State Board of Administration FRS Pension Plan Risk Management and Asset Allocation FGFOA Meeting May 8, 2012 INVESTING FOR FLORIDA’S FUTURE.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
STRATEGIC ASSET ALLOCATION
Advertisements

Pension Protection Act of 2006 (PPA) Overview: Sweeping Changes for Defined Benefit Pension Plans Presented by David S. Boomershine, Senior Actuary Boomershine.
1 Administration Single-Employer Pension Reform Proposal.
New Sources of Capital from Target Date Funds October 16, 2012 National Association of Real Estate Investment Managers Moderator: Lennine Occhino Mayer.
1 New Hampshire Retirement System Presentation to NHSAA September 25, 2008.
CCRIF – A Captive for all Seasons Cayman Captive Forum 2013 William Dalziel, Partner London & Capital Asset Management Ltd 5 th December 2013.
Alternative Investments “Outlook for the Investment Management Industry” San Antonio October 17, 2007 Bank Depository User Group Meeting.
Current Developments in the Securities Lending Industry.
Asset Allocation Decision
© 2008 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. 3/1/2008 LCN Stocks and Bonds.
Pension Fund Operations
Florida Government Finance Officers Association Webinar GASB’s New Pension Standards December 18, 2014.
The World Bank Sep 2001 Pension Fund Management “IBRD’s experience” Sudhir Krishnamurthi The World Bank Public Pension Fund Management, Washington, DC.
Secure your future today Save early and prepare for the retirement lifestyle you want.
PENSION FUNDS. PENSION PLANS 1.PUBLIC PENSION FUNDS Created by state, local or federal govt. 2.PRIVATE PENSION PLANS Created by private agencies including.
Agenda Why is the Pension Investor different? The journey, the destination or both? Saver or Investor? Tailored Solutions Managing the journey to the destination.
INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT PROCESS Setting investment objectives Establishing investment policy Selecting a portfolio strategy Selecting assets Managing and.
Adding Value While Managing Risk. 2 Profile of Fairlane Asset Management Manages traditional & non-traditional bond mandates Experienced investment professionals.
For Dealer Use Only. 2 Key Features Tactical Asset Allocation Benefits of Indexing, Convenience of ETFs Experienced Portfolio Management Low Cost, Managed.
2008 General Meeting Assemblée générale 2008 Toronto, Ontario 2008 General Meeting Assemblée générale 2008 Toronto, Ontario Canadian Institute of Actuaries.
Bell Pension Group – Ottawa Chapter May 27, 2014 Bell Pension Plan and Post-Retirement Benefits CONFIDENTIAL.
Utility Finance: A View from the Trenches Brad Jackson Foley & Lardner, LLP.
Matching and Return The Hoogovens Pension Plan Experience a concept for transparent, predictable and secure pensions Presentation IMF seminar Aging, Pension.
Financial Statement Analysis K.R. Subramanyam Copyright © 2014 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the.
1 Chapter 8 Bond Valuation and Risk Financial Markets and Institutions, 7e, Jeff Madura Copyright ©2006 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning.
SMU Cox School of Business January 31, AMR INVESTMENT SERVICES, INC. 1) OVERSEE MANAGEMENT OF AMERICAN AIRLINES $16.5 BILLION PENSION PLANS 2)
The Montgomery Institute Investment Proposal December 2013.
2009 Annual Meeting ● Assemblée annuelle 2009 Halifax, Nova Scotia ● Halifax (Nouvelle-Écosse) 2009 Annual Meeting ● Assemblée annuelle 2009 Halifax, Nova.
For Dealer Use Only. 2 Key Features Tactical Asset Allocation Benefits of Indexing, Convenience of ETFs Experienced Portfolio Management Low Cost, Managed.
P 3 Actuaries you can understand 1 Introduction to the Actuarial Valuation: Funding and Assumptions January 12, 2006 P.
Financial Markets and Institutions
Joint Forum of Financial Market Regulators Forum conjoint des autorités de réglementation du marché financier Guidelines for Capital Accumulation Plans.
1 FIN 604 Introduction and Overview 1. Investor vs. Speculator 2. Participants in the Investment Process 3. Steps in Investing 4. Types of Investors and.
CAUBO Winnipeg, June 17, 2008 Presentation by Lucie Mercier-Gauthier Debt Capacity.
Long Term Investment Portfolio Annual Review – FY 2011 September 8, 2011.
Collin County Retirement Plan Briefing September 7, 2010.
March 9, 2006www.psers.state.pa.us1 PSERS An Update on the State of the Fund, the Employer Contribution Rate and Pending Legislation.
5847 San Felipe, Suite 4100, Houston, Texas (713) (800) (713) (Fax) INVESTING IN RETIREMENT THE GAME HAS CHANGED … OR HAS.
Funding Public Pensions Seventh Annual Employee Benefits Symposium John Marshall Law School April 20, 2009 by Jon Forman Alfred P. Murrah Professor of.
1 Economic Benefits of Integrated Risk Products Lawrence A. Berger Swiss Re New Markets CAS Financial Risk Management Seminar Denver, CO, April 12, 1999.
Economic Capital at Manulife
New Trends in ALM Methodologies
-1- Restrictions on Pension Investing: A Canadian Perspective Michael Nobrega OMERS President and CEO 4 June 2008.
Bond Valuation and Risk
CIA Annual Meeting LOOKING BACK…focused on the future.
Absolute Return Strategies 29 January 2008 A Pensions Perspective “Our Changing Future” Gareth Derbyshire.
1 The Benefits of Hedge Funds The First Seoul International Derivatives Securities Conference Thomas Schneeweis & Vassilis Karavas August 28, 2003.
CHAPTER 9 Investment Management: Concepts and Strategies Chapter 9: Investment Concepts 1.
Copyright © 2016 by The Segal Group, Inc. All rights reserved. Unfunded Actuarial Accrued Liability (UAAL) Presentation to the Joint Board of Supervisors.
Prepared by Aon Hewitt Consulting | Retirement Update on Retirement Glide Path Strategy AgriBank District Retirement Plan John Hanson and Ron Kalvoda August.
Mercer Human Resource Consulting Limited is regulated by the Financial Services Authority and is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council Registered.
October 11, 2005 PRESENTATION TO THE 1818 SOCIETY The World Bank.
2017 Investment Management Division Major Initiatives
1818 Society Annual Meeting Pension Plan Performance October 11, 2006
CalPERS Background 1,439 School Districts 1 State of California 1,581
Senior Research Consultant, NEPC
Annual Investment Report Presentation to City Council
TLFFRA Educational Conference
Financial Statement Analysis K.R. Subramanyam
California Public Employees’ Retirement System (CalPERS)
2017 Investment Management Division Major Initiatives
2017 Investment Management Division Major Initiatives
22 Investors and the Investment Process Bodie, Kane, and Marcus
MU Retirees Association Retirement Plan Update March 17, 2018
Pension Protection Act of 2006 Playing by the Rules for DB
22 Investors and the Investment Process Bodie, Kane, and Marcus
2009 AT&T Pension Asset Liability Study and Risk Budget L
12 Multinational Capital Structure & Long Term Financing
Financial Service Solutions
Legislative Update: SB 2224 and SB 322 October 1, 2019.
Presentation transcript:

State Board of Administration FRS Pension Plan Risk Management and Asset Allocation FGFOA Meeting May 8, 2012 INVESTING FOR FLORIDA’S FUTURE

Presentation Outline SBA Overview SBA Enterprise Risk Management FRS Pension Plan Case Study –Pension Finance –Asset Liability Modeling –Asset Allocation –Implementation and Business Model Other Management Considerations 2

3

4 SBA Funds Under Management April 23, 2012 Estimates

5 SBA’s Strategic Risks 1.Investment Management Risk 2.Governance/Management Risk 3.Communication/Public Affairs/Reputational Risk 4.Legislative/Political Risk 5.Compliance Risk 6.Fraud/ Misconduct/ Internal Controls Risk 7.Service Provider Risk 8.Client Relationship Risk 9.Operational Risk 10.Human Capital Risk 11.Security Risk 12.Business Continuity/Infrastructure Risk 13.Legal Risk

6

7 SBA Investment Risk Components –Policy Risk Policy Design Risk Investment Objective Risk Capital Market Assumption Risk Liability Risk –Implementation Risk Strategy Risk Portfolio Under Performance Risk Trading Risk Asset Transition Risk Model Risk Due Diligence Risk Leverage Risk Aggregate Issuer/Counterparty Credit Risk –Inherent Risk Market/Systematic Risk Idiosyncratic/Unsystematic Risk

FRS Pension Plan Case Study Pension Finance Asset Liability Modeling Asset Allocation Implementation and Business Model 8

Pension Obligations – Future Benefit Cash Flows A BC1 C2 D Millions of 2011 $ A = benefits for current retirees B = benefits already accrued/earned for current employees C1+C2 = benefits yet to be earned for current employees (C1 = portion allocated by actuarial method for past service) D = benefits for future employees 9

10 FRS Pension Plan Investment Policy Objective –… provide investment returns sufficient for the plan to be maintained in a manner that ensures the timely payment of promised benefits to current and future participants and keeps the plan cost at a reasonable level. –To achieve this, a long-term real return approximating 5% per annum (compounded and net of investment expenses) should be attained, consistent with the actuarial investment return assumption of 7.75%. –As additional considerations, the Board seeks to avoid excessive risk in long-term cost trends. –To manage these risks, the volatility of annual returns should be reasonably controlled.

Structure Of Asset-Liability Model Asset Returns Interest Rates Inflation Economic Simulation Asset Growth Liability Growth Plan Cost & Funded Status Asset Smoothing Actuarial Methods Actuarial Assump. 11

For the 2012 asset liability update we used an equity risk premium assumption equal to 4.36%, the average of the assumptions used by the four SBA investment consultants. The resulting expected average compounded return for U.S. equities is equal to 7.4% (the U.S. bond expected return of 3.0% plus the equity risk premium of 4.4%): U.S. Equity Return All returns are 15-year geometric average expected returns. 12

FRS Pension Plan Return & Risk Assumptions Risk Assets Fixed Income 13

Range of Possible 15-Year Compound Returns -- Nominal Percentile: 95th 75th 50th 25th 5th Best estimate = 7.4% (mean value) 7.75% actuarial assump. ( 50% probability ) 50% confidence range: from 4.7% to 10.5% 90% confidence range: from -0.1% to 13.8% 50 th %-tile = 7.8% (median value) 14

Range of Funded Ratios – Current Asset Allocation Policy Trend line Dark shaded area indicates the 50% probability zone, and light shaded area indicates the 90% probability zone. 15

Range of Employer Contribution Rates (DB Plan Only) – Current Asset Allocation Policy Trend line Dark shaded area indicates the 50% probability zone, and light shaded area indicates the 90% probability zone. 16

More risk Lower cost Higher cost Current Mix Change in cost relative to values using current mix Less risk Avg. Risk Increase ($MM) (Worst 100 scenarios) Avg. Cost Savings ($MM) (All 500 scenarios) Risk / Reward Analysis Based On Long-Term Economic Cost Diagonal line = 3-to-1 risk/reward benchmark 17

2011 Asset Liability Update: Diversification Impact Diversification changes can improve the results. The Recommended policy offers long-term cost savings of $2.3 billion, with no material change in risk profile Avg. Risk Increase ($MM) (Worst 200 scenarios) Avg. Cost Savings ($MM) (All 1,000 scenarios) June 2010 Policy (before diversification) Recommended Policy (with diversification) Increased diversification shifts curve in favorable direction 18

Investment Policy Themes: Enhancing diversification and taking risk more efficiently Maintain or reduce the overall level of investment risk in the fund –Reduction in the fund’s overall exposure to global stock markets –Decrease in the fund’s use of active management in the public stock and bond markets Further increase diversification of investments –Greater global diversification within the publicly traded stock investments –Greater diversification into a broader array of investment types (i.e. alternative investments) that do not necessarily fluctuate with stock markets Increase flexibility to take investment risks more efficiently –Downside protection from volatile markets through bond investments –Participate in worldwide economic growth through stock investments –Generate above market returns, with strong risk controls, through skillful opportunistic investing 19

FRS Pension Plan Asset Allocation Policies *Prior to July 2010, Global Equity was composed of two asset classes, Domestic Equities and Foreign Equities, with target allocations of 38% and 20%, respectively. ** Global Equity asset class includes existing Domestic Equity, Foreign Equity and Global Equity mandates; Strategic Investments includes existing High Yield allocation. *** In recognition of the dynamic nature of this asset class, there is no specific expected weight. Its actual allocation will vary within the policy range depending on the mix of included strategies at any given time. When the actual allocation of Strategic Investments is greater than zero, all other asset class target allocations shall be reduced pro-rata. Asset Class Pre-July 2010 Policy Current Policy Expanded Authority Policy Global Equity 58% 56% 52% Fixed Income High Yield Fixed Income2–– Real Estate777 Private Equity445 Strategic Investments–611 Cash111 Total100% 20

Strategic Investments Detail Asset Category Recommended (% of Total Fund) Debt-Oriented Funds 3.0% Infrastructure2.0 Absolute Return Hedge Funds2.0 Long/Short Equity Hedge Funds2.0 Open Mandate Hedge Funds2.0 Commodities-- Timberland-- Total Strategic Investments11.0%  Allocations reflect current expectations for future allocations in Strategic Investments for modeling purposes. Actual allocations, including possible investments in commodities and timberland, will vary dependent on identification of attractive opportunities. 21

22

23 FRS Pension Plan Net Managed and Target Returns As of March 31, 2012

FRS Results Relative to TUCS Top Ten Defined Benefit Plans Periods Ending 12/31/2011 Total FRS (Gross)Top Ten Median Defined Benefit Plan Fund (Gross) Note: The TUCS Top Ten Universe includes $1.1 trillion in total assets. The median fund size was $112.5 billion and the average fund size was $109.7 billion. Rate of Return (%) Quarter1-Year3-Year5-Year10-Year 24

Comparison of Asset Allocation As of 12/31/2011 FRS Pension Plan vs. Top Ten Defined Benefit Plans **Global Equity Allocation: 28.9% Domestic Equities; 17.9% Foreign Equities. Note: The TUCS Top Ten Universe includes $1.1 trillion in total assets. The median fund size was $112.5 billion and the average fund size was $109.7 billion. *Global Equity Allocation: 25.5% Domestic Equities; 28.7% Foreign Equities; 2.8% Global Equities. Percentages are of the Total FRS Fund. FRS TOTAL FUND Fixed Income 26.0% Private Equity 4.9% Strategic Investments 4.1% Cash 0.7% Real Estate 7.4% Global Equity* 56.9% TUCS Top Ten Cash Global Equity** 46.8% Fixed Income 27.3% Real Estate 6.3% Alternatives 17.6% 2.1% 25

OutperformanceLower Risk Growth of a Dollar Jan 1994 – Dec 2010 Annualized Volatility Jan Dec 2010 Hedge Fund Return and Risk Attributes 26

FRS Pension Plan Cost Comparison to CEM Peer Group 27 Cost Effectiveness Measurement (“CEM”) maintains a global database of detailed cost information provided by public and corporate pension plans. The SBA’s 2010 CEM Peer Group included 16 U.S. plan sponsors with assets from $22.5 billion to $225.6 billion. 27

28 High Level Investment Guidelines Public market asset classes shall be well diversified with respect to their benchmarks and have a reliance on low cost passive strategies scaled according to the degree of efficiency in underlying securities markets, capacity in effective active strategies, and ongoing total fund liquidity requirements. Private Equity, Real Estate and Strategic Investments asset classes shall utilize a prudent process to maximize long-term access to attractive risk- adjusted investment opportunities through use of business partners with appropriate: –Financial, operational and investment expertise and resources; –Alignment of interests; –Transparency and repeatability of investment process; and –Controls on leverage.

29 FRS Pension Plan Asset Class Allocations February 2012

30 FRS Pension Plan Active Risk Budget Monitoring Standards Active Risk Active Share TAA/ Asset Class Monitoring Standard Current Market Standard Tactical Asset Allocation0.20%0.40%-- Global Equity1.00%1.50%[40%, 60%]* Fixed Income0.75%1.25%[25%, 75%] Real Estate5.00%8.00%-- Private Equity (secondary benchmark)6.00%10.00%-- Strategic Investments4.00%6.00%-- Cash0.10%0.20%-- Total Fund1.00%1.50%

31

32

Looking Forward: 2012 FRS Pension Plan Asset Liability Update Supports continuation of the current multi-year implementation of increased allocations to real estate, private equity, and strategic investments, but identifies changes to be considered –Conflicting indicators on best portfolio risk target – some supporting an increase in risk and some supporting a decrease in risk –Growing importance of liquidity management over intermediate-term –Re-emphasizes the value of diversification The funding policy has a direct impact on some of the investment policy risk-reward analysis –Deferring actuarially recommended contributions (“UAL”) –Treatment of 2011 benefit changes –Actuarial assumptions –Amortization and other actuarial cost methods 33