Role and Components of Project Evaluation

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
UNIT 1 CONCEPT OF MANAGERIAL ECONOMICS (continue)
Advertisements

Feasibility Study Preparation Venelina Varbova. Session Overview  Purpose of the Feasibility Study  The Feasibility Study process according.
4. Project Investment Decision-Making
0 Role of Economic Analysis in Cost-Benefit Analysis.
MBA (Trimester) Term V Module Title : Project Finance and Management
CONCEPTS of VALUE. FACTORS OF VALUE UTILITY –THE ABILITY OF A PRODUCT TO SATISFY HUMAN WANTS. RELATES TO THE DAMAND SIDE OF THE MARKET. SCARCITY –THE.
Investment Appraisal and Management Chapter 1 The Role of Project Evaluation.
Lecture(2) Instructor : Dr. Abed Al-Majed Nassar
CISB444 - Strategic Information Systems Planning
Project planning Lecture 1 6/10/20151Dr. Joshua Onono.
IE673Session 11 - Cost of Quality1 Cost of Quality.
Differential Analysis: The Key to Decision Making
Chapter 2 A Strategy for the Appraisal of Public Sector Investments.
NextEnd. Preparation of Business Plan for Setting up Enterprise Business Plan.. The business plan is a written document prepared by the entrepreneur that.
Supplier Selection & Evaluation
LECTURE ESSENCE AND STRUCTURE OF BUSINESS PLAN. 1.The concept of business – plan 2.Contents (parts) of business plan.
Introduction ► This slide deck provides a suggested framework for the financial evaluation of an investment project. When evaluating any such project,
0 Lecture Notes ECON 437/837: ECONOMIC COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS Lecture One.
Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA): Overview
Strategic Capacity Planning for Products and Services Copyright © 2015 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without.
Project Planning and Capital Budgeting
Return, Income, Value and Capitalization Learning objectives: –Understand the meaning of investment decision making. –Understand the role of the appraisal.
Why are economic and financial instruments needed? A presentation made by Noma Neseni, IWSD.
PEIP National workshop in Montenegro: developing environmental infrastructure projects in the water sector Feasibility Study Preparation Venelina Varbova.
PROJECT IDENTIFICATION AND FORMULATION
Last Update 26/02/2007 Lecture Notes ECON 622 ECONOMIC COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS Lecture One.
Quality Control Project Management Unit Credit Value : 4 Essential
Project preparation and appraisal. Preparation of project report and appraisal are intimately tied up.
1. Development Planning and Administration MPA – 403 Lecture 17 FACILITATOR Prof. Dr. Mohammad Majid Mahmood Bagram.
Ecosystem Services & their Role in Poverty Alleviation in Suynik Province, Armenia Armenia.
Ghent University – Department Agricultural Economics Project Management Financial and economic analysis of investment projects.
1 ECGD4214 Systems Engineering & Economy. 2 Lecture 1 Part 1 Introduction to Engineering Economics.
Developing and opening a new facility. Stages in hospitality facility development There are five (5) steps in the development of a hospitality facility:
Module 1 Session 1.3 Visual 1 Module 1 Understanding the Project and Project Management Session 1.3The Project Preparation/Analysis Process and the Hierarchy.
INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT AND PLANNING FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT 1 Click to edit Master title style 1 Analysis of the planning process Why and how? Session.
Welcome to Session 3 – Project Management Process Overview
1 of 27 How to invest in Information for Development An Introduction Introduction This question is the focus of our examination of the information management.
Project quality management. Introduction Project quality management includes the process required to ensure that the project satisfies the needs for which.
Overview of Fundamentals of Finance
Amity School of Business Economics for Managers: Gaurav Shreekant 1.
Feasibility Study.
The Business Plan: Creating and Starting the Venture
Financial Management (An Introduction). Contents of the Chapter Meaning of Finance Meaning of Financial Management Three Major Decisions of Financial.
Software Project Management
Understanding Financial Management
Managerial Economics. What is Managerial Economics???  It is the integration of economic principles with business management practices  It is essentially.
1 CS-19 Risk Tools and Modeling - Risk Tolerances and Limits Russ Bingham Vice President and Director of Corporate Research Hartford Financial Services.
Credit Rating Strategies in India Presented By: Cauvery Sharma (82008) Chetna Malhotra (82009) Kavya M. Chandra (82017) Neha Tandon (82026) Neha Malhotra.
Essay Skills 2 nd attempt!. Olde Edexcel Essay style! Feb 2010 UNIT 6 paper. 1. (a) Assess the impact on the world economy of the growth of regional trade.
NAMA potential of Vietnam Vuong Xuan Hoa Institute of Meteorology, Hydrology and Environment Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment Climate Change.
Dolly Dhamodiwala CEO, Business Beacon Management Consultants
Organizations of all types and sizes face a range of risks that can affect the achievement of their objectives. Organization's activities Strategic initiatives.
Develop Schedule is the Process of analyzing activity sequences, durations, resource requirements, and schedule constraints to create the project schedule.
EN Regional Policy EUROPEAN COMMISSION Francesco ANGELINI European Commission, DG for Regional Policy Coordination Unit – Major Projects Team.
Understanding the Integrated Resource Plan (IRP 2010 Rev 2)
Introduction and Overview
Chapter 1 Market-Oriented Perspectives Underlie Successful Corporate, Business, and Marketing Strategies.
The Feasibility Study: something we already know
Feasibility Study Preparation Venelina Varbova
Introduction and Overview
Capacity Planning For Products and Services
Capacity Planning For Products and Services
NEPAL ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE Project Appraisal: Group Works
Of Financial Management Traditional View Modern View Objective of Financial Management Scope of Financial Management Relationship of Finance with other.
ECONOMICS IN THE WFD PROCESS
METHODS FOR ANALYZING AND SUPPORTING A SUSTAINABLE PRODUCTION SYSTEM
Micro Hydro Power Management
LECTURE TWO: INTERNATIONAL TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER (ITT) PROCESS:
Capacity Planning For Products and Services
TOTAL COST CONTROL ON CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS
Presentation transcript:

BNFN 521 INVESTMENT APPRAISAL Lecture One

Role and Components of Project Evaluation

The Role and Components of Project Evaluation l. The Role of Project Appraisal To stop bad projects To prevent good projects from being destroyed To determine if components of projects are consistent To assess the sources and magnitudes of risks To determine how to reduce risks and efficiently share risks

Impact of Analysis Quality of analysis has been shown by the World Bank to be a key determinant of the success of a project’s performance. A proper analysis will cause the project to be redesigned so that it is less likely to fail World Bank experience shows that the probability of failure for poorly prepared projects within 3 years of a project’s life is 7 times that of well-prepared projects Poorly prepared projects have 16 times as high a probability of failure within 5 years as compared to well-prepared projects

Role and Components of Investment Evaluation II. Stages in Project Appraisal and Approval Why should a project evaluation be done in stages? A. Idea and Project Definition B. Pre-Feasibility Study C. Feasibility and Financing D. Detailed Design Project Implementation Ex-Post Evaluation

A. Idea and Project Definition Sources of Ideas for Investments: Key questions a. Where is the demand? b. Is this project consistent with the organization’s expertise, current plans and strategy for the future?

Project Definition Project definition is defined broadly to include the scope and specification of the objectives of the project, its output, its different stakeholders, its economic and social benefits, and the data requirements. Most of the project’s data requirements are identified in the pre-feasibility and feasibility stages of the project where the project’s variables and parameters are analyzed in detail. The data are generally arranged in what we refer to as “building blocks” because they constitute the foundation for the different types of analyses.

B. Pre-Feasibility Study Examines overall potential of project Should maintain same quality of information across all variables Wherever possible should use secondary information Biased information better than mean values Key questions: a. Is this project financially and economically feasible throughout the project’s life? b. What are the key variables? c. What are the sources of risk? d. How can the risk be reduced?

C. Feasibility Study Focus is on improving accuracy of the key variables Alternatives for reducing risk are examined in detail Some primary data may be needed Key questions: Is project financially attractive to all interested parties in activity? What is level of uncertainty of key variables? Can final decision for approval be taken?

Modules of Pre-Feasibility and Feasibility Studies Why break study into modules? Building Blocks A. Demand (including environmental factors) Module B. Technical (including environmental factors) Module C. Environmental Assessment Module D. Human Resources and Administrative Support Module E. Institutional Module Analysis Modules F. Financial/Budget Module G. Economic Module H. Social Appraisal or Distributive and Basic Needs Analysis

Building Block A: Demand Module Study of sources of demand, nature of market, prices and quantities Major distinction between domestic versus internationally traded goods and services For internationally traded goods, prices are given to the project by world markets Secondary information most important For domestic market, primary research more important financial and economic values are often affected by project Output of Module Forecast of quantities and real prices for life of project Taxes, tariffs, subsidies, public regulations, technological trends Environmental impacts

Building Block B: Technical or Engineering Module A study of input requirements for investment and operations and their costs In this module, secondary information can be used very effectively Need to avoid conflict of interest between supplier of technical information and seller of investment equipment, or contractor for construction Output of Module Technology and life of project Quantities of inputs by type needed for investment and operation Labor required by type and time Input prices and sources of supply Environmental impacts

Analysis Module C: Environmental Assessment Module Environmental Assessment augments information for the Economic Analysis Identification of Environmental Impacts and Risks Where possible, Quantify the Environmental Impacts Key questions: a. What are the likely environmental impacts from undertaking project ? b. What is the cost of reducing the negative impact? c. Evaluation of the environmental impacts and risks with and without technical measures are taken to reduce these impacts? d. Are there alternative ways of supplying the good or service of project without incurring these environmental costs? What are the costs of these alternatives?

Building Block D: Human Resources and Administrative Support Module What are managerial and labour needs of the project? Does organization have the ability to get the managerial skills needed? Is timing of project consistent with quantity and quality of management? What are wage rates for labor skills required? Manpower requirements by category are reconciled with availabilities and project timing

Building Block E: Institutional Module This module deals with the adequacy of the institution responsible for managing the different stages or phases of the project. Insufficient attention to the institutional aspects creates serious problems during the implementation and operations phases of the project. Key questions: Is the entity that is supposed to manage the project properly organized and its management adequately equipped to handle the project? Are the capabilities and facilities being properly utilized? Is there a need for changes in the policy and institutional set up outside this entity? What changes may be needed in policies of the local, regional and central governments?

Analysis Module F: Financial Module What is done: Integration of financial and technical variables from demand module, technical module, and management module – this is not a mechanical exercise Construct cash flow (resource flow) profile of project Identify key variables for doing economic and social analysis Key questions: a. What is relative certainty of financial variables? b. What are sources and costs of financing? c. What are minimum cash flow requirements for each of the stakeholders? d. What can be adjusted to satisfy each of the stakeholders?

Analysis Module G: Economic Module What is done: Examines the project using the whole country as the accounting entity Evaluation of externalities including environmental Key questions: a. What are differences between financial and economic values for a variable? b. What causes these differences? c. With what degrees of certainty do we know values of these differences? d. What is the expected value of economic net benefits? e. What is the probability of positive economic feasibility?

Analysis Module H: Stakeholders and Basic Needs Analysis What is done: Identification and quantification of extra-economic impacts of project Distributive Appraisal Income, Cost, and Fiscal Impacts on various stakeholders Poverty Alleviation and Political Necessities Basic Needs: Evaluate the impact of project on achieving basic needs objectives Basic needs will vary from country to country Key Questions: a. In what ways does project generate beneficial and cost impacts on stakeholders? b. What stakeholders could the project impact? c. Who benefits and who pay the costs? d. What are the basic needs of the society that are relevant in the country? e. What impact will the project have on basic needs? f. What alternative ways are there to generate desirable social impacts? g. Is project relatively cost effective in generation of desirable social impacts?

Incrementality of Projects One of the important concepts when defining a project is to measure the impact of the project’s cash flows and net benefits and costs on an incremental basis. We should carefully identify the benefits and costs that are only associated with the project, and not include any other benefits that would exist “WITHOUT” the project being undertaken. It is normal for the benefits and costs to change over time for the “WITHOUT” project case. The “WITHOUT” project scenario must be properly defined before using it as the base case from which to measure incremental benefits and costs produced by the “WITH” project case. It is an optimized “WITHOUT” project situation that should be compared with the “WITH” project situation to calculate the incremental benefits and costs. There is another perspective “before the project” versus “after the project” scenarios. “Before the project” is NOT the appropriate base case from which to measure incremental benefits and costs.

Integrated Projects Integrated projects can get very complex and need to be approached cautiously to avoid costly errors. It is possible for the bundled project to be financially and economically viable even though some of the components are not. Dropping the components that generate negative returns will maximize the project’s benefits. Defining and understanding the objectives of the project is particularly important when analyzing integrated projects. Ultimately, the ‘bundle’ that succeeds the most in accomplishing the desired objectives should be undertaken. If the objective of the project is to maximize the wealth of people in Country, then the component or bundle that yields the highest economic NPV should be undertaken.