWh/Year reduction against ‘business as usual’ 41% reduction in demand against ‘business as usual’

CIMS Results Results reflect: Significant adoption of most efficient currently available technologies in all sectors by 2010 High levels of cogeneration in industrial and commercial sectors Large shift from electric to natural gas heating

CIMS Results Largest savings from: Commercial/institutional building shell and HVAC, and lighting improvements Elimination of electric hot water heating in residential and commercial/institutional sectors Provision of innovative financing to reduce perceived payback period for efficiency investments has largest impact on behaviour

Impact on Natural Gas Consumption Increase of 130 PJ in gas consumption by 2020 attributable to fuel switching and increased cogeneration 12% higher than business as usual projection

Societal Costs and Benefits of Efficiency Gains Total investment $18.2 billion over % recovered through energy savings Net savings for industrial and institutional/commercial sectors Net costs for residential sector of $6 per person per year Does not take into account health and environmental co-benefits of avoided generation

Peak Capacity Requirement Reduction Capacity requirement reduction from CIMS projections of efficiency, cogeneration and fuel switching (using IMO load factors) = 12,300 MW by 2020.

Additional Peak Reductions from Demand Response Potential shift of 10% Peak through Demand Response (Navigant consulting study for IMO)

Peak Load Shaving through Demonstration Projects 1000MW solar roof program to reduce peak demand 750MW. Addresses summer peaks

Peak Demand Reduction Summary 2010 Peak (MW)2015 Peak (MW)2020 Peak (MW) WinterSummerWinterSummerWinterSummer IMO Forecast for Peak Demand 26,00027,80026,50028,70028,00030,000 Peak Demand Reduction from Energy Efficiency, Fuel Switching, and Cogeneration (4,500) (8,900) (12,300) Demand Response Measures (2,330) (1,980 ) ( 1,770) On-Site Generation (250) (500) (750 ) Net Grid Peak Demand 19,17020,70015,620 17,32013,930 15,180

Renewable Supply Options Hydro Current Capacity 7600MW OWA indicates additional potential for MW Assume 2000MW new capacity including 600MW Niagara expansion Total 9600MW

Renewable Supply Options Wind OWPTF estimate of 3000 to 7000MW excluding offshore Good match between wind generation and peak demand and hydro storage Assumed 7000MW capacity by 2020 (on and off-shore)

Renewable Supply Options Biomass Landfill gas and biogas generation and combustion Assumed 800MW

Renewables Summary

9,800 MW installed renewable capacity, contributing 4,600MW to peak supply by 2020 Remaining grid requirement by 2020: 25,633GWh/4500MW Capacity Less than full replacement of current coal generation (36,946GWh in 2003)

Remaining Base load Options Imports Quebec/Manitoba Hydro Political, environmental and social risks Nuclear High and unpredictable capital costs Reliability, safety, waste management and life-cycle environmental concerns Integrated gasification combined cycle Reduced smog and acid rain precursors and heavy metals, but not GHGs relative to conventional coal

Remaining Base load Options Combined Cycle Natural Gas Highest efficiency Large reductions in smog and acid rain precursors, heavy metals and GHGs May imply need to expand pipeline capacity Long-term supply issues Transitional fuel to full reliance on renewables

Policy Implications – Efficiency Minimum efficiency standards and building codes raised to 2004 high efficiency levels by 2010/2012 Labeling of efficient technologies Planning Act amendments

Policy Implications – Efficiency Ontario Energy Board mandate and DSM incentive mechanism for all electrical utilities Mandate to include low income program delivery

Policy Implications – Efficiency Establishment of Ontario Sustainable Energy Authority Coordination Standards Development Assessment and demand forecasting Research Proposed Power Authority should be a division of sustainable energy authority

Policy Implications – Efficiency Rebate of sales tax and other financial incentives for 5 years to kick start market transformation Innovative financing programs in conjunction with utilities that allow efficiency investments to be paid out of savings Small (0.3 cents/KWh) system benefits charge to finance efficiency programs Access federal financing via Kyoto Protocol implementation agreement

Policy Implications – Peak Demand Reduction Demand response Time of use, time of day, critical peak pricing Interruptible or ripple supply rates Smart metering Peak Shaving Solar roofs program Net metering and removal of institutional barriers for on-site generators

Policy Implications – Renewables/Supply RPS for wind, hydro and biomass May include feed-in tariff Improved integration of dispatchable and intermittent power sources Analysis of renewable potential Land-use guidelines re: wind Long-term supply contracts for needed base load

Policy Implications – Costs to Government Significant number of efficiency initiatives run by utilities under DSM Incentive mechanism Administrative cost of many other efficiency programs covered by public benefits charge Efficiency incentive costs can be shared with Federal government (e.g. EnerGuide grant) Incremental cost of renewables and needed base load recovered through tariffs

Policy Implications – Cost to Government Primary costs to government: Tax rebates/grants (Ontario share) Administration of standards, codes and RPS