Exploring structure around submillimetre-bright QSOs Francisco J. Carrera (IFCA, CSIC-UC, Spain/Imperial, UK) Mathew J. Page (MSSL-UCL, UK) Jason Stevens.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Star Formation in AGN hosts Li Shao & PACS Evolutionary Probe (PEP) group Hangzhou, China April 28, 2011 Evidence from Herschel PACS.
Advertisements

Desika Narayanan EVLA Conference The Formation and Evolution of SMGs: A (mostly) Panchromatic View Desika Narayanan Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.
Statistical analysis of the X-ray emission properties of type-1 AGN in the XMM-2dF Wide Angle Survey Silvia Mateos Leicester University (UK) Leicester.
The multiwavelength surveys of the ELAIS-S1 and GOODS fields Fabrizio Fiore & M. Brusa, A. Comastri, C. Feruglio, A. Fontana, A. Grazian, F. La Franca,
Luminous obscured quasars in the HELLAS2XMM survey: the Spitzer perspective Cristian Vignali Dipartimento di Astronomia, Universita`degli Studi di Bologna.
Probing the X-ray Universe: Analysis of faint sources with XMM-Newton G. Hasinger, X. Barcons, J. Bergeron, H. Brunner, A. C. Fabian, A. Finoguenov, H.
Star formation at high redshift (2 < z < 7) Methods for deriving star formation rates UV continuum = ionizing photons (dust obscuration?) Ly  = ionizing.
THE MODERATELY LARGE SCALE STRUCTURE OF QUASARS
Boston, November 2006 Extragalactic X-ray surveys Paolo Tozzi Spectral analysis of X-ray sources in the CDFS.
Star Formation in High Redshift Submillimeter Galaxies and QSO Hosts Dieter Lutz MPE Elisabetta Valiante, Eckhard Sturm, Reinhard Genzel, Linda Tacconi,
Obscured and unobscured growth of Super-massive Black Holes Francisco J. Carrera, X. Barcons, J. Bussons, J. Ebrero, M. Ceballos, A. Corral (IFCA, CSIC-UC,
Space Density of Heavily-Obscured AGN, Star Formation and Mergers Ezequiel Treister (IfA, Hawaii Ezequiel Treister (IfA, Hawaii) Meg Urry, Priya Natarajan,
Dusty star formation at high redshift Chris Willott, HIA/NRC 1. Introductory cosmology 2. Obscured galaxy formation: the view with current facilities,
Jerusalem 2004 Hans-Walter Rix - MPIA The Evolution of the High-z Galaxy Populations.
Astrophysics from Space Lecture 8: Dusty starburst galaxies Prof. Dr. M. Baes (UGent) Prof. Dr. C. Waelkens (KUL) Academic year
Massive galaxies at z > 1.5 By Hans Buist Supervisor Scott Trager Date22nd of june 2007.
RXJ a soft X-ray excess in a low luminosity accreting pulsar La Palombara & Mereghetti astro-ph/
Alexandra Pope (UMass Amherst) JWST Workshop – STScI Baltimore June 8, 2011 Mid-Infrared Observation of High Redshift Galaxy Evolution.
Obscured AGN in the (z)COSMOS survey AGN9, Ferrara, May Angela Bongiorno Max-Planck-Institut für extraterrestrische Physik, Garching, GERMANY AND.
The Evolution of Quasars and Massive Black Holes “Quasar Hosts and the Black Hole-Spheroid Connection”: Dunlop 2004 “The Evolution of Quasars”: Osmer 2004.
From JCMT Partner Nations: Rob Ivison, Alexandra Pope, Ian Smail, Douglas Scott, Kristen Coppin, Andy Biggs, Christine Wilson, Mark Halpern, Steve Eales,
Star Formation. Introduction Star-Forming Regions The Formation of Stars Like the Sun Stars of Other Masses Observations of Brown Dwarfs Observations.
Coevolution of black holes and galaxies at high redshift David M Alexander (Durham)
Past, Present and Future Star Formation in High Redshift Radio Galaxies Nick Seymour (MSSL/UCL) 22 nd Nov Powerful Radio Galaxies.
Active Galaxies Definition – –Amount of Energy –Type of Energy Non-thermal Polarized Other characteristics –Emission spectra Hydrogen – Balmer series &
RADIO OBSERVATIONS IN VVDS FIELD : PAST - PRESENT - FUTURE P.Ciliegi(OABo), Marco Bondi (IRA) G. Zamorani(OABo), S. Bardelli (OABo) + VVDS-VLA collaboration.
Obscured AGN and XRB models Andrea Comastri (INAF-OABologna-Italy) Roberto Gilli (INAF-OABologna-Italy) F. Fiore (INAF-OARoma-Italy) G. Hasinger (MPE-Garching-
Dust emission from powerful high-z starbursts and QSOs The combined power of submillimeter and mid-IR studies for tracing the most powerful starbursts.
Vandana Desai Spitzer Science Center with Lee Armus, Colin Borys, Mark Brodwin, Michael Brown, Shane Bussmann, Arjun Dey, Buell Jannuzzi, Emeric Le Floc’h,
Properties of the point-like sources in the XMM-LSS field Olga Melnyk and XMM-LSS collaboration N. Clerc, L. Chiappetti, A. Elyiv, P.Gandhi, E.Gosset,
Bruno Altieri | Toledo 2011 | 23 Nov | vg #1 Star Formation from Herschel deep surveys B. Altieri, on behalf of PEP (PACS Extragalactic Probe, PI.
“Nature and Descendants of Sub-mm and Lyman-break Galaxies in Lambda-CDM” Juan Esteban González Collaborators: Cedric Lacey, Carlton Baugh, Carlos Frenk,
Black hole accretion and host galaxies of obscured quasars Vincenzo Mainieri with Angela Bongiorno, Andrea Merloni & COSMOS.
X-ray clues on the nature of sub-mm galaxies I.Georgantopoulos INAF/OABO A Comastri INAF/OABO E. Rovilos MPE.
With: V. Smolcic, A. Karim,, B. Magnelli, A.Zirm, M. Michalowski, P. Capak, K. Sheth, K. Schawinski, S. Wuyts, D. Sanders, A. Man, D. Lutz, J. Staguhn,
The Accretion History of SMBHs in Massive Galaxies Kate Brand STScI Collaborators: M. Brown, A. Dey, B. Jannuzi, and the XBootes and Bootes MIPS teams.
An Evolutionary Model of Submillimeter Galaxies Sukanya Chakrabarti NSF Fellow CFA.
Quiescent and Starbursting star-forming galaxies at z=2 Giulia Rodighiero (University of Padova) On behalf of the PEP Team Trieste - The Physics of Star.
X-ray emission properties of BLAGN in the XMM-2dF Wide Angle Survey S. Mateos, M.G. Watson, J. A. Tedds and the XMM-Newton Survey Science Centre Department.
AGN9: Black Holes & Revelations 25 May 2010 Eleonora Sani Enhanced star formation in Narrow Line Seyfert 1 AGN Co-Is: D. Lutz, G. Risaliti, L. H. Gallo,
AGN deep multiwavelength surveys: the case of the Chandra Deep Field South Fabrizio Fiore Simonetta Puccetti, Giorgio Lanzuisi.
The Differences in the SEDs of Type 1 and Type 2 AGNs: Contributions from starbursts Xue-Bing Wu Collaborator: Ran Wang (Astronomy Department, Peking University)
How do galaxies accrete their mass? Quiescent and star - forming massive galaxies at high z Paola Santini Roman Young Researchers Meeting 2009 July 21.
COSMIC DOWNSIZING and AGN METALLICITY at HIGH REDSHIFT Roberto Maiolino INAF - Oss. Arcetri & Oss. Roma Tohru Nagao INAF - Oss. Arcetri & NAOJ Alessandro.
HST Workshop Bologna Jan 31, 2008 Heavily obscured SMBH at high redshift Andrea Comastri INAF - OABologna C. Vignali, R. Gilli, K. Iwasawa, F. Civano,
Observations of Obscured Black Holes
Obscured and unobscured growth of Super-massive Black Holes from the XMM-Newton Medium Survey Francisco J. Carrera, X. Barcons, J. Bussons, J. Ebrero,
Black hole accretion history of active galactic nuclei 曹新伍 中国科学院上海天文台.
A multi-band view on the evolution of starburst merging galaxies A multi-band view on the evolution of starburst merging galaxies Yiping Wang (王益萍) Purple.
The Links Between AGN and Galaxy Formation
Formation and evolution of dusty ellipticals Laura Silva (INAF, Trieste, Italy) Gian Luigi Granato (INAF, Padova, Italy) Gianfranco De Zotti (INAF, Padova,
Super Massive Black Holes The Unknown Astrophysics of their initial formation.
How do galaxies accrete their mass? Quiescent and star - forming massive galaxies at high z Paola Santini THE ORIGIN OF GALAXIES: LESSONS FROM THE DISTANT.
I. Georgantopoulos NATIONAL OBSERVATORY OF ATHENS A. Georgakakis, O. Giannakis, S. Kitsionas, A. Akylas, D. Gaga, M. Plionis, V. Kolokotronis, S. Basilakos.
X-ray selected Type-2 QSOs and their host galaxies Vincenzo Mainieri with A. Bongiorno, A. Merloni, M. Bolzonella, M. Brusa, M. Carollo, G. Hasinger, K.
Aug 8th, 2007MAGPOP Summer School Models for source counts and background spectrum, from submm to ultraviolet ingredients for counts model at submm to.
AGN / Starbursts in the very dusty systems in Bootes Kate Brand + the Bootes team NOAO Lijiang, August 2005.
3-8 µm diagnostics of starbursts and AGNs in the local and high-z Universe Guido Risaliti INAF - Osservatorio Astrofisico di Arcetri & Harvard-Smithsonian.
KASI Galaxy Evolution Journal Club A Massive Protocluster of Galaxies at a Redshift of z ~ P. L. Capak et al. 2011, Nature, in press (arXive: )
Warm Dust in the Most Distant Quasars Ran Wang Department of Astronomy, Peking University, China.
Tools for computing the AGN feedback: radio-loudness and the kinetic luminosity function Gabriele Melini Fabio La Franca Fabrizio Fiore Active Galactic.
Spectral Energy Distributions of obscured AGN E. Lusso, A. Comastri, E. Treister, D. Sanders, H. Hao, M. Elvis, C. Vignali, R. Gilli, G.Zamorani, M. Brusa,
High Redshift Galaxies/Galaxy Surveys ALMA Community Day April 18, 2011 Neal A. Miller University of Maryland.
The Genesis and Star Formation Histories of Massive Galaxies Sept 27, 2004 P. J. McCarthy MGCT Carnegie Observatories.
Growth of SMBH studied through X-ray surveys
Winds from X-ray absorbed QSOs
Cosmic evolution of AGN in several X-ray bands
QSO2 and their host galaxies
Black Holes in the Deepest Extragalactic X-ray Surveys
The Formation and Evolution of SMGs: A (mostly) Panchromatic View
Presentation transcript:

Exploring structure around submillimetre-bright QSOs Francisco J. Carrera (IFCA, CSIC-UC, Spain/Imperial, UK) Mathew J. Page (MSSL-UCL, UK) Jason Stevens (CAR, U. Hertfordshire, UK) Rob Ivison (ROE, UK) Serena Falocco (IFCA, CSIC-UC, Spain), Jacobo Ebrero (SRON, NL) MSSL, 14-July- 2010

Outline Introduction: our hard QSO sample –What we now so far about them Environment in submm: strong overdensities Confirmation for RXJ0941 –Radio imaging –SEDs –Presence of AGN –Evolutionary status Summary

Introduction: our hard QSO sample (Page+01,04,10 Stevens+04,05) Sample of Broad Line QSO with X-ray absorbed spectra –At z and L X where most contribution to X-ray background –Matched sample of similar (L X,z) unabsorbed QSO Strong difference in submm fluxes: –Absorbed mostly bright, unabsorbed mostly faint –All submm detected are at z>1.5 –Submm much too bright to come from AGN: strong star formation Absorbed BLQSO are ~10-15% of BLQSO population X-ray-UV spectra: strong ionized winds, enough to terminate SF Simultaneous strong growth of BH and star formation Stronger SF in the past Transitory phase ~10-15% QSO life Just starting to blow away circumnuclear material?

Environment in submm: SCUBA 850  m (Stevens+05,+10) ~400kpc ~2´ 2-4x overdensities Structure in 100skpc Each an ULIRG Some: disturbed morphol. –Major galaxy merger These QSOs are sitting in overdensities in the Universe Submm luminosity from starburst (triggered by fusion/interaction?)

Confirmation for RXJ0941: radio imaging  m sources,  m sources (2 in common): 5 total All in radio (plus blob?) ( Carrera+10 ) iK4.5  m 8  m24  m450  m 850  m 6cm20cm

Confirmation for RXJ0941: photo-z Radio imaging: submm sources real –pinpoint some counterparts Counterparts very faint for spectroscopy Photometric redshifts ( hyperz ): –Fitting spectral templates ( MRR08 ) to RiZJK-4.5,8μm Also tried Bruzual & Charlot 2003: similar z Only fit to rest-frame optical-NIR: no dust –Best if conspicuous feature: between Z and J –M K : bulge (stellar) mass M * from Borys+05 Also used MRR08 (diff M/L): a factor 2-3 larger

Confirmation for RXJ0941: z and SEDs Once z: Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) Using Chary & Elbaz 2001 templates for ≥MIR –Dust emission –Not expected good match to rest-frame Opt.-NIR But surprisingly good… –Not fit: renormalizing to 450μm, 850μm, 4.5μm,… From CE01 templates: –L IR  Star Formation Rate (SFR) (Kennicutt 1998) From 450μm/850μm fluxes: –Assuming (T/ ,  ) (QSO/SMGs Martínez-Sansigre+09)  dust mass

F (cgs/Å) RXJ0941: the QSO 850_1/450_1 iK4.5  m 8  m24  m450  m 850  m 6cm20cm obs (Å) z=1.82 Several components: –AGN direct accretion (MRR+08) –AGN re-processing: torus (MRR+08) –Star formation: L IR ~2x10 13 L  Dominates in MIR/submm SFR~4000M  /y

850_2/450_2 Phot. z=1.85 L IR ~2x10 13 L  SFR~4000M  /y log(M * /M  )~11.6 obs (Å) F (cgs/Å) iK4.5  m 8  m24  m450  m 850  m 6cm20cm Photo-z fit CE01 450μm CE01 850μm

obs (Å) F (cgs/Å) 850_3 Phot. z=1.85 L IR ~0.5x10 13 L  SFR~900M  /y log(M * /M  )~11.5 iK4.5  m 8  m24  m450  m 850  m 6cm20cm Photo-z fit CE01 4.5μm CE01 850μm

Phot. z=1.85 L IR ~10 13 L  SFR~2400M  /y log(M * /M  )~11.5 obs (Å) F (cgs/Å) 450_4 iK4.5  m 8  m24  m450  m 850  m 6cm20cm Photo-z fit CE01 450μm

Phot. z=2.8 L IR ~2x10 13 L  SFR~4000M  /y log(M*/M  )~11.5 iK4.5  m 8  m24  m450  m 850  m 6cm20cm 450_3 obs (Å) F (cgs/Å) Photo-z fit CE01 4.5m CE01 450μm

Table summary Sourcez L IR (10 13 L  ) SFR (M  /y) M dust (10 8 M  ) logM * (logM  ) Flux ( μJy) 450(850)μm 850_1/450_  _2/450_  _ (3  2) 450_  9 450_  8 One spurious expected from logN-logS (Coppin+06) log(M * /M  )~11.5  0.2 (inc.  z and  K) SFR~2000 M  /y M dust ~10 9 M  (interval from  z,  T/ ,  ) –M gas ~5×10 10 M  (Kovács+06 SMG, Seaquist+04 SCUBA)

Presence of AGN X-ray upper limits on soft (6× cgs) and hard (4× cgs) bands: –Using Gilli+07 models –2-10keV luminosity upper limits All 24μm from AGN: very conservative (Elvis+94)  log(L X /cgs)<44 BC~35 (Marconi+04,Elvis+94)  ~0.2 (SMGs z~2 low L X Alexander+08)  log(M BH /M  )<8.1 ( +log(BC/35)-log(  /0.2) ) soft hard

Evolutionary state (Borys+05, Alexander+08, Michalowski+10…) log(M * /M  )~11.5  0.2 (~other SMG samples): –~Schechter mass of MIR-sel gals. (Pérez-González+08) –Gas mass ~10% galaxy mass  Galaxy mature and not much further growth log(M BH /M  )<8.1 ( with  BC,  ) (M BH /M * )/(M BH /M * ) local < 6 (1-100 with  ) (Marconi&Hunt 04) –~1 only if flux at X-ray upper limit and NH>> –L X ~5×10 43 erg/s (SMG Alexander+08), M * ×2 if MRR08…  Growth of BH lags the growth of the galaxy

Evolutionary state Plenty of fuel for AGN growth: -Only ~1.5% of M gas into BH to reach local M BH -M * If BH in exponential growth phase: -Mass e-folding time: t=4.4×10 8 y ×  /  (1-  ) (Martínez-Sansigre & Taylor 09, Rees 84)  =0.2 (low L X SMG Alexander+08)  =0.08 (Marconi+04, M-S&T 09)  M BH ×6 (local): t~340My (over by z~1.65)

Summary We confirmed overdensity around RXJ0941 Counterparts to 4/5 sources at same z –Expected ~1 spurious from submm source counts –HLIRGs, SFR~2000 M  /y Counterparts are massive submm galaxies: –Limited additional growth  Already mature Any AGN must have log(M BH /M  )<8.1 –Below local M BH /M * relationship  Growth of BH lags growth of galaxy Growth of AGN feasible: –Enough fuel –Relatively quickly Need: Herschel to measure submm SED shape (good T/ , M dust …), deeper X-ray to measure MBH, photo-z for the rest…

And there are more... Photo-z successful for 225 –Peak ~1.5-2 –Similar for BC03 89 sources “close” to z=1.82 within 99% with  3 points M * histogram for those 89: –Broad –Narrower if only  M*<1: 8-11 –All three counterparts in highest bins

Interpretation: an evolutionary sequence? More massive DM halos collapse earlier Collisions and mergers occur These processes channel material to the center which –Makes stars –Feeds the BH Material obscures opt/UV (dust) and X-ray (gas) Heated dust emits FIR which escape unimpeded Joint spheroid/QSO evolution within a hierarchical clustering scenario (Granato+04, Silk & Rees 1998, Fabian’99, Di Matteo+05) FIR X-ray

Interpretation: an evolutionary sequence? FIR X-ray FIR X-ray FIR emission increases  ULIRGs Bulk of submm gal. population discovered by SCUBA (Smail+97) ? As BH grows it reaches Sy-like X-ray luminosities Absorbed X-ray sources (Alexander+05) Signatures of buried AGN in opt spec. (Chapman+04) Joint spheroid/QSO evolution within a hierarchical clustering scenario (Granato+04, Silk & Rees 1998, Fabian’99, Di Matteo+05)

Still forming stars (FIR>>) BH allmost fully grown: QSO luminosities QSO radiation and starbursts are starting to sweep out circumnuclear material: Less absorbed X-ray sources  our X-ray absorbed QSOs BALQSOs in slightly later stage? (Fabian’99) Interpretation: an evolutionary sequence? FIR X-ray FIR X-ray FIR X-ray  our X-ray absorbed QSOs Joint spheroid/QSO evolution within a hierarchical clustering scenario (Granato+04, Silk & Rees 1998, Fabian’99, Di Matteo+05)

Interpretation: an evolutionary sequence? FIR X-ray FIR X-ray FIR X-ray Fully grown QSO “living off the rents”  our X-ray unabsorbed QSOs Passively evolving stellar population  our X-ray unabsorbed QSOs Joint spheroid/QSO evolution within a hierarchical clustering scenario (Granato+04, Silk & Rees 1998, Fabian’99, Di Matteo+05)