Alternate Delivery Methods and Sharing Contract Risk APTA - Business Member Board of Governors APTA - Business Member Board of Governors Mike Robertson.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Managing Your Staff.
Advertisements

CM/CG Contracting Tom Ravn, Mn/DOT Director, Office of Construction and Innovative Contracting.
Effective Contract Management Planning
Fawzy Al-Alami G Term Paper.  Introduction.  Effect of Teamwork in Design-Build. Construction Contract.  Factors Can Enhance Design-Build.
Twelve Cs for Team Building
Effective SBIR/STTR Proposal Responses How to Beat the Odds February 20, 2013.
PROJECT MANAGEMENT. What is project management? Define and scope project Determine tasks, schedule activities Perform work, coordinate, communicate Monitor.
Chapter 10 Schedule Your Schedule. Copyright 2004 by Pearson Education, Inc. Identifying And Scheduling Tasks The schedule from the Software Development.
Alternative Project Delivery
Chapter 3 Project Initiation
1 LaCrosse PMI Chapter Meeting A discussion about the Introduction of PM within your business 4/20/2011 Jim Strong Mayo Clinic DLMP PMO Director.
PROJECT SUCCESS THROUGH FACILITATED PARTNERING: UNLEASHING THE POWER OF COOPERATION & TEAMWORK.
Small Projects & Tailoring Using the PPA 1:15 – 2:15 Teresa Kinley, OPHPR With Panelists: Susan Wilkin, NCCDPHP Andy Autry, NCBDDD Carol Waller, NCEH/ATSDR.
Action Implementation and Monitoring A risk in PHN practice is that so much attention can be devoted to development of objectives and planning to address.
LEADERSHIP AND STRATEGIC PLANNING Source: John M Bryson and Barbara C. Crosby, “Leadership Roles in Making Strategic Planning Work,” in John M Bryson,
By Saurabh Sardesai October 2014.
IS&T Project Management: Project Management 101 June, 2006.
Managing Risk to Reduce Construction Claims (And Improve Project Success) Presented by Laurie Dennis, PE, CVS-Life, FSAVE.
IS&T Project Management: How to Engage the Customer September 27, 2005.
Pre-Project Planning Lessons from the Construction Industry Institute Construction Industry Institute Michael Davis, P. Eng, PMP Ontario Power Generation.
Managing Outsourced SW Projects Lesson Learned Manoj Singh, PMP.
NORMA GOMEZ, MBA, MSN, RN, CNN Unique Challenges for the Nephrology Professional in Managing Change.
Outsourcing: Managing Interorganizational Relations CHAPTER TWELVE Student Version Copyright © 2011 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Internal Auditing and Outsourcing
> taking best practice to the world International Experience with Performance Based Maintenance Contracts.
Shared Decision Making: Moving Forward Together
Acquisitions, a Publisher’s Perspective Craig Duncan Development Manager External Development Studio Building the partnership between.
Multidisplinary Approach.. What are your expectations Write on board.
1 Module 4: Designing Performance Indicators for Environmental Compliance and Enforcement Programs.
EMgt 4110 Engineering Professionalism and Practice
Be more effective at “planning the work and working the plan” Project Management Tips.
ABA Dispute Resolution Section Women in Dispute Resolution December 2014 Dispute Boards: An Introduction Deborah Bovarnick Mastin Law Office of Deborah.
An EDI Testing Strategy Rosemary B. Abell Director, National HIPAA Practice Keane, Inc. HIPAA Summit IV April 24-26, 2002.
Engaging in Effective Performance Discussions June 6, 2013.
November, 2000 Slide 1 Project Services Division RISK MANAGEMENT Project Services Division Presentation By: Adam Malkhassian November, 2000.
Building & Sustaining Your Local Team’s Efforts Seven Essential Factors to Consider for Successful Interagency Collaboration Stakeholders’ view of factors.
12-1 Project Management from Simple to Complex This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported.
1 Outsourcing: Managing the relationship Example: Reclining chair project FIGURE 12.1.
to Effective Conflict Resolution
1. 2 IMPORTANCE OF MANAGEMENT Some organizations have begun to ask their contractors to provide only project managers who have been certified as professionals.
A New Paradigm for Utility Coordination Kenny Franklin INDOT Director of Utilities and Railroads.
Programs That Succeed “Building Student Leadership Teams” The Key to Building Ownership in the Classroom John Chevalier CTE Instructor / Apple Certified.
Steps for Success in EHR Planning Bill French, VP eHealth Strategies Wisconsin Office of Rural Health HIT Implementation Workshop Stevens Point, WI August.
DESIGN-BUILD The Culture of Builders The “Design–Builder" is typically a general contractor. Some design–build firms employ professionals from both the.
1 Software Process Models-ii Presented By; Mehwish Shafiq.
1 The University of California Berkeley Extension X470 Project Management Lisa Bausell.
Chapter 7: A Summary of Tools Focus: This chapter outlines all the customer-driven project management tools and techniques and provides recommendations.
SacProNet An Overview of Project Management Techniques.
Technology Transfer Execution Framework. 2 © 2007 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved. Relationship Between Your EPRI Value and.
Community Board Orientation 6- Community Board Orientation 6-1.
Chapter 14: Using the Scalable Decision Process on Large Projects The process outlined is meant to be scaleable. Individual steps can be removed, changed,
Individual, Interpersonal, and Group Process Approaches
How To: A Process for Successful Partnerships. Partnership Definition A partnership IS: A written agreement between the parties. Mutual interest in, mutual.
Project Management Workshop James Small. Goals Understand the nature of projects Understand why Project Management is important Get an idea of the key.
FINAL PRESENTATION OF ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOUR AND ANALYSIS Prepared for : Dr. S. Kumar Group : Dollar 2 A. R. S. BANDARA - PGIA / 06 / 6317 B. A. G. K.
An EDI Testing Strategy Rosemary B. Abell Director, National HIPAA Practice Keane, Inc. HIPAA Summit V October 30 – November 1, 2002.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin© 2008 The McGraw-Hill Companies, All Rights Reserved Outsourcing: Managing Interorganizational Relations Chapter 12.
Planning to Plan Cheri Hayes Consultant to Nebraska Lifespan Respite Statewide Sustainability Workshop June 23-24, 2015 © 2011 The Finance Project. Used.
Community Engagement to Advance Mitigation Action.
Company LOGO. Company LOGO PE, PMP, PgMP, PME, MCT, PRINCE2 Practitioner.
1 1 Effective Administration of Commercial Contracts Breakout Session # Session D06 Name: Holly Walker, CPCM Corporate Learning Solutions and Contract.
Getting to the Root of the Problem Learn to Serve 501 Commons November 6, 2013 Bill Broesamle.
1 Working with Project Stakeholders in a Statewide Project PMI-SVC PMO Forum Monthly Meeting Dan Conway, PMP October 22, 2008.
Chapter 3: Strategy and Tactics of Integrative Negotiation
MAKING SENSE OF STRATEGY B301-B tutorial week 3
Alternate Delivery Methods and Sharing Contract Risk
The Two Most Common Types of Contemporary Planning Techniques
Designed for internal training use:
Outsourcing: Managing Interorganizational Relations
The Two Most Common Types of Contemporary Planning Techniques
Presentation transcript:

Alternate Delivery Methods and Sharing Contract Risk APTA - Business Member Board of Governors APTA - Business Member Board of Governors Mike Robertson Frontlines 2015 Program Management Group Utah Transit Authority January 11, 2008

Sharing Contract Risk Why do we contract? –Establish a relationship with others to accomplish work we cannot do ourselves Who do we contract with? –Multiple entities who share a common language but have a different culture

Sharing Contract Risk Honest Self Assessment Box the Risk Gathering the Right People Order of Importance

A Good Start Goes a Long Ways Honest Self Assessment –How do we want to work with our contractors? –What do we expect to accomplish? –What do we do best? –Where do we need help? –What problems can get in our way? Box the Risk – define the problem and create the mitigation plan –Perform enough investigation/design/evaluation to understand the nature and size of the risk? –Who has the most to gain when the problem is solved? –Who can solve the problem at the least cost and time? The Right People –Appropriate Delivery Method to acquire external needs (tailor this to your needs-not a set recipe) –Creative, Build Solution Oriented Relationships, Trusting, Experienced What is it How big is it Who can best solve it

Self Assessment Why am I Using a Creative Approach? –It’s a mandate!!! (malicious obedience) –Process/Schedule/Budget – Dictates a change –We want to do more - Great things are accomplished by a group of people working together at what they do best. Maybe there is a better way!! (Gerber’s Strained Peas or Pumpkin Pie?) Form of Motivation Must Should Will Potential for Success

Self Assessment What are our objectives? –Positive Relationships w/Contractors and Stakeholders –Avoid Litigation and Costly Changes –Manage Risk - Coordinated effort –Value Engineering –Resolve Technical Complexity –Early Fixed Price- Increased knowledge at an earlier date –Shortened Schedule –Reduced Internal Staffing –Funding Assistance –Meet Political Ambitions

Box the Risk Risk Assessment Exercises - Facilitated exercise with a broad group –Probability and Impact –Low, Medium and High –Start in the concept phase, End when the contract closes out, Refresh often Gather Information Internal –Business and Project Managers –Designers –Contractors –Real Estate, Legal, Finance –Utility & Permits –Operations and Maintenance –Legislative Liaison IMPACT PROBABILITY External –DOTs –FTA –Business Community –Cities/Counties –Utility Owners –AGC

Box the Risk Assign Risk - Think like a business –Mutually agree on who can best solve the issue and has the most incentive to do so. –Create incentives where valuable D-B-B provides incentive to contractor to increase scope and costs Public Involvement on the University Line Port of Long Beach - $6.8M instead of $600K Access Roads w/UP – Quick solution w/low current and future costs Flagging Costs – Lowest cost and partnered approach to mitigate probability of event

Appropriate Delivery Methodology Objective - Creation of the Appropriate Relationships with all Parties Establish Critical Factors for Success 1.Complete Self Assessment 2.Establish goals, objectives, interests, obstacles, etc 3.Define Contractor and Major Stakeholders objectives 4.Set criteria to measure success Evaluation of Options 5.Brainstorm “Best Fit” Process - incentivises all parties 6.Is that approach legal? Can it become legal? 7.Have others tried it? Can I alter a known approach? 8.Will the approach succeed?

The Right People Managing Risk - Relationships and Contracts “You can’t be bulletproof – Live in a safer neighborhood” May be a culture shock to existing staff. Manage the change effectively Pick the right contractor who can appreciate the owners interests Work to help the other parties meet their objectives. Corporate Identities Dissolve Contract codifies the approach – use as a tool not a weapon Share and Build Synergy

Common Success Stories Business Improvements –Problem solving (Access Roads and Fencing costs) Recognize the problems early Define Responsibility and Authority Regular events to address issues Whole team works to solve or avoid all problems –Value Engineering (Ogden Bridge) Weekly Event Systematic Process Share in Returns –Allow Time to set Cost and Schedule –Developed Cost and Schedule “envelope” Establish goals towards the low end Help everyone meet their objectives if you can “beat the target” – incentives –Attract the interest of the contracting community Pay on time Evaluate bonding requirements Incentive programs

Common Success Stories Build Synergy –Shared goals (University Line and the CCT) Incentives may help –Co-Locate Constant Communication Owner/Contractor/Designer/Stakeholders in one location Water cooler talk –Build each other up Have some fun together Celebrate Success Awards –Access the Team Work to provide new opportunities for growth Everyone may not like Pumpkin Pie

Key Points Figure out what you do best, Find the rest, and don’t settle for Second Best Bring the right people to the project Golden rule with all (no second class citizens) Communicate constantly Avoid/Solve problems effectively Select the appropriate contracting methodology – Tailor it to fit your needs