Are sham operations and placebos justifiable in research? Leslie J. Kohman, MD SUNY Upstate Medical University Syracuse, NY Cardiothoracic Ethics Forum:

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Respect for participants Dr Enoka Corea. maintaining the privacy of the participant by ensuring confidentiality ensuring that participants may withdraw.
Advertisements

24 April Elements of Research Ethics Review II Social Value Malik Fernando M.B.,Ch.B. (Bristol)
Is it True? Evaluating Research about a Therapy Allen F. Shaughnessy, PharmD, MmedEd Tufts University School of Medicine Department of Family Medicine.
Introduction to basic principles
天 津 医 科 大 学天 津 医 科 大 学 Clinical trail. 天 津 医 科 大 学天 津 医 科 大 学 1.Historical Background 1537: Treatment of battle wounds: 1741: Treatment of Scurvy 1948:
The Cochrane Reviews of Acupuncture Doris Hubbs, MD, FACP April 26, 2013.
Behavioral Research Chapter Three Ethical Research.
Clinical Trials Medical Interventions
Subject Selection and Recruitment David Wendler Department of Clinical Bioethics NIH, USA.
STANDARD Anything serving as a type or pattern to which other like things must conform (Stedman’s Medical Dictionary) STANDARD OF CARE The level at which.
Access to Drugs Balancing Personal Autonomy and Social Justice Richard Ashcroft Imperial College London.
PPA 691 – Seminar in Public Policy Analysis Lecture 1d – The Belmont Report.
International Research Ethics Jenell Coleman, M.D. Clinical Fellow, Reproductive Infectious Diseases, UCSF M.P.H. Candidate 2005, UCB March 1, 2005.
An Introduction to Clinical Epidemiology and Research Methodology
ETHICAL ASPECTS of PLACEBO SURGERY AAOS ETHICS COMMITTEE Matthew J. Matava, MD 1.
Placebo: Ethics and Alternatives Samuel Frank, MD Assistant Professor of Neurology Boston University School of Medicine.
MEDICAL RESEARCH AND CLINICAL TRIALS Rels 300 / Nurs October 2014.
Human Subject Research Ethics
Research Design Interactive Presentation Interactive Presentation
CME Disclosure Statement The North Shore LIJ Health System adheres to the ACCME's new Standards for Commercial Support. Any individuals in a position.
Ethical Issues in Pediatric Research: Placebo controlled trials for gastoesophogeal reflux Benjamin Wilfond MD Medical Genetics Branch National Human Genome.
Idara C.E.. Three ethical principles guides research with human participants. principle of Autonomy 1. The principle of Autonomy requires investigators.
James G. Anderson, Ph.D. Purdue University
Lecture 16 (Oct 28, 2004)1 Lecture 16: Introduction to the randomized trial Introduction to intervention studies The research question: Efficacy vs effectiveness.
What makes Clinical Research Ethical? Dr Enoka Corea Co-secretary, ERC Faculty of Medicine, Colombo.
THE ETHICS OF PLACEBO-CONTROLLED RANDOMIZED CLINICAL TRIALS
Confounding and the Language of Experimentation Part II - Importance of Proper Comparisons and Randomization.
© Oxford University Press 2011 IB Testing new drugs Testing new drugs.
Effectiveness in Review & Oversight of Human Subjects Research Steven Joffe, MD, MPH Assistant Professor of Pediatrics.
1 Ethical issues in clinical trials Bernard Lo, M.D. February 10, 2010.
Placebo-Controls in Short-Term Clinical Trials of Hypertension Sana Al-Khatib, MD, MHS Assistant Professor of Medicine Division of Cardiology Duke University.
Clinical equipoise & the RCT dilemma
MEDICAL ETHICS ETHICS PROJECT. MEDICAL ETHICS MEDICAL ETHICS STUDIES PRINCIPLES OF RIGHT AND WRONG FOUR PRINCIPLES OF MEDICAL ETHICS AUTONOMY JUSTICE.
EBC course 10 April 2003 Critical Appraisal of the Clinical Literature: The Big Picture Cynthia R. Long, PhD Associate Professor Palmer Center for Chiropractic.
Good Research, Bad Choices? Mary Coombs. What Makes Something Research Rather Than Treatment?
Experimental studies Jean-François Boivin 25 October 2010.
Providing Research Results to Participants David Shalowitz Department of Clinical Bioethics National Institutes of Health Pre-conference Program: Advanced.
The ethical conduct of research with human participants Nancy E. Kass, ScD Department of Health Policy and Management Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of.
The Cochrane Reviews of Acupuncture Doris Hubbs, MD, FACP April 26, 2013.
WHS AP Psychology Research Methods: Experiments. I CAN ANSWER How do psychologists use the scientific method to study behavior and mental processes? What.
EXPERIMENTAL EPIDEMIOLOGY
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم جامعة أم درمان الإسلامية كلية الطب و العلوم الصحية - قسم طب المجتمع مساق البحث العلمي / الدفعة 21 Basics of Clinical Trials.
Cost-effectiveness of Screening Tests Mark Hlatky, MD Stanford University.
$100 $200 $400 $500 $300 $100 $200 $400 $500 $300 $100 $200 $400 $500 $300 $100 $200 $400 $500 $300 $100 $200 $400 $500 $300 Terms Clinical Trial Facts.
PTP 661 EVIDENCE ABOUT INTERVENTIONS CRITICALLY APPRAISE THE QUALITY AND APPLICABILITY OF AN INTERVENTION RESEARCH STUDY Min Huang, PT, PhD, NCS.
Idara C.E.. Three ethical principles guides research with human participants. principle of Autonomy 1. The principle of Autonomy requires investigators.
ETHICAL ISSUES AND INFORMED CONSENT Juan M. Lozano, MD, MSc Department of Paediatrics and Clinical Epidemiology Unit School of Medicine, Javeriana University.
Health Research. What is the placebo effect? An expectation of an effect gives that effect.
CCEB October 30 David J. Margolis MD PhD Associate Professor of Dermatology and Epidemiology Center for Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics University.
Human and Animal Research 1. What issues does this raise? 2.
Methodological Issues in Implantable Medical Device(IMDs) Studies Abdallah ABOUIHIA Senior Statistician, Medtronic.
Rene Descartes: “I think; therefore I am.”. 3.3: Data Ethics Statistics Chap 3: Designing Experiments.
Evidence in the research ethics application process
Analytical Interventional Studies
Is High Placebo Response Really a Problem in Clinical Trials?
Role of The Physical Therapist in Critical Inquiry
CLINICAL PROTOCOL DEVELOPMENT
Alcohol, Other Drugs, and Health: Current Evidence
Clinical Trials Medical Interventions
Chapter 7 The Hierarchy of Evidence
Cluster Randomized Trials
Ethical Principles of Research
Clinical Trials.
Outcome-adaptive randomization: some ethical issues
Ethical Issues in Medical Writing
Role of The Physical Therapist in Critical Inquiry
Greg Nezat CRNA, PhD CDR/NC/USN Chairman, IRB II
Ethics Review Morals: Rules that define what is right and wrong Ethics: process of examining moral standards and looking at how we should interpret and.
Ethical Theories and Principles in Clinical and Research
Presentation transcript:

Are sham operations and placebos justifiable in research? Leslie J. Kohman, MD SUNY Upstate Medical University Syracuse, NY Cardiothoracic Ethics Forum: Surgical Ethics Course April 25, 2015

Key Issues What makes research ethical? What is equipoise? What is the placebo effect? What is placebo surgery? Can placebo surgical trials be ethically justified?

Example: Chronic stable angina Fluctuating courses with spontaneous remissions associated with a placebo-response rate of 30 to 80% long history of apparently successful treatments that have been disproved by blinded, placebo-controlled trials

No benefit to IMA ligation vs. sham procedure 1959

What makes Clinical Research Ethical? Ezekiel J. Emanuel, MD, PhD; David Wendler, PhD; Christine Grady, PhD. JAMA. 2000;283(20): RequirementJustifying Ethical Values Social or Scientific ValueScarce resources and nonexploitation Scientific validityScarce resources and nonexploitation Fair subject selectionJustice Favorable risk-benefit ratioNonmaleficence, beneficence, nonexploitation Independent ReviewPublic accountability, minimizing influence of potential conflicts of interest Informed consentRespect for subject autonomy Respect for potential and enrolled subjects Respect for subject autonomy and welfare

What makes Clinical Research Ethical? Ezekiel J. Emanuel, MD, PhD; David Wendler, PhD; Christine Grady, PhD. JAMA. 2000;283(20): RequirementJustifying Ethical Values Social or Scientific ValueScarce resources and nonexploitation Scientific validityScarce resources and nonexploitation Fair subject selectionJustice Favorable risk-benefit ratioNonmaleficence, beneficence, nonexploitation Independent ReviewPublic accountability, minimizing influence of potential conflicts of interest Informed consentRespect for subject autonomy Respect for potential and enrolled subjects Respect for subject autonomy and welfare

Equipoise

What is the placebo effect?

Placebo Effect

May be very strong Hard to quantify Strongest in conditions that wax and wane, have spontaneous remissions (e.g. pain, depression, migraine, Parkinson’s, IBS) High levels of stress and rituals involved with surgery can lead to a strong placebo effect.

When is a placebo trial required from scientific standpoint? Existing therapies only partly effective or have serious side-effects Low frequency of condition means that an equivalence trial would have to be so large that it would reasonably prevent adequate enrollment and completion of study. Emanuel EJ, Miller FG. The Ethics of Placebo-controlled trials – a middle ground. NEJM 2001;345:915-9.

Placebome The study of genomic effects on placebo response There are genetic variations in neurotransmitter pathways that mediate placebo effects Future of placebo trials? – Screen to identify placebo responders Increase RCT efficiency Improve therapeutic care – Possibility of interaction between placebo and drug molecular pathways warrants consideration in RCTs.

Placebo surgery

Surgery and the Placebo Effect Intervention of surgery may have a particularly strong placebo effect Although risks seem higher, avoiding a procedure or implant of device that later turns out to be ineffective or in fact dangerous may be of great benefit to patient.

Is placebo surgery different from placebo medication? Placebo medication by itself has no risk Risks come from omission of treatment for the relevant condition, either to individual participant or a population Placebo surgery has risks (no surgery is without risk) Risks are greater if “sham” operation more closely resembles the real operation

Results of placebo surgery trials Stable angina – Ligation IMA – >50% in both groups substantial improvement in angina Vertebroplasty – Both groups substantial improvement in disability and pain Parkinson’s – fetal tissue transplant into brain – Neither group improved Knee pain – debridement vs. lavage. vs sham – All groups some improvement in disability and pain Migraine – decompression of cranial nerves – 1 randomized sham trial with excellent result Many methodological flaws

Continuous Variable Binary Variable

Does the researcher have an ethical responsibility to act in the best interests of subjects? Placebo Surgery appears to violate the principles of beneficence and nonmaleficence This confounds the ethics of clinical care vs. those of clinical research ? ?

Summary Placebo surgery is inherently different than placebo medication It can be equally justified and ethical if strict guidelines are followed – Clinical equipoise exists (honest disagreement) – Scientifically valid study design – Risks and harms minimized – Subjects fully informed

References 1.Cobb LA, Thomas GI, Dillard DH, Merendino KA, Bruce RA. An evaluation of internal-mammary-artery ligation by a double-blind technic. N Engl J Med 1959;260: Emanuel EJ, MD, PhD; David Wendler, PhD; Christine Grady, PhD What Makes Clinical Research Ethical? JAMA. 2000;283(20): Freedman B, Equipoise and the ethics of clinical research. 1987;N Engl J Med 317: Horng S, Miller FG. Is placebo surgery unethical? N Engl J Med, Vol. 347, No Moseley JB, O’Malley K, Petersen NJ, et al. A controlled trial of arthroscopic surgery for osteoarthritis of the knee. N Engl J Med 2002;347: Wartolowska K, Judge A, Hopewell S et al. Use of placebo controls in the evaluation of surgery: systematic review. BMJ 2014;348:g3253 doi: /bmj.g Weijer C. I need a placebo like I need a hole in the head. J Law, Medicine & Ethics 2002;30:69-72.

Amended October, 2013