George Bartlett Director, Transmission Operations Economic Transmission Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Evaluation Independent Monitoring Presented at: LPSC Staffs Technical Conference and ESIs Bidders Conference for the Fall 2006 Limited-Term RFP September.
Advertisements

Al McBride MANAGER, AREA TRANSMISSION PLANNING Existing Import Interfaces: Transmission Transfer Capabilities and The Calculation of Tie Benefits DECEMBER.
1 Entergy Gulf States, Inc. (Louisiana) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004.
Company LOGO Cleco Planning Process. Models Cleco uses SPP’s annual series of models to determine the NERC reliability violations. Cleco uses SPP or VST.
1 Entergy Louisiana, Inc. (North) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004.
Houston Import Evaluation Cross Texas Transmission & Garland Power & Light ERCOT RPG Meeting August 27th, 2013.
The Need for an Energy Grid in the Maldives
KURTEN SWITCH PROJECT (BRYAN/ COLLEGE STATION AREA UPGRADES) Technical Advisory Committee December 1, 2005 Transmission Services.
1 JULY 2010 PRELIMINARY TECHNICAL CONFERENCE REPORT – WORK IN PROGRESS Session 4 Discussion of Alternatives and Implementation Activities for Real- Time.
Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 31, 2007
1 Entergy Louisiana, LLC (South) & Entergy New Orleans, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans,
Preliminary Analysis of the SEE Future Infrastructure Development Plan and REM Benefits.
Transmission planning in Vermont Past, present and future Docket 7081 workshop By Dean LaForest 9/19/05.
1 Transmission Development at Ameren and in the Midwest ISO Mid-America Regulatory Conference Maureen A. Borkowski June 8, 2010.
1 Entergy Mississippi, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004.
Charles Hosken, General Manager Imperial Irrigation District
ICT Strategic Transmission Plan (ISTEP) Review and Status Update Entergy Transmission Summit July 29, 2008 Astor Crown Plaza New Orleans, Louisiana Douglas.
Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration.
PJM© PJM Confidential PJM Generation Interconnection Overview Virginia Offshore Wind Conference Virginia Beach June 22, 2011 Paul McGlynn General.
Warren Lasher Director, System Planning October 4, 2014 Our Energy Future.
2006 Reliability Study Scope Name Date. DRAFT 2 Purpose of Study Assess the PEC and Duke transmission systems’ reliability Develop a single reliability.
The Need for Electric Transmission Improvements in Dane County.
1 Update on the 2006 Transmission Study LPSC B&E Meeting Baton Rouge, LA November 29, 2006.
Lyndonville Electric Department Feasibility Analysis Review December 2,
WestConnect Activities Charles Reinhold WestConnect Project Manager 2008 ACC BTA Workshop Phoenix, AZ May 22, 2008.
OSC Meeting April 27, Transmission Cost Allocation Overview.
1 Generator Interconnection Status Update Tom Lanigan Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
1 Entergy Transmission Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
John Dumas Director of Wholesale Market Operations Jeff Billo Manager of Mid Term Planning Dan Jones Director with Potomac Economics, the ERCOT IMM Board.
ISTEP Phase II Final Report Summary LTTIWG Meeting – January 27, 2009 Douglas Bowman, PE Lead Engineer, ICT Planning
1 Entergy Gulf States, Inc. (Louisiana) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
Proposed North – South Congestion Mitigation Plan Luminant Energy July 2008.
MISO Northwest Exploratory Study Presented to National Wind Coordinating Committee Participants in study – MISO, Various utilities in Minnesota, North.
SPP.org 1. Southeastern Inter-Regional Planning Update (SIRPP) Entergy Transmission Summit August 11, 2009 Astor Crown Plaza New Orleans, Louisiana.
1 Stability Issues in Entergy System Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
1 Entergy Gulf States Louisiana, L.L.C. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects.
1 Entergy Louisiana, Inc. (South) & Entergy New Orleans, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans,
1 Entergy Louisiana, Inc. (South) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
© ABB Group August 23,2010 | Slide 1 MBPC Study – 1 st Load Pocket Preliminary Results for Discussion only Entergy Regional State Committee (ERSC) Southwest.
CMWG Update WMS September 2015 Meeting. CRR Balancing Account Fund Discussion The CRR Balancing Account fund appears to be working as expected The cap.
1 Entergy Gulf States, Inc. (Louisiana) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 31, 2007.
1 Entergy Louisiana, Inc. (North) Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
Project Tracking Update July 12, 2011 MOPC. 2 STEP List (Excel Spreadsheet) –Engineers enter technical data and analysis on upgrades –Used as a repository.
SPP.org 1. Status Update for Reliability and Economic Assessments Stakeholder Meeting September 16, 2008 Austin, TX.
SPP.org 1. Final Report: Reliability and Economic Assessments Stakeholder Meeting December 1, 2008 Austin, TX.
1.
SPP.org 1. Status Update for Reliability and Economic Assessments Stakeholder Meeting June 20 th, 2008 Austin, TX.
TRANSMISSION INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS — Current Projects — The Center for the New West “ The Sun Valley Energy Roundtables 2006” November 30 – December.
ESI Alternate Economic Study Process E-RSC Meeting October 21, 2010.
Coordinated Planning Concept (For Discussion Only) revised 11/30/04 07/01/04.
Update on the North Carolina Transmission Planning Collaborative January 30, 2007 For the North Carolina Utilities Commission and the North Carolina Public.
1 Entergy Mississippi, Inc. Proposed Transmission Reliability Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003.
ERCOT Transmission Planning Process Overview and Recommendations November 6, 2002.
SERC Reliability Corporation 1 SERC RELIABILITY CORPORATION MID-AMERICA RELIABILITY CONFERENCE June 21, 2006 COLUMBUS, OHIO.
1 Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 10, 2003 Generation and Transmission Development in the Southeastern United States.
ISTEP Update Transmission Planning Summit August 11, 2009 Crown Plaza Hotel New Orleans, LA.
2006 Reliability Study James Manning Bryan Guy May 12, 2006.
Entergy Mississippi’s Bright Future Plan & Renewable Energy October 16, 2015 Aaron Hill Entergy Mississippi, Inc.
Douglas Bowman, PE, PMP Project Manager Entergy Corporation New Projects and Processes Ensure Power Transfer for Northeast Arkansas Customers.
PJM© Market Efficiency RTEP Proposal Window PJM TEAC 1/9/2014 – Market Efficiency Presentation.
©2003 PJM 1 Presentation to: Maryland Public Service Commission May 16, 2003.
EE590 Transmission Planning Projects and Cost Allocation Ming NI Economic Studies, Midwest ISO.
IMM Report on MISO South Integration Presented by: David B. Patton, Ph.D. Independent Market Monitor Presented to: Entergy Regional State Committee April.
The Midwest ISO – Platform to Meet Tomorrow’s Challenges Wisconsin Industrial Energy Group August 7, 2008.
1 New Orleans, LA July 29, 2008 Randy Helmick Vice President, Transmission Entergy Services Inc. Entergy Transmission Planning Summit.
Status Update for Reliability/Market Power Mitigation Assessment
WECC Annual Meeting 9/11/2018 Cameron Warren
WECC Annual Meeting 9/11/2018 Cameron Warren
Strategic Plan and Economic Upgrade Process
Presentation transcript:

George Bartlett Director, Transmission Operations Economic Transmission Projects Entergy Transmission Planning Summit New Orleans, LA July 8, 2004

2 Topics Issues & Challenges in Transmission Planning Internal Studies Performed to Date Proposed Future Plan

3 Merchant Generation in Entergy Area by State StateMW# of IOAs AR 7,7907 MS 6, LA 8, TX 2,9756 TOTAL 25,28340 Merchant generating facilities with filed IOAs Merchant generating facilities that have filed IOAs and completed construction (19,000 MW)

4 Energy Mix for Entergy for 2003 Source: GOL/AFC/WPP Technical Conference presentations ( Issue

5 Composition of Purchases for 2003 Not reflected in long-term planning model Source: GOL/AFC/WPP Technical Conference presentations (

6 Composition of Short-Term Purchases Source: GOL/AFC/WPP Technical Conference presentations ( Reflected only in short-term monthly operations model

7 Summary of Issues in Entergy System Generation to load ratio will be ~2:1 by Uncertainty in planning for future system due to short-term purchases. Loop flow due to various tie lines. Incentive to invest in bulk transmission system

8 Internal Studies Performed to Date Bulk Power Study (2002) Identified transmission projects to accommodate point to point transmission requests on Entergy system. Ten projects, including at least 800 miles of 500 kV lines and three autotransformers, are required to move ~9,300 MW to Entergy’s border and to embedded load. Total transmission expansion cost is ~$1.9 Billion (i.e., $205/kW) LPSC Phase II Transmission Study (2003)

LPSC Phase II Transmission Study: A cost-benefit analysis verified the effectiveness of transmission expansion alternatives Examined transmission expansion alternatives Aimed at alleviating internal and external interface limitations Considered 13,800 MW of merchant capacity available by summer 2004 along with Entergy owned units to serve native load 81 potential constraints identified for simulation period in PROMOD

Generation Locations

11 East/ Northeast Import Northeast AR Area Import into Entergy from Southern/TVA Western Import Import into Entergy from SPP Amite South Import LPSC Phase II Transmission Study: Top Four Areas for Potential Benefits

12 LPSC Phase II Transmission Study: Transmission Projects NoExamined Transmission ProjectsStateExpected Benefit (Location) 1Construct new line from Panama to Dutch Bayou LA Improve Amite-South interface. (Between Baton Rouge and New Orleans within the Company’s industrial corridor) 2Rebuild 230 kV line from Coly to Vignes LA 3Rebuild 230 kV line from Conway to Bagatelle LA 4500/230 kV autotransformer at McAdams MSRelieve congestion in Entergy’s central region. (Near Entergy-TVA border in central Mississippi near of Jackson) 5Rebuild 115 kV line from Couch to McNeil ARRelieve identified constraint. (Near Arkansas-Louisiana border) 6Upgrade 230 kV line from PPG to Rose Bluff LARelieve identified constraint. (Near Louisiana-Texas border in Lake Charles area) 7500/115 kV autotransformer at Sterlington LAImprove North-South Interface (North Louisiana near city of Monroe) Detail Set A Detail Set B Detail Set C

13 Set A Projects: Amite South Construct a new 230 kV line from Panama to Dutch Bayou Rebuild 230 kV line from Coly to Vignes Rebuild 230 kV line from Conway to Bagatelle Estimated project cost: $45 million << Back

14 Set B Projects: East Area Set A Projects, Plus: McAdams autotransformer to improve Entergy’s import capability from the east Estimated project cost: $53 million total << Back

15 Set C Projects: Miscellaneous Set A and Set B Projects, Plus: Rebuild 115 kV line from Couch to McNeil Upgrade 230 kV line from PPG to Rose Bluff 500/115 kV autotransformer at Sterlington Estimated project cost: $78 million total

16 Cost/Benefit Study Results Case 20 Year NPV of Savings ($MM) Set A Set B Set C $260.5 $127.6 Upper Bound Lower Bound $170.6 $147.2 $310.9 $290.3

Upper and Lower Bounds Upper Bound Assumes Increases in transfer capability constant throughout study No additional transmission expansion projects Lower Bound Assumes Transfer capabilities reduced throughout study period No additional transmission expansion projects

Limitation of LPSC Phase II Study Could not examine voltage constraints PROMOD IV output based on DC solution methodology Unable to monitor all transmission constraints Footprint of the detailed model is limited to Entergy only Changes in external system dispatch that may impact various internal constraints were not considered Must-run unit requirements and import/export limits could not be changed dynamically based on the system condition in PROMOD IV

Summary of LPSC Phase II Study North Arkansas area constraint City of Jonesboro committed to fund third line (ISES-Newport) In Service Date: By Summer 2005 Import from Western area OG&E committed to install a 500/161 kV auto at Ft. Smith In Service Date: By December 2004 Company committed to proceed with the projects identified in Set A (Amite South improvement plan) At present, projects are in scoping/engineering phase Projected In Service Date: Summer 2007 Projects in Sets B and C to be reviewed through planning process Company identified Sterlington 500/115 kV auto as RMR issue and committed to install additional auto by year end 2005.

20 Proposed Future Plan Reliability planning Continue to determine reliability projects based on traditional planning models and software (PSS/E, MUST) Verify the need of those proposed reliability projects that might be impacted by a change in unit commitment by looking at market-based dispatch. Use indicators like congestion hours, production cost or load payment to compare/prioritize proposed projects. Prioritize those projects that have both reliability and economic impact.

21 Proposed Future Plan (Cont.) Economic Planning Identify potential bottlenecks on the system using historical operational constraints (TLRs, flowgates, etc.) Determine cost-effective solutions that would increase the transmission throughput Coordinate this effort with neighboring utilities to address any seams issues. Encourage participant funding for the market- driven economic projects

Questions?Questions?