Harald Uhlig “Economics and Reality” J. of Macroeconomics 2012 Examines 4 points of view: 1.Economics is a science. 2.Economics is an art. 3.Economics.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Carrying Out an Investigation in Science

Advertisements

What is Social Theory?. Theory Harrington 2005: 1-3 Greek word theōria, opp. of praxis contemplation / reflection Reflection on the value and meaning.

Best Practice Precepts [... next] Arguments Arguments Possibility of the Impossible Possibility of the Impossible Belief, Truth, and Reality Belief, Truth,

Ch 1: What Economics Is About. Economic Definitions Scarcity is the condition in which our wants are greater than the limited resources available. Economics.

Popper On Science Economics Lawlor. What is and inductive inference? Example: “All Swans are white” Needs an observation to confirm it’s truth.

We Forgot Everything Keynes Taught Us Robert Skidelsky The Washington Post 19/10/2008.

Business Research Methods William G. Zikmund

Is Psychology a Science?

HON 200C Macroeconomics Instructor: Bernard Malamud –Office: BEH 502 Phone (702) 895 –3294 Fax: 895 – 1354 » Website:

Scientific Thinking - 1 A. It is not what the man of science believes that distinguishes him, but how and why he believes it. B. A hypothesis is scientific.

The role of theory in research

Introduction, Acquiring Knowledge, and the Scientific Method

Melissa Seeborg. Reasoning is the process of drawing inferences or conclusions from established knowledge Reasoning uses the audience’s existing knowledge.

Introduction to Social Science Research

Money, Output, and Prices Classical vs. Keynesians.

Accounting Theory & Practice OVERVIEW OF ACCOUNTING THEORY

Scientific Method Lab.

Progress in Economics As elusive as soap in the bath?

PARADIGMS These are frames of reference that are used for understanding things Different paradigms suggest different theories that in turn inspire different.

Introduction to Earth Science Doing Science.  Scientific method – a systemic approach to answering questions about the natural world  Sufficient observation.

1 Ch. 15: Expectations Theory and the Economy James R. Russell, Ph.D., Professor of Economics & Management, Oral Roberts University ©2005 South-Western.

Chapter 2: The Scientific Method and Environmental Sciences.

Literature and Ourselves Writing About Literature: Introduction.

What is Science ? Science has become synonymous with reliability, validity and certainty It is an activity characterized by three features : It is a search.

Biological Science.

Nature of Science. Science is a Tentative Enterprise  The product of the judgment of individuals  Requires individuals to defend their conclusions by.

Chapter 1 Psychological Science The Need for Psychological Science.

Revision Questions The Scientific Method. What is the Scientific Method? It is the only scientific way accepted to back up a theory or idea. It is the.

Economics for the 21 st Century An Introduction (Part 1) Henry B. Stobbs, MFA.

Introduction to Science.  Science: a system of knowledge based on facts or principles  Science is observing, studying, and experimenting to find the.

Introduction to Scientific Research. Science Vs. Belief Belief is knowing something without needing evidence. Eg. The Jewish, Islamic and Christian belief.

1 Economic Thinking At the start of class, we used the review questions at the end of chapter 1 to review the remaining concepts. I did not emphasize the.

The Scientific Method: Terminology Operational definitions are used to clarify precisely what is meant by each variable Participants or subjects are the.

Theories and Hypotheses. Assumptions of science A true physical universe exists Order through cause and effect, the connections can be discovered Knowledge.

RESEARCH METHODS The Nature of Science. WHAT IS SCIENCE? You can’t study psychology without being aware of what science is (Dyer 2006) Learning Objectives.

No 01. Chapter 1 Introduction to Macroeconomics. Chapter Outline What Macroeconomics Is About What Macroeconomists Do Why Macroeconomists Disagree.

Copyright  2004 McGraw-Hill Australia Pty Ltd PPTs t/a Microeconomics 7/e by Jackson and McIver Slides prepared by Muni Perumal, University of Canberra,

G544:DEBATES IS PSYCHOLOGY A SCIENCE?. Is Psychology a Science? Where do you stand and why? Yes No Justify!!!

Chapter 2: The Role of Economics

Lecture №1 Role of science in modern society. Role of science in modern society.

G544:DEBATES IS PSYCHOLOGY A SCIENCE?. Is Psychology a Science? Where do you stand and why? Yes No Justify!!!

The Nature of Science and The Scientific Method Chemistry – Lincoln High School Mrs. Cameron.

THE NATURE OF CAUSATION Free Will Vs. Determinism Causation in the natural sciences -- plants and nutrition Causality in the social sciences assumes determinism.

The Scientific Method. The scientific method is the only scientific way accepted to back up a theory or idea. This is the method on which all research.

Lesson 2: The Scientific Method. What is the Scientific Method? The Scientific Method is a logical and rational order of steps by which scientists come.

EXPERIENCE REASONING RESEARCH DEDUCTIVE AND INDUCTIVE REASONING Deductive Reasoning (Top-Down Approach) Deductive reasoning works from the more general.

Unit 4 Issues and Debates How far psychology is a science.

Introduction to Research Methodology

Chapter 1 The Nature and Method of Economics

Business Research Methods William G. Zikmund

Ch 1. Limits, Alternatives, & Choices

Research & Writing in CJ

Introduction to Research Methodology

Nature of Science, Chapter 1

Sociology & Science: Sociology is often referred to as a ‘Social Science’ but can it truly be classified as a science? Scientific methodology can be used.

Introduction to Research Methodology

Business Research Methods William G. Zikmund

Ch 1. Limits, Alternatives, & Choices

SCIENTIFIC INQUIRY Life Science 1.3 Mrs. Senese.

Market definition - does it help?

Part I: Introduction to Business economics

THE PROCESS OF SCIENCE.

Introduction to Research Methodology

Nature of Science Dr. Charles Ophardt EDU 370.

Introduction to Research Methodology

Research Methods.

FCAT Science Standard Arianna Medina.

Important Concepts Above and Beyond Biology I

Warm-up Natural Systems are usually “open systems.” How are open systems different than “closed systems?” Human actions create ___________ in all other.

Business Research Methods William G. Zikmund

Presentation transcript:

Harald Uhlig “Economics and Reality” J. of Macroeconomics 2012 Examines 4 points of view: 1.Economics is a science. 2.Economics is an art. 3.Economics is a competition. 4.Economics is politics. Examines specific cases for illustration and debate: 1.Is there a Phillips curve? 2.Are prices sticky? 3.Does contractionary monetary policy lead to a contraction in output? 4.What causes business cycles?

1. Economics is a Science Theory-led deductive approach Derive falsifiable predictions from a prior hypothesis (Popper (1934)) Vs. Empirically-grounded inductive approach Derive theoretical principles from careful observation Uhlig conclusion: Reality does guide economics. Empirical evidence influences and should influence economics, as in any scientific discipline, but there is not a single successful approach to do so.

2. Economics is an Art. Economists should not try to construct a “Theory of Everything.” Occam’s razor: The hypothesis with the fewest assumptions able to explain a given set of facts must be the correct one. “Beware of theorists bearing free parameters.” (Goldberger and Lucas) A good theory is false by design. The key is to summarize key facts that a good – and therefore minimalistic – theory is meant to capture. Uhlig conclusion: Reality influences economic thinking by guiding theorists to design beautiful, minimalistic theories that connect to a select set of key facts.

3. Economics is a Competition of Ideas How do economist decide which direction of research is correct, which line of inquiry is fruitful, which argument is convincing? McCloskey: Economics is rhetoric. Old theories are never really discarded. Economists love to hang on to beliefs once formed. Uhlig conclusion: New theories predict or explain new facts. Nonetheless, old theories stay around, whether they explain existing new and old facts or not.

4. Economics is Politics “Practical men, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influence, are usually the slaves of some defunct economist.” (Keynes, 1936, Ch. 24) There is a competition of ideas in practical politics as well. Uhlig concludes that “economic thinking at the practical level of economic policy is thick-skinned and conservative. It is rarely influenced by fresh economic theory or by fresh empirical evidence, unless it fits well with an agenda that had been established elsewhere already.”

1. Is there a Phillips Curve?

Phillips (1958)

Uhlig (2012)

2. Are prices sticky?

3. Does contractionary monetary policy lead to a contraction in output?

Effect of a positive shock to the fed funds rate (sign restrictions constrain the price response to be non-negative.)

4. What causes business cycles?